This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Questions without Notice: Take Note of Answers
Answers to Questions
Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning
3:16 pm
I move:
That the Senate take note of all the answers given to questions without notice asked by coalition senators today.
In particular, I want to focus on the economic questions that were asked. Sadly, Australians, right across, are paying the price for an economy that is going backwards under this Prime Minister and under this Treasurer. It is undeniable that Australians are worse off today than they were before this government came in. The economic management of this Prime Minister and his Treasurer is inept. They are hopeless. And, unfortunately, it's not just a case of a political point. Australians are paying the price and they are feeling the burden of this every single day.
By every single metric, this Treasurer has been an unmitigated disaster. No wonder there are whispers—which we hear loud enough, on this side—of there being, maybe, some sort of change over the Christmas period, in relation to the Treasurer. But you know what? Not since, I think, the time of the dismissal has there been an opportunity for just a Treasurer to be swapped out. That's because the Treasurer and the Prime Minister are a team; they go hand-in-hand together. And what we've got is this Albanese-Chalmers government that is failing Australian people. The economic management of this government is an unmitigated disaster. The government is responsible. The Prime Minister is responsible. The Treasurer is responsible. The Treasurer sets the fiscal policies of this government, and it's his fiscal policies that have put pressure on the economy and enabled the declining productivity and the inclining, increasing, unemployment rate.
Unemployment, as we've seen today, has lifted to 4.9 per cent. That's a 0.2 per cent increase—and, on that point, I'm pretty sure I heard the minister say it had gone up by only 0.1 per cent. Now, I may be wrong. I may have misheard. But if he has said that it's only gone up by 0.1 per cent, he ought to come back in here pretty quickly and correct the record, because it's gone up by 0.2 per cent—
We've got this issue of a bit of stagflation going on in this country. It means that we've got inflation going up while unemployment is also going up. Australians are hurting. We've seen mortgage stress like never before. Unemployment hasn't been this high since 2021, and people on their side will say, 'You were in government at that point.' That was the peak of COVID. That was the very peak of COVID, when, because of the necessitation of the economic conditions of a global pandemic, employers were having to let people go. We've got General Pants, which today announced that they're going into administration. Sadly, David Jones, right across the country—with three stores in Western Australia alone—is gone. Unemployment is up and hope is down in this country, because you are deferring hope, and hope deferred makes the heart sick. What a Christmas present you're delivering to the Australian people! (Time expired)
Varun Ghosh WA, Australian Labor Party
3:21 pm
Where angels fear to tread! When the coalition starts talking about economics, you really have to look twice, because what they come in here and do is talk down the Australian economy, but they have no clear policies and no clear positions. They want to complain that people are doing it tough—and they are doing it tough—but they're against cost-of-living relief. They're against wage increases and they don't actually have any fundamental policy positions. When you've got a government that's dealing with difficult circumstances in a global inflationary environment, that's trying to balance bringing down inflation with giving people a little bit of a hand, all the Libs can do is come in here and carp and criticise.
Let's go to interest rates first. This is a problem that this government is trying to bring under control. We've got a globally high inflationary environment. We've had a fuel crisis. We've got two ongoing conflicts. We're trying to bring inflation down. And do you know what? You can look at the last five years or so. Let's go back to March 2022. Inflation was around 5.1 per cent. It's still lower than that now. It peaked in December 2022 at around 7.9 per cent—the hangover of the profligate spending of the Morrison government—and now this government is trying to fight it while also making sure that people don't fall behind or aren't doing it as tough as they might if they didn't get our cost-of-living relief.
