This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Glenn Sterle WA, Australian Labor Party
4:54 pm
Senator Nampijinpa Price has submitted a proposal, under standing order 75, today. It has been circulated and is shown on the Dynamic Red:
That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:
The Albanese Labor Government's relentless attack on Australian small businesses, including the Australian Taxation Office's issuing of more than 150,000 automated debt notices threatening penalties against small business owners, often in error, its heavy-handed debt recovery practices that threaten business viability and livelihoods, and Labor's proposed trusts tax that will impose an additional $1.7 billion annual burden on hundreds of thousands of small businesses already struggling with rising costs, excessive red tape and record levels of insolvencies.
Is consideration of the proposal supported?
More than the number of senators required by the standing orders having risen in their places—
With the concurrence of the Senate, the clerks will set the clock in line with the informal arrangements made by the whips.
Jacinta Nampijinpa Price NT, Country Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Skills and Training
I move:
That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:
The Albanese Labor Government's relentless attack on Australian small businesses, including the Australian Taxation Office's issuing of more than 150,000 automated debt notices threatening penalties against small business owners, often in error, its heavy-handed debt recovery practices that threaten business viability and livelihoods, and Labor's proposed trusts tax that will impose an additional $1.7 billion annual burden on hundreds of thousands of small businesses already struggling with rising costs, excessive red tape and record levels of insolvencies.
As we approach the festive season, the Albanese Labor government is acting like the Grinch who stole Christmas, taking from hardworking Australian families and businesses every chance that it gets. We now have the ATO pursuing small businesses through automated debt notices, threatening huge fines without first establishing that the small business has actually done anything wrong. Guilty until proven innocent—that is how the Albanese Labor government treats small businesses in this country. So far, 150,000 automated debt notices have been issued, many of course in error. One small construction business from Townsville told me, 'Every week, we live under threat now. It's very stressful—unreasonable penalties and fines, plus interest, for alleged late payment, and no leeway or consideration, creating unsustainable debt. You'd be a mug to start a small business in construction now.' A lot of tradespeople I talk to are looking for a government job: if you can't beat them, join them.
These small businesses are already dealing with higher operating costs, higher interest rates, more regulation and weaker consumer spending on the watch of an economically illiterate Treasurer. And now they are being treated as criminals by their own government, who seem more interested in adding stress and fees than actually helping small business. It's long past time the Albanese Labor government stepped up and did its job to help small business or, at the very least, not make things more difficult. But that would be too much to ask, I expect. Apparently, 46 businesses are entering insolvency every single day in this country, and that number will continue to increase as Labor's war on small business continues. Instead of backing the people who create jobs and contribute to our communities, Labor seems determined to reach deeper into their pockets and squeeze them. To that, I say pull your head in and stop punishing aspiration in our country. Stop asking small businesses to foot the bill for Labor's economic illiteracy. Stop the 30 per cent tax on discretionary trusts. Stop the red tape. Stop the never-ending cycle of increasing costs and government taxes.
Let's be clear about the scale of the latest tax grab. Labor has claimed 'only 10 per cent of businesses are affected'—that's what we keep hearing—by the discretionary trust changes. Well, tell that to each and every one of the 350,000 businesses that Labor is targeting. Tell that to the family businesses, farmers, tradies and hardworking Australians who have spent years trying to build something of their own. They take on the risk, they create the jobs and they employ Australians. They should be treated with respect and supported by their government. They are the backbone of our economy. Labor should do more to listen to people, instead of creating such poor policy and making these decisions without them.
I've heard directly from an agricultural business owner in Victoria who operates two separate businesses, both set up as trusts. They have concerns about the uncertainty surrounding Labor's proposed changes and what it means for them and for their future. They told me, 'Business always needs to prepare for the uncertainty of markets and plan to minimise the risk. With Albo and Jim, this is impossible. The only thing we can predict is that they will make it harder for small businesses. Take family trusts. We still don't know what it actually means—just that Jim wants more of our money.' That is an extraordinary position to put hardworking business owners in. They deserve—
Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning
Senator Nampijinpa Price, could you take a seat. I have Senator Stewart on her feet. Senator Stewart, do you have a point of order?
