This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Bills
Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026; Second Reading
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
12:31 pm
Well, now we see it, don't we? A piece of legislation that literally strips away civil rights and gives extraordinary wartime powers to the defence minister is now being guillotined with barely half an hour's debate. That is absolutely typical of the pro Washington mindset. Whatever Washington wants, whatever you need to do—you need to have extreme powers, to hand arrest powers over to US Defense officials when they turn up to the country—yes, absolutely, we'll get it through.
It's no surprise, is it, that it was Minister Khalil who actually shepherded this through on behalf of the government. Minister Khalil was mentioned as a protected US asset in Wikileaks. We've all read the Wikileaks cables. This is the same bloke who's having his name hidden while he's giving secret information to US intelligence and US embassy officials; the same bloke who was giving the special sauce, that secret information, to the US, having been an adviser to Kevin Rudd and Foreign Affairs; and the same bloke who was having his name protected by the US so that their protected source isn't burnt—that same bloke. Minister Khalil is the bloke who is shepherding this legislation through. Literally a US protected asset is one of the assistant ministers for the Labor government, and he's the bloke you give the job to shepherd this bill through. You can't make this stuff up, can you?
And then because you don't want this dirty laundry aired and you don't want the truth about the complicit hostage relationship between the Labor Party, the coalition and Washington aired, you guillotine this. It's no wonder you don't want the public to hear about it. And I say again, the minister that the Albanese Labor government gave the job to push through these extreme powers is the same bloke mentioned in Wikileaks cables as being a protected US source. And you made him a minister. You give him access to our defence secrets. You've known all along. It's unbelievable. It is unbelievable. Of course, you're given protection by the coalition because they don't want the club to be spooked. They don't want their own, no doubt, protected assets to be publicly disclosed. Just keep those secrets with Washington. This piece of legislation is extraordinary, from the Labor Party—or should I say the Labor political party, because it's so bloody far from the actual interests of working people.
This is what the MUA said about this bill in their submission:
Proposed section 72F prohibits using security powers to prevent or restrict protest, dissent, assembly or industrial action, but contains significant exceptions. These include a reasonable likelihood of a criminal offence involving a risk to defence security purposes or obstruction of a defence activity. The provision therefore does not provide an unqualified protection for industrial action or peaceful protest.
… … …
The MUA seeks express protection for lawful industrial action, union access, safety reporting and workers' rights to cease unsafe work. Opposition to foreign military activities or nuclear-related cargo must not itself be treated as a security threat.
The MUA is saying it pretty clearly here. They have a proud history of stopping weapons and materials going to feed appalling conflicts around the world—a proud history, stopping pig iron going into the then imperial Japanese war machine for its appalling war in China; a proud history, stopping weapons being sent to the NT to commit appalling genocide against First Nations people; a proud history, stopping the Dutch military from feeding weapons into Indonesia after World War II and being critical in seeing Indonesian independence in their post-colonial struggle; a proud history, standing beside First Nations peoples against their land being poisoned by the nuclear industry. And they are concerned that if they take industrial action to protect those kinds of interests in the future then the Albanese Labor government will jail them—that if they block access at a port to some of this nuclear material going into the weapons industry in Australia their members will face two years in jail.
They're right to be worried about it, or to worry that if their members join a protest at Pine Gap and block the road to Pine Gap it will be seven years in jail. They're right to be worried about that. The MUA is often there in solidarity. Of course they're asking the Albanese government, 'Why are you pushing these laws through?' Dissent, protest, industrial action—they're basic rights. What is extraordinary about this bill is that it allows the minister or the minister's delegate to make anybody—it doesn't have to be an Australian, although I think it probably has to be human, but you never can tell; maybe it could be an AI automated bot—a defence security official. Anyone can be called a 'defence security official'. So it could be a member of the US military, it could be an employee of Lockheed Martin or it could be just some staff member of the Department of Defence. Then, being designated a defence security official, they're given extraordinary powers. They can conduct administrative screening searches of people, require people to give the official their name and their residential address. They can detain people they suspect 'might' be planning to commit a criminal offence.
