This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Motions

Carers


Penny Allman-Payne

Penny Allman-Payne Queensland, Australian Greens

4:16 pm

I move:

That the Senate—

(a) notes that:

(i) carers make an invaluable contribution to Australian society through looking after Australia's young, sick, disabled and elderly,

(ii) despite this, Labor has failed to provide an adequate safety net for carers,

(iii) Labor is relying on unpaid, gendered care economies to plug the holes they have created in aged care, health and the National Disability Insurance Scheme instead of taxing gas exporters who are making billions in profit, and

(iv) too many carers are living and retiring in poverty due to the inadequacy of social security payments and the unfair restrictions of the partner income test; and

(b) calls on the Government to:

(i) increase the carer payment to above the Henderson poverty line,

(ii) immediately introduce a minimum 25% tax on gas exports to adequately fund the public services that support carers and the people they care for,

(iii) restore funding to Ask Izzy so carers have access to vital navigation support, and

(iv) urgently establish an independent review of respite care services.

Across the country, carers are at breaking point. For years they've taken time off work to care for Australia's young, sick, disabled and elderly. Without carers, many of whom are unpaid and the majority of whom are women, Australian society would fall apart. There would be a national crisis if all the carers stopped even for just a day. The question is: who's looking after the carers? It's certainly not the government. The Henderson Poverty Line currently sits at $708.86 a week for a single person or $948.25 a week for couples. The maximum rate for the carer payment is $567.70 a week for singles and $855.90 a week for couples, falling about $100 to $150 short of the poverty line each and every week. For someone on the carer payment, their payment starts going down 25c off the dollar once their partner starts to earn more than $396 a fortnight, and there's no superannuation paid on carer payment either, but it's all okay because the aged pension rate is also below the poverty line. The current and former governments have ensured that carers are retiring in poverty either way.

Instead of providing a safety net for carers, the other parties seem more interested in courting multinational fossil fuel corporations. People living in Australia have missed out on an estimated $135 billion in revenue over the past 14 years following Labor's decision to abandon its proposed resource super profits tax under the pressure of the mining lobby. Last month, the Prosper Australia Research Institute released their report, showing that Australia could rake in $45 billion more each year if the government adequately valued and taxed our resources. A minimum 25 per cent tax on gas exports alone would give Australians over $17 billion a year.

Instead Labor has looked to make their budget savings from pickpocketing $37 billion from the NDIS, $1.2 billion from pensioners health rebates and forcing older people to pay up to 80 per cent of the costs of aged-care support. The government is choosing to rob our public services because they know that carers will pick up Labor's slack. When you make cuts to the NDIS, it's carers who step in. When older people can't afford their care, it's carers who step in and pick up the slack. But carers are at a crisis point. More carers are facing burnout, or they are simply unable to afford to keep going because Labor has ripped away the safety net from carers and the people they support.

Just yesterday, a woman named Antonetta called my parliament office in distress. She's been a carer for 40 years. She's dedicated most of her adult life to the person she cares for and, before him, his elderly mother. Antonetta has paid for all his bills, looked after his house and her care responsibilities are practically 24/7. Yet all the person she cares for gets in aged-care support is two hours a week. Antonetta single-handedly helped the person she cares for out of incarceration and into his own home. But now, when Antonetta needs help, there's nowhere she can turn. She's told my staff that she's going to lose her home.

Care is costly, but the carer payment and the carer allowance rates are an absolute joke. Antonetta gave me permission to share her story in parliament because she wants to highlight just what carers are going through in this country and the total lack of support for this cohort that's increasingly at their breaking point. This is her message to the government who has sent the NDIS and aged-care backwards while refusing to increase support for carers. She says, 'What are you waiting for—to kill us?'

Carers like Antonetta are crying out for support. Cuts to social services like Ask Izzy and the NDIS cuts mean carers are spending more time negotiating with bureaucrats just to ensure their loved one doesn't die from government neglect. Carers are contributing to the economy for nothing in return, yet gas corporations like Santos and LNG literally do the opposite. They take Australian resources, profit off them to the tune of billions and then spend their time hiding their income so they can do all that for free. Santos is on their 11th straight year of paying zero corporate tax, despite having nearly $52 billion in sales. LNG, for the seventh year running, has managed to pay no corporate tax or any PRRT despite $53 billion in sales. This Labor government is choosing to protect the profit motives of the wealthiest corporations at the direct expense of Australia's carers.