Jana Stewart Victoria, Australian Labor Party
Yes, a point of order on referring to members of the other place by their correct titles.
Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning
That is true. Senator, I remind you to refer to others in the other place by their correct titles.
Jacinta Nampijinpa Price NT, Country Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Skills and Training
They deserve to know what is being proposed, how it will affect their business and what the financial consequences will be. That is not abstract debate. These are real businesses, real people and real livelihoods, and they deserve better than this Albanese government.
Jana Stewart Victoria, Australian Labor Party
5:00 pm
Small-business owners work hard. They put their savings, their time and, often, their family's future into growing their business. And we know so many of them are doing it tough. They deserve more than a debate about whether things are good or bad; they deserve practical help, and that is what our government is focused on.
So let me use this time to talk about what that help actually looks like: tax relief, less paperwork and support when running a business gets a bit tough. The Albanese Labor government has always backed small business. We're delivering $3.8 billion of tax relief and rolling out tax cuts for working Australians, including 1.5 million sole traders. That includes making the $20,000 instant asset write-off a permanent feature of our system and giving eligible small businesses more certainty about when they can buy the equipment that they need to keep their show running.
This year's budget was designed to help small businesses to invest and to grow. In June this year, 43,393 new businesses were registered. That number is the highest monthly total since records began in 1999. It's an encouraging sign that Australians are backing themselves to get into business. We're also cutting regulatory burden, through less paperwork, making it easier to deal with government, and this will save businesses around $10.2 billion a year. We're giving the Fair Work Commission power to act quickly, to help truck drivers and transport operators get paid enough to cover high fuel costs. Yes, truck drivers are small-business owners too. We're investing over $30 million to support the mental health and financial wellbeing of small-business owners through the NewAccess for Small Business Owners program and the Small Business Debt Helpline.
I really could spend quite a while longer talking about the ways this government is backing small business, but I want to make sure we address other matters in this motion too. We know that many people are struggling with cost-of-living pressures right now, and many small businesses are doing it tough. There is no doubt about that. And debt-recovery action can make it feel just so much more stressful.
We absolutely expect the ATO to be always reasonable and compassionate in their approach, especially when families are going through a stressful and difficult time. Under the Albanese government, the ATO has recently released the Vulnerability Framework guide, which is a guide on how it supports people in difficult circumstances. It is also reviewing its approach to taxpayer relief, including changes announced in January. The ATO letters being referred to in this motion are not penalty notices, and they do not automatically collect money. They ask employers to contact the ATO to fix potential errors, to ensure an employee's superannuation has been paid correctly. Since 1 July, our focus has absolutely been on making sure that workers get their superannuation paid when their pay goes into their bank. Employers, software providers and superannuation funds are making significant changes to deliver payday super. We see the work that they're doing and we thank them for that work. We are focused on making sure that it's a success for employers and for employees.
We're changing the tax rules for trusts, so that money earned from owning assets is taxed more like money earned from working. These changes will also help pay for tax cuts for every single Australian worker—every single Australian taxpayer. These changes are not happening in a vacuum. These concerns aren't new. Reviews have raised concerns about discretionary trusts for years.
Let's be clear about who will actually be affected. Ninety-five per cent of Australians do not receive income from discretionary trusts. Eighty-five per cent of small businesses do not operate through a trust. Fewer than 10 per cent of small businesses will be affected in any given year, so the overwhelming majority of small businesses won't be affected, and minimum tax on discretionary trusts will improve the fairness, integrity and sustainability of the tax system.
Small-business owners back themselves every single day. They deserve a government that backs them too, and that is exactly what this Labor government is doing.
Nick McKim Tasmania, Australian Greens
5:05 pm
There is something deeply wrong with a tax system that relentlessly pursues small businesses while allowing some of Australia's biggest, most profitable corporations to pay absolutely no corporate tax whatsoever. Now, let's be clear: workers must be paid their superannuation entitlements, every dollar, on time without exception. Memo to the Australian Labor Party: that should include workers under 18 years of age as well as adult workers. It beggars belief that the so-called party of the workers in this country will not support requiring workers under 18 to be paid superannuation.
