This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Matters of Urgency

Fossil Fuel Industry


Paul Scarr

Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party

5:25 pm

Senator McKim has submitted a proposal under standing order 75 today. It is shown as item 13 on today's order of business:

That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:

The need for the Australian Government to ensure Australians receive a fair return from the nation's natural resources, noting that Australians have missed out on an estimated $135 billion in revenue over the past 14 years following Labor's decision to abandon its proposed Resource Super Profits Tax in the face of a mining industry scare campaign.

Is consideration of the proposal supported?

More than the number of senators required by the standing orders having risen in their places—

It is supported. With the concurrence of the Senate, the Clerk will set the clock in line with the informal arrangements made by the whips.

Steph Hodgins-May

Steph Hodgins-May Victoria, Australian Greens

5:26 pm

I move:

That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:

The need for the Australian Government to ensure Australians receive a fair return from the nation's natural resources, noting that Australians have missed out on an estimated $135 billion in revenue over the past 14 years following Labor's decision to abandon its proposed Resource Super Profits Tax in the face of a mining industry scare campaign.

Today we have been able to put a figure on Labor's decades-long capitulation to the fossil fuel industry, and that figure is $135 billion. Labor has learned absolutely nothing from the mining industry's campaign to kill the Resource Super Profits Tax. More than a decade later, we are watching the exact same playbook unfold, and Albanese is letting these fossil fuel producers get away with it again and again and again. Every time we talk about getting a fair share of Australia's resources for Australians, the fossil fuel lobby runs the same tired scare campaign—the same talking points that we hear reiterated by the corporate parties in this place, the corporate parties being Labor, the Liberals and One Nation. We hear the fossil fuel lobby stamp their feet and threaten investment. We hear them threaten jobs. They warn that the sky will fall in if we tax them and make them pay what they owe. Well, then we see Labor capitulate, as they have done on the gas tax.

The mining industry spent $22 million on an advertising campaign to kill Prime Minister Rudd's Resource Super Profits Tax back in 2010. You know, $22 million sounds like a lot of money to people out there listening in. But what an extraordinary return on investment for the fossil fuel industry when it saved $135 billion. Twenty-two million bucks is loose change for these guys. It's a couple of lunches for their mates. And what does Australia get out of this deal? What do Australians get out of this deal? Nothing. It's nothing like the fair return that we would have if we received a fair share for our finite natural resources.

The PBO, the Parliamentary Budget Office, has now estimated that the original Resource Super Profits Tax would have delivered $135 billion to government revenue between 2012 and 2026, had it gone ahead. That's $135 billion that could have gone into investing in things to actually make people's lives better. Just imagine what that amount of money could deliver for Australians: universal early education—let's make it free education from early childhood through to university, like it used to be; a properly funded NDIS; cheaper, cleaner, more secure energy; electrification of our homes and businesses; public housing; proper investment in our hospitals and schools; and money back into the pockets of everyday Australians doing it tough. But, instead, this $135 billion stays in the pockets of some of the world's biggest and richest mining corporations.

Meanwhile, we hear this Labor government saying that there are going to be cuts in this upcoming budget—that we need to tighten our purse strings, that we need to count our pennies. They want an austerity budget at the same time as they are leaving billions on the table for these resource corporations, often multinational corporations, to feed their bottom line and to fatten their purse. We are today watching this exact same playbook happen on gas and a gas export tax. The gas industry spent $11 million campaigning against a 25 per cent gas export tax—same scare campaign, same empty threats, same vested interests. And it turns out that, once again, this Labor government is too timid and unwilling to stand up to them, stare them down and say, 'You pay what you owe for Australia's resources.'

The government tells us there's not enough money to have nice things, essential things. Apparently there's no extra money for early childhood education, there's no money for public housing, there's no money to properly fund the NDIS and there is no money to help people get off expensive gas. Well, we say bulldust. There is always enough money for this government to continue to subsidise the fossil fuel industry, but never enough to give Australians their fair share. The Australian people are sick of being told to tighten their belts, to tighten their purse strings, when this money is being left on the table.

