This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Motions

Statute Update Bill 2026


Susan McDonald

Susan McDonald Queensland, National Party, Shadow Minister for Resources and Northern Australia

3:03 pm

I seek leave to move a motion relating to the consideration of Senate amendments to the Statute Update Bill 2026, as circulated.

Leave not granted.

Pursuant to contingent notice of motion and at the request of Senator McKenzie, I move:

That so much of the standing orders be suspended as would prevent me moving a motion to provide for the consideration of a matter, namely a motion to give precedence to a motion relating to the consideration of Senate amendments to the Statute Update Bill 2026.

I rise today because this matter is urgent, and our veterans should not have to wait any longer for certainty about their health care. This Senate has already considered the issue. The Australian people expect that, when a chamber of this parliament votes on legislation, that decision is given proper consideration and acted upon. They do not expect legislation to simply be left sitting on someone's desk, unresolved and gathering dust. That is not how this parliament is supposed to operate. Australians elect us to do a job, and that job is to scrutinise legislation, make decisions and see the parliamentary process through.

It has heard the concerns of veterans, considered the evidence and voted on amendments to protect veterans from arbitrary monetary restrictions on their allied health treatments. These amendments were agreed to by this Senate on 10 September. Yet, more than two months later, they remain unresolved in the House of Representatives. The question before us is simple: why should the Senate allow any further delay? Our veterans have served our country with courage, with commitment and with distinction. They have put their lives on the line to protect the freedoms and ways of life that Australians enjoy. The very least they should expect in return is a government that respects their service and delivers the support that they need.

But what we have seen is a troubling pattern from the Albanese government. Decisions affecting veterans are announced, defended and then reversed after significant public pressure. We saw it with the proposed 20-year time limit on retrospective military honours. We saw it when funding was cut to Invictus Australia, an organisation supporting injured and disabled veterans through sport. We saw it when travel support was withdrawn from Kaye and Doug Baird, the parents of Corporal Cameron Baird VC. And my reason for standing here today: we saw it with the proposed $5,000 annual threshold for veterans' allied health treatment. Each time veterans and their families were forced to speak up and to fight to have their concerns heard.

The $5,000 threshold is particularly concerning because it goes directly to veterans' access to health care. Veterans have made their concerns very clear. The Senate Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade References Committee also examined the issue and recommended that the Australian government consider legislative amendments to protect veterans from arbitrary monetary and numerical restrictions on treatment. Even Labor senators acknowledged the government's decision not to proceed with the proposed annual monetary limit.

This Senate subsequently acted and agreed to amendments to the Statute Update Bill 2026 on 10 September. These amendments are about a very straightforward principle: a veteran's health care should be determined by their clinical needs, not arbitrary financial thresholds or expenditure triggered, bureaucratic restrictions. And this is precisely why this matter cannot continue to sit unresolved.

Here we are on 17 November, and those amendments remain outstanding. What exactly are we waiting for? If the government supports protecting veterans from arbitrary restrictions, it should have no difficulty progressing this matter. And, if it disagrees with the amendments, then it should explain why. But what it cannot do is leave veterans in a state of uncertainty while the matter sits unresolved. That is the urgency before us today. This is not a request for another inquiry, another consultation or another government announcement; it is a request for the Senate to act on a matter that has already been considered and to ensure the House of Representatives is held to its commitment to honour these amendments. There is no reason to allow this to drift into another sitting period. We ask for certainty that this be dealt with this year. There is no reason to make veterans wait any longer for clarity about the protections this parliament intends to provide. It is about trust. (Time expired)

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

3:09 pm

The Greens very much support this suspension, and we support the substantive motion. We don't think it's a laughing matter; we think it's important that veterans get the protection that the Senate endeavoured to give to them.

We know why the government are opposing this motion, and we know why they refuse to move on the amendments that the Senate put into the legislation. Whatever they say, at any one moment, about veterans, they seem to be unwilling to back it up with clear legislation to make sure veterans are protected and that they won't do another sly job to try and put unfair caps and unfair limitations on the medical and treatment needs that veterans have—because that's what the Senate said. We saw what this government did. We saw what Labor had proposed to do with veterans, without consulting with the veterans community—putting arbitrary, unfair, damaging caps on veterans.

