This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party
4:03 pm
Senator Cash has submitted a proposal, under standing order 75, today, as shown at item 13 of today's Order of Business:
That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:
The Prime Minister's repeated failure to uphold the dignity and standards of conduct expected of Australia's national leader, from his vulgar comments about Kylie Minogue and remarks criticised as demeaning to Japan's first female Prime Minister, to his latest crude exchange with the Minister for Climate Change and Energy (Mr Bowen) about their private anatomy at a climate conference in Turkey, where taxpayers are footing a $32,000 bill for free coffee, while Australian families at home are left struggling with soaring inflation, rising interest rates, skyrocketing electricity bills and the consequences of the Albanese Government's economic mismanagement.
Is consideration of the proposal supported?
More than the number of senators required by the standing orders having risen in their places—
With the concurrence of the Senate, the clerks will set the clock in line with the informal arrangements made by the whips.
Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate
4:04 pm
I move:
That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:
The Prime Minister's repeated failure to uphold the dignity and standards of conduct expected of Australia's national leader, from his vulgar comments about Kylie Minogue and remarks criticised as demeaning to Japan's first female Prime Minister, to his latest crude exchange with the Minister for Climate Change and Energy (Mr Bowen) about their private anatomy at a climate conference in Turkey, where taxpayers are footing a $32,000 bill for free coffee, while Australian families at home are left struggling with soaring inflation, rising interest rates, skyrocketing electricity bills and the consequences of the Albanese Government's economic mismanagement.
This is an incredibly important motion because it goes directly to the character of the Prime Minister. What has been on display now for some time is that the Prime Minister of Australia, Anthony Albanese, does not have the character or the judgement that this office demands. Sadly for Australians, that was on full display recently when he was with the Minister for Climate Change and Energy, Chris Bowen, in Turkiye.
There they were hosting COP31, sitting on the world stage—in fact, representing our great country on the world stage—and just minutes before an international delegation, a business delegation, was to be pitched to by our prime minister about Australia what do they do? They behave not like a prime minister and a minister hosting an international climate conference, representing our country on the world stage. Quite frankly, they behave like two grubby little schoolboys at the back of a shed. They're making crude jokes about their anatomy. Now, this wasn't a comedy club. It wasn't a pub. This was an international conference where the Prime Minister was there paid for by the Australian taxpayer.
Sadly, this latest incident highlights a pattern of behaviour on behalf of the Prime Minister. Earlier this year, what did Mr Albanese do? He went on a comedy podcast; he agreed—stupidly, I would say—to play shag, marry, date; and his answer to all three, broadcast in the event globally, was Kylie Minogue. On that same podcast, he turned a diplomatic gift of melons from Japan's first female prime minister into a crude joke complete with hand gestures. He apologised, in the end, to Kylie Minogue—as he should have—but, sadly, to this date, he has refused to apologise to the Japanese prime minister. We have a pattern of behaviour: Kylie Minogue, the Japanese prime minister and now behaving like a dirty little schoolboy whilst on the international stage representing our great country of Australia. That's three embarrassing episodes in but a few months.
This is what is so telling about the Prime Minister. Instead of demonstrating the judgement the office demands, the Prime Minister each and every time finds an excuse. What was the excuse this time? Well, it was just light-hearted banter. Then he says, 'Oh, well, no-one was hurt by what I said.' Sadly for the Prime Minister, that is not the standard that Australians expect of the person who is leading our country and representing our country at an international conference on the world stage. Australians don't just expect their prime minister to avoid hurting someone. They expect him to respect the office that he holds. It is a very privileged office. It is the highest office in our country. They expect him to exercise judgement and when he is, in particular, on the world stage they expect him to represent our great country with dignity of office.
Sadly, though, what has made this latest grubby episode even more extraordinary is the bill that is now being picked up by the Australian taxpayer: more than $2.2 million in contracts for luxury hotels, events and hospitality at COP31, including $32,000 just for coffee for international delegates at a time when Australia and Australians are in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis, and around $150 million allocated to Australia's broader COP engagement. Think about that. Australian families are cutting back whilst this government is living off the largesse of the Australian taxpayer. Sadly, the only thing people now seem to remember about this international conference, which has cost the Australian taxpayer an absolute fortune, is the rude, crude behaviour of the Prime Minister and his climate minister, and, sadly, as I said, the Prime Minister of Australia does not have the character or the judgement that this office demands. (Time expired)
Ellie Whiteaker WA, Australian Labor Party
4:09 pm
I rise to speak against this urgency motion. When I speak to Western Australians and, indeed, to Australians, what they want from their prime minister and from their government is to be focused on the issues that matter to them—the cost of living—and to be doing something about those issues. I don't mind that Senator Cash is giving me another opportunity to come and talk about all the great things that our government is doing to help with the cost of living.
