This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Questions without Notice: Take Note of Answers
Answers to Questions
Slade Brockman Deputy-President
3:18 pm
With the concurrence of the Senate, the clerks will set the clock in accordance with informal arrangements agreed by the whips.
Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party
I move:
That the Senate take note of the answers given by ministers to questions without notice asked by Opposition senators today.
In moving that motion, I note that every single answer that was provided by the government today demonstrated just how untrustworthy this government is when it comes to dealing with the issues that confront people in this country. It's absolutely no surprise to me to see the circumstance that exists with respect to the Australian community' lack of trust for this government. We see obfuscation. We see tricky language. We see manipulated statistics to make things look better than they actually really are. We see the same old tactics of blaming somebody else—the opposition, if you can; the war on Iran, if you can't—and it goes on and on.
When we asked the government questions in question time today about how much tax small business might pay in relation to the tax that the government promised wouldn't occur—that small business didn't ask for—we got the same old tricks. When we asked about what compliance costs might be imposed on small business from these new taxes that the government promised they wouldn't bring in—that small business didn't ask for and that CPA Australia has indicated will cost small businesses and taxpayers up to $2.8 billion annually—they talked about something else. And when we asked about productivity in terms of small business and their operations, they didn't want to know about that either, because small business is being forced to comply with these additional costs of running their businesses and the $2.8 billion additional cost that's being imposed on their operations on an annual basis. It's absolutely absurd that we continue to get this approach of 'just try to blame somebody else or push it onto some other group that isn't the government'.
Then we started talking about homeownership. I've never seen a better manipulation of statistics in all my life. It is the most brilliant manipulation of statistics. This government is building 30,000 fewer houses a year than were being built under the coalition, and then they talk about more houses! They promised that 1.2 million houses would be built by 2029, and they're building something in the order of 40,000 or 50,000 fewer houses per year than their target dictates—and they still talk about more houses. It is just a complete manipulation of the numbers to suit their narrative, to suit their spin.
When it comes to the Big Build, the Labor Party spent nine years voting against measures to deal with corruption in the building industry—nine years. Then they come in and make the claim that they've done more than anybody else, when they were teaming up consistently with the Greens to stop anything of material value happening. And of course the Greens still voted against even the administration of the CFMEU, which is now in place. But for 9½ years the Labor Party tried to stop anyone from doing anything about it. No wonder nobody believes this government anymore.
Josh Dolega Tasmania, Australian Labor Party
3:22 pm
In relation to the CFMEU, we are the ones who took the strongest action to clean up the construction industry. The bill the coalition brought before the parliament was designed to bust unions and attack working people, so it was rightly voted down and sent to the bin, where it belongs. But I digress.
Our changes to taxation arrangements for trusts are part of our broader package of reforms in the federal budget that was handed down by Treasurer Chalmers in May. And yes, we are changing the taxation arrangements for some trust structures, because on this side we want to make the taxation of trusts fairer by more closely aligning income that is earned on investments with the taxation of income that is earned through labour. This is about fairness, and it complements some of our other tax measures—lowering taxes and consecutive income tax cuts that we have delivered for working Australians over our term of government. That's in stark contrast to the other side. They went to the last federal election promising higher income taxes, which is absolutely unbelievable. Our government has delivered for working people a thousand-dollar instant tax deduction to simplify their preparation of income tax returns. We're also delivering the Working Australians Tax Offset and, again, we have more tax cuts in play.
In addition to the changes to the taxation of trusts, we have delivered changes to the capital gains and negative gearing regimes and we are levelling the playing field to allow first home buyers to have the opportunity to own their first home. This was described by Senator Bragg, in one of his supplementary questions to Minister Wong, as having a negative impact on first home buyers. We fundamentally disagree. Our policy positions are getting more people and more first home buyers into their homes, to realise the great Australian dream of being able to buy their first home. When you cut out all the noise in the papers, when you go and look in some of the property guides, you'll see stories of first home buyers at auctions who are not going up and bidding against professional property hoarders that are buying properties to increase their portfolio rather than to live in as a home. We're proud of our changes to taxation and of the budget measures that were handed down in May by the Treasurer.