I also want to mention young carers, who are often left out of the policy conversation. Young carers are people up to 25 years old who provide unpaid care and support to family members or friends who have a disability, mental illness, chronic condition, alcohol or other drug issue, or who are frail and aged. Many young carers emphasise that caring is a positive experience, but inadequate support ruins a young carer's health, mental health and wellbeing. A study published in the Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry reported that two-thirds of all young carers experience extreme mental health challenges. Many young carers aren't even aware that they are one, or that they may qualify for support because care is an expectation from their family and increasingly from governments looking to find budget savings. Even among young carers who are typically looking after family members care is unequally shared, with 58 per cent of young carers identifying as female.

Looking after carers is good for all of us. The Greens would lift the carer payment above the poverty line. We would allow carers to keep more of their Centrelink payment by abolishing partner income testing and fixing taper rates. We'd fix aged-care assessments, which are seeing older people routinely underassessed for their care needs. We would abolish co-payments in aged care that are seeing older people having to refuse services that they can't afford. These are all things that increase the burden on carers. We would properly fund the NDIS and not throw 160,000-plus people off this scheme that provides much-needed care and support.

The thing is: the government could do all of these things. Governments make choices. They make choices about where they're going to find their budget savings. Over this term of government—over the last 4½ years—this government has kept looking to the people with the least. They still haven't increased welfare payments, including the carers' payment, to put them above the poverty line. They still haven't gotten rid of the partner income test—which we know traps people in instances of family and domestic violence and puts vulnerable people with disability in situations that are unsafe—which we need to do to make sure that carers get the money that they need.

This is a government that knows that older people are routinely being underassessed by the IAT. Yet we see review after review and extra review pathways, without it acknowledging that the core of the problem is that the tool is broken and older people cannot get the level of care that they need. This is a government that told older people already in the home-care system that they would be no worse off, and yet we know that people who've moved from home-care packages are now getting 40 per cent less of the care that their packages purchased before. All of these things put additional burdens on carers.

We heard, in the epilepsy inquiry, how devastating it is for people with uncontrolled epilepsy—how they need to have people around them, to have 24/7 care, and yet they can't always get access to the NDIS and the support that they need. That means it's family members who are providing care. We've heard from families in the school refusal inquiry with young people who suffer extreme mental health distress, caused by things in the school environment, who desperately want to go to school but can't. We've heard from parents who've had to give up their jobs to care for their young person at home. Yet every single person in these situations is being asked to live on a poverty payment.

This is a problem that is fixable. It requires governments to care for the carers, who provide billions and billions of dollars' worth of care into our economy.

What we need is a Labor government that is prepared to stand up to the gas and mining lobbyists, to make sure that they pay their fair share. The government needs to make sure that wealthy corporations that are making billions of dollars in profits—the one in three who aren't paying any tax—pay tax. It needs to start looking after the people who care for the carers. It's time this government started taxing the extreme wealth of massive corporations, instead of leeching off the hard work and care of our carers.

Anne Ruston

Anne Ruston SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Health and Aged Care

4:28 pm

I rise to speak on the motion moved by Senator Allman-Payne. Let me say at the outset that there is not a senator on this side of the chamber who does not value Australia's carers.

There are around three million Australians who care for someone they love without being paid a cent: a mum caring for a child with a disability; a daughter caring for her dad with dementia; a husband caring for his wife through a cancer treatment. They do it quietly, and they do it every day, all around Australia. And most of them wouldn't even call themselves 'carers'. They would just say that they are family, helping a loved one.

Carers Australia estimated a few years ago that the care that carers provide would have cost almost $78 billion a year to replace. That's the patience, the love and the sheer hard work holding our health, aged-care and disability systems together. And right now carers are carrying more than ever, because when the system fails, it's the carers who pick up the pieces. When an older person waits months for a home-care package, it's their families who try and fill the gap. And last financial year, more than 6,400 Australians died waiting for a home-care package that they'd been assessed as needing by this government. Behind every one of those people was a family member doing their best to try and hold things together for their older loved one. When an algorithm incorrectly assesses someone's needs, and no human can override it, it is often the carer who is left to fight that decision. And when respite isn't there, it's the carer who goes without sleep and without a break, too often without looking after their own health. This Albanese government keeps building systems around the process and forgetting the person that's at the centre, and the person at the centre so often has a carer standing right beside them.