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Government Senators:

Government senators interjecting—

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

The hypocrisy of this lot, who complain about interjections! They complain about interjections unless they're doing it themselves. Have you ever noticed that? These Labor ministers complain about interjections unless they're throwing it themselves. Their total hypocrisy is here for everybody to see. Everybody can see it.

Slade Brockman

Slade Brockman Deputy-President

Order! Senator Shoebridge has a right to be heard.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

I know Labor doesn't want this discussion. I know they're trying to do everything they can. They refused leave. They could have agreed to give leave to have this debate in an orderly way, but they are so desperate to avoid talking about their ugly attack on veterans rights, their decision to go and put arbitrary, unfair, damaging caps on the medical and other support that veterans could have, without ever talking to the veterans community—without ever having the courage to go and talk to the veterans communities and say to them, to their faces: 'Oh, guys, thanks so much for the service. Thanks so much for putting on the uniform. We're actually, now, going to dud you and put arbitrary caps on.' Is it any wonder they didn't have that conversation with veterans? We know what veterans would have said: 'How dare you?'

Then, when you did it—you did it in a dirty backroom deal inside the Labor Party—veterans came out and said, 'How dare you?' And it turns out that the veterans have a far better sense of where community sentiment lies than the Labor Party has, because the community hated what you did, and they were willing to back in the veterans every single time. They have no time for your nasty way of making budget savings on the backs of the people who most need help. That's all it was—it was a $1.5 billion budget saving you wanted to get from not giving essential medical care to veterans. And, when the Senate puts in place legal protections to say, 'You can never do it again,' you leave it parked in the other place and you refuse even to move on it. You put it into some kind of purgatory in the other house, refusing to move on it, because you don't want to commit to legal protections for veterans and their benefits.

What this motion is saying is: 'Pull it out of purgatory. Have a vote on it.' If it really is the Labor Party's position that you won't put in place clear legal protections to stop you from doing it again to veterans, well, have the guts to bring it on for a vote down in the other place, and then let's see how you get judged. Not by the Greens, not by the National Party—let's see how you get judged by the Australian public if you have another go like this at veterans. Put the legislation to a vote down there. Have the courage next time to talk to veterans before you pickpocket them and take away their benefits, and move on that piece of legislation.

The Senate made it clear—I think every single senator in this place, except for the Labor senators, wrapped themselves around that and said they supported it. We've made it clear. And I'll tell you why we made it clear. It was because we heard from the Australian public that Labor's plans for veterans were toxic—they were wrong, they were nasty, and they were going to harm veterans. So move on the legislation, and have the courage to either vote it up or vote it down.

Katy Gallagher

Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service

3:14 pm

Well, that was quite a speech from Senator Shoebridge—most of it misleading, as we've come to expect in this chamber. Honestly, to take a lecture from Senator Shoebridge, who uses every opportunity to criticise our defence forces—in every estimates hearing, in every committee hearing I have ever sat in, he has been a deep critic. If he doesn't think that translates into veterans—you do know that veterans actually work for the Defence Force that you criticise before they retire, Senator Shoebridge? Don't have a foot in each camp. One minute you're the leader of the Greens, the next minute you're a member of the coalition. That's what we're seeing play out in this chamber.

I won't be lectured by Senator Shoebridge about the extra investment, $16 billion, that we as a government have put into supporting veterans. Go back and have a look at the budget papers, Senator Shoebridge. It is $16 billion extra that has gone into supporting veterans in their post-ADF career. Don't come in here and call us the names you've called us. When we came to government, there were over 40,000 veterans claims sitting—oh, yes, that's what you do, Senator Shoebridge. You come here and you have a spray, most of it misleading, and then you walk away. You walk away because you can't handle the facts, which are that we, as the government, have invested more in veterans care and support than any government, in the time that we have been in power, because of the mess that we inherited—40,000 veterans not even having their claims processed. What have we done? We've invested in the department, they've dealt with the claims and $16 billion has flowed, quite rightly, to veterans for the claims that those opposite kept on the shelf.

