This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Questions without Notice: Take Note of Answers
Aged Care, Taxation
Andrew McLachlan SA, Liberal Party
3:47 pm
I move:
That the Senate take note of the answers given by the Minister representing the Prime Minister (Senator Wong) to questions without notice asked today.
There were four questions to which the answers were taken on notice. I intend to address the answers in relation to aged care, tax on trusts and backpacker visa changes. The question to Senator Wong in relation to aged care concerned 96-year-old Audrey Staniland, who is blind, has emphysema, lives alone in Perth and was told by the government's algorithm that she needed no more support than she had 12 years ago. The minister's answer to the supplementary questions was that $3.7 billion in aged-care funding had been allocated, including for residential care.
The point of the question was directed at the implementation of funding and what was actually happening to those that are the most in need in our community. No answer was really given to the failure to materialise an improvement of service despite any funding increase. It's incumbent upon this parliament and all of us to ensure that our most needy are looked after. Large figures quoted in this chamber mean nothing to the individuals and their families in need, for they are the ones that suffer from poor service. This was a similar criticism of the coalition, and it's right that the coalition seeks to hold the government to account in this regard.
I come to the question in relation to the taxation of trusts which has affected so many largely small-business families who have used this mechanism, quite legally, to arrange their affairs. The language of the answer used the words 'loophole', 'fair and equitable' and 'privilege'. But families that have sought to obey the law—and a law that has been longstanding—should not be cast as those receiving a benefit. Rather, they have simply obeyed the law and structured their affairs accordingly.
The question went to the heart of the cost of them transitioning their affairs, because changes like this create great uncertainty in small-business families and they need to then spend considerable amounts of money on professional services to effect the change. It's not simply a case of a law change and a simple accommodation. I'm reminded of the quote from Jean-Baptiste Colbert that:
The art of taxation consists in so plucking the goose as to obtain the largest possible amount of feathers with the smallest possible amount of hissing.
I think in this case the community that used trusts fairly over a long period of time—and these structures are hard to unwind—should be given the courtesy of having time, if in fact the parliament decides that these laws should be in place, to transition their affairs.
Question agreed to.