This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Matters of Urgency

Data Centres


Dorinda Cox

Dorinda Cox WA, Australian Labor Party

4:41 pm

The Senate will now consider the proposal from Senator McKim, which is shown at item 13 on today's order of business:

That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:

The need for the Albanese Labor Government to put an immediate moratorium on building AI data centres that are driving up inflation, taking supplies and workers away from industries like housing and draining the community's energy and water, all to allow US billionaire tech bros to steal from Australian artists and creatives.

Is consideration of the proposal supported?

More than the number of senators required by the standing orders having risen in their places—

The proposal is supported. With the concurrence of the Senate, the Clerks will set the clocks in line with the informal arrangements made by the whips. I call Senator Shoebridge to move the motion.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

I move the motion:

That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:

The need for the Albanese Labor Government to put an immediate moratorium on building AI data centres that are driving up inflation, taking supplies and workers away from industries like housing and draining the community's energy and water, all to allow US billionaire tech bros to steal from Australian artists and creatives.

That's the question the Greens are putting before the chamber today. I can already see the coalition and Labor working out how they can try and amend this, strip it down or work their magic to get the US tech bros as much of our creatives' juices as they can and as much of our water and power as they can, because that's what they do. This is the AUKUS equivalent, isn't it? Whether it's a defence prime or one of their mates in the US tech bros, they've never seen a US multinational they don't want to feed with Australian money, Australian data, Australian real estate and, in this case, Australian power.

It is pretty extraordinary, isn't it? Right across this country, there are communities organising to save themselves from these AI data centres. They're turning up to these massive buildings—not a window in sight, humming with somebody else's wealth, sucking down their water, sucking down their power, intruding into their communities. Communities are organising and opposing them. And hats off. In my home state of New South Wales, hats off to the communities in and around the Cooks River. Much of that campaigning has been driven by local Greens on the ground, but people are joining across the community. They stopped the data centre on the Cooks River, right in the heart of Sydney. So too did the locals in Lane Cove, getting together when their governments, state and federal, had abandoned them. They got together, they organised, and they fought off that data centre. And so too in the Blue Mountains, protecting the beautiful Blue Mountains.

Right across this country we are seeing communities doing the work that they thought they had governments to do—to protect their water, to protect their land, to protect their power. But, instead, we have Labor and the coalition trying to work out this grand deal to sell our creatives and make Australia a pariah state in the global creative industry, all to drive profits to their mates in Silicon Valley and their US vampire tech bros. Will you support this motion and stand beside Australians? That's the question.

Dorinda Cox

Dorinda Cox WA, Australian Labor Party

Sorry—can you give me one second, Senator Cadell. I'm just checking the list. Yes—Senator Cadell, you have the call.

Ross Cadell

Ross Cadell NSW, National Party, Shadow Minister for Water

4:44 pm

It's the season for getting a list and checking it twice, Acting Deputy President! Here we have this motion. Where the coalition sits, it's a very interesting prospect for us, because we've said we agree with so much. But we're just worried about this moratorium and this ban straight away, because we've been in this chamber, and we've been talking about exactly the same thing. We've been talking about problems with planning, land use and residency around wind towers and transmission lines, and we couldn't get an inquiry up to talk about those concerns.

The environment is like something out of an Orwell novel: if it happens in the cities or the suburbs, it's bad; if it happens in regional areas, they can deal with it. This is what we always hear about—this duplicity of the Greens in not supporting development that hurts people where their vote is. People anywhere else can suck it up and see. That's what we're getting here today.

When we get to the specifics of data centres, there are concerns around them—no question in the world. Australia has a compute deficit. We need to have data, and we need to have compute built in Australia so we can compete. Our researchers need it. We need all of those things so we can do that, and there is a right way to go about it. My concerns, and the reason we originally wanted an inquiry into these transmission lines and renewable energy zones, were about doing it right. That is what should be done here. There shouldn't be a moratorium straightaway. The government should very quickly get the guidelines right so that it is done right. I'm not sitting here saying they are doing things wrong. I'm not saying we're working with them. But I am saying that a moratorium isn't the answer. Sitting down the back of a data centre and saying, 'Listen to the hum'—we know these things have problems. Find the right spots, do them the right way and get them done. That is what the coalition wants to do, just as we wanted to do with the rollout of the transmission lines, but we were denied the right 12 times to have an inquiry into that. Suddenly, the Greens have found the environment again this week. They'll walk away from it next week and do a deal.

