This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Questions without Notice: Take Note of Answers

Answers to Questions


Slade Brockman

Slade Brockman Deputy-President

3:48 pm

With the concurrence of the Senate, the clerks will set the clock in accordance with informal arrangements agreed by the whips.

Dave Sharma

Dave Sharma NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

I move:

That the Senate take note of the answers given by ministers to questions without notice asked by opposition senators today.

Yet again today in this chamber we heard from a government that doesn't understand small business, that doesn't know small business, that has no experience of small business and that has no empathy whatsoever for small business. Small businesses at the moment are failing at the rate 46 per day—that is, going into administration or insolvency—every single day, not just Monday to Friday but Saturdays and Sundays, the highest rate of failure we've seen in several years, and yet what we hear from this government as they go about imposing a new and novel tax on small business is a complete disregard for them. We were told by Minister Wong that it's only 10 per cent of small businesses that operate through trusts. Well, it's 350,000 small businesses that use these, and the bulk of them are classified by the ATO as micro businesses—that is, with turnover under $2 million, the vast majority. These are mum-and-dad, brother-and-sister, mother-and-daughter operations. They're some of the most vulnerable businesses in our country, and Labor is hitting them with new taxes.

It's not like the Labor government took these taxes to the last election. It's not like they told small business before the last election that they were going to put this impost on you. No; they unveiled this in their budget of broken promises. Their assault on aspiration was included in that.

We have small businesses at the moment dealing with a cashflow crisis. They've got weak consumer demand, high electricity prices, high inflation and interest rates that are some of the highest amongst advanced economies in the world. They've got new industrial relations laws to deal with. They had credit card surcharging to absorb. They've got payday super that they've had to absorb. On top of all this, the government think they will now impose a minimum tax on the main vehicle that small businesses use to structure their affairs—a discretionary trust.

This leaves small businesses with only bad options. They can be faced with a 30 per cent minimum tax, but you need to be earning over $230,000 as a small-business owner to be paying anywhere near that level of tax now. You can be forced into restructuring your business at a cost of around $50,000 to $100,000 in legal and advisory fees, plus the stamp duty on that, or you can opt into a fixed trust, which will mean that your business structure and those who can participate in your business will not be able to change or grow or evolve with the business.

This is nothing more than an attack on small business from a government that has no regard for them, as their own ministers say—a government that has no experience of small business and no knowledge of small business. It could only come from a government that is completely cavalier about the state of the economy, the state of small business in Australia and the number of households and businesses doing it tough right now in adverse economic conditions.

Ellie Whiteaker

Ellie Whiteaker WA, Australian Labor Party

3:51 pm

I also rise to take note of answers provided to coalition senators. I'm left wondering why the Liberal Party is standing in the way of our plans to make the tax system fairer. Yet again, day after day, week after week, they come in here and stand in the way of our work to give tax cuts to working Australians, to make it easier for first home buyers to buy their first home and to align the treatment of income that employees make from working with other forms of income. That's what they're doing today and every day when they come into this place. Why is the Liberal Party opposed to working Australians receiving a tax cut? Why did they take a policy to the last election of increasing tax cuts for Australian workers and then come in here and argue that, while workers should pay more tax, the very small percentage of Australians who receive income from a discretionary trust shouldn't be taxed more?

It's really clear today and every day who the Liberal Party and their friends in the National Party and One Nation are here for, and it is not working Australians. It is not ordinary Australians who are trying to put food on the table. It is not ordinary Australians who are going to work day in and day out and paying their taxes. It is not those Australians who the Liberal Party and the National Party and One Nation are here for, but they are the Australians who we are here for, who we will fight for and who we will stand up for. It's clear to me, and I think it's clear to Australians right across the country that the Liberal Party does not have a plan to make life easier for working families. They tell that story every day, whether it's opposing our plans to make the tax system fairer, opposing tax cuts for working Australians—

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Opposition Senators:

Opposition senators interjecting—

Anthony Chisholm

Anthony Chisholm Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Regional Development

Deputy President, I believe Senator Sharma was heard in silence. Yet we've heard nothing but interjections from those opposite since Senator Whiteaker started.

Slade Brockman

Slade Brockman Deputy-President

I will remind those on my left that Senator Whiteaker should be heard in silence.

