This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Questions without Notice: Take Note of Answers
Answers to Questions
Kerrynne Liddle SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Health and Aged Care
3:31 pm
I move:
That the Senate take note of the answers given by ministers to questions without notice asked by Opposition senators today.
Another day, another Albanese Labor government backflip, flip-flop, cartwheel, somersault, U-turn—whatever it's called, it's obviously Labor's mojo. This is becoming an unfortunate familiar pattern. We've seen it on superannuation, the widow's tax, the ATO credit card surcharge and veterans' allied health care. And now, once again, Labor has been forced to retreat, this time on backpacker visas.
Let's remember what Labor proposed. After overseeing record levels of migration, they suddenly realised we've got a problem on our hands. But instead of addressing the broader issues, they chose to target working holiday makers, announcing plans to slash third-year backpacker visas from around 31,000 to just 5,000. This is another example of Labor announcing policy first and then considering the consequences later—no proper consultation, no willingness to consider the evidence, not wanting to listen to anyone. The plan was wrong, and then the realisation: 'Whoops!' Well, don't worry about all those people who were affected and all those businesses that have been left in absolute uncertainty—people who power this nation's employment, people in regional centres who are desperate for workers and certainty in those areas.
How can anyone outside the Albanese Labor government not see exactly what happened here? Labor didn't see it. They didn't see the farmers. They didn't see the tourism operators, the hospitality businesses or the regional communities. The only people who couldn't see it were those sitting around the cabinet table, blinded by the Canberra bubble. Everyone else can see what the government failed to: backpackers are not simply tourists; they are critical to workforce. The backlash has been widespread. The agricultural sector warned it would hurt harvests. The tourism sector warned it would hurt visitor experience. If you hadn't lived and worked and breathed this Canberra bubble, you would know that, in the regions, in tourism, they rely heavily on backpackers not just for the work they do but for the contribution they make to those communities. It's in the cities too. How could Labor not have seen that?
The Victorian Farmers Federation described the original proposal as 'a misfire' and 'a solution in search of a problem'—and look where Labor finds itself now. The Australian Hotels Association welcomed the eventual changes as 'a victory for common sense'—would have been good to see some common sense from Labor while it was sitting in the cabinet room trying to work out what it was going to do. The industries are all saying the same thing: the Working Holiday Maker program was not broken and did not need fixing.
What is the Liberal-Nationals coalition going to do? We're going to differentiate between working holiday makers in regional areas by raising visa fees, with an exemption for regional areas, to encourage more people to the regions. It's good for tourism. It's good for the cattle industry. It's good for the agricultural sector. It's good for pretty much everyone—and for the Australian economy, which is in such bad shape under Labor. Our plan will actually consider migration and its impact on regional communities, rather than simply cutting numbers. (Time expired)
Richard Dowling Tasmania, Australian Labor Party
3:35 pm
I want to again use this opportunity to correct some misunderstandings about the government's trust tax reforms. We will get to those, because there are many of them. It's actually a problem that was recognised more than 50 years ago with the Asprey review, which was commissioned by a coalition government. The coalition would have us Australians believe that the government suddenly invented a problem with discretionary trusts, but it's been recognised for a very long time. It's just that this government had the courage to deal with it. If we go back to 1972, Liberal Treasurer Billy Snedden commissioned the Asprey review, and in 1975 he identified the concern around income-splitting through trusts. Asprey did not propose the legislation that we have before us, but he identified the same issue: that people can have different tax outcomes purely by how they structure their income. That's a fundamental fairness question, which was examined by the Liberal Treasurer, and the coalition should not dismiss it just because Labor is addressing it.
Indeed, John Howard, also through his tax work, recognised similar issues—that different incomes received different tax treatment depending on whether they were held through a trust or a company—and proposed reforms to the taxation of trusts to try to correct some of those distortions. The Howard government recognised that tax distortion, but today's coalition want to preserve it. Indeed, even as late as 2015, the Abbott government released its Re:think tax discussion policy paper, where it explicitly acknowledged that discretionary trusts can provide tax benefits by distributing income among beneficiaries with different incomes. This illustrated, in the coalition's own work, that a family business allocating income among family members could reduce tax, acknowledging that this was a particular advantage for that business but something that ordinary workers were absolutely not entitled to access. Purely through a structuring arrangement, people could pay different rates of tax. That is a fundamental unfairness that is really what this legislation is all about.
Consider two Tasmanian families on similar incomes. One earns wages. The other receives income through a discretionary trust. The nurse in Hobart cannot divide her pay packets among her relatives to reduce her tax rate. A teacher in Burnie cannot choose which family member declares the salary. But a discretionary trust can provide flexibility to allocate income to beneficiaries at lower tax rates. Treasury has found that families with discretionary trusts face an average tax rate of around four percentage points lower than families with similar incomes without them. Those opposite talk about rewarding hard work. Why should the tax system provide an advantage based on how income is arranged?