The motion, which refers to Aussie families, somehow stops for a coffee on the way to getting to the point, which is odd. I'm a little surprised that those opposite would complain about the price of anything, given their record in government. After all, the cost of housing outpaced wages for years on their watch, and they never seemed to be that worried about the price of housing then. When the coalition were in government, they built 373 social and affordable homes in nine years and, for most of that time, didn't have a housing minister. They're still fighting to keep the tax breaks that make it harder for young people to buy a first home. If the coalition ran a coffee cart the way they ran the housing portfolio, it'd be about $32,000 a cup, and they'd be telling us to take out a small loan from the bank of mum and dad while telling everyone else that they'll just have to suck it up and miss out.
It's a good thing that Labor is in government, so that first home buyers can get into a home of their own with a five per cent deposit. We've changed our tax system and made it fairer, so that they're not bidding against someone buying their seventh investment property. That is real cost-of-living relief, and that is the work that our government is focused on. We know that Aussies are doing it tough, and they want their government to be focused on doing what it can to make life a little bit easier. That's why we continue to step in and deliver real cost-of-living relief for Australians—cost-of-living relief for Australians that those opposite come in here and vote against time and time again, cost-of-living relief that the coalition and their friends in One Nation oppose, stand in the way of and complain about time and time again.
In July, every Australian taxpayer got another tax cut—one of five that our government has legislated. Let's remember that Senator Cash, the Liberals and the Nationals voted against our tax cuts. PBS scripts now cost Australians no more than $25. More than three million Aussies have had their student debt cut by 20 per cent. Hundreds of TAFE courses are free. We're putting more money into bulk-billing so it's easier to see a doctor for free. We've opened 137 free Medicare urgent care clinics right across the country, including 14 in my home state of Western Australia. Paid parental leave is now for six months, with super paid on top. Families get three days of subsidised childcare a week. We know this doesn't fix everything, and there's plenty more to do. People are still under pressure. Interest rates have gone up, and we know that hurts. But only our government has a plan to get us through this challenging period and play our part in bringing inflation down.
The coalition voted against our tax cuts. They voted against tax cuts for every Australian worker. They even went to the last election promising higher taxes; it sounds unbelievable, I know, from the Liberal-National coalition, but that was their promise. They opposed free TAFE. Time and time again, they vote against our cost-of-living relief here in the Senate, and then they complain about it on their socials and in the media. But they have no real plan to help Australians with the cost of living. It was no different when they were in government. When we came to office, real wages were in freefall—and two-thirds of the fall since the 2021 peak happened on the coalition's watch. This is the same coalition that tried to bring in a GP co-payment and froze the Medicare rebate for years. The coalition has a woeful track record on the cost of living.
Sean Bell NSW, Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party
4:14 pm
I think we can all agree that the Prime Minister's performance at COP31 was pretty embarrassing, but equally embarrassing is the government's clear contempt for everyday Australians struggling with mortgages, rent, electricity and groceries. They may pay for their embarrassing performance at COP31. The waste, the vanity, their obsession with net zero, their determination to look important overseas while failing Australians here at home—this Albanese Labor government has handed Australians the bill for all of it, and people are rightfully disgusted. In Western Sydney, families are struggling with mortgage repayments, rent and grocery bills. In the Hunter, workers want affordable, reliable power and the confidence that their jobs will be there for their kids. In the Riverina, farmers and small businesses watch every dollar because they have to, and they also have to watch as this government takes their dollars and wastes it.
People are making hard decisions each week. Australians are there putting groceries back on the shelves. They are putting off repairs on their house or their car. You've got people scared to turn on the air conditioner when it gets hot and scared to turn on the heating when it gets cold. And Labor's answer to all of this was to take a bit more of their money for an overseas net zero promotional conference. Their answer to this was to take 192 official representatives of the Albanese Labor government with them and pay for contracts for a pavilion costing more than a million dollars. It was hundreds of thousands of dollars for the hotels for this, and $32,000 to pay for free coffee—$32,000 for coffee at a conference where Labor was pushing their net zero agenda, pushing policies that are going to drive up your electricity prices. All across New South Wales, people are cutting back on things like takeaway coffee to save a few dollars. At Labor's COP31, the Albanese government made you pick up the tab for their mates. This is something they are continuously doing.