The Speaker went into the AI aspect of this; let's talk about that. We do have concerns. When I gave my maiden speech, I spoke about the priority of property rights to me. Growing up in the Hunter, we had our family bus line nationalised by the government. Because my family are basically stubborn and mean at times, we buried the engines and burnt the buses rather than hand them over to the government. It cost a fortune, but it was okay because, being in the Hunter Valley, we still had mineral rights to the coal under the ground. In the seventies, that was taken off us.

There is no way we are going to support an AI system that takes away the property rights of creatives. There's no way we are going to support Australians having to hand over their hard work in the wrong way. But the industry is talking to people—they're talking to the government and they're talking to us—about the way they want this done. We're looking at methods that are working in Europe. We're talking about national court cases. We're talking about no change. All of these things are on the table, because, as I said in an interview once, there are so many things that this may do. It may revolutionise the workforce. It may make Australia one of the most productive countries. It may help our security. What it will definitely do, however, is drain power and water, put some workers at risk and, as things currently stand, harm creatives. We can't have that. I'm not willing to definitely hurt people for a 'maybe' outcome.

The coalition will support working through this to get it done right, because it is important to Australia. It is important for our data security. It's important for our regional security that we have onshore compute. It is important that we are involved in the AI world. We've seen a data attack on Coles today, whether it was AI induced or not. We've seen it happen in France, where the fridges got turned up. We've seen attacks all over the place, and, if we're not in the game, then we are at risk. We accept that. But, when we were talking about data centres in the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence, all the researchers and all the Australians who get out there and try to help said that we have this failure to compute. They're not getting enough time on compute. We need data centres, but the government should get out there quickly and urgently and say, 'This is how they're powered.'

I note that we've gone around and handed out almost $12.5 billion in subsidies for high-energy-use industries. That's $12.5 billion of taxpayers' money, and we're going to build these things that chew through more. The real numbers are that, if you look at the one proposed by Anthropic in western Queensland, it has a peak power use of 2.13 gigawatts. Up in Newcastle—in the Hunter, where I'm from—Tomago Aluminium has a peak use of 950 megawatts. It's less than half the size, and we've had to bail that out for $2.5 billion. But now we're going to build something that uses twice as much power. This is not being done right. We need to get it right. We can't support this motion, but we do need to build data centres and do it right.

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

4:49 pm

Data centres and digital infrastructure are critical to Australia's modern economy. The government cannot support a motion that would put at risk critical infrastructure that underpins essential services Australians rely on, including hospitals, transport and security. We need to work across the parliament to ensure that investment in data centres and AI infrastructure works for communities and serves Australia's national interest. I seek leave to move an amendment to the motion as circulated.

Leave not granted.

At the request of the Leader of the Government in the Senate, Senator Wong, and pursuant to contingent notice, I move:

That so much of the standing orders be suspended as would prevent me moving an amendment to the motion.

And I move:

That the question be now put.

Dorinda Cox

Dorinda Cox WA, Australian Labor Party

The question before the chair is the closure of the suspension motion moved by the minister.

Dorinda Cox

Dorinda Cox WA, Australian Labor Party

4:57 pm

We'll now return to the debate on the suspension of standing orders. Senator Hanson-Young, are you seeking the call?

Sarah Hanson-Young

Sarah Hanson-Young SA, Australian Greens

4:58 pm

I will seek the call briefly, because what's clear here is that the government is trying to shut down a legitimate debate about data centres in this country. Why are they trying to shut it down? Why are they trying to amend things? Why are they trying to cover and paper over this? Because they know that big AI and their data centres have no social licence in this country. They know that they are losing every single day and they're scared. They are scared and they should be, because we've seen what happened in the United States during the midterms only a fortnight ago. Americans stood up to big AI, and big AI are now having to walk back with their tail between their legs. These same companies want to come to Australia and set up shop here with weaker rules, weaker laws and more government bending over backwards for them.

This is a debate that is about putting communities first and putting a moratorium on the approvals of the applications on the development of any new big AI data centres before communities even know what on earth they get out of this technology. All we do know is that these huge computer servers put in air conditioned sheds around the country across from people's homes, across from schools, across from hospitals and on prime agricultural land. You know what we do know? It's going to suck up a lot of water. It's going to take Australians' drinking water. It's going to take drinking water. In my home state of South Australia, this is an industry that wants to take water from our Murray, a river that is already crying out for protection because too much is extracted for greed and profit, and the big AI companies want to come in and take even more.