I'll give you an example. Say you make one of these Lockheed Martin employees a defence security official. They're there at Pine Gap. They see a protest happening. They think, 'Oh, you might block the road; therefore in the future you might commit a criminal offence,' and they're going to detain you. You could literally be arrested by a defence contractor, or you could be arrested by a member of the US military, because they think you might commit an offence. Those are the powers that are being given here. I mean, what the bloody hell? Why do you think these extraordinary, totally fascist kinds of powers are necessary? My reading of Australians is that they're overwhelmingly law-abiding people. They respect our democracy. They respect each other. But they also respect the right to call out their government and to protest. What government thinks you need these kinds of powers over your fellow Australians? What are you fearing about your fellow Australians—that they're suddenly going to come together and not agree with the government? Well, that's their right. What are you fearing about Australians—that they're going to come and protest, because they don't like nuclear weapons being brought into the country? Well, that's their right. What if they're going to come and protest because don't like hundreds of billions of dollars of our money being funnelled off to the United States and the UK for weapons? That's their right—that's our fellow Australians' right.
But to Labor and the coalition: One Nation are going to join with you in this. In fact, One Nation wants to toughen the offences. They want to make them even tougher offences, if anyone dares to protest. And you, the three war parties in this place—the Labor Party, the coalition and One Nation—are not going to war against some foreign country; you're going to war against your fellow Australians. That's who this legislation is aimed at. It's not aimed at China. It's not aimed at Russia. It's definitely not aimed at the US. It's aimed at your fellow Australians. You want to criminalise and jail and punish your fellow Australians because they might disagree with you—they might have a different view about the way this world goes. And let's be clear: this legislation is going to war against democracy; it's going to war against our own civil rights. And you, the three war parties here, are going to war against your fellow Australians.
For all the disagreements we had, I had thought we shared values on basic rights about democracy and about the right to protest, and about not giving these extraordinary wartime powers to ministers like Minister Khalil, or to the Deputy Prime Minister, as he insists on being called—the Minister for Defence, Minister Marles. Why do you think that your fellow Australians are such a threat to you all that you need these extraordinary powers—that you can appoint anyone to shake them down in public, demand their names and demand their address, and, if you don't like what they're about to do, detain them, because they might commit a crime in the future, and, if they resist, put them in jail for two years? Why are you going to war against your fellow Australians with this? You're so fearful of people organising, expressing dissent and having a different view that you're coming down like this. And all for what? So that you can get AUKUS going up, or you can get another US military base going up, or you can keep Pine Gap going? You are betraying your own country with this legislation. You are betraying our democratic values. And that's why the Greens are opposing it.
Jessica Collins NSW, Liberal Party
12:42 pm
I rise to speak on the Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026. Australia faces the most challenging strategic times we have seen in decades. The warning signs around the world are clear: major powers are competing more aggressively, military technologies are evolving at extraordinary speed and the prospect of conflict can no longer be treated as a distant or theoretical possibility. We must act on the assumption that we are living in a pre-conflict environment and prepare accordingly. That means ensuring that the Australian Defence Force has the capabilities, authorities and resources it needs to defend our nation. It means making sure the delivery of AUKUS—the AUKUS submarine program—does not come at the expense of other critical capabilities. It means ensuring that our service men and women have the powers they need in a modern operational environment. It also means removing unnecessary regulatory barriers that slow the development, testing and transfer of defence technology, particularly where those barriers undermine our ability to work effectively with trusted partners through AUKUS. For those reasons, the coalition supports this bill in principle.
The legislation seeks to modernise defence laws that, in many cases, have not kept pace with the way defence operates today. Technology has changed. The nature of threats has changed. Industry participation has changed. International collaboration has changed. Yet much of the legislative framework underpinning defence activities remains rooted in the past. The bill attempts to address that reality by creating new arrangements for defence capability development, by strengthening protections around Defence facilities and bases and by establishing oversight mechanisms intended to provide accountability for these expanded powers. There is merit in many of those objectives and, for many years, Defence industry participants have argued that Australia's overlapping and complex regulatory requirements can make it easier to test certain technologies overseas than here at home. That is not a good outcome for our national security. If we want Australia to become a serious defence industrial nation, we need an environment that encourages innovation, experimentation and capability development within our own borders. Of course, we need a regulatory environment that enables defence innovation and preparedness. Of course, we need flexible and fit-for-purpose policy to govern the defence of our ADF bases and capabilities. These are sensible objectives, and they deserve bipartisan support.
The second major reform in this bill relates to Defence security zones and the protection of Defence establishments. In recent years, we've seen a sharp increase in reports of drone incursions over Defence facilities. Figures released by Defence indicate that reported drone incursions at ADF bases increased dramatically from 21 in 2022-23 to 60 in 2023-24 and now 246 since mid-2025. That trend should concern every senator in this chamber. There have been reports that ADF personnel have effectively been left with little option but to shut blinds and limit visibility when drones are operating overhead. That is not a credible approach to security. It is not a serious deterrent. It is not fair on the men and women charged with protecting Australia's most sensitive military facilities. Our ADF personnel deserve the authority and legal protections necessary to detect, disrupt and neutralise unlawful drone activity around Defence sites.
