This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Matters of Urgency

Housing


Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

6:03 pm

The Senate will now consider the proposal from Senator Bragg, which is also shown at item 13 on today's Order of Business:

That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:

The Government's failure on housing, including the Budget tax hikes that have smashed lending for homeowners and first home buyers.

Is consideration of the proposal supported?

More than the number of senators required by the standing orders having risen in their places—

With the concurrence of the Senate, the Clerks will set the clock in line with the informal arrangements made by the whips.

Andrew Bragg

Andrew Bragg NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Housing and Homelessness

6:04 pm

I move:

That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:

The Government's failure on housing, including the Budget tax hikes that have smashed lending for homeowners and first home buyers.

The matter of urgency is that the government have imposed taxes onto the Australian economy and onto the Australian housing system, which have been an absolute disaster. They've been an absolute disaster. I think most people would look at it and say, 'Why are you imposing taxes on everything in order to solve a housing problem which has made the economy sicker and has made the housing system much worse?' I say to the good doctor, over in the other place—Dr Chalmers is what he calls himself now—that there are really three tests for this budget. Test 1 is: do you have more loans or fewer loans? Test 2 is: are rents going up or are rents going down? Test 3 is: are you getting more houses or are you getting fewer houses?

On the first test, in terms of loans, we saw last week the ABS coming out with their historic publication in which they said that this was the biggest drop in home lending since records began. I think that gives you a pretty clear score on the lending side. We saw a drop in loans to investors; yes, we did. We saw a drop in loans to owner-occupiers. We also saw a drop in loans to first home owners—apparently, the people who were supposed to be the great beneficiaries of this fantastical, magnificent, beautiful largesse from Canberra! So you've got lower loans to owner-occupiers, to first home owners and to investors. The Labor Party hates investors more than they want to solve the housing crisis; that is well established. But who knew that they hated first home owners so much? Who knew that they hated owner-occupiers this much? Who knew? Not I, and not anyone else. So you've got a massive collapse—in fact, the biggest and most historic collapse in home lending since records began. That's how good this budget is on that front.

Then we go to rents. The good doctor, when he was cooking up this crooked stew, said 'two bucks a week'—'two bucks'. In Sydney, already, we're seeing rents increasing by up to 200 bucks. So there you go: he's failed on rents; he's failed on loans.

But maybe the biggest of them all is that he's failed on supply. Now, I imagine that most people in this place are of sound mind. I imagine that's the case—even as to the members of the government. I believe they're of sound mind, at some level. But I have to say I was scratching my head on budget night, when I saw in the budget papers that these tax measures would reduce housing supply by 35,000 dwellings. I thought to myself: 'Why would we want to reduce dwellings by one, let alone by 35,000? Something is awry over on the government benches. They've been down to Treasury, down at Langton Crescent, and they've had too much punch, and something's happened!' But that's what the budget papers say. They want to reduce housing supply by 35,000, because they hate investors more than they want to build houses for Australians. And that is in their budget papers.

But, when you look at the industry analysis, it all stacks up. The industry agrees: there will be 35,000 fewer houses, but it will be more than 35,000; it will be more like 50,000 over the 10-year period.

What's more, when the government did the deal to pass their stinking budget through this Senate, they did a deal with the Greens to stop SMSFs from investing in new houses. So, the doc—the good doc; I'm trying to be generous here, Deputy President—

Slade Brockman

Slade Brockman Deputy-President

Senator Bragg, you know you have to refer to people properly.

Andrew Bragg

Andrew Bragg NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Housing and Homelessness

Well, Dr Chalmers is his name—the Treasurer. That's his name, isn't it? Yes. Anyway, he comes up and he says: 'We're only going to take away 4,000 SMSF-funded houses. It's only 4,000 houses. You won't even notice. It's so small, you won't even see it. It's not even there. It's like it's hiding. Four thousand are going to go—4,000 new houses. That's 4,000 houses we don't need.'

But the problem with that is that then, when estimates roll around, and I say, 'Well, how's it going with your 4,000 fewer houses?' the Treasury officials say, 'It's actually 8,000.' So he was wrong on that. But then the bigger problem is that the industry says it's 16,000—16,000 houses in the last financial year were supported by SMSFs. The problem with the doc's data is: he got the wrong data from the Treasury and the wrong data from his office. He doesn't know what he's doing. But the main point is: why is he cutting supply at all? Why is he cutting them by 35,000? Why is he cutting them by 16,000? There'll be a cumulative total, over the decade, of 75,000 fewer houses. So, if you want to look at this stinking wreckage of a budget, this stinking turd of a budget, you are looking at higher rents, you are looking at fewer houses and you're looking at fewer loans to the people who are supposed to be helped.