So, yes, everyone should be paid their superannuation payments, but the government should have learned something from the robodebt scandal about the dangers of automated compliance processes. We've got 150,000 letters sent to small businesses, including some who've undoubtedly done absolutely nothing wrong, and that should set alarm bells ringing.
But interestingly, I'll tell you who's not getting these letters: corporations like Santos, AGL, Netflix and Transurban. Those four corporations together paid precisely zero dollars in corporate tax in 2020 425. Santos has paid virtually no corporate tax for a decade now. And here's the extraordinary thing: we're in the middle of a massive gas price spike, but Santos and AGL would have us believe apparently there's no taxable profit to be found. Well, Santos reported nearly $900 million in underlying profit last year. AGL recently announced a $756 million statutory profit, yet somehow they owe the Australian people precisely no corporate tax. Make that make sense if you can.
More than a quarter of Australia's top-100 largest corporations paid no corporate tax in 2024-25, and the coalition wants to use this debate to defend tax loopholes exploited by wealthy Australians. Well, the Greens won't have a bar of that either. The real scandal here is a tax system that rolls out the red carpet for corporate giants while sending threatening letters to small businesses. Where is the government's urgency to make the top end of town pay its fair share? Because the message is clear: if you're a small business, expect a threatening letter; if you're a corporate giant with an army of tax lawyers, expect the red carpet.
Andrew Bragg NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Housing and Homelessness
5:08 pm
I rise to speak on this motion and to make the point again that the government hates small business and hates investors more than it wants to solve the housing crisis, which of course is germane to this tax debate, because the government said that more taxes would be good for the housing system, which is a bizarre state of mind. I wonder what's going on down there at the ministerial wing and what's happening down at Langton Crescent that the government thinks that it's a good idea to cut housing supply, put taxes up and have fewer houses in a housing crisis.
Putting that aside for a moment, let's just consider this issue here of the robodebt on steroids. Even the Greens are now saying that the Labor Party and the tax office are pursuing small businesses unreasonably for these superannuation debts really just to line the coffers of their mates. They are so desperate to get more and more money ensnared in their superannuation scheme that they're willing to kill off small business with these threatening letters that the ATO has been sending over the last few weeks. The problem with these ATO letters is they're wrong amounts. They're using technology rather than people to look at any of these pieces of paper that are going to people who are running small businesses.
The thing that is fundamental to understanding the problem the Australian people have is that small businesses are just people. A small business is just a person. It doesn't have an HR department. It doesn't have a legal department or a compliance wing. It doesn't have union officials. It's just a person trying to make a buck and feed their family. And when that person, who happens to be a small business, receives a threatening letter from the tax office, which is wrong and is just done to enrich the Labor Party for political and financial reasons, that is a very stressful event for that person.
There is no doubt that the super funds are behind this campaign. They've been whinging and whining to the Labor Party, saying, 'We haven't got enough money. We're not getting enough money out of the poor old small businesses. Let's send them some threatening letters to scare them into giving us a bit more cash.' As I say, the letters are wrong. They're not being properly vetted by humans. In one case, we've seen a Sydney business receive a bogus claim for 170,000 bucks, but they owed only $4,000. These are the extraordinary lengths that this government will go to to destroy small business.
But then we go to this ridiculous trust situation. Three in five tradies use a trust. That's not my data; that's data from the Housing Industry Association, the people who represent all the builders. Most home builders in Australia are small businesses. Again, they are family businesses; they are small businesses. They're building houses around Australia, or at least they would like to be building houses. Many of them are not in operation anymore because they've been deleted by this government. But the ones that are still surviving—hanging by a thread—are trying to engage in the great endeavour of home building. Three in five of these use trusts. Now they've got to endure a $50,000 compliance burden just because they use a trust, and they've got to deal with tax arbitrage. If a person who works for the government housing fund, which is crowding out the market, earns $45,000, they pay 15 per cent tax. If a small business person is running a trust—which is, in many cases, what they're doing—and they are earning $45,000, they will pay 30 per cent. That is double. So you get double taxation just for being a small business, compared to working for the government's housing fund. That's the kind of system that they've got now. They're going out of their way to collapse small business.