The coalition has consistently argued that this gap must be addressed, and we welcome the fact that the bill seeks to provide Defence with clearer authority to respond to these emerging threats. However, while the coalition supports the broad direction of this legislation, we do have concerns. The first is that parliament has been given limited time to properly scrutinise legislation that grants significant new powers and authorities. Parliamentary review is not an inconvenience and it is not a roadblock. It is a vital part of our democratic system. It allows stakeholders, industry participants, experts and parliamentarians to identify drafting problems, unintended consequences and areas where safeguards might be inadequate. Ideally, there should have been more time for public consultation. Ideally, defence industry should have had greater opportunity to engage with the detail. Ideally, parliament would have had longer to examine the provisions that will have lasting implications for Defence operations and government accountability.
Notwithstanding these concerns, the coalition believes these reforms are sufficiently important that the legislation should proceed. That is why the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Defence conducted an inquiry into the bill and why coalition members proposed a number of sensible amendments to strengthen oversight and accountability. I have serious concerns about the oversight and checks and balances surrounding the powers provided to the minister under this legislation. The bill grants the minister significant authority in relation to capability declarations and the operation of these new frameworks. Yet, in circumstances where public transparency mechanisms may be limited for national security reasons, the parliament must ensure that alternative oversight arrangements are sufficiently robust. These concerns are not theoretical.
They are made more pressing because these significant new authorities will be exercised by a Defence minister whose judgement has repeatedly fallen short of the standards Australians should expect. I am deeply concerned about the prospect of concentrating more power in the hands of a minister whose record demonstrates such consistently poor judgement on some of the most important issues facing Defence, veterans and national security. This is a minister who has supported the divestment of strategically important Defence sites at a time when Australia should be strengthening our national resilience, preserving strategic options and expanding our sovereign capability. At the very moment our strategic outlook is deteriorating, his instinct has too often been to retreat rather than reinforce.
This is a minister who has failed to secure the level of defence investment required for the times in which we live. Australians are constantly told that our strategic environment is the most dangerous since the Second World War, yet Defence continues to face capability pressures, workforce shortages and growing concerns about whether AUKUS can be delivered without hollowing out our other essential capabilities. And this is a minister whose treatment of veterans has seriously undermined confidence within the veteran community. Many veterans will never forget the government's attempts to impose a $5,000 cap on healthcare support. At a time when our obligations should have been to stand beside those who served our nation, this government proposed measures that veterans rightly viewed as abandonment of them. This is also a minister whose reforms and Defence discipline matters have raised legitimate concerns about political interference in systems that must remain independent, impartial and trusted. Confidence in military justice and Defence discipline depends on those systems operating free from political interference. When ministers involve themselves in those matters, confidence in those institutions is diminished.
For those reasons, I do not believe parliament should simply accept assurances from the minister and move on. Strong powers demand strong safeguards, and expanding ministerial authority demands stronger oversight. Where transparency is necessarily reduced in the name of national security, accountability must be increased rather than weakened. Unfortunately, the government's approach should surprise no-one. Time and again, we have seen a preference for secrecy over scrutiny, for concentrating power within the minister's office rather than sharing accountability, and for controlling information over embracing transparency. That is their natural state—obfuscation. This is precisely why the coalition sought stronger parliamentary oversight, more robust review mechanisms and additional safeguards around the exercise of those powers.
Despite those concerns, there are important reforms in this bill that should proceed. An amendment will be moved by One Nation that would create two Commonwealth criminal offences for damaging, destroying, desecrating or defacing Australian war memorials, with penalties of up to 12 years imprisonment. This is already the coalition's policy. Under the coalition, we will protect Australia Day on 26 January in Commonwealth law, with any future change to our national day requiring the approval of the Australian people through a national plebiscite. We will create a criminal offence for serious public desecration of the Australian national flag where a person is reckless as to whether their actions will incite hatred or violence, threaten public order or cause a public disturbance. And we will, importantly, create a federal criminal offence with serious penalties for deliberately damaging, defacing, desecrating or destroying war memorials and other significant memorials commemorating Australia's history.