Let's look at jobs. Jobs are very important to the labour movement. Unemployment has ticked up slightly, and we're worried about that. We want it to come down and we'll work every day to do that. We'll work to keep Australians in jobs. But the participation rate is still high. You've still got a lot of Australians in jobs—more than there were last year. But we don't just care about people being in jobs. We care about wages. We care about job security. When it comes to wages, that's how you give people a chance to earn so that they can buy the things they need and they can take some of the pressure off the household budget. That's why the government has supported and has made numerous submissions to the Fair Work Commission about lifting the minimum wage, something that's gone up a number of times under this government. That's why we've supported same job, same pay—to make sure that labour hire arrangements can't dud people of entitlements and wages in a range of different contexts, including the mining industry. It's why this government will always be committed to increasing wages, not bringing them down to help mates in business.
Let's also talk about security of jobs and these administrations that they keep bringing up that are going on at the moment where people really need support. I think what you'll see is that the Labor government is a government that's been willing to support people who are doing it tough—people who've lost their jobs and are committed to a social safety net. I also want to take this opportunity to say something quickly about David Jones. There are a lot of workers in Australia who are doing it tough, and I just want to say something about the profile of those workers at David Jones. David Jones has a 79 per cent female workforce. A large proportion of that workforce is over 45, and that creates a particularly perilous circumstance where, if they lose their job, they may find it difficult to find another job. That's the experience of the 1990s recession. When we talk about jobs, we also talk about people taking care of people who've lost their jobs and are finding it difficult, and that's something that the Labor government is committed to.
I want to say another quick word about cost of living and health care. That's the other piece here that we see in Western Australia. The government's policies are working. There are 14 new urgent care clinics in Western Australia, and 45 per cent of presentations to those clinics are ones that would have gone to an emergency department or called an ambulance. So we're already doing something that takes pressure off the health system. And the number of bulk-billing GPs has gone up. The number of bulk-billing GP clinics in Western Australia has nearly doubled since the incentive came into place. That means people don't have to pay when they go to a doctor. So we're about quality jobs, we're trying to fix the economy and we're about providing health care for free. (Time expired)
Ross Cadell NSW, National Party, Shadow Minister for Water
3:25 pm
After hearing that, I feel I should almost apologise for taking note of answers, because things are going so great! People are getting their pay, things are going great, the economy is in good shape and we're fixing the cost of living, according to this government. They accuse this side of talking the economy down. But there's no need to talk it down when the other side is sending the economy down the gurgler. Every day in every way, this place is getting worse and worse for Australians. This is what's happening. Forget about the answers. We hear times are tough, that 'the rest of the world is doing it tough'. We have higher interest rates than the rest of the world, we have higher inflation than the rest of the developed world and we are now getting more unemployment than the rest of the world, but somehow this isn't our problem, this isn't contained here, this is everywhere else.
If this government was a person it would have narcissism traits throughout. Why did the narcissist cross the road? They didn't; you saw it wrong. Why is the economy down the gurgler? It isn't; we got it wrong. This is what happens here. And what they're forgetting: 11.3 per cent youth unemployment. They are selling the future of our country with bad decisions. We heard a minister on TV two days ago announce, consult—backflip. Is that the normal way government works? This is what we've got here. Poor decisions have led us here, and it is not good enough, when the only thing government is doing well is exceeding their own poor targets. The Reserve Bank said we would reach 4.9 per cent unemployment in December 2027. You're ahead of target—well done! You've beaten it by a whole year, getting to 4.9 per cent unemployment a year early. And how's your housing target? Not even close. How's your emissions target? Not even close. How are your interest rates? Not even close to target. The only thing you are beating to target is failure. What a great way to run a country. What a great way to build hope.
What we need is a way forward that gives people a chance. When we hear the stories—when we hear about Qantas offloading jobs, when we hear about Bunnings and Wesfarmers offloading jobs—they're saying it's because you have made it too hard to do business in Australia. The big employers out there are giving you a message loud and clear: you are making it too hard to employ. But you come in here and say, 'But it's okay, because wages have gone up.' And sure, the numbers in pay packets might have gone up, but what that money buys is so much less. That is real wages, and real wages have fallen since this government has come in. So don't look at the numbers and say, 'We're doing well.' Don't listen to the spin that says you're getting paid more and you are doing well. Look at what you can buy with your pay packet, and that is less, because it is spending and economic control that this government has no idea on.