Ellie Whiteaker

Ellie Whiteaker WA, Australian Labor Party

What we're seeing here is a desperate attempt to claw back votes—votes that they've continued to haemorrhage, election after election, because they have no plan to make life easier for working Australians. They're not here for the 95 per cent of working Australians who do not earn income from discretionary trusts. They're not interested in arguing for them to get a tax cut. In fact, they voted against it in this place. Senator Hume called those tax cuts 'egregious'. Yet they're willing to come in here and make the argument that our tax system should not be fair, that we should not align the tax that is paid on income—by workers, by employees—with the tax paid by the five per cent who make money from a discretionary trust. What they conveniently leave out is that there's quite a bit in our tax reform that makes life easier for small businesses. They're not interested in talking about that, because they are desperate and they have no plan to make life easier for working Australians. But Labor does, and we will not let them stand in the way.

Leah Blyth

Leah Blyth SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Defence Infrastructure

3:55 pm

It is offensive, quite frankly, to sit on this side of the chamber and listen to what Labor are spewing at the Australian people, and I think the Australian people are seeing through it. What we've just heard from the senator on the other side is astounding, and I wonder if she actually knows what she is talking about. Australian businesses are everyday Australians. They are mums, they are dads, they are hardworking families who are just trying to make ends meet. But it seems Labor have decided that if you have a successful business they're going to come after you, because they've got to fix the huge hole in their budget. We've heard from them that they're going to come after veterans as well to try to fix this huge hole in their budget.

So this is about socialism and it is about how they want to redistribute wealth in this country, even from the finance minister, Katy Gallagher. She got up and told Australians, 'Come on: we're working really hard to fix the economy in Australia.' Well, like all other Australians, I wish that Labor would stop working so hard. You've collapsed the housing market, you are coming after aspiration in this country and you are making it impossible for small businesses to flourish. When we are seeing dozens of small businesses in this country closing every single day, you have to ask yourself: what is this government's plan for our economy? Those opposite come in here and tell us they've got a plan. Please, scrap the plan. Australia cannot afford the plan. They cannot afford this path that you are leading us all down.

It is very clear that the Labor government has no experience when it comes to running a small business. They've got no idea. They see this as, 'Well, it's only five per cent of businesses that take income from a discretionary trust.' 'Only five per cent?' Is this how they justify it? That is 350,000 small businesses. That is 350,000 families that these businesses are supporting. But it's okay, because it's only five per cent! If we talk about it in those terms, we don't have to see these business owners as real people who are struggling with the high energy prices in Australia, who are struggling with the additional tax—after this Labor government promised they would not introduce any new taxes. Well, we know what this Labor government does. Anything they say you can pretty well take with a grain of salt, because then they come along and introduce taxes.

I think it's fair to say that the Australian people are wide awake to what this Labor government is doing to small business in Australia. And I am proud to say that on this side of the chamber—in the coalition, the Liberals and the Nationals—we are standing with small businesses here in Australia, because we want to see those 350,000 small businesses. And we don't want to see this government making it impossible for our farmers. Where do you think food comes from in this country? Who do you think is filling the shelves at Woolworths and Coles? It is our hardworking farmers, and a lot of them use trusts—and they use trusts because that is a structure that allows them to pass their farming business from one generation to the next. If you want to see the killing of aspiration, the killing of farming—making sure we cannot eat in the cities—then absolutely, Labor's plan is what we should be following!

Lisa Darmanin

Lisa Darmanin Victoria, Australian Labor Party

3:59 pm

The key question that Senator Wong asked in response to the original question from Senator Hume in question time is: 'Why are you standing up for the 10 per cent and not the 90 per cent?' We need to look at the broader context here. What this government is doing is trying to bring back fairness into our tax system, making judgements and treating people in a way that is reasonable. Everyone should have a fair crack at the opportunity to succeed, particularly when we know that Australians are under pressure. Importantly, this taxation legislation is part of a suite of reforms that are about taking pressure off families, making the economy more productive and resilient and making the budget more sustainable. That is the driver of all of these things for Australians: tax cuts for workers, expanding Medicare, funding aged care and early childhood care, and enabling the budget to pay for these things for 100 per cent of Australian society. Those are the values of our government, and that is what we are seeking to enshrine with these laws.