What else do we know? We know that they are very hungry when it comes to energy and power. There isn't the power to power these things, so how are they going to get powered? They're going to have diesel backups. Big diesel generators in people's backyards are going to be churning on and on and on, putting out pollution and making noise right next door to people's homes, schools and hospitals and in the middle of good farming land. Of course, if it's not diesel, it's going to be gas—more for the fossil fuel companies, more for big AI. This is why we need a moratorium.

These companies, of course, are coming to Australia to set up shop here because they want Australia to be the loophole when it comes to being able to scrape, take and steal culture, intellectual property, our music, our artists' work, our stories and our journalism. They want to be able to do it here in Australia, feed their machines, the hungry machines that are spewing out pollution and taking all of our water. They want to feed their machines with the content that is made by other people, and these buggers don't even want to pay a cent for it. They don't want to pay anything, and the government wants to roll out the red carpet, let these centres be developed and let them have as many rules and regulations that suit them. That's why we say a moratorium—because, until the rules are in place, until the laws are there, until communities are consulted first, not after, none of these centres should be built.

David Pocock

David Pocock ACT, Independent

5:02 pm

While I think a blanket permanent moratorium goes too far, we should absolutely be having a pause, a moratorium, on any new data centres being built until we have very strong, clear, stringent, mandatory national standards in place—standards that actually protect communities and ensure that there is some level of community consultation to ensure that we have a mechanism for—

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

I think I have a point of order from Senator Sheldon.

Tony Sheldon

Tony Sheldon NSW, Australian Labor Party

I'm reluctant to do it but appropriately doing it, and that is that it has to be on the suspension motion that's in front of us.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

Yes. I remind senators that we are debating the suspension, so you need to be relevant to the suspension motion that's before us. We could just put this vote and then go back to the substantive debate, if you wish, but I'm in the hands of the Senate. So, Senator Pocock, please be relevant to the question before the chair.

David Pocock

David Pocock ACT, Independent

Sure. This is urgent because we are debating this urgency about a moratorium on data centres. At a moment in time where we saw Goodman Group trying to build a data centre 16 metres from people's front doors, we absolutely need to be debating this as a Senate. We're seeing companies plan data centres relying on gas. We're seeing down in Tassie data centres saying, 'We'll use diesel for backup,' and now, 'No, we want to use it permanently to run diesel generators around the clock.' It is absolutely urgent that the—

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

I have Senator McCarthy on her feet, on a point of order?

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

With the greatest of respect, we do need to stick to the suspension and the question before the chair.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

I'm listening carefully, and I will remind you, Senator Pocock, just to be relevant to the question before us, which is whether or not it is urgent or not urgent to suspend.

David Pocock

David Pocock ACT, Independent

Thank you, Acting Deputy President. This is urgent because we see the Beetaloo Digital data centre in the NT proposing to use some 400 terajoules of gas a day, the same as 16,000 ACT households would use in a year, in the middle of a climate crisis. It's urgent because we've had a Labor government that has been asleep at the wheel, in denial about the need for national standards and about the need to actually stand up to US tech companies rather than just rolling out the red carpet. That is why this is urgent, because we're in a moment in time where we can actually act as a country, put some standards in place and ensure we have a mechanism for long-term benefit from hosting this infrastructure. At the moment, all I hear about is how urgent it is to build the infrastructure. Don't worry that the RBA is saying that it's adding to inflation. Don't worry that we actually have no way of raising tax from these big multinationals.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

Senator Pocock, my job is to enforce standing orders, and you need to be relevant to the urgency of the suspension, so please bring it back to that.

David Pocock

David Pocock ACT, Independent

Thank you, Acting Deputy President. This is urgent because allowing big multinational companies to build data centres in this country does not give us sovereign compute capacity. We have to delineate between sovereign data centres, sovereign compute and big multinationals, the hyperscalers who want to build the infrastructure.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

Senator Grogan on a point of order? I have ruled on this already.

Karen Grogan

Karen Grogan SA, Australian Labor Party

Yes, indeed. This is just a point of clarity, really. Is Senator Pocock saying that we're—

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

No. Senator Pocock, I understand your point. You don't have to understand what he's saying. That's not against standing orders. But I will remind senators of one way to resolve this. I just want to make a suggestion. We can just put it to a vote, and then there's no confusion over what we're actually debating. But I will insist, Senator Pocock, that you do have to be relevant to the suspension question. Thank you.

