This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Questions without Notice: Take Note of Answers

Answers to Questions


Kerrynne Liddle

Kerrynne Liddle SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Health and Aged Care

3:31 pm

I move:

That the Senate take note of the answers given by ministers to questions without notice asked by Opposition senators today.

Another day, another Albanese Labor government backflip, flip-flop, cartwheel, somersault, U-turn—whatever it's called, it's obviously Labor's mojo. This is becoming an unfortunate familiar pattern. We've seen it on superannuation, the widow's tax, the ATO credit card surcharge and veterans' allied health care. And now, once again, Labor has been forced to retreat, this time on backpacker visas.

Let's remember what Labor proposed. After overseeing record levels of migration, they suddenly realised we've got a problem on our hands. But instead of addressing the broader issues, they chose to target working holiday makers, announcing plans to slash third-year backpacker visas from around 31,000 to just 5,000. This is another example of Labor announcing policy first and then considering the consequences later—no proper consultation, no willingness to consider the evidence, not wanting to listen to anyone. The plan was wrong, and then the realisation: 'Whoops!' Well, don't worry about all those people who were affected and all those businesses that have been left in absolute uncertainty—people who power this nation's employment, people in regional centres who are desperate for workers and certainty in those areas.

How can anyone outside the Albanese Labor government not see exactly what happened here? Labor didn't see it. They didn't see the farmers. They didn't see the tourism operators, the hospitality businesses or the regional communities. The only people who couldn't see it were those sitting around the cabinet table, blinded by the Canberra bubble. Everyone else can see what the government failed to: backpackers are not simply tourists; they are critical to workforce. The backlash has been widespread. The agricultural sector warned it would hurt harvests. The tourism sector warned it would hurt visitor experience. If you hadn't lived and worked and breathed this Canberra bubble, you would know that, in the regions, in tourism, they rely heavily on backpackers not just for the work they do but for the contribution they make to those communities. It's in the cities too. How could Labor not have seen that?

The Victorian Farmers Federation described the original proposal as 'a misfire' and 'a solution in search of a problem'—and look where Labor finds itself now. The Australian Hotels Association welcomed the eventual changes as 'a victory for common sense'—would have been good to see some common sense from Labor while it was sitting in the cabinet room trying to work out what it was going to do. The industries are all saying the same thing: the Working Holiday Maker program was not broken and did not need fixing.

What is the Liberal-Nationals coalition going to do? We're going to differentiate between working holiday makers in regional areas by raising visa fees, with an exemption for regional areas, to encourage more people to the regions. It's good for tourism. It's good for the cattle industry. It's good for the agricultural sector. It's good for pretty much everyone—and for the Australian economy, which is in such bad shape under Labor. Our plan will actually consider migration and its impact on regional communities, rather than simply cutting numbers. (Time expired)

Comments

No comments