In relation to the allied health reforms that we sought to put in place, we did two things: we increased the fees being paid to allied health practitioners in response to allied health practitioners seeking an increase in those arrangements; and we sought to reform an area that is growing considerably and continues to—and, as finance minister, I have a responsibility to keep an eye on that. We have responded to the views of the Senate, and we have been clear and Minister Keogh has been clear—and it was talked through with veterans. All that Senator Shoebridge says—and for those listening: when he gives a speech like that, go and do a fact check on it, because most of it isn't factually correct.

We put out a public statement saying we will not proceed with those changes. That is on the public record. The finalisation of that will be clear through the budget update, as we make those reforms clear, but it has been made public. This motion is not needed because we are not pursuing the changes we sought, because the Senate said no. We've listened to the Senate. We have made a public statement. We are adjusting the costs. We are increasing funding to veterans on top of the $16 billion we have already provided into that very important area to support veterans in their post-serving careers, for the supports they need. That is the position of this government. To pretend otherwise—and I can't listen to that spray from Senator Shoebridge without responding to it, because most of it is factually incorrect. You should be sitting over there, Senator Shoebridge, with some of the positions that you bring into this chamber; one minute you're this, and the next minute you're that.

Sometimes, responding to some challenges requires difficult decisions. We've heard the Senate on the veterans reforms that we sought. We are not proceeding with them. That is on the public record. The minister has responded. Adjustments will be made through the budget process, as we have to do, to respond to that decision. There is no need to suspend standing orders and there is no need for this motion to go to the House.

Anne Ruston

Anne Ruston SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Health and Aged Care

3:19 pm

The reason why this is so urgent is that, despite the minister's protestations that when the government say something we should take them at their word, their history proves that when they say something they have to be forced into actually putting their word into action. You went to the last election promising no new taxes and no increases in taxes. Subsequent to that, you've actually gone and increased taxes. We saw them all at the budget. You say, 'You heard the Senate.' Well, did you hear the Senate when the Senate said you needed to put a human back in charge, put human override back in charge, of the aged-care algorithm? You didn't, because the bill's parked down there, alongside the veterans allied health bill, in the other place. So I think it is a little disingenuous for the minister to stand there and say that we shouldn't be doing this because they 'can be taken at their word', because the government keeps ignoring the will of the Senate. The government keeps ignoring the bills that are sent down to the other place, where it has the numbers. What they say and what they do are often two very, very different things. The reality is that this government, time and time and time again, has proved that it cannot be taken at its word. So to come in here and stand up and make the comments that the minister just made—I think that maybe it should be her that's going and checking the record for the accuracy of the actions that have been taken, because you'll find it is the Labor government that is the one that cannot be trusted to keep its word.

And this is really urgent because, when you consider it, the people that are impacted by the refusal of the government to accept the will of the Senate on so many different occasions are some of the most vulnerable in our society. We are talking about people who are veterans, who often are requiring this allied health support because of injuries that they've sustained in combat. To take that away—and then the minister comes in and starts waffling on about some other thing that they've done in veteran affairs. The reality is that their cruel action was to take away the opportunity for our veterans, our serving veterans, to get the health care that they need quite often as a result of the injuries that they received serving our nation in combat. What sort of government thinks that veterans should be paying the price for its budget mismanagement?

Another instance is the private health insurance rebate for over-65s. This is a government who thinks pensioners, age pensioners, should be paying the price for its budget mismanagement and the need for it to try and rectify its budget. Once again, the will of this Senate said it did not want that particular bill to proceed. It was discharged from the Notice Paper. What is the government doing? Apparently, they don't hear what the Senate has to say, because the bill has been reintroduced in the other place and, no doubt, will turn up here again. So don't, Minister, come into this place and tell us that you have heard what the Senate said, because all you do when you hear what the Senate says is ignore it.

Another piece of legislation, as I said—the aged-care algorithm, for older Australians, people who need care, who are towards the end of their lives and are needing care in order to remain in a dignified environment as they age. You have put a computer in charge of making the final decision about the care that they need and the urgency with which they receive that care. Even the Ombudsman was completely damning of that proposal and the fact that you're doing that. So we moved a bill in here. It passed this Senate with the support of everybody in the chamber, apart from the government. Where is it? It's languishing down in the other place, alongside the veterans allied health bill and where the private health insurance rebate bill for over-65s is sitting.

