This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Questions without Notice: Take Note of Answers

Answers to Questions


Paul Scarr

Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party

3:26 pm

Where do I start? I'd prepared a speech, but then I listened to Senator Dolega. I don't need to read my speech notes; I can just respond to the good senator.

In relation to small business: to a small business, their business is not an investment; it is their livelihood. The government talk about taxing investments differently from livelihoods, but for a small business their business is their livelihood. That's where the discretionary trusts tax changes introduced by the Albanese Labor government fall down. There are 350,000 small businesses that are going to be impacted by these changes to discretionary trusts. That is where the government's argument collapses. Small businesses are being hammered. It's a kick in the guts to Australian small businesses at the worst possible time.

It's been estimated that these small businesses are going to have to pay $2.8 billion just to get the accounting and legal advice they need for this change. That is dead money. That money could have gone into building up small businesses employing more Australians. We know small business employs over 40 per cent of Australians who are employed in the private sector. That money could have been used to boost productivity. Instead, it's dead money. It's a productivity killer at the worst possible time. And 60,000 of those small businesses who are being hit by this toxic tax on discretionary trusts are in the construction industry.

Senator Dolega talked about the changes to tax in terms of negative gearing, in terms of capital gains and in terms of self-managed super funds no longer being able to invest in property investments. He says this is helping housing supply. All the evidence is to the contrary. We are now building 30,000 fewer homes a year than we were under the previous coalition government. If we look at the latest statistics in relation to home loan approvals, in the last quarter new home loan approvals crashed by 15 per cent. The number of Australians going to their bank and seeking a new home loan so they can buy their house has collapsed by 15 per cent. In relation to the new first home buyers, who Senator Dolega referred to, the figures are down 8.6 per cent. It is 8.6 per cent less. Maybe the next speaker could address this: if these tax changes are actually helping first home buyers or potential first home buyers, why has there been a crash of 8.6 per cent in the number of first home buyers seeking a mortgage? If it's working that well—if it's actually meeting its intended purpose—wouldn't you expect that number to go up? But, in fact, the number is going down. It is 8.6 per cent less.

Then we come to Victoria's Big Build. The Victorian state election can't come soon enough. The CFMEU tax on construction across this whole country, under Labor's watch, has been an absolute disaster for all Australians. The cost of schools, hospitals and even Ronald McDonald House in my home state of Queensland, which is there for families who have got kids in hospital—the cost to construct Ronald McDonald House blew out by between 20 and 30 per cent because of the CFMEU.

Comments

No comments