So, yes, there are serious issues here that deserve this Senate's attention, which is why I am very disappointed this motion from the Greens is not a standalone motion. Carers deserve a motion about carers. Instead, the Greens have moved a motion about some of the most selfless people in our community and tacked on a policy that has absolutely nothing to do with them. That is not standing up for carers; that's actually using them. It cheapens the very contribution this motion claims to honour.

Carers should not be a prop for the Greens' or anyone's political agenda. Carers are not a gotcha moment, and they are certainly not a bargaining chip. Australians, I think, quite frankly, are sick of that sort of politics. They're sick of the grandstanding, and they're sick of watching serious issues be turned into stunts. If the Greens were genuinely serious about carers, they would have let this motion stand on its own. They would have let the Senate speak with one voice for carers. Instead, they've made that impossible for anybody who disagrees with their unrelated policy to support it. I suspect that may well have been the point.

It was the coalition that established the Carer Gateway, so carers had one place to turn for advice, counselling and respite, and the coalition will keep standing with carers and the organisations that support them. Carers give everything they have to the people that they love. The least the Senate can do is treat them honestly, because carers deserve nothing less.

Barbara Pocock

Barbara Pocock SA, Australian Greens

4:32 pm

I rise to support this motion, and I associate myself with the comments of my colleague Senator Allman-Payne. One of the great lies of modern economic thinking is that the world of production, the economy, is not thoroughly dependent on the work of unvalued carers and all that they do in terms of social reproduction. That's what feminist economists have come to call the 'great hidden iceberg of care' that underpins the small peak of the economy that we see peeking out of the ocean. We know that GDP is overshadowed by the incredible value of unpaid care that we do not count, that we often ignore and in many cases that we load up and increase through our policy work and changes.

This motion is important. It points to the fact that carers make an invaluable contribution to our society through looking after young people, the disabled and our kids, raising the next generation and looking after the elderly. Despite this, the Labor government has failed to provide an adequate safety net for our carers. Our economy is increasingly relying on the unpaid, gendered care economies that plug the holes as we thin out systems like the aged-care system and the NDIS. We want more and more carers—women—into the economy, but we are not assisting them with the enormous amount of care they do over the life course, as they move in and out of paid employment and meet the predictable and unpredictable care responsibilities that most women—especially women—encounter over the life course.

The motion points to the fact that too many carers are living and retiring in poverty due to the inadequacy of social security payments and the unfair restrictions of the partner income test. It calls on the government to increase the carer payment to above the Henderson Poverty Line. Well, what a basic ask. In this wealthy country—the third-wealthiest country on per capita wealth calculations by international agencies; such a wealthy country—why are we setting a policy framework which leaves so many of our carers living below the Henderson poverty line?

The motion says we can fund this, and one of the ways we can fund it, this motion suggests—just one of the ways—is by introducing a minimum 25 per cent tax on gas exports to adequately fund the public services that we know are essential for the carer economy that underpins the production economy. We also need to see the restoration of funding to Ask Izzy so that carers have access to the vital navigation support they need as they try and put together all the separate demands in their lives. And we urgently need a review of respite care services.

We know that millions of Australians are dependent or reliant on the care provided by their family members and friends. Around 1.2 million Australians are primary carers, and 70 per cent of them are women. I remember, many years ago, listening to human rights commissioner Elizabeth Broderick talk about how too many Australian women give over decades of their life to hard work in the paid sphere of employment and at the same time care for their families, their aged relatives, their kids and often sick friends, yet find themselves consigned after those decades of incredibly hard paid and unpaid work to an old age of poverty. What a shocking way to treat Australians who give so much to our world.

