This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Matters of Urgency

Small Business: Taxation


Andrew Bragg

Andrew Bragg NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Housing and Homelessness

5:08 pm

I rise to speak on this motion and to make the point again that the government hates small business and hates investors more than it wants to solve the housing crisis, which of course is germane to this tax debate, because the government said that more taxes would be good for the housing system, which is a bizarre state of mind. I wonder what's going on down there at the ministerial wing and what's happening down at Langton Crescent that the government thinks that it's a good idea to cut housing supply, put taxes up and have fewer houses in a housing crisis.

Putting that aside for a moment, let's just consider this issue here of the robodebt on steroids. Even the Greens are now saying that the Labor Party and the tax office are pursuing small businesses unreasonably for these superannuation debts really just to line the coffers of their mates. They are so desperate to get more and more money ensnared in their superannuation scheme that they're willing to kill off small business with these threatening letters that the ATO has been sending over the last few weeks. The problem with these ATO letters is they're wrong amounts. They're using technology rather than people to look at any of these pieces of paper that are going to people who are running small businesses.

The thing that is fundamental to understanding the problem the Australian people have is that small businesses are just people. A small business is just a person. It doesn't have an HR department. It doesn't have a legal department or a compliance wing. It doesn't have union officials. It's just a person trying to make a buck and feed their family. And when that person, who happens to be a small business, receives a threatening letter from the tax office, which is wrong and is just done to enrich the Labor Party for political and financial reasons, that is a very stressful event for that person.

There is no doubt that the super funds are behind this campaign. They've been whinging and whining to the Labor Party, saying, 'We haven't got enough money. We're not getting enough money out of the poor old small businesses. Let's send them some threatening letters to scare them into giving us a bit more cash.' As I say, the letters are wrong. They're not being properly vetted by humans. In one case, we've seen a Sydney business receive a bogus claim for 170,000 bucks, but they owed only $4,000. These are the extraordinary lengths that this government will go to to destroy small business.

But then we go to this ridiculous trust situation. Three in five tradies use a trust. That's not my data; that's data from the Housing Industry Association, the people who represent all the builders. Most home builders in Australia are small businesses. Again, they are family businesses; they are small businesses. They're building houses around Australia, or at least they would like to be building houses. Many of them are not in operation anymore because they've been deleted by this government. But the ones that are still surviving—hanging by a thread—are trying to engage in the great endeavour of home building. Three in five of these use trusts. Now they've got to endure a $50,000 compliance burden just because they use a trust, and they've got to deal with tax arbitrage. If a person who works for the government housing fund, which is crowding out the market, earns $45,000, they pay 15 per cent tax. If a small business person is running a trust—which is, in many cases, what they're doing—and they are earning $45,000, they will pay 30 per cent. That is double. So you get double taxation just for being a small business, compared to working for the government's housing fund. That's the kind of system that they've got now. They're going out of their way to collapse small business.

Ultimately, it seems, it's not a conspiracy or a conspiracy theory; they just want everyone to work for the government and the public sector and to come and work at the Housing Australia Future Fund, where everything's free—free lamingtons, free unicorns—and there's cheap housing. This is becoming a joke, frankly, which is why I think the Australian people struggle to take this prime minister and this treasurer seriously when they come into this place and say they're building more houses. The ABS stats show they're building 30,000 fewer houses a year. Look at this terrible, stinking carcase of a budget, which hasn't even been legislated yet. Who can recall a budget so bad that, seven months later, they haven't even put it through the parliament? It's extraordinary incompetence and disgusting maladministration that we see in this country with Dr Chalmers and Mr Albanese presiding over this nightmare of an economy. All we've seen so far is higher rents, fewer houses, fewer loans to owner-occupiers and fewer loans to first home buyers. What a joke!

Comments

No comments