Speaking of picking up the tab, Labor also reportedly spent $3 million on a net zero documentary—an easy three million of your dollars to pay for Minister Bowen's agenda while families across New South Wales continue to struggle to pay for their electricity bills, electricity bills made more expensive by the Albanese Labor government's net zero obsession. Aussies in Wollongong, Dubbo and on the Central Coast are paying more for basics, more for groceries, and yet this government rewards themselves by paying for more overseas trips and more promotional net zero tours at your expense, which is a disgrace.
It was the Labor government that signed off on all of these expenses. The Labor ministers were there giving them the tick. It was the Labor ministers deciding that COP31, their net zero promotional tour, was their priority, and their priority was for taxpayers to fund it. I think the Labor government needs to remember that this money isn't coming out of the Prime Minister's pocket or Chris Bowen's pocket or their pockets. It's coming out of the pockets of hard-working Australians. It's coming out of the pockets of nurses working a night shift in Liverpool. It's being ripped from the pockets of tradies driving to jobs across Penrith. It's been taken from the family business in Tamworth that has to pay its staff and keep the lights on.
Every dollar that this government is wasting on net zero or wasting promoting net zero is a dollar someone else had to earn. Labor can just rustle up an easy $150 million for an overseas conference, but it's the families who are footing the bill. They're the ones being squeezed. That's where this government's priorities are—more money for net zero publicity paid for by Australians struggling with the cost of living. While they're over there overseas spending it up big, people back in New South Wales are still being hit with huge power bills, and businesses are being savaged. Businesses need reliable electricity, for instance. Yet the Labor government's net zero agenda is taking that away from them, which is why One Nation will scrap net zero.
This is why One Nation always puts affordable, reliable electricity and energy security first. It is one of our No. 1 priorities. That's why One Nation is consistent when it comes to stopping the waste. Ministers shouldn't be allowed to just fritter away your money pushing their agenda. Clearly, the Albanese Labor government has forgotten who pays the bills, and it's time for the people of Australia to remind them. (Time expired)
Jane Hume Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Employment and Industrial Relations
4:19 pm
Last week, in front of the world, the Prime Minister and his energy minister were caught on a hot mic behaving like a couple of schoolboys, trading crude jokes just minutes before they were supposed to be pitching Australia to the world, to international investors. This came after the infamous Bush Deep podcast—what a choice that was—and after the now infamous melons joke, which, of course, fell flat. We've now moved from double entendres to the ever-so-witty single entendre, and he has again brought ridicule to Australia on the world stage. No-one was hurt! 'It's okay. No-one was hurt,' says the Prime Minister. Well, isn't that the standard that Australians set their Prime Minister!
Isn't it fantastic that the Prime Minister is doing real damage, and not necessarily just to Australia's international reputation via a hot mic! No, no, no—it's in the household budget where the Prime Minister is doing real damage. On Melbourne Cup Day, Australians the country over felt it in their hip pockets when they were hit with the fifth interest rate rise this year: February, March, May, September and then November. The cash rate is now 4.85 per cent. That's the highest it's been since 2008. And where was the Prime Minister when that rate rise occurred? He was in the Caribbean, and then he was in Turkiye, and now he's in the Philippines, and next he's going to China. I don't have a problem with the Prime Minister representing us on the world stage. I don't have a problem with that, but, if he's going to do it, at least he shouldn't make a git of himself.
Let's be honest: the Prime Minister is racking up frequent flyer points while Australians are racking up mortgage repayments.
Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party
Senator Hume, order! If I heard correctly, I think you might be a bit unparliamentary.
Jane Hume Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Employment and Industrial Relations
Git.
Jane Hume Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Employment and Industrial Relations
Git.
Jane Hume Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Employment and Industrial Relations
Git. Sorry, it's an old-fashioned term, Mr Acting Deputy President Ciccone.
Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party
You were facing the other way. I just wanted to double-check.
Jane Hume Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Employment and Industrial Relations
Git, definitely. No.