On average, carers lose over half a million dollars in wages and super on retirement, leaving many of them with little to live on once they hit pension age. Unpaid carers provide care worth $77.9 billion a year; that's care the government would otherwise have to fund. We should be looking after the people who do all that work creating the web of support for Australians. Labor's cuts to the NDIS and aged care are piling ever more burdens on these carers, and everything would literally fall apart without the contribution of these carers. They give up their careers, they give up enormous income, they give up countless hours of their personal time to care for those they love—and it's time we looked after them, too. What's good for carers is good for the people they care for, and it's good for our public system and the health of our communities. Respite care is essential to sustaining home based care arrangements, meaning fewer crisis points for carers, fewer hospitalisations, savings in our health system, fewer long-term admissions and fewer premature entries into permanent residential care.

The Henderson poverty line currently sits at around $708 a week for a single person or $948 for couples, but the maximum rate for the carer payment right now is $567 a week for singles or $855 a week for couples; that's about $100 to $150 short every week. For someone on the carer payment, their payment starts going down 25c in the dollar once their partner starts to earn more than $396 a fortnight. The government is living in a fantasy land if it thinks a weekly combined income of $198 means a family doesn't need as much help anymore.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

You've got 200 bucks!

Barbara Pocock

Barbara Pocock SA, Australian Greens

It's a joke. Anyone who's tried to live that life and put a life together on those rates has no idea. You have to have had the experience, it seems, before you fully understand. We should be able to imagine what that experience is like, and we have a lot of people coming to every one of our offices, no doubt, telling us what it is like and how inadequate and impossible it is to put together a life on those kinds of payments. There is no superannuation paid on the carer payment either—but, don't worry, the age pension rate is also below the poverty line, so Albo is making sure carers are retiring into poverty every which way.

We know that Australians have missed out on an estimated $135 billion of revenue over the past 14 years, following Labor's decision to abandon its proposed resources super profits tax under the pressure of the mining lobby. A lobby that voraciously walks the corridors of this parliament is on the phone to all the Labor and coalition members in this parliament, pushing to avoid the tax which Australians want them to pay and know they can afford and which is exactly the kind of contribution we know can make a contribution to a decent standard of living for our carers.

Last month the Prosper Australia research institute, through their report, showed that Australia could rake in $45 billion more each year if the government adequately valued and taxed our resources. We can do this. A minimum of a 25 per cent tax on gas exports alone would give us $17 billion a year. Instead, Labor has made their budget savings from pickpocketing $37 billion from the NDIS and $1.2 billion from pensioners' health rebates and forcing older people to pay up to 80 per cent of the cost of support just to shower and grocery shop. What kind of penny-pinching misallocation of resources is this?

The government is choosing to rob our public services because they know carers will pick up Labor's slack, but we shouldn't be running critical services like carers provide across our communities off the back of love. They deserve a decent standard of living, the chance to pay for their groceries and security in their housing. Carers are at a crisis point. More carers are facing burnout or are simply unable to afford to keep going because Labor has ripped away the safety net from carers and the people they support.

What's this like on the ground? How does this machinery of poverty actually work? Let me give you one example. A woman in her 60s cares for her 85-year-old father at home. Her father has dementia and has been assessed as needing the highest category of aged-care support. Despite receiving this assessment, she's told her father needs to wait another year until the funding becomes available. The woman has lost her job because she's taken too much time off work, but she's not yet pension age. She applies for the carer payment and has to wait three months before a Centrelink officer even looks at her application. Her father deteriorates and passes away before he sees any of his aged-care funding released. Now she can't go back into the workforce because employers won't hire someone so close to pension age and because of the gap in her resume from when she was caring for her father. This is not an unusual story. This is a story I hear in South Australia in my senators office. We know there are people there who have done the right thing, stood by caring for their family and their parents, and find themselves locked out of the labour market and locked in to poverty.

Instead of helping families like this, this government is making it harder for Australians through its cuts to the NDIS and to aged-care services which mean those kinds of carers have to spend more time painfully negotiating, under incredible stress, with bureaucrats just to ensure their loved one doesn't die from government neglect. Labor is choosing to protect the profit motives of the wealthiest corporations in our country at the direct expense of Australians' carers who could benefit from a proper and fair tax regime. Santos is in the 11th straight year of paying zero corporate tax, despite nearly $52 billion in sales. What are we doing here? Why are we protecting these major, huge corporations with big bottom lines while, at the other end of the story, 70 per cent of carers are women struggling in poverty to look after us as citizens? Carers are contributing to the economy for nothing in return, but gas corporations, like Santos and LNG, literally do the opposite. They take Australian resources, profit off them to the tune of billions and then spend their time hiding their income so they can do all that and for free in terms of tax.