We've also had other positive housing policies directed to helping first home buyers. There is our five per cent deposit scheme, which, I understand, over 270,000 Australians have taken part in to help them get into their first home. We also have our shared equity scheme through Help to Buy. Our approach is in stark contrast to those opposite. During their period of government, during their decade of neglect, they didn't even have a housing minister for a great portion of that, and they absolutely had the worst track record for building homes during their tenure. We, through our Housing Australia Future Fund, are delivering more social and affordable homes for those who need them most. (Time expired)
Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party
3:26 pm
Where do I start? I'd prepared a speech, but then I listened to Senator Dolega. I don't need to read my speech notes; I can just respond to the good senator.
In relation to small business: to a small business, their business is not an investment; it is their livelihood. The government talk about taxing investments differently from livelihoods, but for a small business their business is their livelihood. That's where the discretionary trusts tax changes introduced by the Albanese Labor government fall down. There are 350,000 small businesses that are going to be impacted by these changes to discretionary trusts. That is where the government's argument collapses. Small businesses are being hammered. It's a kick in the guts to Australian small businesses at the worst possible time.
It's been estimated that these small businesses are going to have to pay $2.8 billion just to get the accounting and legal advice they need for this change. That is dead money. That money could have gone into building up small businesses employing more Australians. We know small business employs over 40 per cent of Australians who are employed in the private sector. That money could have been used to boost productivity. Instead, it's dead money. It's a productivity killer at the worst possible time. And 60,000 of those small businesses who are being hit by this toxic tax on discretionary trusts are in the construction industry.
Senator Dolega talked about the changes to tax in terms of negative gearing, in terms of capital gains and in terms of self-managed super funds no longer being able to invest in property investments. He says this is helping housing supply. All the evidence is to the contrary. We are now building 30,000 fewer homes a year than we were under the previous coalition government. If we look at the latest statistics in relation to home loan approvals, in the last quarter new home loan approvals crashed by 15 per cent. The number of Australians going to their bank and seeking a new home loan so they can buy their house has collapsed by 15 per cent. In relation to the new first home buyers, who Senator Dolega referred to, the figures are down 8.6 per cent. It is 8.6 per cent less. Maybe the next speaker could address this: if these tax changes are actually helping first home buyers or potential first home buyers, why has there been a crash of 8.6 per cent in the number of first home buyers seeking a mortgage? If it's working that well—if it's actually meeting its intended purpose—wouldn't you expect that number to go up? But, in fact, the number is going down. It is 8.6 per cent less.
Then we come to Victoria's Big Build. The Victorian state election can't come soon enough. The CFMEU tax on construction across this whole country, under Labor's watch, has been an absolute disaster for all Australians. The cost of schools, hospitals and even Ronald McDonald House in my home state of Queensland, which is there for families who have got kids in hospital—the cost to construct Ronald McDonald House blew out by between 20 and 30 per cent because of the CFMEU.
Dorinda Cox WA, Australian Labor Party
3:30 pm
I also rise to take note of answers to coalition questions. Gee, where do I start with Senator Scarr's contribution on the back of Senator Dolega's? These are some of the tough decisions that the Albanese Labor government are making in relation to tax reform. It goes to the heart of my question to Senator Gallagher around the $180 billion that we found in savings and reprioritisations—the largest savings package in history. Our government, our minister for finance and our treasurer continue to work, as we know, in relation to the global shocks that are happening and having an impact right here at home. Our tax reforms, as Senator Dolega already said, are delivering tax cuts for workers and a fair go for first home buyers, better aligning with the treatment of income earned in other ways. We on this side of the chamber are unapologetic about making those tough decisions. It means that Australians will look to investing and growing their wealth. Those concessions that are in the tax system are targeted at starting new, innovative businesses and investing in new builds, regardless of the mis- and disinformation that is being spread about that.
