This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Questions without Notice: Take Note of Answers
Answers to Questions
Lisa Darmanin Victoria, Australian Labor Party
3:59 pm
The key question that Senator Wong asked in response to the original question from Senator Hume in question time is: 'Why are you standing up for the 10 per cent and not the 90 per cent?' We need to look at the broader context here. What this government is doing is trying to bring back fairness into our tax system, making judgements and treating people in a way that is reasonable. Everyone should have a fair crack at the opportunity to succeed, particularly when we know that Australians are under pressure. Importantly, this taxation legislation is part of a suite of reforms that are about taking pressure off families, making the economy more productive and resilient and making the budget more sustainable. That is the driver of all of these things for Australians: tax cuts for workers, expanding Medicare, funding aged care and early childhood care, and enabling the budget to pay for these things for 100 per cent of Australian society. Those are the values of our government, and that is what we are seeking to enshrine with these laws.
We are taking the hard decisions to reform the system in the name of fairness—to reduce the tax burden for over 13 million workers and support 75,000 Australians to enter the housing market. That is the context of these reforms in our bills. We are seeking to undertake the hard reform in our tax system by showing leadership to make sure our economy works in the interests of Australians, businesses and future generations—for not only the 10 per cent but 100 per cent.
The Senate Economics Legislation Committee inquired into this legislation very recently, and I wanted to pull out a few things from that inquiry to share with Australians who might be watching. Dr Mark Zirnsak from the Tax Justice Network observed that those with an interest in retaining existing arrangements may be more strongly motivated to engage in the debate than the broader group of taxpayers who may benefit from this reform, which I think is worth bearing in mind.
I wanted to also briefly talk about the comments from Senator Canavan with regard to farms. Senator Canavan asked why we were punishing hardworking farming families. The National Farmers' Federation CEO said in the inquiry:
… our principal request to the committee is straightforward: please protect the primary production income exemption contained in the bills.
He went on to say:
I'd like to thank particularly the Treasury and the Treasurer for the enormous amount of consultation. The detailed work that was done in both these areas was incredibly constructive and helpful from our perspective—
support for the bill from the National Farmers' Federation, quite the contrary to what we heard from Senator Canavan in his question purporting to be on behalf of farmers in this country. The CEO of the NFF went on to say:
The baseline request from us is that primary production income, as described by the ATO, be the carve-out, or the exemption, not the total income by that business, to the extent they have income that is not primary production income.
I think that is actually the opposite point to what Senator Canavan was raising in question time. The NFF went on to say:
What we are asking for, and what we believe is very important for family farms and for Australian agriculture, is the primary production income exemption, as defined by the ATO.
(Time expired)
No comments