David Pocock

David Pocock ACT, Independent

Acting Deputy President, this is urgent because we have a Labor government that doesn't understand the need for long-term benefit from hosting this infrastructure. We have a government that doesn't understand the difference between sovereign compute and just having hyperscalers here—having multinationals set up shop here. That is why this is urgent. We have to, as a country, stand up to these tech companies, say it's on our terms and actually invest in the sovereign compute that our researchers need and that Australians want access to rather than just saying: 'Well, we'll just allow big multinationals who don't pay much tax here to come and set up. We'll cop all the downside. You can take our energy and our water and hoover up our creatives' works.' We've got to stand up to these companies. I hear some good things from Senator Cadell. He talks about the urgency to ensure that we're looking after copyright holders. But clearly it is very urgent that, as a country, we stand up to the United States government and the United States tech companies when it comes to artificial intelligence and data centres.

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

5:08 pm

I move:

That the question be now put.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

I've just been informed we have to wait 15 minutes before you can do that again, because you did already move it, and we're not quite there.

Mehreen Faruqi

Mehreen Faruqi NSW, Australian Greens

5:09 pm

This debate on data centres is urgent. It is urgent because they are sucking up our energy and our water. They are sucking up the intellectual property, the minds, of our workers and our artists. What the government is doing here is taking up time that has been allocated for known government issues because they are afraid. They are really afraid that we are right. They are afraid that the community out there, who are fighting for their rights, energy and water, are right. You can see that. That's why you don't want to have this debate. That's why this debate is even more urgent. You're passing these piss-weak amendments to usurp a motion that was brought here by the Greens—

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

Senator Faruqi, I'll ask you to withdraw. I believe that term is unparliamentary.

Mehreen Faruqi

Mehreen Faruqi NSW, Australian Greens

I withdraw. Labor's breathless adoration of US tech companies would be really cringe-worthy if it weren't dangerous. That's why this debate is important. The way these data centres are being built now and the way that the red carpet is being rolled out for the US tech oligarchs—that is why it's urgent to have this debate. Ask anyone if we should be cautious about a new technology built on the stolen efforts of Australian workers and artists. It's technology that happens to drain massive amounts of water and energy. It's technology that fuels misinformation, scams, racism and harassment of women. It's technology that further concentrates the egregious power that far-right billionaires have over our lives and our democracy. What could be more urgent than that? What could be more urgent than having a debate on that?

Do you know what ordinary people out there are saying to this? They are saying: 'Whoa! Hang on. We've got to hit pause for a second and think this through.' That is what this debate and this motion are about—thinking it through, putting a pause or a moratorium on this and saying: 'Let's stop and see what the dangers are. What are the risks? What is this technology actually doing?' Do you know, when ordinary people fight, they win. Last week, a proposal in the Adelaide Hills was paused. All 79 Victorian councils now support a moratorium on data centres.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

Senator Faruqi, I'll bring you back to the question.

Mehreen Faruqi

Mehreen Faruqi NSW, Australian Greens

That is why it's urgent. Out there, people are saying: 'This is really urgent. Stop this. Put a pause. Have a moratorium.' People power has already seen three Sydney data centres scrapped. Isn't that telling this government something? That is exactly what they are afraid of. We've seen it recently in the US midterms. It was a wipe-out, with 44 ballot measures restricting data centres being passed. Even they, under a Trump administration, think it is urgent.

Labor should heed this warning. Look at this urgency motion. Heed this warning. I don't know if you are. Your amendment says you're absolutely not. You have lost the ability to listen to the communities out there. You have lost the ability to actually represent your constituents. Why? That's the big question. Why have you lost the ability to do that? It's because big corporate donations are buying the feather-light regulations that you are thinking about.

Look at the half a million dollars that Amazon have handed Labor and the Liberals this decade while they have pursued massive data centre expansions across this country. If we want to avoid becoming a dumping ground for tech oligarchs rejected by the US, we need a moratorium on AI data centres and we need to properly regulate these capitalist nightmares urgently.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

Before I give the call to Senator Ghosh, I'll clarify that the 15-minute rule isn't actually a rule. It's only when we're in committee. I've just been advised. It's my mistake there. I was given the wrong advice.

Varun Ghosh

Varun Ghosh WA, Australian Labor Party

5:14 pm

I agree with Senator Hanson-Young in this respect: this issue requires a proper debate, and it is too important for Australians to do it on the premise that's been set out here. That's why it's so urgent for us to suspend. It's why it's essential to conduct this debate on a proper basis, and that is the rationale for the suspension. Let's look at the suspension in a bit more detail. Let's look at what happened. There was an attempt to suspend standing orders to amend the motion and conduct this debate on a proper footing. It was not the kind of facile nonsense that was in the original motion but a change that related to the way in which this debate is conducted, and leave was refused for that amendment. That's what made the suspension necessary and it's what creates the urgency of this debate and the way we do this.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

Senator Ghosh is not speaking to urgency. I ask you to direct his attention to urgency.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

I was having a bit of conversation with the clerks, so I didn't hear it all, but, from the bits that I've heard, I believe he is being relevant. I'll continue to listen carefully.