We are taking the hard decisions to reform the system in the name of fairness—to reduce the tax burden for over 13 million workers and support 75,000 Australians to enter the housing market. That is the context of these reforms in our bills. We are seeking to undertake the hard reform in our tax system by showing leadership to make sure our economy works in the interests of Australians, businesses and future generations—for not only the 10 per cent but 100 per cent.

The Senate Economics Legislation Committee inquired into this legislation very recently, and I wanted to pull out a few things from that inquiry to share with Australians who might be watching. Dr Mark Zirnsak from the Tax Justice Network observed that those with an interest in retaining existing arrangements may be more strongly motivated to engage in the debate than the broader group of taxpayers who may benefit from this reform, which I think is worth bearing in mind.

I wanted to also briefly talk about the comments from Senator Canavan with regard to farms. Senator Canavan asked why we were punishing hardworking farming families. The National Farmers' Federation CEO said in the inquiry:

… our principal request to the committee is straightforward: please protect the primary production income exemption contained in the bills.

He went on to say:

I'd like to thank particularly the Treasury and the Treasurer for the enormous amount of consultation. The detailed work that was done in both these areas was incredibly constructive and helpful from our perspective—

support for the bill from the National Farmers' Federation, quite the contrary to what we heard from Senator Canavan in his question purporting to be on behalf of farmers in this country. The CEO of the NFF went on to say:

The baseline request from us is that primary production income, as described by the ATO, be the carve-out, or the exemption, not the total income by that business, to the extent they have income that is not primary production income.

I think that is actually the opposite point to what Senator Canavan was raising in question time. The NFF went on to say:

What we are asking for, and what we believe is very important for family farms and for Australian agriculture, is the primary production income exemption, as defined by the ATO.

(Time expired)

James McGrath

James McGrath Queensland, Liberal National Party, Shadow Special Minister of State

4:03 pm

It is a fact that the CFMEU are corrupt. It is a fact that the CFMEU are a corrupt cartel that have cost not just taxpayers but all Australians billions of dollars because of their corruption and the connection with Labor Party politicians. We only have to look at the evidence that has been provided to the Queensland commission of inquiry into the CFMEU on the links between CFMEU officials and Labor Party ministers—these are ministers who sat around the cabinet table—in terms of the power that the CFMEU held over the Labor Party when it came to the awarding of contracts and when it came to the bastardisation of the award system in Queensland. That's why it is not surprising that, in response to the questions that were put by my colleague Senator Kovacic in relation to the CFMEU, Senator Wong—who happens to be a member of the CFMEU; the forestry division, to be sure—failed to answer the questions that were put by Senator Kovacic, and in particular failed to explain why the Labor Party would not support a Senate inquiry into allegations of corruption in the construction sector.

It's pretty obvious why Senator Wong, Prime Minister Albanese and the other Labor Party ministers who sit around the cabinet table do not want to support a Senate inquiry into corruption within the construction sector—because they know that the Labor Party itself, whether at a state level or a federal level, is intrinsically linked to the CFMEU. The Labor Party, since Mr Albanese became leader, has taken over $7 million worth of donations from the CFMEU. When the coalition was in government, the Labor Party opposed the Australian Building and Construction Commission. They opposed the Registered Organisations Commission. They not only opposed stronger union accountability; they dismantled the watchdogs holding unions accountable. This is the hypocrisy that Labor often forgets. In 2019, the coalition introduced legislation to strengthen the Federal Court's powers to put a dysfunctional union into administration, and the Labor Party voted against it. When the coalition were fighting for stronger powers to remove rogue union officials and place lawbreaking unions into administration, Labor stood in our way, and we know why—because of the $7 million money trail that goes from the CFMEU to the Labor Party.

We also know, because of the evidence that has been provided to the commission of inquiry in Queensland, of the corruption between Labor Party ministers who are still serving in the Queensland parliament and CFMEU officials. We can be certain that the commission of inquiry in Victoria will unveil similar evidence. This is why the Labor Party do not want a federal Senate inquiry into corruption—because they are up to their necks in corruption, and they should be called out for it.

Question agreed to.