If you want to know what corporate capture looks like, it is this; this is corporate capture. This is a fossil fuel industry funding our major parties, our 'corporate parties', through donations, offering them jobs after they finish in this place and fighting any reform that will help Australians live better lives. Australian Labor keeps falling for it—or, more perhaps more accurately, keeps choosing to fall for it. Tax our resources and make Australians' lives better. (Time expired)

Susan McDonald

Susan McDonald Queensland, National Party, Shadow Minister for Resources and Northern Australia

5:31 pm

Once again, we're going to have another debate with people who don't understand how the world works or how economies work. For the five millionth time, I'm going to go through it. The Greens political party is not interested in running a successful economy that allows Australians to live a first-world lifestyle, as we have for generations. Instead, they are interested in the complete destruction of our resources sector and our economy, and are happy to spend money ahead of receiving it. We talk about scare campaigns; we hear a lot about them from the Greens. Well, Australia should be incredibly worried; what would happen if the Greens ever got near the Treasury benches? One of the only truths in this chamber is that if a Greens member is talking about the economy, you can be pretty sure it will be the end of that economy. They are trying to make Australians poorer, and this is one more example of how this works. This is a wholehearted campaign by the Greens against our mining sector that pays billions of dollars into the economy every year.

The Greens talk about missed revenue. Well, let's talk about what the actual revenue is. The mining industry has paid $255.1 billion in capital expenditure over the last 10 years in Australia. The Australian mining industry has paid $432.2 billion in company taxes and royalties over the past 10 years. That is real revenue—the billions of dollars of Australian wages and salaries, more than double what the average wage and salary in Australia is, paid by resources companies to Australians. That then floods into other businesses around Australia—small businesses, boating and camping, fishing, motorbikes, jet skis and all other sorts of interesting and fun things—and it is thanks to wages and salaries from the mining sector.

What would have been missed if the mining tax was kept? The proposed resources super profits tax was fundamentally flawed. It would have undermined investor confidence, threatened Australia's competitiveness and created significant uncertainty for an industry that is one of the largest contributors to our national prosperity. We can point to other jurisdictions that went down exactly the same socialist road. Argentina, a country that is now clawing its way back into the world economy, is fighting desperately to be competitive for attracting investment into its resources sector, its gas sector and, indeed, its beef sector. The claim that Australians have missed out on $135 billion is based on some hypothetical calculation of revenue that may have been collected, but it conveniently ignores the potential economic consequence of the tax and of the investment that would have fled the economy.

What about an analysis of the terms of trade impact, of what that tax would have done to Australia? Do you enjoy buying a well-priced motor vehicle that was manufactured overseas, a well-priced TV that was manufactured overseas or a well-priced fridge that was manufactured overseas? All of those things would not have been possible without the fantastic terms of trade that Australia enjoys because of, primarily, mining and gas and, to a lesser extent, agricultural exports. It is the giants of mining and gas that ensure that we can enjoy that First World lifestyle.

Our resources sector supports hundreds of thousands of Australian jobs, particularly in regional and remote communities. It underpins local businesses. It creates opportunities for workers and apprentices. It supports regional infrastructure and contributes significant revenue through company tax royalties and other taxes. It is the Australian resources sector that is the largest funder of environmental measurement and management in this country. Australians benefit when our resources sector is successful, and our focus should be on maintaining our high-quality resources sector, our high standards of workplace health and safety, our high environmental standards and all the contributions they make to Australians and to the First World lifestyle that we have. We should be encouraging resource companies and supporting them here in Australia, not revisiting a failed tax that would have put all of that at risk—or, worse, introducing a new one.

Lisa Darmanin

Lisa Darmanin Victoria, Australian Labor Party

5:36 pm

In considering this urgency motion from Senator McKim, I think it's important to put some facts on the record. Australia has a profits based tax applying to offshore petroleum projects, the petroleum resource rent tax or the PRRT. The PRRT taxes excess profits from offshore petroleum projects at a rate of 40 per cent after allowing projects to recover their costs and achieve an appropriate return on their investment. Since coming to government, Labor has strengthened that system to ensure LNG projects pay more tax and pay it sooner. We also introduced a cap on the deductions LNG projects can use to offset their PRRT liability in any one year. Once a project becomes liable for PRRT, accumulated deductions can no longer be used to completely eliminate that liability. We have also reformed the way gas transfer pricing is calculated and strengthened the PRRT's anti-avoidance rules, bringing those arrangements into line with the broader tax integrity framework.