The laws would protect not only traditional war memorials but significant monuments, statues, plaques and commemorative structures recognising the people, events and institutions that form part of Australia's national story. Australians should never be made to apologise for loving their country. Australians are entitled to be proud of their country, and we should protect the symbols and memorials that have made us the great nation that we are. The coalition believes Australia is the greatest country in the world and is worth protecting. We will stand up for our country, honour those who came before us and protect the Australian way of life for generations to come.
The coalition has approached this defence legislation amendment constructively and in good faith, because Australia's national security should always come before politics. We are proud of the role the former coalition government played in establishing AUKUS. It was a decision that required courage, foresight and vision. It was made because it was in Australia's national interest. Delivering on that vision will require patience, determination and a bipartisan commitment to strengthen Australia's defence capability over the long term. The coalition will continue to support measures that strengthen Australia's national security. We want Australia's defence force to be stronger. We want our defence industry to grow. We want our bases to be secure. We want to protect our war memorials and commemorative statues. We want to protect our great national story. We want our servicemen and servicewomen to have every tool they need to protect this country and, if necessary, to fight and win. We will continue to hold this government to account to ensure it is doing everything possible to provide the Australian Defence Force with the resources, authorities and support it needs. On that, I commend the bill to the Senate.
Pauline Hanson Queensland, Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party
12:55 pm
I want to go to One Nation's amendments on sheet 4233 to protect war memorials. I'm very pleased to hear of the coalition's support for our war memorials, so I don't see that there should be any problem with them supporting my amendments. The amendments draw a very simple line in the sand: if you deliberately destroy or desecrate a war memorial in Australia, you should face serious consequences. One Nation says those consequences should be up to 12 years in jail. War memorials remind us of the sacrifice and people who died for our freedom and democracy. They carry the names of Australians who served this country. They commemorate Australians who fought, Australians who sacrificed and Australians who never came home.
These amendments create a specific Commonwealth offence where a person intentionally engages in conduct that results in the destruction, damage, desecration or defacement of a war memorial or part of it and is reckless as to that result. That includes plaques, inscriptions, statues and other parts of a memorial where the conduct results in destruction, damage, desecration or defacement. The basic offence carries a maximum penalty of seven years imprisonment and civil penalties. For the most serious cases, there will be a separate aggravated offence carrying up to 12 years imprisonment. That higher penalty can apply where the basic offence involves substantial destruction or damage; conduct motivated by hostility towards the person or Australian military history commemorated; conduct forming part of a coordinated or organised attack or activity; or a person previously convicted of the basic offence—repeat offenders. Offenders who aren't citizens will be deported.
The amendments are intended to provide protection across Australia. They cover objects commemorating Australian military history. It will not matter whether the memorial belongs to the Commonwealth, a state or territory, a council, an RSL, another community organisation or a private owner. It will not matter whether it stands on public or private land. The sacrifice being remembered doesn't change depending on who owns the memorial or where it stands. The amendments also provide an exception for conduct undertaken in good faith for the purpose of repairing, maintaining or performing authorised works on the memorial. They don't replace existing state or territory laws; they create a specific Commonwealth protection that can operate alongside them.
These amendments are supported by section 51(vi) of the Constitution, the defence power. It is connected on several grounds. The first ground is the preservation of military institutions. War memorials preserve the history, traditions and identity of Australians armed forces. Their protection supports the continuity of those institutions rather than serving only a heritage or property protection purpose. The second ground is the maintenance of military morale and standing. Memorials provide enduring public recognition of military service and sacrifice. Protecting that recognition contributes to the institutional role and public standing of the Australian Defence Force. The third ground is the capacity to raise and maintain armed forces. Public recognition of military service supports recruitment, retention and community support for the Australian Defence Force. Protecting memorials contributes to maintaining the armed forces.
Finally, the national character of defence explains the proposed nationwide application. Memorials to Australian military service retain their connection to defence regardless of ownership or location. Protecting them requires a Commonwealth offence that applies to the whole country. Every year, politicians line up on Anzac Day, lay their wreaths, give their speeches and tell us, 'Lest we forget.' Those words have to mean something. Someone who deliberately desecrates a war memorial is not simply damaging property; they are attacking something deliberately created to preserve the memory of Australians who served their country. This amendments recognise that distinction in Commonwealth law. It says that the memorials to Australian service and sacrifice deserve protection wherever they stand in this country and that deliberately destroying or desecrating them is a serious offence. I urge senators to support the amendments and punish those low-life thugs who wish to tear down the memory of Defence personnel who died protecting our country.
Sue Lines President
Pursuant to order, the time allotted for consideration of these bills has expired.