This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Matters of Urgency

Housing


Andrew Bragg

Andrew Bragg NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Housing and Homelessness

6:04 pm

I move:

That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:

The Government's failure on housing, including the Budget tax hikes that have smashed lending for homeowners and first home buyers.

The matter of urgency is that the government have imposed taxes onto the Australian economy and onto the Australian housing system, which have been an absolute disaster. They've been an absolute disaster. I think most people would look at it and say, 'Why are you imposing taxes on everything in order to solve a housing problem which has made the economy sicker and has made the housing system much worse?' I say to the good doctor, over in the other place—Dr Chalmers is what he calls himself now—that there are really three tests for this budget. Test 1 is: do you have more loans or fewer loans? Test 2 is: are rents going up or are rents going down? Test 3 is: are you getting more houses or are you getting fewer houses?

On the first test, in terms of loans, we saw last week the ABS coming out with their historic publication in which they said that this was the biggest drop in home lending since records began. I think that gives you a pretty clear score on the lending side. We saw a drop in loans to investors; yes, we did. We saw a drop in loans to owner-occupiers. We also saw a drop in loans to first home owners—apparently, the people who were supposed to be the great beneficiaries of this fantastical, magnificent, beautiful largesse from Canberra! So you've got lower loans to owner-occupiers, to first home owners and to investors. The Labor Party hates investors more than they want to solve the housing crisis; that is well established. But who knew that they hated first home owners so much? Who knew that they hated owner-occupiers this much? Who knew? Not I, and not anyone else. So you've got a massive collapse—in fact, the biggest and most historic collapse in home lending since records began. That's how good this budget is on that front.

Then we go to rents. The good doctor, when he was cooking up this crooked stew, said 'two bucks a week'—'two bucks'. In Sydney, already, we're seeing rents increasing by up to 200 bucks. So there you go: he's failed on rents; he's failed on loans.

But maybe the biggest of them all is that he's failed on supply. Now, I imagine that most people in this place are of sound mind. I imagine that's the case—even as to the members of the government. I believe they're of sound mind, at some level. But I have to say I was scratching my head on budget night, when I saw in the budget papers that these tax measures would reduce housing supply by 35,000 dwellings. I thought to myself: 'Why would we want to reduce dwellings by one, let alone by 35,000? Something is awry over on the government benches. They've been down to Treasury, down at Langton Crescent, and they've had too much punch, and something's happened!' But that's what the budget papers say. They want to reduce housing supply by 35,000, because they hate investors more than they want to build houses for Australians. And that is in their budget papers.

But, when you look at the industry analysis, it all stacks up. The industry agrees: there will be 35,000 fewer houses, but it will be more than 35,000; it will be more like 50,000 over the 10-year period.

What's more, when the government did the deal to pass their stinking budget through this Senate, they did a deal with the Greens to stop SMSFs from investing in new houses. So, the doc—the good doc; I'm trying to be generous here, Deputy President—

Comments

No comments