House debates Bills

Workplace Gender Equality Amendment (Setting Gender Equality Targets) Bill 2024; Second Reading

Thursday, 28 November 2024 House of Representatives

David Gillespie

David Gillespie Lyne, National Party

12:04 pm

The Workplace Gender Equality Amendment (Setting Gender Equality Targets) Bill 2024 amends the Workplace Gender Equality Act 2012, and I would like to highlight that there are many practical impossibilities for parts of the Australian workforce and non-government, private employers, particularly in my rural and regional electorate. Admittedly, we don't have Microsoft, EY and SAP in my electorate, but we have plenty of big employers where this will really cause huge problems through either the gender target or the selection of the three items described, from the list of what will become mandatory.

We have some very significant big businesses with several hundred employees, like the Wingham Beef Exports abattoir. There is no way in my known calculation that we will get gender equity among abattoir workers. It is a very horrific and challenging experience working in the slaughter room or in the boning room. Most women that I know couldn't think of anything worse, and that's why 99 per cent of workers in that side of the business are generally male. There is more of a gender split for people in management and in executive positions, but to put these unrealistic targets on some industries—I've been underground in coalmines and I can tell you it's rare to find a woman who wants to be stuck underground, but that's what the vast majority of the people working there do.

In fact, all of my childcare centres are overwhelmingly employing women in childcare positions. That will mean they will have to set targets to get a whole lot of men to work in their business, which is totally unrealistic. Look, there are some men who work in child care—great. I think part of the problem for some of our children is that we don't have enough men in these caring roles; in the old days we had many more male teachers in the system. Does that mean that all the government schools and private schools—some of them have easily a hundred teachers on their payroll—will have to get many more men? They won't be able to, so they'll be in breach.

I'm talking about boilermakers, steelworkers and workers like that. Human nature means that males tend to do this work because of its nature; it's physical, it's hard, it's dirty and it's relentless. Traditionally, they would have great trouble getting a lot of women to meet these targets. Sure, you can have targets for boardrooms, white-collar jobs and things like that, but, in the real world out in my electorate, we have many people who aren't in that space—and that's the problem.

In the big cities of Australia now, even in this wonderful capital of Australia, there are two or three generations that haven't had anyone in their immediate family or extended family who's been in a greasy, blue-collar, hard, ugly workplace called a factory. In Sydney—or over in Queanbeyan, where I grew up—we used to have heaps of people working in factories. Now everything comes from China, and we order it online. We have a laptop economy, and people are working in air-conditioned buildings. It's part of the reason we are so vulnerable: we've lost a lot of that industry.

I think you need a bit of a reality check, because, in my world, this won't fly. It will fly in some places, but I don't know if forcing companies to mandate that they have gender targets and penalising them if they don't by removing contracts will fly for these companies like EY and SAP. Even the minister mentioned in her second reading speech that we are going to use $70 billion worth of contracting to force people to employ people and to meet gender targets and all the other lists. I think that's going to be a bit of an interesting challenge.

In her own words—I will just get her second reading speech—she outlined that no-one else in the world is doing this. Is that not telling you something? This really needs a reality check. There's going to have to be much more flexibility in this for many private employers who have more than 100 people. I know some colleagues here ran big civil constructing companies and got workers from all around the world when we built all the gas infrastructure in Queensland and the Northern Territory. Just about every one of those companies down the line would be in breach of this law. There is no way that they could maintain it. So this needs a total rethink, a touch of reality. By all means, get more pay equity, but in the businesses I have worked in—in health and administration—there is no pay gap. There's a pay rate that everyone gets. It's gender blind. Admittedly, in the corporate world, people get different salaries, but, when you look at part-time versus full-time work, because of the nature of how families have set up since time immemorial, generally a lot of women don't want to have a full-time job. It works for their family, their partner and their own personal choices; they would prefer part-time work. In the same vein, I would not be in a rush to take up all the parts of this bill. I would accept some of them, but, really, it needs a rethink.

Comments

No comments