Those reforms have already resulted in an additional $1.2 billion being collected from LNG projects, and the contributions of the resource sector extend well beyond the PRRT. Senator McDonald outlined some of those, including some of the numbers, but I'll add a couple more. In 2022-2023, the resources sector contributed nearly a third of all company tax paid in Australia, amounting to $47.3 billion. Of that, mining contributed $37.8 billion and the oil and gas sector contributed $10.4 billion. Treasury forecasts from MYEFO 2025-26 in December last year showed that the PRRT alone will raise $5.4 billion in receipts over the next four years from 2025-26. At the state and territory level, around $22 billion in royalties was received from the resources sector in 2024-25.

I think it's worth having the full picture when we debate the return Australians receive from their natural resources, and I do agree with Senator McKim's sentiment on the motion that Australians should receive a fair return on our natural resources. That is why this government is also acting directly on the domestic supply of gas. Australian gas should work for the Australian people. We have abundant gas resources, and Australians rightly expect reliable access to those resources at a reasonable price. That is why the government's domestic gas reservation legislation package is designed to address this. The proposition is straightforward: where exporters benefit from Australian gas resources, they also have a responsibility to contribute to meeting Australia's domestic needs.

Under the legislation, gas exporters will be required to make sufficient gas resources available to the Australian market before exporting gas overseas. This has not been developed in isolation. The government's 2024 Future Gas Strategy recognised that gas will continue to play a role through the transition to net zero, including as a peaking and firming capacity to support renewables and in industrial uses where alternatives are not yet readily available. It also made clear that gas must remain affordable for Australian users through that transition. The gas market review then considered the longer term settings for Australia's gas market. Its final report, released in December 2025, found that those settings needed to evolve, and recommended establishing a domestic gas reservation scheme. The government has subsequently worked through the design of that scheme so it can respond to changing economic and supply circumstances, rather than operate as a blunt instrument.

Australians absolutely should expect a fair return from the resources that they own. That means making sure resource companies pay their fair share of tax. It means protecting the integrity of the tax system. It also means making sure Australians have access to the resources produced here. The government has strengthened the PRRT so LNG producers pay more tax and pay it sooner. We have strengthened integrity rules and we are now putting in place a domestic gas reservation scheme to ensure Australia's gas resources also contribute to Australia's domestic needs. Rather than rehearse a debate from 14 years ago, this government is focused on what will make a practical difference now—ensuring LNG producers pay more tax, pay it sooner, strengthen the integrity of our tax system and ensure Australian gas is available to meet Australian needs.

Fatima Payman

Fatima Payman WA, Australia's Voice

5:41 pm

A teacher earning $100,000 a year pays more than $20,000 in income tax. They don't get to negotiate that obligation with the Treasurer. When governments ask multinational resource companies to contribute fairly from their profits, suddenly the rules are up for negotiation. We have families struggling to pay their bills, underpaid teachers, overstretched hospitals, and communities waiting for essential childhood education and care facilities and infrastructure that this government promised them. Australians are drowning. But, in the meantime, we see enormous profits continue to flow offshore, with Rio and BHP alone reporting approximately $35 billion in profits this year.

Sixteen years ago, the Labor government proposed a resource superprofits tax but backed down under pressure from the resources lobby. Today Parliamentary Budget Office analysis estimates that, had the original tax been introduced and maintained, Australia's budget could be $135 billion better off. Imagine what that money could have meant to Australian families, and imagine where we'll be in another 16 years if we continue to reject measures like a 25 per cent tax on excess gas export profits—still telling parents struggling with childcare fees that we can't afford to help, still cutting disability and support services, still failing to deliver meaningful relief for renters, still putting our climate targets at risk to protect the profits of fossil fuel companies and still asking the most vulnerable Australians to make sacrifices while multinational corporations extract billions from our natural resources. Every dollar we fail to collect from our natural resources is a dollar we cannot invest in the Australian people, and the people deserve better.

