House debates Bills

Workplace Gender Equality Amendment (Setting Gender Equality Targets) Bill 2024; Second Reading

Thursday, 28 November 2024 House of Representatives

Allegra Spender

Allegra Spender Wentworth, Independent

12:11 pm

Workplace gender equality is extremely close to my heart. I've sat in boardrooms and, indeed, parliamentary groups where there have certainly been too few women. Gender equality is about more than just motherhood statements; it's about ensuring a diversity of ideas and methods and getting the best out of businesses and organisations.

Our economy is more productive for it. For the past number of years, one of the leading drivers in Australia's economic growth has been the increasing participation of women across the economy. Economists from Stanford and the University of Chicago estimate the dividend from increased female participation and workforce allocation to be between 20 and 40 per cent of the rise in living standards since 1960.

However, I am conflicted by the Workplace Gender Equality Amendment (Setting Gender Equality Targets) Bill 2024. On the one side, I am hugely supportive of the work of WGEA. Their data creates transparency around gender pay and equity in Australian companies, which has really lit a fire, frankly, under many businesses that I am aware of. This is something that I know the businesses I talk to think about, and there is much more transparency here in the Australian economy now than there ever was in the past. It is actually achieving results. We are seeing more continually dropping gaps in gender disparity, pay and other things than we have seen at any time in the past. I think this is absolutely fabulous, so congratulations to WGEA both for the data they collect and for the way that they demonstrate this and share it with the community.

However, I do have concerns about the practical arrangements in this bill. I'll be honest: I'm not sure that what is being outlined in this bill will actually make a significant difference to gender equity and genuine differences in the pay and conditions and opportunities for women.

This bill sits alongside previous legislation to implement 10 recommendations of the 2022 review of the WGEA act. Last year, this government passed the 'closing the gender pay gap' legislation—which I supported—that moved on recommendations 2, 3, 5 and 9 of that review. As part of that legislation, the government released a schedule of the recommendations, showing progress or completion against all of the other 10 recommendations. This bill seeks to implement recommendation 3.1 of the review of workplace gender equality and will require companies with 500 or more employees to select and meet gender equality targets and report progress to the agency. These targets will operate on a three-year rolling basis where new targets from the menu will be selected at the start of each cycle. While there are no penalties included in the legislation, the EM infers that failure to meet targets will have implications on government procurement.

I have a number of concerns in relation to this. Firstly, I think the application of these targets is not overly scientific, and I'm concerned that it has the potential to become another tick-box exercise for business. For good reason, the list of targets is long, but it also relies on self-selection and self-reporting. It is unclear to me whether this would meaningfully shift the dial on workplace equality and whether it would start to be gamed by businesses on the basis that it might affect procurement.

I am also concerned that, while WGEA has taken some really significant and positive steps in trying to improve the efficiency and simplicity of its reporting, it is still a very difficult reporting framework for companies to provide that data. I think the transparency that WGEA provides is excellent. However, I know that, in many businesses, it takes senior people a significant amount of time to complete the WGEA framework. My concern is that this is going to add to that without necessarily driving better outcomes.

I am also concerned that it's not clear to me—and certainly not clear in our conversations to date with WGEA—how this works in different businesses that might be skewed more towards women. There are industries out there where women are a significant proportion of the workforce, in certain workplaces. I'm still trying to understand, from WGEA whether the purpose is to have fifty-fifty in every single industry, in every single business. What do you do with a business that has, for instance, 80 per cent women? How is that treated? To be honest, when we've had some of those conversations, we haven't had particularly clear outcomes and advice. So, as I said, I very much support the work of WGEA, and I would certainly be in support of businesses voluntarily setting and publishing these targets. But I do think the transparency and accountability that the current WGEA framework provides is actually the best way to get our companies, particularly our big companies, to move further on gender equity. I think that is much more powerful than what is being proposed in this bill.

One other, additional question that has been raised with me by community members, in examining WGEA, is around partnership organisations such as law firms and accountancies, where different types of partners get remunerated in different ways. The equity schemes around partnerships mean that some aspects of gender inequity aren't really coming out in these statistics, particularly if partners are salaried versus equity partners. We might need to have slightly different reporting frameworks to do the right thing by this area.

Those are some potential opportunities for improvement that I think we can make. As I said at the start, I really do think that WGEA does incredible work, and I think it is that transparency—shining a light on businesses—that is the best chance for us to drive gender equity, particularly in a tight labour market where people have real choices about where they work. I am concerned about some aspects of this bill which are really more about ticking boxes—which I think can be gamed and aren't actually particularly scientific or, in my mind, necessarily going to drive the outcomes.

Comments

No comments