Ultimately, it seems, it's not a conspiracy or a conspiracy theory; they just want everyone to work for the government and the public sector and to come and work at the Housing Australia Future Fund, where everything's free—free lamingtons, free unicorns—and there's cheap housing. This is becoming a joke, frankly, which is why I think the Australian people struggle to take this prime minister and this treasurer seriously when they come into this place and say they're building more houses. The ABS stats show they're building 30,000 fewer houses a year. Look at this terrible, stinking carcase of a budget, which hasn't even been legislated yet. Who can recall a budget so bad that, seven months later, they haven't even put it through the parliament? It's extraordinary incompetence and disgusting maladministration that we see in this country with Dr Chalmers and Mr Albanese presiding over this nightmare of an economy. All we've seen so far is higher rents, fewer houses, fewer loans to owner-occupiers and fewer loans to first home buyers. What a joke!
Michelle Ananda-Rajah Victoria, Australian Labor Party
5:13 pm
In Australia we have around 2.7 million small businesses, and we know them well. They fill our retail strips and they give our neighbourhoods character. They also include our sole traders. Many of those people provide really essential services when we need them most, and we value their contribution. We understand that these people take a punt. They set up business, and we are here as a government to back them in. It's important to really moderate some of the hyperbole and, frankly, confusion and misinformation from those opposite, and we've heard no shortage of that in this debate.
Far from businesses collapsing, under our government we have seen record numbers of business creations. For the first time in Australian history, we have seen the number of small businesses being created hit 40,000 per month, and that hasn't happened just once; it's happened twice. It happened in June and in July this year. So, far from small businesses collapsing, we've seen quite the opposite. People would not start a business unless they had faith in the country. And Australians still have faith in Australia. Why wouldn't they? We're a great country. We have abundant opportunities. We have skilled capability. We have wealth. We have guts. Those opposite instead choose to trash-talk this country and tear it down. This is what I find most objectionable. You don't instil confidence in a country by tearing it down and trash-talking it. That's the currency used by those opposite. How can you stand in this parliament and call yourself a representative of the people if all you do is come in here and tear down our nation when there are people out there remortgaging their homes to start a business to back themselves?
What we are doing as a government is consulting with them and listening to their concerns and acting on those concerns. That's why we brought in a range of measures after consulting with Australian small businesses. It begs the question as to why the opposition didn't do it when they were in government for 10 years. I can rattle through them, and you know them well. We made the instant asset write-off, which you introduced, permanent. You could have made it permanent. You didn't; we made it permanent, in order to give small businesses certainty. But we've gone further. We also reintroduced the loss carry back tax offset, which again provides cash flow when times are tough for small business. But that's not all. With regard to the CGT changes, which those opposite have used every opportunity to berate and said that they will repeal—and they will break the housing system again—we listened to small businesses, and we made adjustments and expanded the 50 per cent small business CGT discount to encompass all 2.7 million small businesses. We did that because we listened. We listened, and we consulted, and we made the change.
That's not all. There are a range of other measures that we have brought in to support small business. We know that running a small business is not easy. It is isolating at times. It does take a toll. And that's why we've invested over $30 million to support mental health and the financial wellbeing of small-business owners through our NewAccess program for small businesses. It doesn't get enough air time, this program, but it's used by a lot of small-business owners, as well as the Small Business Debt Helpline. We've improved their digital and cyber capabilities. In this era of AI fuelled cyber attacks, volumetric attacks, which rob small businesses of their financial heft and ballast. This is a really important capability, and we introduced it—not those opposite; we did. And this has happened through a more than $60 million investment in the Digital Solutions program, as well as the Small Business Cyber Resilience Service and Cyber Health Check programs.
