This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Ross Cadell NSW, National Party, Shadow Minister for Water
4:44 pm
It's the season for getting a list and checking it twice, Acting Deputy President! Here we have this motion. Where the coalition sits, it's a very interesting prospect for us, because we've said we agree with so much. But we're just worried about this moratorium and this ban straight away, because we've been in this chamber, and we've been talking about exactly the same thing. We've been talking about problems with planning, land use and residency around wind towers and transmission lines, and we couldn't get an inquiry up to talk about those concerns.
The environment is like something out of an Orwell novel: if it happens in the cities or the suburbs, it's bad; if it happens in regional areas, they can deal with it. This is what we always hear about—this duplicity of the Greens in not supporting development that hurts people where their vote is. People anywhere else can suck it up and see. That's what we're getting here today.
When we get to the specifics of data centres, there are concerns around them—no question in the world. Australia has a compute deficit. We need to have data, and we need to have compute built in Australia so we can compete. Our researchers need it. We need all of those things so we can do that, and there is a right way to go about it. My concerns, and the reason we originally wanted an inquiry into these transmission lines and renewable energy zones, were about doing it right. That is what should be done here. There shouldn't be a moratorium straightaway. The government should very quickly get the guidelines right so that it is done right. I'm not sitting here saying they are doing things wrong. I'm not saying we're working with them. But I am saying that a moratorium isn't the answer. Sitting down the back of a data centre and saying, 'Listen to the hum'—we know these things have problems. Find the right spots, do them the right way and get them done. That is what the coalition wants to do, just as we wanted to do with the rollout of the transmission lines, but we were denied the right 12 times to have an inquiry into that. Suddenly, the Greens have found the environment again this week. They'll walk away from it next week and do a deal.
The Speaker went into the AI aspect of this; let's talk about that. We do have concerns. When I gave my maiden speech, I spoke about the priority of property rights to me. Growing up in the Hunter, we had our family bus line nationalised by the government. Because my family are basically stubborn and mean at times, we buried the engines and burnt the buses rather than hand them over to the government. It cost a fortune, but it was okay because, being in the Hunter Valley, we still had mineral rights to the coal under the ground. In the seventies, that was taken off us.
There is no way we are going to support an AI system that takes away the property rights of creatives. There's no way we are going to support Australians having to hand over their hard work in the wrong way. But the industry is talking to people—they're talking to the government and they're talking to us—about the way they want this done. We're looking at methods that are working in Europe. We're talking about national court cases. We're talking about no change. All of these things are on the table, because, as I said in an interview once, there are so many things that this may do. It may revolutionise the workforce. It may make Australia one of the most productive countries. It may help our security. What it will definitely do, however, is drain power and water, put some workers at risk and, as things currently stand, harm creatives. We can't have that. I'm not willing to definitely hurt people for a 'maybe' outcome.
The coalition will support working through this to get it done right, because it is important to Australia. It is important for our data security. It's important for our regional security that we have onshore compute. It is important that we are involved in the AI world. We've seen a data attack on Coles today, whether it was AI induced or not. We've seen it happen in France, where the fridges got turned up. We've seen attacks all over the place, and, if we're not in the game, then we are at risk. We accept that. But, when we were talking about data centres in the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence, all the researchers and all the Australians who get out there and try to help said that we have this failure to compute. They're not getting enough time on compute. We need data centres, but the government should get out there quickly and urgently and say, 'This is how they're powered.'
I note that we've gone around and handed out almost $12.5 billion in subsidies for high-energy-use industries. That's $12.5 billion of taxpayers' money, and we're going to build these things that chew through more. The real numbers are that, if you look at the one proposed by Anthropic in western Queensland, it has a peak power use of 2.13 gigawatts. Up in Newcastle—in the Hunter, where I'm from—Tomago Aluminium has a peak use of 950 megawatts. It's less than half the size, and we've had to bail that out for $2.5 billion. But now we're going to build something that uses twice as much power. This is not being done right. We need to get it right. We can't support this motion, but we do need to build data centres and do it right.
No comments