An incident having occurred in the chamber—

And your phone's ringing, by the way.

Slade Brockman

Slade Brockman Deputy-President

The bell was tolling for someone, Senator Bragg!

Josh Dolega

Josh Dolega Tasmania, Australian Labor Party

6:09 pm

I thank Senator Bragg for the opportunity to talk about the great work that's been done by the Albanese Labor government, as we address the housing crisis after a decade of neglect. Unfortunately, buying a home has become a life-defining challenge for so many people. Far too many Australians are burning the midnight oil and doing everything right but haven't been able to find a place to call their own home, and many younger Australians have just given up hope. It's an utter disgrace that we've come to this, and it should never have been allowed to happen. Put simply, we've had a housing market geared towards investors for a generation, which left us nothing more than plummeting homeownership rates, spiralling house prices and a generation of losing hope.

This year's budget helps to build more homes and levels the playing field for her first home buyers. House prices have risen around 54 per cent since COVID and more than 400 per cent since 1999—400 per cent! As a result, the average time taken to save a 20 per cent deposit has increased to more than 11 years, while the median dwelling price has risen from roughly four times the average income in 1999 to more than eight times the average income. This is unacceptable. That's why, since coming to office, we've pursued the most ambitious housing agenda in generations. We recognise more needs to be done. We're limiting negative gearing for residential property from the 2027-28 financial year so that it can only be used for new builds, and we're replacing the 50 per cent capital gains tax with inflation adjusted indexation from 1 July 2027 to restore the taxation of real gains. These changes will help around 75,000 first home buyers into the market over the next decade.

Our efforts are already helping to level the playing field and ensuring investment flows to where it's more productive, instead of housing, where more and more Australians are being priced out of the market. Recent ABS data backs our reforms. Investors are now moving away from bidding up the price of existing homes and moving towards new builds, encouraging new supply. This is in addition to our five per cent deposit scheme, which is helping more than 270,000 first home buyers into the housing market and saving them $2.3 billion in lenders mortgage insurance costs. Despite the chorus of contempt from those opposite, the RBA governor has said that negative equity remains very limited, affecting less than one per cent of borrowers. Sure, home lending may have declined a little, but this has been caused by many factors, including unprecedented global economic uncertainty and higher interest rates, as seen during other periods of decline, such as from 2017 to 2019 and 2022 to 2023.

Here are some impressive numbers painting a crystal-clear picture of what we're doing compared to what those opposite did. We're investing $47 billion in our Homes for Australia plan, nearly 10 times what the coalition invested in housing. They invested just $5 billion. We're investing $6.3 billion in housing-enabling infrastructure, over 50 times what the coalition invested, which was just $123 million. We're building 55,000 social and affordable homes, which is nearly 150 times what the coalition built. They built just 373—yes, just 373. We are also building homes for first home buyers and working to deliver 1.2 million homes. In fact, since we were elected, more than 700,000 homes have been built across the nation. I'm quite surprised, Senator Bragg, that you wanted to keep talking about housing, given there are more homes under construction right now in Australia than at any other time in our history. Construction cost inflation has fallen from 17 per cent under the coalition—a half-century high—to 3.8 per cent. Approvals have risen for three consecutive years. They are up nine per cent over the past year, and approvals were 26.3 per cent higher in the June quarter compared to the June quarter 2024, just before the accord started.

Senator Bragg and those opposite want to see their rich property mogul mates buying more investment properties while telling those on lower incomes to just accept substandard housing. Add to that the shadow treasurer's advice to put on a jumper in winter rather than spending huge amounts of money, which starts to resemble a modern form of medieval feudalism. It's just crazy. It's about accessibility, energy efficiency and basic livability, not luxuries. These are the bare minimum housing standards that all Australians are entitled to expect.