Richard Dowling

Richard Dowling Tasmania, Australian Labor Party

5:43 pm

Well, there's one part of this motion that I do agree with. Australians do deserve a fair return from the natural resources they own. But everything else beyond that causes some issues. We hear that Australia somehow missed out on $135 billion from a tax that never existed. This is not money collected and it's not money guaranteed. If we look at the PBO work, it's actually an estimate of what might have happened, assuming no change to investment, production or prices. So it's effectively hypothetical revenue from a hypothetical scenario, and nobody should be fooled otherwise. Have a look at the PBO's own work. It's a purely hypothetical scenario; nevertheless, the Greens have already gone ahead and spent the money.

Since the Greens want to go back many years and revisit history, I think we should go back to 2009, when Labor in fact proposed an emissions trading scheme—a price on carbon pollution that would reduce emissions and raise billions through the sale of permits. Treasury estimated back then that around $13 billion in permanent revenue in 2012-13 alone would have been raised, with much of those billions supporting households and businesses. At that time, what did the Greens do? They voted with the coalition against an emissions trading scheme. Apparently it wasn't ambitious enough, and, instead of getting a carbon price, Australia got no scheme at all. They demanded perfection and achieved nothing. Now, 17 years later, they're lecturing the Senate about the revenue Australia might have collected from a tax. The Greens suddenly have a very selective interest in missed economic opportunities.

Let's return to this latest proposal. It is a 25 per cent tax on gas exports, which they claim will raise $17 billion a year, and, my word, they've been busy spending it—dental care, mental health, housing, schools, free university, student debt, solar panels, batteries. That $17 billion hasn't even been collected yet, but it's already visited the dentist, paid off its HECS debt, bought a house and installed solar panels. It's the hardest working money in Australia, especially considering it doesn't even exist. There's a rather significant problem: the Greens want to phase out the very industry they're proposing to tax; their policy calls for fossil fuel exports to cease. So the plan is simple—tax the gas, spend the revenue, stop exporting the gas and somehow keep spending the revenue. I've got news: 25 per cent of zero is zero. They've tried the same trick in Tasmania as well. The Tasmanian Greens have proposed $108 million a year from taxing salmon farming. Meanwhile, Senator McKim and his Tasmanian colleagues want salmon farms moved out of state waters. Apparently, fish can leave the water but the revenue is expected to keep swimming.

Underneath the comedy is a serious economic problem. The Greens want to fund permanent public services with revenue from industries they're determined to close. Schools, hospitals and dental care need funding long after the Greens finish their press conference. You cannot build a sustainable budget around a revenue stream you've promised to abolish. Labor understands that economic reality. That is why we have strengthened the petroleum resource rent tax. In 2024-25, oil and gas companies paid $10.6 billion in company tax, with another $1.9 billion in petroleum resource rent tax payable. That is real revenue from real economic activity.

We're also proposing the domestic gas reservation to improve supply and put downward pressure on prices for Australian households and manufacturers. In fact, I've just returned from Japan, where our partners made very clear how much they value Australia as a reliable energy supplier. We've been supplying gas to Japan since the 1960s, and a shipment has not been missed. We are one of the most reliable suppliers in the world, and that is why we can command premium prices for our exports. We should not forget those factors as we consider how we capture the most from our resources. These decisions have consequences for investment, jobs, international relationships and household budgets. The Greens can promise the revenue, promise the spending and promise to abolish the industry all at the same time, all before lunchtime. That's not a budget; it's a magic trick, and eventually Australians will be left holding the empty hat.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

5:48 pm

We've now got a small insight into how different the world would be if the Labor Party actually had a backbone and was willing to do what the Australian public have been demanding, which is govern for them, not govern for their vested interests and the one per cent. The Greens asked the Parliamentary Budget Office to work out how much revenue the Australian public would have received if the tax reforms on the resource sector that Kevin Rudd proposed and put in place for a very brief period of time 14 years ago had actually been held on to and hadn't been undermined and ratted by the Gillard government and then entirely gutted by the coalition.