There's also been a lot of discussion about the government's proposed 30 per cent minimum tax on discretionary trusts, including claims that low-income Australians will inevitably be worse off. But that's not how the legislation works. Let's take a simple example. Sarah, a nurse, works part-time earning $35,000 a year. She also receives a $10,000 distribution from her family trust, for a total taxable income of $45,000. Under the proposed reforms, the trust pays $3,000 tax on that distribution. But here's the important point. Sarah also receives a corresponding $3,000 tax credit. She can use that credit against her entire personal income tax liability, including tax on her wages. By using the tax rates that will apply when these reforms commence, Sarah's personal income tax liability would ordinarily be $3,427. If she applies to $3,000 credit, that leaves just $427 to pay personally—precisely what she would have paid under the existing system and not a dollar more. These reforms are about fairness.
Dean Smith WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister to the Shadow Treasurer
3:39 pm
The Labor government on the other side has a hearing problem. It is ignorant to the challenges being faced by working Australians. It is ignorant to the challenges being faced by regional communities. It is ignorant to the challenges being faced by small businesses. It is ignorant to the challenges being faced by Australia's veteran communities. Today in question time we heard the Leader of the Government in the Senate say that Labor is committed to real change. But, as every Australian knows, that is real change in the wrong direction. That is real change reversing the prosperity of this country and reversing the financial wellbeing of ordinary and working Australians—rising living costs, wages not keeping up with prices, rental prices on the rise and interest rates making it harder for first home buyers. All of this points to a government that is committed to making sure that the country heads in the wrong direction and not in the right direction.
The data and the statistics don't lie. Politicians have got talking points. They try to dress things up, but the data and the statistics do not lie. Roy Morgan Research recently revealed that 31.8 per cent of mortgage holders in this country are at risk of mortgage stress. Think about that for a moment—31.8 per cent of mortgage holders in this country are at risk of mortgage stress. That is 1.7 million people in Australia on the brink of experiencing mortgage stress. Roy Morgan Research suggests that's 560,000 people this year alone living on the brink of experiencing mortgage stress. It's worth remembering that they are levels equal to 2008, when Labor was last in government. Add to that what Roy Morgan Research says about the number of Australians considered to be already extremely at risk. That number has reached 1.2 million Australians, or 23 per cent.
Unfortunately, the scenario for Australians is that 2027 is going to be significantly worse. Inflation continues to go up, interest rates continue to go up, and now everyone is talking about and seeing for themselves rising levels of unemployment—David Jones, Bunnings, KPMG, Qantas, Canva and the National Australia Bank, just to name a few. That's not politics. That's economics. When inflation goes up, the Reserve Bank has one lever, and that is interest rates, to dampen the economy, to bring inflation down. When we dampen the economy, that leads to rising levels of unemployment. It's not politics. It is economics.
What is the one solution to this problem that Labor does not want to recognise? The solution to this problem is wasteful and excessive government spending. When the government spends too much, inflation goes up. Interest rates are forced to rise. Unemployment then follows. Rising levels of unemployment follows. That is the bleak future facing Australians in 2027. All this is from a prime minister who said that life would be easier under Labor. All this is from a prime minister who committed to Australians in 2022 before they went to the polls that life would be easier under Labor. (Time expired)
Carol Brown Tasmania, Australian Labor Party
3:43 pm
I rise to take note of the answers given today on aged care and particularly the Support at Home program. An older person who needs help getting dressed in the morning, a daughter trying to organise care for her father after a fall and a couple who have lived in the same house for 50 years and want to stay there for as long as possible want safe, reliable care without being left to navigate a confusing system or face unreasonable costs. We will be the first to acknowledge that we have more work to do. There are older Australians still waiting for too long for support and families understandably frustrated by that. We should listen to them, but we should also be clear about the crisis the Albanese Labor government inherited.
The Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety exposed heartbreaking failures and neglect. After nine years of the coalition government, it was clear that our aged-care system needed fundamental change. That is why we have been rebuilding it, not just talking about it. Support at Home began in November last year. Its purpose is straightforward: to help older Australians receive the care they need while continuing to live in their own homes close to family, friends and community. For older Tasmanians, that matters enormously. Whether someone lives in Hobart, on the north-west coast or in one of our smaller regional communities, being able to remain at home can make a real difference to their independence and dignity.
One of the most important changes took effect on 1 October. The government invested $1 billion to fully fund personal care under Support at Home. For people approved for those services, with funding available in their packages, that means no participant contribution for help with showering, dressing, eating, continence care or taking medication. These are not luxuries. They're basic parts of everyday life. Nobody should have to weigh up the cost of a shower against other household bills. This change happened because older Australians and their carers told us the original settings were not right. We listened and we changed them. That is what responsible government should do.
We have also heard concerns about what some providers are charging. Some of the prices reported have been hard to justify, and older Australians should not be taken advantage of. That is why we have strengthened the powers of the Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission to investigate unreasonable charges and secure refunds. More than $300,000 in refunds have already been facilitated. Providers must explain their prices and treat the people who rely on them fairly.
Then there is the issue of waiting times. Minister Rae has been upfront about the demand on the system. The number of people receiving home care has grown dramatically and the workforce is under pressure. There has been progress. The median wait for an aged-care assessment is coming down, and urgent Support at Home packages are delivered within a month. But other Australians still wait longer than they should. That's why this year's budget included another $3.7 billion for aged care, including faster access to home support, and investment to support the construction of 5,000 additional residential aged-care beds a year.
Question agreed to.