Fatima Payman

Fatima Payman WA, Australia's Voice

6:14 pm

I'm not sure about everything Senator Bragg proposes in this motion, but he is right to suggest that this government has failed on housing. The situation in Perth and across Western Australia, particularly for renters, is desperate. The latest Cotality data from September puts the median rent in Perth at $798, not far behind Sydney. That amount has increased by eight per cent over the last year, in spite of an increase in vacancy from 1.2 per cent to 2.2 per cent. For Australians looking to buy their first home, things aren't much better. At the same time that the government makes changes to negative gearing and capital gains tax discount, it is running programs like the five per cent deposit scheme, which has no maximum income limit. It is pushing down on prices with one lever while inflaming demand with another. We need a fair go on housing.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

6:15 pm

I thank Senator Bragg for bringing this important subject before us to debate today, and I commend Senator Bragg on the outstanding work that he's been doing in holding this government to account and unpicking the folly of their failed housing program. It is not meeting the objectives of Australians that are desperate to be able to get into a home—an affordable home—and this government is failing at every level, not just in housing but right across their entire platform. At the heart of this is a very simple question: are young Australians any closer now to owning a home than they've been before? The 2026 Intergenerational report puts a stark number on this challenge. It now takes 11.2 years to save for a 20 per cent deposit, and in December 2002 it took just 7.1 years. For a young person or a couple, that means working, paying rent and trying to save while the goal just keeps moving further away. Even the most naturally optimistic young Australian must be asking how long they are expected to wait.

This government claims that it's done more than any previous government to help young people and families buy their home. But—and these stats were missed by the previous speaker, Senator Dolega, who obviously just used an outdated version of ChatGPT or something to come up with his speech, because it did not reveal facts and truth—the ABS figures show that new home loan commitments fell 15 per cent in the September quarter alone. First home buyer loans fell 8.6 per cent in the quarter and 12.3 per cent over this year. Owner-occupier commitments fell 5.3 per cent. Young Australians need more than announcements. They need a chance to be able to buy and save for their home.

As Peter Costello, one of the greatest treasurers that this country has ever seen, put it, 'Debt-free government is the best youth policy you'll ever come across.' No truer words have been spoken about the economy. That captures a broader truth. Sound economic management is the foundation of sound housing policy, yet young people face high inflation and the highest interest rates since 2008. Labor's new taxes on housing investment risk discouraging investment in homes and making ownership harder to reach. For some first home buyers, the pressure continues after they get the keys. Reporting this week on Equifax data found that some buyers using the government's five per cent deposit scheme are now behind on their repayments. Among those in administration and other services, almost six in every thousand were at least 30 days behind, compared to about two in every thousand in finance and education. This shows how quickly repayments can squeeze households with very little room in their budgets.

In question time today, Minister Watt said that the government is making the economy more resilient. Resilience means withstanding a shock and then recovering from it. Minister Watt and his government sure have delivered shocks and difficulties to Australians, but I cannot see a recovery in sight delivered by this government. I can see families facing higher costs of living, higher mortgage payments and a housing market pushing them further from homeownership. Where is the bounce back for a couple in their late 20s who moved in with their parents to be able to save for a deposit? Some have told me it feels like they are stepping backwards and not stepping forwards. That pressure is not just limited to first home buyers; it is in the community at large.

I want to spend the last 40 seconds of this speech talking about the AUKUS program and the pressure that that is putting on the housing market in Western Australia and in the southern suburbs of Perth. We've got sailors and submariners coming here, thankfully, as part of the AUKUS program, from the United States and the UK. Where are they going to be housed? All that's happening is Defence is taking up homes within the local economy, on the local market, and there are not enough new homes being built. How many new homes do we need? How many times does the government need to be reminded that this is an urgent problem that needs to be resolved? They are doing nothing about it—and not just this federal government but, indeed, the state government. (Time expired)

Malcolm Roberts

Malcolm Roberts Queensland, Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party

6:20 pm

A young couple today have a very different life to that of their parents, who were able to raise a family and buy a home on one wage. Here's why. The McMahon government fell in 1972 when unemployment went over two per cent. Today it's 4.7 per cent. Full employment is considered anything under four per cent—a figure more beneficial to corporate profits than workers' wages. Full-time employment has fallen from 87 per cent of wage earners in 1975 to just 68 per cent today. A family earning the median wage in 1975 spent 35 per cent of their gross salary on a mortgage; today, it's 50 per cent or more. An average home in 1975 was 12 times the worth of median earnings; today, it's 28 times. Taxes take two per cent more today than they did in 1975. Housing affordability is not about one thing; it's about everything. That's why One Nation's policies are detailed and work together to restore opportunity for young Australians and all Australians.