We also, during the fuel crisis, recognised the pressures on small business, and that's why we stepped in and cut the fuel excise for three months. We also extended further concessions and asked the ATO to actually help small businesses during that period of fuel insecurity. (Time expired)
Ralph Babet Victoria, United Australia Party
5:18 pm
There's something special about Labor's pathological attitude towards small business. I know I give Labor a lot of heat, but that's because they're in government. Don't think that I don't think similar about the Liberal Party. This government regards anyone who employs people, takes risks and manages to accumulate a little bit of wealth as a potential source of revenue a candidate for regulatory supervision. As a small-business owner, I can attest that this government seems to have never encountered a business, a business owner or a business opportunity that it didn't want to smother in paperwork and red tape. It is an instinctive response to anyone who dares to get ahead. It's: 'Why do you have that? Do you know what? We're going to regulate it. We're going to control it. We're going to tax it. We're going to take it.' That's what's happening. Is it any wonder, then, that according to ASIC 48,000 businesses have gone into administration since Labor came to power. Before entering the Senate, I worked seven days a week in my small business, and I could easily spend two or three of those days filling out forms and satisfying bureaucrats to ensure that I haven't inadvertently violated some obscure state or federal requirement.
Apparently, running a business is no longer about providing goods and services to your customers. It's about demonstrating your continued willingness to be governed. And the burden is not merely financial; it's psychological. Every new regulation sends the same message: we don't trust you, we don't like you making decisions, and we'd prefer you spent more time answering to us instead. Perhaps that's the point, because people who are financially independent are harder to control. But if you're dependent on government, well, heck, it's much easier to control you, isn't it? Is that the point? I think it is.
Slade Brockman Deputy-President
5:20 pm
Well, where to start? It's the hypocrisy of those opposite, those in government, standing up saying on the one hand that they feel small businesses' pain then, on the other hand, telling small business that it's never had it so good. The hypocrisy just runs from every word they say.
Let's start with a few facts, seeing as small businesses apparently, according to Labor, have never had it so good. SME unincorporated business exits in the last year increased 37 per cent. Small-business exits in construction were up 58 per cent. Small-business exits in retail were up 54 per cent. New ATO tax default filings were up 42 per cent. That is Labor's impact on small business across Australia and literally every single small business I have seen in the last year. And that would include hundreds and hundreds of small businesses saying that this Labor government has been an absolute disaster for them.
There are so many issues that we could go through here today, talking about just how badly small business is doing under this Labor government. But, on the excellent motion moved by my colleague Senator Nampijinpa Price, I will just cover off a couple of them. The first is the automated ATO letters—and I don't blame the ATO for this. This is the Labor government telling the ATO to wring as much tax as possible out of our small businesses around Australia. These letters have been sent out—letters to small businesses already under extraordinary pressure.
We've seen from a number of examples published in the media that these letters were simply wrong. They were not small errors. A restaurateur in Sydney was sent a claim for $170,000 from the ATO; on review and audit, it came back that the bill was actually $4½ thousand. Think about the pressure that that letter of demand would have put that small business under. Think about it. If you were at home, and you received a letter from a debt collector saying that you owed them hundreds of thousands of dollars when you actually owed a few thousand, think about the psychological pressure that puts on Australia's small business. And this isn't just one or two cases. There are over 150,000 of these letters sent out by this Labor government. That's 150,000 letters sent out to struggling small businesses that are facing interest rates at the highest level they've been in years and facing repayments on their debt, which is often financed through their family home, at the highest level for decades. In many cases, it's over $10,000 or $20,000 more, since this Labor government came to power.
Then, because they want to squeeze even more tax out of our small-business community, they go after trusts. Labor has been wanting to do this for years. Don't ever forget that. Labor has been wanting to go after trusts for years. Trusts affect small businesses more than any other part of the economy. Around 50 per cent of farming businesses still use trusts, and the vast majority of those are classified as either small- or microbusiness entities. These are not big operations. These are not multinational firms. These are the farming families of Australia and these are the people that Labor is squeezing. Whilst they say, 'Oh, we've exempted primary production,' they haven't exempted any other income that comes through that trust. So, if you do some off-farm harvesting work, it doesn't exempt that income. Labor simply wants to squeeze more tax out of our small businesses.
Sue Lines President
The question is that the urgency motion as moved by Senator Nampijinpa Price be agreed to.