I especially want to acknowledge, as did my colleague Senator Allman-Payne, the work of younger carers. They are a hidden population of people who do so much, who give so much out of time that they should be giving, possibly, in some cases, to their own education and wellbeing. They're young people under 25 who provide so much support and unpaid care to family members who have a disability, a mental illness, a chronic condition or an alcohol or some other drug issue or who are frail aged. Their stories are incredible to hear. They're amazing young people. There are more than 391,000 young carers in Australia. They're looking after their parents. They're looking after their siblings and sometimes their own children or a relative or friend. They often find the experience very positive, they won't talk negatively about the person they give so much time to caring for but they often surrender their own education chances and have their own health affected, including their mental health and wellbeing.

A study published in the Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry reported that two-thirds of all young carers experience extreme mental health challenges. Young people give a lot, but they're 86 per cent more likely to experience suicidal ideation, suicidal experiences and self-harm. They are much more likely than their peers to have that experience and more likely to disengage from work or study and experience poverty.

A lot of young carers aren't even aware that they are one. They're just part of their family. They're just part of looking after their sibling or their parent. They may not be aware that they qualify for support, because care is an expectation in their family, and, increasingly, governments are looking to fluff out their budgets. Even among young carers, who are typically looking after family members, care is unequally shared, with 58 per cent of young carers identifying as female.

So we can do things differently, and we should. We should be lifting the carers payment above the poverty line, we should be abolishing partner income testing and we should let carers earn more before their payment is cut. We should fix aged-care assessments and make care affordable, and we should properly fund the NDIS. We can do this by making big corporations pay their fair share. It's a simple ask. It's not easy to do, but it's the right thing to do. We cannot keep running the whole world of our economy and the whole world of production on the backs of unpaid carers, who give up so much over their working lives. In a wealthy country like this, we can do better and we must.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

4:46 pm

I want to associate myself with the comments from my two colleagues Senator Allman-Payne and Senator Barbara Pocock, who I think have made the case very clearly for this parliament and the nation to start recognising and appropriately rewarding carers for the invaluable contribution they make, looking after Australians who are young, sick, elderly or disabled. As we look around at what we as a nation do for carers, I think all you see is gaps. If there is a safety net, it is so full of holes that carers are falling through left, right and centre, and the reliance seems to be that unpaid family members, community members or friends will just somehow plug the holes that have been left by government and the refusal to pay for adequate public aged care, public health or an NDIS that is actually bringing those who need care in rather than throwing those who need care out.

There is an underlying issue here that we, the Greens, see in how carers are treated and how those in need of care are treated. The underlying message that we see that unifies all of this is that we need to take profit out of care. We need to ensure that there aren't corporations skimming off public funds, family savings or our wages. Instead of that money being put in to make those elders, young people and people who are sick or have a disability in our community safe—instead of it going into the care—it is going into corporate profits. Either it is being skimmed out of care or we're paying extra, not for the care but for the profit. We need to get profit out of care.

We also need a government that's going to recognise that it doesn't just magically happen that carers get the recognition and the economic support they need. I listened carefully to the coalition's contribution. Whilst I recognise that they stated their support for carers, they reject the political frame put forward by the Greens, which is that we believe carers should be remunerated, that the gender gap should be closed, that carers should get superannuation, that carers should not be living below the poverty line and that there should be a mechanism to make that happen, which is to make the one per cent pay, make export gas pay and make the corporate sector, which is taking a record part of our economy, pay. That's an actual pathway to respect carers. The coalition somehow reject that idea as politicising it. Not doing that is the bigger political decision. Not taking on the one per cent to find the resources so that the Commonwealth can make this a nation of fairness when it comes to carers is a far bigger political decision—to back in the big gas companies and other resource companies and to refuse to actually have a pathway so that carers can get the respect. Anyone can come in here and complain, but if you're really going to have a serious political project to get the funding to lift carers out of poverty and to respect them, you need to have a source for that. Greens have it—tax, export gas, tax the resource sector. Saying to Santos, 'Well, I'm sorry. This is your last year of making billions of profit and not paying tax,' is a pathway to make it happen.