Carol Brown

Carol Brown Tasmania, Australian Labor Party

6:21 pm

This motion brought on by the opposition today is quite laughable when, just three weeks ago, the coalition put $4.7 billion in proposed housing cuts on the table. They would abolish the Housing Australia Future Fund, scrap Help to Buy and the New Home Bonus Program and remove incentives for building more rental homes. That is their published policy. Senator Bragg should explain how taking away that support will help Australians find a home. Indeed, for most of the nine years the coalition were last in power, they didn't even have a housing minister. They built just 373 social and affordable homes over that entire period.

Andrew Bragg

Andrew Bragg NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Housing and Homelessness

That's not true!

Carol Brown

Carol Brown Tasmania, Australian Labor Party

Now they come in here and try to convince us that they care, but actions speak louder than words, and no amount of shouting from Senator Bragg will change their record.

This is the thing about Senator Bragg; it's not a serious response. And Australians deserve a serious response.

Our $47 billion housing plan is about building more homes, giving renters a better deal and helping more Australians buy their first home. For too long, people bidding for the first time have competed against investors receiving tax concessions to buy another existing property. Our budget reforms to negative gearing and the capital gains tax are designed to give first home buyers a fairer chance and encourage investment in new housing. We know that when the coalition was in government they did nothing about this situation. They did nothing to help first home buyers try to get into the housing market.

From 1 July next year, eligible new builds will still qualify for negative gearing, and investments made before budget night will still be protected. If we're going to use the tax system to support housing investment, it makes sense to encourage investment that adds to the number of homes available. We're also tackling the deposit barrier directly. In the first year after we expanded the five per cent deposit scheme, more than 100,000 Australians used it to buy their home. I met one a few months ago who told me that he never really thought that he'd ever be able to get into his own home, a home that he has managed to purchase. He was so excited and so grateful for this scheme. All we have with Senator Bragg is that he comes in here and he is negative about the government's program, but he's not serious about having a real response to assist people who are looking for affordable housing, renters and people who are looking for their first home. The person I spoke to is one of 1,600 Tasmanians. Since Labor came to office, the scheme has helped more than 280,000 Australians, including those Tasmanians. For an eligible buyer, that means being able to buy with a deposit of as little as five per cent, without paying lender's mortgage insurance. It can mean getting into a home years sooner, rather than not getting into a home at all.

So I'd say to Senator Bragg and the coalition that they need to get serious about their housing policy. I'm not convinced that we'll ever see a coalition housing minister. We have to base their actions on what they did while they were in government and, as I've said, for most of those nine years, they didn't care enough to even have in the Australian parliament someone responsible for housing. I reject this— (Time expired)

Barbara Pocock

Barbara Pocock SA, Australian Greens

6:26 pm

We are living in a house price tornado. House prices have surged by more than 400 per cent nationwide since 1999, when changes to the capital gains tax discount were introduced. Through the 27 years of coalition government and Labor government, we've seen nothing but a rising disaster in house prices confront first home buyers trying desperately to get into the market. Over that 27 years, we have seen housing turn from being a roof over your head to something in your investment portfolio. Thank you, major parties! What a gift to the young people and to the generations ahead! What a disaster to present to them as they turn to the creation of their own homes and families.

Senator Bragg mentioned his concern about rent increases. If he's really worried about rent increases, let's have a look at the increase in rent from 2000, when it started at $150, to now, when rent is over $700 per week and the minimum wage is $1,000 a week. That's 70 per cent of your before-tax income to pay in rent, on average, across our nation. That's the gift of the major parties to those younger generations, especially those lower income households that don't have a parent as their banker and that have no-one to turn to for assistance to get into that market. Indeed, one in two of those 20- to 30-year-olds are living at home with their parents because they have no other option. They can't afford the rent and they can't get to a deposit.

In Adelaide, median house prices have increased from around $125,000 in September 1999 to nearly a million dollars right now. That is a 680 per cent increase. This is a brutal housing market—and it is a market; it's not a roof over your head. It is not the human right that it should be. Yet the second we see house prices start to cool down—as soon as prices for those luxury houses on the waterfront in the eastern suburbs of Sydney come back a bit and prices for those luxury houses in Melbourne start to turn around—we're in a disaster. What a disaster! We hear from the banks endlessly. We hear from brokers and from property spruikers. What about listening to those young people who have been trying to accumulate their deposit? Every time six months goes by, they have to put forward another $30,000 to get to that deposit. The housing market is running ahead of them and is impossible to meet. There is incredible disappointment and deep depression in so many young people's households as they try to find their way to stable and secure housing.