Varun Ghosh

Varun Ghosh WA, Australian Labor Party

The proper debate of this issue is urgent. It's the necessity of the suspension and the urgency of the suspension that I'm speaking to. I want to take you through the premises that I just set out in relation to why I say the suspension is urgent and the amendment is urgent and why we need to do this and why the fact that we have been prevented from doing it is now a matter of some debate.

Let's look at point 1, which is the moratorium. The urgency is embedded in this, but it's embedded in the kinds of signals it sends to the market. You might think I'm talking about something of substance, but I'm actually talking about the way this debate is conducted, which goes directly to the suspension motion and the amendment that we're talking about. The signals that a debate like this in the Australian parliament on this sort of topic can send into the market can cause problems because it's a closing window in this space. It goes to why the way we have this debate and the amendment to the motion are so important to what we're debating underneath it.

In its submission to the Senate inquiry into artificial intelligence and data centres, the UNSW AI Institute highlighted the nature of that closing window and the urgency of what we're talking about here and the urgency of getting the framing of this debate right. They said this technology gives Australia as a country an opportunity to close a gap, but that window is not open forever. Indeed, we're in a globally competitive environment for that. That means that, if we give a signal to the market through a debate like this on a motion that, in the first instance, is full of this kind of hyperbole, then—

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

Where's the urgency?

Varun Ghosh

Varun Ghosh WA, Australian Labor Party

The urgency is in correcting this nonsense, Senator Shoebridge, but it is also in having this debate on appropriate terms and providing a proper basis for dealing with it. A moratorium would pause roughly $115 billion of investment, the RBA staff expect. That, of course, has a substantive impact on the Australian economy, but it also highlights the importance of debating these things on proper terms. It highlights the importance of getting the fundamentals right. That's what—

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

You're not speaking to urgency.

Varun Ghosh

Varun Ghosh WA, Australian Labor Party

No, I am. That's why we need to suspend and that's why we need to amend. That's the urgency of it. That's point 1.

I now go to the second point in relation to this, which is that the concern is with the motion. It's the premise of the debate that I really have to take issue with and it's the reason for the urgency of suspending this debate. The motion says data centres are taking workers and supplies away from industries like housing and draining the community's energy and water.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

That's what the Reserve Bank said.

Varun Ghosh

Varun Ghosh WA, Australian Labor Party

No, it's not. The capacity constraints—

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

Through the chair.

Varun Ghosh

Varun Ghosh WA, Australian Labor Party

Sorry, Acting Deputy President O'Sullivan. I am, as usual, so eager to hear what Senator Shoebridge says that I can't help but engage with him. I apologise to the chamber.

Investment in data centres, according to the RBA's November 2026 Statement on monetary policy, has been mostly met by stronger imports, which has limited the impact overall on supply or capacity constraints in Australia. This is predominantly done by imports. Why is this relevant to the urgency of the suspension motion? It's because you cannot debate these issues properly if you don't have the premises right and, when you need to try to correct premises on an issue that's as important and urgent to the Australian people as this, you need to suspend urgently. Acting Deputy President O'Sullivan, I think I might have convinced you that it is urgent we suspend.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

It's not my job to make that decision in this moment, Senator Ghosh, but thank you. We've got about 25 seconds. Go for it, Senator Hodgins-May.

Steph Hodgins-May

Steph Hodgins-May Victoria, Australian Greens

5:19 pm

Well, this matter is urgent because AI data centres are taking our water, they're taking our power and they are taking our jobs in this country. This issue is urgent because Australia's AI data centre boom only benefits big tech billionaires, no-one else. And this is urgent because last week the RBA revealed that AI data centres are also fuelling inflation, while mortgage holders face yet another rate rise. As things get even tighter, American tech billionaires are laughing all the way to the bank. Well, I dare you to tell the people in Victoria who are going to a state election that this issue is not urgent.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

The motion to suspend standing orders was not determined before the time of the urgency motion expired, so the motion to suspend standing orders has lapsed. The question is that the unamended urgency motion be agreed to. Just so we're clear, we're voting on the urgency motion that was unamended.