So I think it is pretty disingenuous for the government to stand up here and spray everybody in the chamber for wanting to make sure that a very serious issue is dealt with. In another classic example, we had to force you to get rid of your widows tax. You said you were going to get rid of the widows tax. But, once again, that is what you say, and then you just leave it and do not fix it. We had to force you through legislative means to actually get rid of the widows tax. What this seeks to do today—what Senator McDonald is seeking to do today—is actually force you into doing what you have promised to do, because, quite frankly, your refusal to ever do anything that you promise to do is the reason that this Senate has to force you into doing it.

Ross Cadell

Ross Cadell NSW, National Party, Shadow Minister for Water

3:24 pm

This government shows that a promise of something means nothing to it, because what we have here is a government that got wedged. They were going to wear the criticism. They were going to wear the veterans laying the medals down out the front. They were going to witness the veterans coming in here. We had people like John Armfield, Dr Tim Nelson, Julie-Ann Finney and Marc Diplock—all those people—coming here and telling their stories. We had Sean Smith. When I go back to the Hunter, I see Ruth Rogers. At the funeral of Brett Wild, a person who championed the Branxton to Greta memorial walk, I met people who told me that they wouldn't be on this planet if it weren't for the allied health services. This government was going to wear that until the Senate came together—until the Liberal Party, the National Party, the Greens and the crossbench, including Jacqui Lambie, with all the work that she did, got together and voted this down. There was a mechanism that found a way to put pressure on the government so they had to cave in.

Now they say, 'Trust us; we've got this.' Well, we can't trust them. These veterans, these people who signed up to put their lives at risk, can't trust them. We saw the great work done in the committee by Senator Jess Collins here, pointing this out and getting down to it. This was a budget saving of $748 million over the first three years and then $340 million a year after that. It was a budget line item. These people didn't matter. The reason the Senate must insist on sending this message, suspend standing orders and send this downstairs is to make sure we deliver certainty to these people, who deserve it. This is not a budget line item to those sitting around here and on the crossbench. This is an item about people. This is an issue about people—the people that we rely on, the people that trusted us to deliver for them and the people this government was ready to betray.

So that is why we are here. We've heard the evidence in the committee. We have seen the lobbying. We've seen the people coming here. We've seen the personal stories. We've heard the emotional things from families. We heard a personal story from veterans in this building, in this chamber. All they are asking for is the next step of certainty. Get it done. You can tell from the way those people are speaking today that, if it came back here, it would be insisted upon. We aren't backing down from this, because this Senate should never walk away from Australians who put their lives on the line for us. It's not a big ask. It is to reaffirm the decision we made not long ago, a few months ago, in September—I think it was 14 September. It is to say that, when the other place said, 'Oh, we'll make it a matter for the next sitting; we'll kick it down the path,' we remember what happened. They waited till the Thursday or Friday of that week, when parliament wasn't sitting, and said, 'We're going to fix it.' Well, we don't trust that. Australians don't trust it. The veterans who originally knew you promised to look after them and their health after their service can't trust it, because you were ready to renege on that promise.

So here we stand. I heard the conversations earlier pointing out how sad it is that we're up here and we're misrepresenting this and that. Everything is clear. It was in the budget papers: budget savings of $748 million in the first three years and $340 million a year after that. It was a savings measure that hurt people. So forgive us if we don't believe you when you get up here and say it's misrepresenting what the facts are, because they're clear. It was in the budget. People came here and protested. They lobbied. The public cried out. The veterans community rose up and said, 'Not good enough.' Even then, you were still wearing it. Even then, this government said: 'We can take pressure. It doesn't matter.' It was this Senate that found a way to finally make you see you have no way out. Now you're saying: 'Trust us again. We've still got it.' Well, we don't. Send this message. Have the lower house not review the bill as it originally was. Have them either accept it or put it up.

I don't believe there's been any consultation with the minister talking to the coalition, One Nation, the Greens or the crossbench about another way of doing this. You say it's dead, but what is another way of doing this? How do we know? How do we go forward? What we find time and time again is that what you say is not what happens. Even what you intend doesn't happen, even when you go there and we flip all the time. We mentioned the trust taxes. We mentioned increased taxes everywhere that you just pluck out of nowhere. A thought bubble comes all the time here.

