This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Matters of Urgency

Fossil Fuel Industry


Richard Dowling

Richard Dowling Tasmania, Australian Labor Party

5:43 pm

Well, there's one part of this motion that I do agree with. Australians do deserve a fair return from the natural resources they own. But everything else beyond that causes some issues. We hear that Australia somehow missed out on $135 billion from a tax that never existed. This is not money collected and it's not money guaranteed. If we look at the PBO work, it's actually an estimate of what might have happened, assuming no change to investment, production or prices. So it's effectively hypothetical revenue from a hypothetical scenario, and nobody should be fooled otherwise. Have a look at the PBO's own work. It's a purely hypothetical scenario; nevertheless, the Greens have already gone ahead and spent the money.

Since the Greens want to go back many years and revisit history, I think we should go back to 2009, when Labor in fact proposed an emissions trading scheme—a price on carbon pollution that would reduce emissions and raise billions through the sale of permits. Treasury estimated back then that around $13 billion in permanent revenue in 2012-13 alone would have been raised, with much of those billions supporting households and businesses. At that time, what did the Greens do? They voted with the coalition against an emissions trading scheme. Apparently it wasn't ambitious enough, and, instead of getting a carbon price, Australia got no scheme at all. They demanded perfection and achieved nothing. Now, 17 years later, they're lecturing the Senate about the revenue Australia might have collected from a tax. The Greens suddenly have a very selective interest in missed economic opportunities.

Let's return to this latest proposal. It is a 25 per cent tax on gas exports, which they claim will raise $17 billion a year, and, my word, they've been busy spending it—dental care, mental health, housing, schools, free university, student debt, solar panels, batteries. That $17 billion hasn't even been collected yet, but it's already visited the dentist, paid off its HECS debt, bought a house and installed solar panels. It's the hardest working money in Australia, especially considering it doesn't even exist. There's a rather significant problem: the Greens want to phase out the very industry they're proposing to tax; their policy calls for fossil fuel exports to cease. So the plan is simple—tax the gas, spend the revenue, stop exporting the gas and somehow keep spending the revenue. I've got news: 25 per cent of zero is zero. They've tried the same trick in Tasmania as well. The Tasmanian Greens have proposed $108 million a year from taxing salmon farming. Meanwhile, Senator McKim and his Tasmanian colleagues want salmon farms moved out of state waters. Apparently, fish can leave the water but the revenue is expected to keep swimming.

Underneath the comedy is a serious economic problem. The Greens want to fund permanent public services with revenue from industries they're determined to close. Schools, hospitals and dental care need funding long after the Greens finish their press conference. You cannot build a sustainable budget around a revenue stream you've promised to abolish. Labor understands that economic reality. That is why we have strengthened the petroleum resource rent tax. In 2024-25, oil and gas companies paid $10.6 billion in company tax, with another $1.9 billion in petroleum resource rent tax payable. That is real revenue from real economic activity.

We're also proposing the domestic gas reservation to improve supply and put downward pressure on prices for Australian households and manufacturers. In fact, I've just returned from Japan, where our partners made very clear how much they value Australia as a reliable energy supplier. We've been supplying gas to Japan since the 1960s, and a shipment has not been missed. We are one of the most reliable suppliers in the world, and that is why we can command premium prices for our exports. We should not forget those factors as we consider how we capture the most from our resources. These decisions have consequences for investment, jobs, international relationships and household budgets. The Greens can promise the revenue, promise the spending and promise to abolish the industry all at the same time, all before lunchtime. That's not a budget; it's a magic trick, and eventually Australians will be left holding the empty hat.

Comments

No comments