If you are an investor, it's time we did see a cooling-off. It's time we did see investors step away from competition with first home buyers. It's time we saw those house prices that have gone up by 400 per cent come back a bit so that first home buyers have the beginnings of a shot of getting into their own homes.

Kerrynne Liddle

Kerrynne Liddle SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Health and Aged Care

6:29 pm

Everyone in this place should know that the first job of any government is to keep its citizens safe. What could be more urgent? Fundamental to keeping people safe is them having a roof over their heads. The evidence of Labor housing failure is both significant and alarming. This is urgent for the increasing numbers of men, women and children who are living in cars, living on the streets, in tents or couch surfing, not just because of a housing crisis but because of Labor's induced economic crisis. Those Australians are waiting, waiting and waiting for Labor to get its act together to do what it said it would do—that is, not to hold Australians back nor leave them behind. Remember that? It's another broken Labor promise writ large in housing.

Labor's out-of-control spending is fuelling the cost-of-living crisis, the exorbitant rents and the higher mortgages and interest rates. You cannot bring 1.4 million people into Australia, as Labor has done in its term—about the population of Adelaide—and not have somewhere to house them. But that's what Labor did. It is urgent because homeowners cannot weather 17 mortgage interest rate rises, let alone more. It is urgent because a severe shortage of tradespeople will just add to the crisis. Walk into any pub, any shopping centre, any playground, anywhere there's people and they are not applauding Labor's outcome. Right now, as we speak, everyone is losing under the Albanese government—renters, investors, first homeowners and owner occupiers.

The policy decisions made in Canberra have real consequences. Labor is overseeing a once-in-a-generation housing downturn that everyone except Labor saw coming as a consequence of the policies Labor is delivering. Auction clearance rates have dropped to 40 per cent, the lowest since COVID. The latest ABS lending data shows the total number of new home loans fell 15 per cent in the September quarter alone. This is a record decline. Labor is building around 30,000 fewer homes a year than the coalition did when in government. Now Labor's higher housing taxes are discouraging investment when Australia desperately needs more homes. Lending to owner occupiers was down by 5.3 per cent this quarter and, even worse, lending to first homebuyers fell by 8.6 per cent. Investor lending was smashed by more than 30 per cent compared to a year ago. The total number of new home loans is down by over 21 per cent. The number of loans to owner occupiers is down by 9.8 per cent and down by a massive 12.3 per cent for first homebuyers.

Labor's economic incompetence has pushed interest rates to their highest level since 2008, adding $33,000 a year to the average new mortgage. Who on earth can sustain that? Not the ordinary hardworking Australians Labor does not see, does not hear and does not believe. A rise in negative equity as house prices soften has particularly impacted first homeowners. We have the highest inflation and interest rates amongst comparative advanced economies, so the persistent failures we're experiencing cannot simply be dismissed as international affairs. The focus must instead be on Labor's failure.

The urgency of this issue was loud and clear at the Senate Economics References Committee inquiry into social housing, which I chair. The committee heard from Treasury that the Housing Australia Future Fund that we heard about before has delivered only 530 social and 1,080 affordable homes so far, and yet Labor claims there will be 40,000 new social and affordable homes across Australia by mid 2029. How is that believable? Officials could not say that they will deliver them. They said that is their target.

The Master Builders Association told the inquiry that it has become more difficult to deliver high volumes of new home building since the May 2026 federal budget, and it will only get worse. Labor's so-called tax reforms impacting negative gearing and capital gains tax and self-managed super funds have made it less attractive and more expensive to provide rental accommodation to the market, in turn putting greater pressure on social housing. As the committee heard from the Australian Institute of Architects, it was bad news too. The Australian dream is, for many, now a nightmare. The coalition will repeal Labor's housing taxes because Australians shouldn't pay for this incompetence. (Time expired)

Slade Brockman

Slade Brockman Deputy-President

The question is that the motion moved by Senator Bragg be agreed to. A division is required. It being after 6:30 pm, the division will be deferred until it suits the chamber, probably tomorrow.