The legislation we're progressing means that the government is now delivering over $4 billion in new tax relief and concessions for businesses and startups as part of our tax reform package. We're also simplifying the tax system with reforms and reducing those compliance costs by $540 million a year, with our regulatory reforms to cut business compliance costs by $10 billion a year. These are some of the tough decisions that our government are making to ensure that people are able to invest, particularly in what Senator Scarr was talking about around housing and businesses.
I might just pick up on that point of housing. This year's budget is about building more houses and about getting more supply, and it levels out the playing field for first home buyers. We've heard from people like Senator Walker, who has talked at length in this chamber about young people and making sure that they can get into their first home. Too many Australians feel that the housing system is stacked against them, especially younger people, and I want to acknowledge that that has been part of the conversations that I've had with constituents in my home state of Western Australia.
We have the most ambitious housing agenda in generations. We didn't stop after building 373 social and affordable homes in nine years, like the coalition did. We are trying to make those systemic and structural changes to the budget and to legislation. When we bring those cost-of-living measures into this place, they are blocked by the opposition. They are not supported. Yet the hypocrisy is that you come in here and try to attack us about tax reform when we are finding $180 billion of savings just this year.
I want to quickly turn to some of the issues in the questions that were raised by Senator McDonald to Senator Wong, representing the Prime Minister. Our climate action is about Australia's national interest and national security—more investment, more jobs, stronger energy security, a more resilient economy and a safer region with our Pacific partners. I've had the pleasure of being in the room with Senator Wong, as our minister for foreign affairs, overseas, talking to PIF leaders about the global uncertainty and the support Australia can provide.
Maria Kovacic NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Women
3:35 pm
Well, I feel like we must be living in a parallel universe. This government isn't making tough decisions; this government is making decisions that are crushing Australia's economy. Households are struggling. Small businesses are struggling. No-one is immune from what this government has done. They're sitting here and trying to tell us that this is all okay.
What I take a great deal of offence to is the suggestion that this has somehow been good for young people and that this has delivered an opportunity for young people to own their own homes. Well, I'll take you back to last year, when many of us stood up on this side of the chamber and warned—warned—that the open floodgate of the five per cent deposit guarantee that wasn't means tested was going to create a scenario that increased prices. And guess who has been hit by the falling prices that have been constructed by this government? Those very people that they lured into homeownership last year with the five per cent deposit guarantee. Have a think about that: people who had saved their five per cent deposit to finally enter the property market to own their own home are now entering negative equity, with all of their savings, all of that effort gone. We're being lectured to by those opposite that this is something good. It is not good; it is really, really bad.
Do you want to know who are making the tough decisions? The people that can't afford to feed their children, the people that are deciding what goes into the trolley and what doesn't go into the trolley, the people who are deciding how much petrol can go in their tank and how far they're going to be able to go, the parents that are deciding which one of their kids gets to go to the doctor—because I can tell you most people are not just using their Medicare card to go to the doctor—and the women that are making choices around the fact that they'll take their children to the doctor and leave their own health concerns till later, the families that are deciding who gets to buy their medicines and who doesn't. These are choices that Australians are making every single day, and it is fundamentally unacceptable that those opposite pretend that everything is okay. They cannot even answer the question around whether it was deliberate—deliberate—to tank the housing market. Because you know what? They don't know. Their own cabinet didn't even get briefed by Treasury in relation to the tax change agreement that they made with the Greens. I understand why they're all upset over there, because they're finding this stuff out second hand. So no wonder there are the disruption and the disunity over on the other side.
But I want to finish up on the CFMEU. You all know how important that is to me and others on this side of the chamber. We are sick and tired of taxpayer money being wasted on corruption, and I noticed the change in language today from Minister Wong. It was no longer, 'We are doing everything possible to combat corruption'; it's now, 'We're doing a lot to combat corruption.' Well, there's one thing that you can do to combat corruption in construction: you can support a Senate inquiry, because the Victorian royal commission is showing a lot to be concerned about. The Queensland commission of inquiry has shown that some $24 billion has potentially been saved because of the stick in the spokes of the CFMEU, and we should all be worried about what is happening in every other state of our country. If we sit here blindly and pretend to care about Australians and do nothing about that, we should be ashamed.
Question agreed to.