This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Anne Ruston SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Health and Aged Care
3:19 pm
The reason why this is so urgent is that, despite the minister's protestations that when the government say something we should take them at their word, their history proves that when they say something they have to be forced into actually putting their word into action. You went to the last election promising no new taxes and no increases in taxes. Subsequent to that, you've actually gone and increased taxes. We saw them all at the budget. You say, 'You heard the Senate.' Well, did you hear the Senate when the Senate said you needed to put a human back in charge, put human override back in charge, of the aged-care algorithm? You didn't, because the bill's parked down there, alongside the veterans allied health bill, in the other place. So I think it is a little disingenuous for the minister to stand there and say that we shouldn't be doing this because they 'can be taken at their word', because the government keeps ignoring the will of the Senate. The government keeps ignoring the bills that are sent down to the other place, where it has the numbers. What they say and what they do are often two very, very different things. The reality is that this government, time and time and time again, has proved that it cannot be taken at its word. So to come in here and stand up and make the comments that the minister just made—I think that maybe it should be her that's going and checking the record for the accuracy of the actions that have been taken, because you'll find it is the Labor government that is the one that cannot be trusted to keep its word.
And this is really urgent because, when you consider it, the people that are impacted by the refusal of the government to accept the will of the Senate on so many different occasions are some of the most vulnerable in our society. We are talking about people who are veterans, who often are requiring this allied health support because of injuries that they've sustained in combat. To take that away—and then the minister comes in and starts waffling on about some other thing that they've done in veteran affairs. The reality is that their cruel action was to take away the opportunity for our veterans, our serving veterans, to get the health care that they need quite often as a result of the injuries that they received serving our nation in combat. What sort of government thinks that veterans should be paying the price for its budget mismanagement?
Another instance is the private health insurance rebate for over-65s. This is a government who thinks pensioners, age pensioners, should be paying the price for its budget mismanagement and the need for it to try and rectify its budget. Once again, the will of this Senate said it did not want that particular bill to proceed. It was discharged from the Notice Paper. What is the government doing? Apparently, they don't hear what the Senate has to say, because the bill has been reintroduced in the other place and, no doubt, will turn up here again. So don't, Minister, come into this place and tell us that you have heard what the Senate said, because all you do when you hear what the Senate says is ignore it.
Another piece of legislation, as I said—the aged-care algorithm, for older Australians, people who need care, who are towards the end of their lives and are needing care in order to remain in a dignified environment as they age. You have put a computer in charge of making the final decision about the care that they need and the urgency with which they receive that care. Even the Ombudsman was completely damning of that proposal and the fact that you're doing that. So we moved a bill in here. It passed this Senate with the support of everybody in the chamber, apart from the government. Where is it? It's languishing down in the other place, alongside the veterans allied health bill and where the private health insurance rebate bill for over-65s is sitting.
So I think it is pretty disingenuous for the government to stand up here and spray everybody in the chamber for wanting to make sure that a very serious issue is dealt with. In another classic example, we had to force you to get rid of your widows tax. You said you were going to get rid of the widows tax. But, once again, that is what you say, and then you just leave it and do not fix it. We had to force you through legislative means to actually get rid of the widows tax. What this seeks to do today—what Senator McDonald is seeking to do today—is actually force you into doing what you have promised to do, because, quite frankly, your refusal to ever do anything that you promise to do is the reason that this Senate has to force you into doing it.
No comments