This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Questions without Notice: Take Note of Answers
Answers to Questions
Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party
3:18 pm
I move:
That the Senate take note of the answers given by ministers to questions without notice asked by Opposition senators today.
In moving that motion, I note that every single answer that was provided by the government today demonstrated just how untrustworthy this government is when it comes to dealing with the issues that confront people in this country. It's absolutely no surprise to me to see the circumstance that exists with respect to the Australian community' lack of trust for this government. We see obfuscation. We see tricky language. We see manipulated statistics to make things look better than they actually really are. We see the same old tactics of blaming somebody else—the opposition, if you can; the war on Iran, if you can't—and it goes on and on.
When we asked the government questions in question time today about how much tax small business might pay in relation to the tax that the government promised wouldn't occur—that small business didn't ask for—we got the same old tricks. When we asked about what compliance costs might be imposed on small business from these new taxes that the government promised they wouldn't bring in—that small business didn't ask for and that CPA Australia has indicated will cost small businesses and taxpayers up to $2.8 billion annually—they talked about something else. And when we asked about productivity in terms of small business and their operations, they didn't want to know about that either, because small business is being forced to comply with these additional costs of running their businesses and the $2.8 billion additional cost that's being imposed on their operations on an annual basis. It's absolutely absurd that we continue to get this approach of 'just try to blame somebody else or push it onto some other group that isn't the government'.
Then we started talking about homeownership. I've never seen a better manipulation of statistics in all my life. It is the most brilliant manipulation of statistics. This government is building 30,000 fewer houses a year than were being built under the coalition, and then they talk about more houses! They promised that 1.2 million houses would be built by 2029, and they're building something in the order of 40,000 or 50,000 fewer houses per year than their target dictates—and they still talk about more houses. It is just a complete manipulation of the numbers to suit their narrative, to suit their spin.
When it comes to the Big Build, the Labor Party spent nine years voting against measures to deal with corruption in the building industry—nine years. Then they come in and make the claim that they've done more than anybody else, when they were teaming up consistently with the Greens to stop anything of material value happening. And of course the Greens still voted against even the administration of the CFMEU, which is now in place. But for 9½ years the Labor Party tried to stop anyone from doing anything about it. No wonder nobody believes this government anymore.
No comments