So let's do the right thing by our veterans. Let's push this. The Senate stands united to look after Australians, because that is what we should do. To vote against this means nothing more than that you are still trying to be tricky.

Jessica Collins

Jessica Collins NSW, Liberal Party

3:29 pm

We are here. This is an urgent motion to be passed, yet for 12 sitting days it had been sitting there, over in the House, collecting dust. It's on such an important issue. We've seen, time and time again, this year, this government not standing by its veterans.

We have just chaired the inquiry into the allied health for veterans. Let me tell you what we found in there. The No. 1 recommendation that the committee made was:

The committee recommends that the Australian Government consider potential legislative amendments to protect veterans from arbitrary monetary and numerical restrictions on health treatment to ensure that care is provided according to clinical need.

It would mean that they could never do this again to our veterans.

We heard from the minister that this was just about money—that this was just about trying to find some budget savings. But these are the people that ticked that box to give their lives to our nation, for our freedom, and they're trying to find the savings from them!

We heard, through the committee, that the allied health system is actually a very, very complex system to go through. The time it takes for them to actually get the health care that they need—let alone the caps that this government put on them—can be up to 10 years. I had somebody tell me it took 10 years to get the health care that they needed. These are the people who, as I said, ticked that box for unlimited liability: 'I will lay down my life for this nation.' That's what they said. Their families ticked that box too. And this government wanted to take away the care that they needed. We still have a significant challenge with the allied care system for our veterans. The administrative burden on them, while they're coping with their physical and mental health challenges, makes their physical and health challenges only worse.

So we are standing here today to say to this government: 'Why are you still sitting on the Senate's request—the amendment that we made to the statutory bill that would protect our veterans from this cap?' We all know that this government didn't do any consultations on the cap. They did it. They thought they'd get away with it. It took veterans coming down to this parliament, to lay down the medals that they'd received, to send a message to the government, on behalf of the rest of the veterans around Australia, that this was not okay. What an extraordinary message to be sending to their government that they were prepared to lay down their lives for—to hand back their medals!

I have heard stories from these veterans—from a long line of generations of service to this country—that they're now telling their own children: 'Do not do it. Do not tick that box. Do not be prepared to lay down your life for this country, because this country, this government, will not have your back.' They have taken hit after hit after hit from this government, all year long: the cuts to funding for Corporal Baird's parents to go around and tell a story of courage and valour; the cuts to Invictus, an important program for our veterans.

Of course, let's not forget the selling of our defence estate and the spiritual home of the Army—an army that will be evicted from Victoria Barracks in a matter of weeks.

Slade Brockman

Slade Brockman Deputy-President

Senator Collins, the time for the debate has expired.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

The question is that the suspension motion be agreed to.

Susan McDonald

Susan McDonald Queensland, National Party, Shadow Minister for Resources and Northern Australia

3:41 pm

I move:

That a motion relating to the consideration of Senate amendments to the Statute Update Bill 2026 may be moved immediately, have precedence over all other business and be determined without amendment or debate.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

The question is that the motion moved by Senator McDonald be agreed to.

Susan McDonald

Susan McDonald Queensland, National Party, Shadow Minister for Resources and Northern Australia

3:44 pm

I move:

(1) That the Senate—

(a) notes that:

(i) on 10 September 2026, the Senate agreed to amendments to the Statute Update Bill 2026 to protect veterans from arbitrary monetary restrictions and expenditure-triggered barriers to allied-health treatment,

(ii) the bill and the Senate's amendments were returned to the House of Representatives seeking its concurrence,

(iii) on 14 September 2026, the House resolved that the Senate's amendments be considered 'at the next sitting', and

(iv) as part of its inquiry into the Department of Veterans' Affairs-funded health treatment, the Senate Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade References Committee recommended that the Australian Government consider legislative amendments to protect veterans from arbitrary monetary and numerical restrictions on health treatment; and

(b) requests that the House of Representatives consider and determine the Senate's amendments without further delay.

(2) That this resolution be communicated by message to the House of Representatives.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

The question is that the motion moved by Senator McDonald be agreed to.