Jane Hume Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Employment and Industrial Relations
Inflation has now climbed to 4.3 per cent. It's still rising. Far from our homegrown inflation going down and far from the challenge being behind us, as the Prime Minister and the Treasurer so desperately want us to believe, that is not the case. It is still rising, and the Australian Bureau of Statistics is telling us that housing and electricity are driving this. That is remarkable, coming from a government that promised Australians $275 off their energy bills. Instead, energy bills have gone up—by nearly 40 per cent in some places—and the Minister for Climate Change and Energy has finally admitted that Australia has more work to do to get energy prices down. He just chose to say this to the world in Turkiye rather than to families back home who are paying the bills.
Let's talk about what this COP trip has cost us. Around 200 public servants were flown over to the conference. There was $36,000 worth of free coffee. I've actually done a bit of a calculation on this. Just bear with me, Mr Acting Deputy President. According to Google, disposable paper cups of coffee generate around 110 grams of carbon emissions per cup. Did you know that? So, assuming it's $5 per cup of coffee—let's round it out to $30,000 worth of coffee—that's 660 kilograms or 0.66 tonnes of carbon emissions caused by the Prime Minister's coffee cart. Oh, my goodness! But it's not just that. There was $2.2 million in hospitality and nearly $150 million in COP related spending overall. At the same time, families at home are thinking twice about their $5 cup of coffee. Because of the ATO's inability to pass on a surcharge, we've now seen that increase. At the same time, Labor is shouting Greta Thunberg a free latte overseas. This is not a one-off. The government's now operating its spending at its highest level in 40 years outside of the pandemic. The government's spending like a drunken sailor, putting pressure on prices, and the Reserve Bank has to respond now.
It's not all that much to ask that a prime minister take his job seriously and that he represent his country with pride and dignity on the world stage. But that's not what we're getting. We want a government that lives within its means, and we want Australians to have a chance to get ahead, not just get by. What we've got is a government for which the taxpayer is paying the bill and families are paying the price—a government whose prime minister is all innuendo and no outcome. Why can't Australians rely on their prime minister to do what's important, not what's glamourous? Why can't they rely on a prime minister to do what's necessary rather than what's ideological? That's this Labor government and their failed economic model at work.
Leah Blyth SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Defence Infrastructure
4:24 pm
It seems absolutely absurd that we would need to have a motion such as this because the Prime Minister of Australia continues to embarrass himself and Australia on the international stage. This is the Prime Minister that has spent years lecturing Australians about respect, integrity and the treatment of women, yet his own conduct has repeatedly been vulgar, immature and, quite frankly, unbecoming of any person who holds the office of Prime Minister. The Prime Minister himself has declared that it is completely unacceptable to demean, objectify, belittle or offend women. It is such a shame that he doesn't abide by the standards he sets for everyone else.
We can recall the Bush Deep podcast, where the Prime Minister engaged in a playful game. He was asked if he would sleep with, marry or date Kylie Minogue. The Prime Minister of Australia responded that he would do all of the above, which is outrageous. He then went on to have a discussion on that same podcast—a really crude exchange—about melons gifted to him by Japan's first female prime minister. He continued to use hand gestures referencing women's breasts in that exchange. This is the Prime Minister of Australia. This might be fine for some blokes chatting around a barbecue, but this is the Prime Minister of Australia representing Australia. I think it's fair to say that, with all of that, you could—what else do we add? We haven't spoken about what sits in his pants. Don't worry, because the Prime Minister managed to include that one last week when he and Minister Bowen, who were supposed to be leading negotiations and Australia's delegation at COP, were caught on a hot mic talking about where they keep their mobile phones and that it's far more important to protect what sits in your pants then what sits in your chest. This is the Prime Minister.
I was thinking we could play bingo with the Prime Minister. You know, have we talked about shagging Kylie? Have we talked about melons? Have we had a penis joke? The Prime Minister has hit the trifecta on that. Rather than accepting the responsibility, this prime minister is always about making excuses. I think, rather than the Prime Minister obsessing himself with which Australian he's going to shag, perhaps he should stop screwing Australians. Australians are struggling. They are struggling to keep the lights on. They are struggling to pay their mortgages while the Prime Minister and the Minister for Climate Change and Energy are overseas discussing their private anatomy. While they're on the global stage, embarrassing Australians, they have allocated nearly $148 million to COP31 and all of the related activities. At the taxpayers' expense, they took 192 Australian government representatives from at least 20 different departments. They spent more than $32,000 of Australian taxpayer dollars on coffee in the Australian pavilion. They have also managed to give complimentary drinks to the climate delegates. While Australians, while they can't afford their own grocery bills, are footing the bill for paying for the drinks of the delegates, there was approximately $2.26 million in the pavilion and associated contracts. It goes on and on to get to $148 million of Australia's hard-earned taxpayer dollars.