There are about 1.2 million Australians who are primary carers, and 70 per cent of them are women. On average, what happens to carers? Over their lifetime, they lose more than half a million dollars in wages and super by retirement. That is a core reason, a core element, for the gender pay gap. Unpaid carers are providing an enormous amount of care per year. I mean, estimates will vary but the best figure that we've seen is almost $80 billion a year in unpaid care—$80 billion a year. They are services that, if carers weren't providing, the government would have to provide. The government are quite happy for it to be invisible, quite happy for women—overwhelmingly women—to be providing this care, invisible to the rest of society. Don't shine a light on it because then you might actually have to fix it. Instead of actually trying to narrow that gap, what have we seen Labor do in the last few months? Savage cuts to the NDIS. Who's going to pick up the care for people thrown off the NDIS? We know who's going to pick up the care 70 per cent of the time. It's going to be women. They're going to be picking up care—more unpaid labour, more time out of the paid labour market—and that gap at retirement will get bigger and bigger and bigger.

Women will be doing the care but also have a look at who needs the care. It's estimated that the NDIS cuts are going to throw 120,000 young boys off the NDIS—120,000! Overwhelmingly, they're going to come from disadvantaged backgrounds and they're not going to have the care they need—more pressure on families who are already doing it tough, more pressure on their mums, their dads, their aunts, their uncles, their sisters, their brothers. Families that are already stressed have been given a message from Labor that is going to put more stress on them, take away more services. We know what carers do in circumstances like that. Their son's not getting the care they need. Dad's not being given aged care because he's been thrown off on an algorithm put in by Labor. Grandma's not getting the care. Who picks up that care? Who takes a step away from paid careers? Who loses their liveable incomes? Who throws countless hours, if they are working, after work into that care? Overwhelmingly, women are going to be picking that up.

I think we should be clear about this. Systems that are good for carers are also good for the people they care for, and, fundamentally, they're good for society. Systems that respect and pay and recognise care are good for our public health system. Because isn't it better if you can respect and reward carers and have people cared for at home, keep out of hospital and stop a health condition deteriorating because you've got love and care and time? Respecting carers means fewer crisis points for carers, fewer hospitalisations for those who are being cared for, fewer long-term admissions, fewer premature injuries into permanent residential care. And what do we do for carers? Well, the Henderson poverty line at the minute sits at about $710 a week for a single person, about $950 a week for couples. So that's the poverty line. That's where you need to get to.

An incident having occurred in the gallery

Slade Brockman

Slade Brockman Deputy-President

Just hold one second. Up in the gallery, you're welcome to stay. The distraction is fine. We can handle it.

Tim Ayres

Tim Ayres NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Industry and Innovation

It's always very welcome to have little kids in the gallery.

Slade Brockman

Slade Brockman Deputy-President

There's enough noise coming from around the chamber. Please stay. Anyway, sorry to interrupt you, Senator Shoebridge.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

The Henderson Poverty Line puts the payment—what you need so as to not fall into poverty, but to just scrape above poverty—at $710 a week if you're a single person, and at $950 a week for a couple. But do you know what the maximum rate for carers is? It's $567 for a single person. So what the government is saying there is: 'If you choose to be a carer, or if you feel compelled to be a carer—if your love for someone means that of course you're going to be their carer—then we are going to guarantee you're in poverty. Unless you've got some sort of private wealth, unless you've got some private resource, we're going to guarantee you're in poverty if you're single.' And it's no better for couples. The carer payment for couples is $855 a week. Both those payments are between $100 and $150 short of the poverty line. That's a message to every carer.

Then, if someone's on the carer payment and their partner starts working, as soon as their partner starts earning $400 a fortnight, they start having their carer payment cut by 25c. That's 200 bucks a week. As soon as your partner starts earning more than $200 a week, the government says, 'Actually we're going to have a bit of that. If you kick over that, we might tax your partner, but we're going to start chopping down your carer payment by 25c a dollar as soon as your partner starts earning more than $200 a week.' That's not just mean; that seems a policy intended to keep carers in poverty. Of course there's no superannuation paid on the carer payment either. Then of course there's the aged pension. Is that above or below the poverty rate? That's below the poverty rate as well.

