This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Questions without Notice: Take Note of Answers

Answers to Questions


Dave Sharma

Dave Sharma NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

3:48 pm

I move:

That the Senate take note of the answers given by ministers to questions without notice asked by opposition senators today.

Yet again today in this chamber we heard from a government that doesn't understand small business, that doesn't know small business, that has no experience of small business and that has no empathy whatsoever for small business. Small businesses at the moment are failing at the rate 46 per day—that is, going into administration or insolvency—every single day, not just Monday to Friday but Saturdays and Sundays, the highest rate of failure we've seen in several years, and yet what we hear from this government as they go about imposing a new and novel tax on small business is a complete disregard for them. We were told by Minister Wong that it's only 10 per cent of small businesses that operate through trusts. Well, it's 350,000 small businesses that use these, and the bulk of them are classified by the ATO as micro businesses—that is, with turnover under $2 million, the vast majority. These are mum-and-dad, brother-and-sister, mother-and-daughter operations. They're some of the most vulnerable businesses in our country, and Labor is hitting them with new taxes.

It's not like the Labor government took these taxes to the last election. It's not like they told small business before the last election that they were going to put this impost on you. No; they unveiled this in their budget of broken promises. Their assault on aspiration was included in that.

We have small businesses at the moment dealing with a cashflow crisis. They've got weak consumer demand, high electricity prices, high inflation and interest rates that are some of the highest amongst advanced economies in the world. They've got new industrial relations laws to deal with. They had credit card surcharging to absorb. They've got payday super that they've had to absorb. On top of all this, the government think they will now impose a minimum tax on the main vehicle that small businesses use to structure their affairs—a discretionary trust.

This leaves small businesses with only bad options. They can be faced with a 30 per cent minimum tax, but you need to be earning over $230,000 as a small-business owner to be paying anywhere near that level of tax now. You can be forced into restructuring your business at a cost of around $50,000 to $100,000 in legal and advisory fees, plus the stamp duty on that, or you can opt into a fixed trust, which will mean that your business structure and those who can participate in your business will not be able to change or grow or evolve with the business.

This is nothing more than an attack on small business from a government that has no regard for them, as their own ministers say—a government that has no experience of small business and no knowledge of small business. It could only come from a government that is completely cavalier about the state of the economy, the state of small business in Australia and the number of households and businesses doing it tough right now in adverse economic conditions.

Comments

No comments