You could say that we've got to present ourselves on the global stage, but what is the return on investment for the taxpayer from this enormous expenditure? Did it bring their power prices down by $275, like the government promised? No. Is it helping with the cost of living here in Australia? No. What is the point of this prime minister and this obsession with spending to keep their net zero fantasy going? It is absolutely obscene, not just in how this prime minister behaves on a global scale but in the amount that they are spending and the debt that they are putting Australians in while not addressing the cost-of-living crisis here on our shores—instead gallivanting all over the countryside.
Anne Ruston SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Health and Aged Care
4:29 pm
I think Australians can expect two things of their prime minister—one, that he conducts himself like one, and the other, that he spends his time and their money on things that matter to them. This prime minister has failed on both accounts. On the first, as Senator Cash laid out in her contribution to this, there was a crude podcast, remarks about the Japanese first female prime minister that he won't apologise for and now a hot mic issue in Turkiye. This is a prime minister who told Australians—and I quote—'Australians that demean, objectify or diminish women—it is completely unacceptable.' I agree with the Prime Minister, but perhaps he might like to listen to himself. Once again, the apologies came only after the cameras did.
But it's his second failure to Australians that is more important, really. And that is that, right now, every single Australian family are opening up their power bills and they simply can't afford them. Before the 2022 election, remember all those times that Labor and the Prime Minister promised that your power bills were going to go down by $275. Instead, Australians have paid $23 billion more on their electricity since the Prime Minister first made that promise. So what were the Prime Minister and the energy minister talking about in Turkiye? Not about how to bring down power bills and not about where they went wrong in delivering Australians the $275 energy bill relief that they promised; they were talking about where Chris Bowen keeps his phone. Taxpayers were paying $32,000—
Dorinda Cox WA, Australian Labor Party
Just to interrupt you—please refer to others from the other place by their correct title. That is just a reminder.
Anne Ruston SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Health and Aged Care
Mr Chris Bowen. Taxpayers were paying $32,000 for free coffee. That coffee is part of almost $150 million that this government has put towards the climate conference program, and every single dollar of that comes out of the pockets of Australian taxpayers, the very same taxpayers who are struggling to pay their power bills. So not only do they pay once; they pay twice—once on their power bills and then again on their tax bills. Australians just cannot afford more of Anthony Albanese and Chris Bowen.
It's not only their power bills that are being ignored. Our aged-care system is in complete crisis. Those aren't my words; they're the words of Labor's own health minister in New South Wales, who has called the situation a national crisis. Around 3,700 older Australians who are well enough to be discharged from hospital but with nowhere to go are stuck in our hospital beds, as well as nearly 200,000 older Australians who are either waiting for an assessment or waiting for the care that they've been assessed as needing. The average wait time for a homecare package is now out towards 12 months. So where is the Prime Minister? Not here making sure that older Australians get the care that they need, and not telling his ministers Mark Butler and Mr Rae to fix up the problems so older Australians can get the care that they need. Maybe it's because he doesn't consider older Australians to be his people. Here's what he has done: he has cut $1.4 billion from aged care and banked it to save his budget bottom line. His own finance minister, Senator Gallagher, here told Australians the budget had improved in part by spending less on aged care, spending less in a national crisis. That money was meant for aged-care beds and homecare packages. Instead, it is propping up Labor's budget mess. Then, from yet another overseas summit, the Prime Minister said he was trying to find savings to fund aged care. But he'd already found $1.4 billion. He just didn't spend it on aged care.
Australians aren't asking for much of their prime minister—just for somebody who takes their job seriously, who takes them seriously, who deals with the issues that are important to Australians, who spends their money like it were his own and not just some free-for-all that he can spend as he likes and who is working on their problems, the problems that everyday Australians face every day, not on his next punchline. Right now, they do not have a prime minister who is doing that. Australians cannot afford Anthony Albanese and Chris Bowen, and I absolutely commend this motion to the Senate, because Australians expect nothing less and nothing more of their prime minister.
Dorinda Cox WA, Australian Labor Party
The question is that the motion moved by Senator Cash be agreed to.