So if you are out of work as you've had a lifetime of caring, with big chunks of your working life not in a paid career but in being a carer, then you don't have superannuation and you don't have savings. You live in poverty as a carer, and then, when you retire, you go onto the aged pension and you go into poverty again. That's what's wrong with the system.

What could we do? Well, we could put a 25 per cent tax on gas exports. That would give us $17 billion-plus a year. Then we could fund carers. We could build fresh industries to provide tax revenue to fund carers in the long run, instead of Labor pickpocketing $37 billion from people on the NDIS; or $1.2 billion from pensioners, who they want to take health rebates off; or forcing older people to pay up to 80 per cent of the costs of their support, just to shower or go to the grocery shop. We could actually look at the resource sector, and we could get the resource sector to pay a fair return on resources across the country, based upon what Queensland does with coal. There's at least $25 billion there—$25 billion, based on a report from Prosper. Does government do any of that? No.

Is the Labor government having a look around and saying: 'You know, it's a bit odd that News Corp have been operating here for the last 12 years and have been sending profits back to their billionaire US owners for the last decade and a half, and they haven't paid tax for a decade and a half'? Maybe News Corp should pay tax. Maybe the government could be looking at Santos, who've had 11 years straight of paying zero corporate tax—despite having $52 billion in revenue, paying no tax. Santos and News Corp want us to believe that they're operating as charities here—that they're not doing it for profit! Why are they doing it? What a rort! You say to us that you haven't got the money; you can't provide the income for carers. Well, of course you can't provide the income for carers if you're going to let Santos, News Corp and Woodside—all of these corporations—steal from us like that.

I do want to finish on this point. We often think there's a stereotype of carers as perhaps people who are older, more mature in life, and are looking after an ageing partner. Well, actually, so many of our carers are young people, under the age of 25. Sometimes, from as early as they can remember, they have been looking after a sibling, looking after mum, looking after dad, looking after grandparents or sometimes looking after a combination of those. They're providing the unpaid care to support family members or friends who might have a disability or maybe an addiction, a mental illness, a chronic condition or a mix of those things in their lives. They've spent their life working for them. Something in the order of 390,000 young people are carers in Australia, providing that care. They're caring for their mum, their dad, their partner, their sibling or their own child.

What we find when we look at the data for young people who are carers is that they're living in poverty. They're living in some of the most extreme conditions. They have housing insecurity. They're dealing with all of this as well as being a carer and wondering what they can do with their life. Are they going to get an education? Are they going to be able to build their career? Some are feeling trapped, and they're asking themselves what's going to happen with their life? Is it any wonder that some of the data shows what an impact that has on young carers? They are 86 per cent more likely to experience suicidal ideation, suicide and self-harm than their peers who aren't caring, more likely to disengage from work or study and vastly more likely to be experiencing poverty.

A study published recently in the Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry said that two-thirds of all young carers experience extreme mental health challenges. Do you know what we could do to fix all of this stuff? We could act like caring matters. We could lift the carer payment above the poverty line. We could abolish partner income testing. We could let carers and their partners earn more before we start cutting their payments so they could maybe not just get out of poverty but even actually get a little bit of savings and a bit of economic security in their lives. We could fix things like brutal aged-care assessments that are done by an algorithm and not a person. We could make aged care affordable. We could stop cutting the NDIS. If you're asking, 'How could you afford all that?' then I would say, 'Why don't we tax gas exports? Why don't we tax resources?' I've got another idea: why don't we cancel AUKUS and give ourselves another $375 billion of headroom and actually work out what makes Australia safe. What makes us safe is having loved ones and family support structures so that, if things go bad for us, there's someone who will stand up for us. That's what makes us safe.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

The question is that the motion be agreed to. A division is required. We'll hold that at another time, given it's past 4.30. The matter before the Senate must be adjourned until the next day of sitting, at a time to be fixed by the Senate. The debate is adjourned accordingly.