How much revenue has been lost because Labor got rolled internally by the resources industry and then the coalition came over and did the coup de grace on good policy? It's $135 billion in lost revenue because Labor did not and does not have a backbone. At least 14 years ago the Labor Party was willing to have a look at getting some of the public wealth back from these largely multinational corporations that are getting access to public resources. Remember, every tonne of iron ore, every megajoule of gas, every gram of gold, every tonne of aluminium, are all public resources—public resources that corporations get a licence for access to then dig up and flog off. And of course, the Labor Party, their mates in the coalition and their mates in One Nation, are quite happy for the public to have these resources stolen and get nothing back.

But now we know, and I really want to credit Senator Hodgins-May for pushing this issue, for finding out the answers and for getting this result. Lost revenue of $135 billion is an extraordinary amount. Now, you may only buy two of Labor's AUKUS submarines or one of the coalition's extraordinary gifts that they want to give to corporate Australia. But I'll tell you what it would build. It would build a world-class hospital system. It would build extraordinary public schools. It would build the core infrastructure we need to have publicly owned, incredibly low-cost renewable energy being pumped into everyone's home. That's what $135 billion would build.

But what have we got Labor doing now? Roll on 14 years, and they've lost $135 billion because they had the backbone-removal exercise. What have we got now? Well, now we've got Prime Minister Albanese and his Treasurer, Jim Chalmers, getting ready to make a substantial package of cuts and an austerity budget. And who's in Labor's sights right now? Is it the export gas industry? No, they're getting away—no export gas tax, $17 billion lost a year. Is it the resource sector, who are making record profits? No. Who's in the line of sight for Labor in this budget? Pensioners, people with disability, migrants—that's who Labor's going after.

We've just seen some of the impacts of Labor gutting the NDIS. The analysis has come out, and we see that there have been 120,000 children being kicked off the NDIS because of Labor's changes. That's what it's going to mean. They're overwhelmingly boys from disadvantaged backgrounds that are getting the biggest cuts. Labor's getting its budget savings from boys from disadvantaged backgrounds with disability—that's who. That's who Labor are getting their budget savings from, because they won't take on the export gas industry, because they won't take on the resource sector.

Rather than another round of austerity, the Greens have identified billions of dollars of revenue that the government could have. Why don't you knock off the $16.3 billion a year you're giving fossil fuel subsidies to the resource sector? Why don't you join with the Greens and get rid of the tax perks and the tax breaks you give to billionaires, who are getting $640 million a year in tax subsidies when they fill up their private jets? They pay one-fifteenth of what an ordinary motorist pays in tax per litre. Join with us. But no, you're too happy to be giving Senator Hanson $174 every time she fills up her private jet or $3,000 every time your mate Clive Palmer fills up their jet. This is not the time for austerity; this is the time to be backing in Australians and Australian families.

VB

Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens

5:53 pm

Fossil fuel corporations are taking taxpayers for a ride. By not paying a fair tax on the resources that they extract, fossil fuel corporations have deprived taxpayers of receiving cost-of-living relief and the services that they need and deserve. By using and abusing insolvency laws, they also make taxpayers pay billions of dollars cleaning up the mess that these massive fossil fuel corporations leave in our oceans. There are currently 6,000 kilotons of oil and gas infrastructure sitting in our oceans. They're all going to have to be cleaned up. The cost: $60 billion. Now, onshore mining companies have to pay a bond to clean up after themselves when they finish digging holes in the ground. Renters have to pay a bond in case they don't clean up after themselves when they move out of the house that they have been renting. But we just want to give big, polluting corporations operating offshore oil and gas rigs a free ride on the taxpayer.

This federal Labor government has been promising that it will make laws requiring these big, offshore, polluting corporations to pay a bond to clean up after themselves so that we do not have toxic junk left in our ocean, polluting it and killing our marine wildlife. Where is it? A company that used insolvency laws to walk away before it had to clean up its offshore junk is now being given the money to clean up the junk by this federal Labor government from the taxpayer's pocket. We keep on being told that there isn't the money to fund the services we deserve and government departments keep being asked to find savings. We wouldn't be in this situation if the government grew a backbone and told fossil fuel corporations to stop taking taxpayers for a ride.

Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

The question is that the motion moved by Senator McKim be agreed to.