We've got a wheelbarrow full of problems and a wheelbarrow full of excuses over here, but we've got a thimbleful of answers. It should be the other way around. We should be talking to the community more. We should be talking to people more. They're willing to throw copyright rules out the window, throw out anything to get the AI investment, to keep this economy going, because we have had a per capita recession ever since this government came in. There were just one or two quarters when that didn't happen. Nothing in the economic frame is working. The Australian people deserve better and the Australian economy needs better, because it will not be fixed in a year; it will not be fixed in two years. What this government has done will take a decade to fix. And they come in and say, 'Oh, but this is the same employment rate as five years ago'—a global pandemic. That was a pretty good reason to have some unemployment out there, but they've managed to get it today. Congratulations! Without a pandemic, you have got there. Well done! (Time expired)
Karen Grogan SA, Australian Labor Party
3:29 pm
The people in the gallery could be forgiven for wondering what on earth is going on in here, listening to some of the commentary that's being put out about the state of our country. But it is complex. It's not as easy as spending five minutes just saying, 'We hate the government.' I mean, that's easy. Anyone can do that. The reality is that our economy is a complex beast. The interface globally is complicated. The manner in how we choose to go about addressing those things is different. Our colleagues across the chamber have a very different view about where we should invest our money and how we should progress our society, as well as our economy. We have different views, but, to be clear, what we are doing is strengthening. Every time we raise things like the investment in Medicare, colleagues over on the other side of the chamber laugh.
I don't think it's funny. I spend a lot of time in regional South Australia, and what I see is significant increases in people being able to see a doctor without having to pay for it. That makes a difference, because what I was hearing previously from people is they weren't going to the doctor because they were afraid of the fees. They couldn't go and know that they wouldn't have to pay money. That may sound small; it's not. We have cheaper medicines. People were not taking their medication because they can't afford it. We have cheaper medications. The notion of working through the different elements—our investment in Medicare is critical, as far as we're concerned, to keep people in this country healthy.
You've heard some of the conversation throughout this take-note debate about tax rates and about job numbers, but the bottom line is the kind of investments that we are making, tax cuts, and the commentary out there about slowing down spending—we've had $180 billion worth of reprioritisation and savings knocked back, blocked, in this chamber over and over again by the Liberal Party, the National Party and Pauline Hanson's crew over there. These savings that we are trying to bring in are about dealing with some of that inflation. They're about making that difference. But no, they get blocked in this chamber over and over again, so we can't bring them to bear. Then each of those guys on the far side of the chamber go out into the media and go, 'Labor's spending too much money, and they have to make savings.' Then they all have a big chuckle and come back in here and vote against every last one of them. Unless they vote for them, those savings are not going to come to bear.
We have invested significantly in housing. We are on track. Some of the challenges we've seen in bringing to bear our social and affordable housing, which is going to make a big difference to people by bringing down rents and lifting the availability, is going to make a difference, but that's a pipeline situation. That takes time. We are on track. We are pushing ahead with all of that building of social and affordable housing, which is going to make a difference to people, but it does take a little bit of time. As my colleague Senator Ghosh said, we accept that things aren't as rosy as we'd like them to be. We accept that and are working very hard to make a difference for those people out there in our society who are doing it tough and who are having a hard time. That is where we prioritise the policies that we put in place. We just need those opposite to actually come to the party on some of those savings that we need to make a difference to the economy. (Time expired)
Chris Gatenby Tasmania, Liberal Party
3:33 pm
I rise to take note of answers to all questions from coalition senators, particularly in relation to answers from Minister Wong on economics, covering the cost of living, unemployment and small business viability. It's clear that Labor is turning its back on households, small businesses and regional Australia from the answers that we got. Australians are paying the price for a government that is addicted to spending, taxing and more regulation. They're now worse off than when this government came in. In Labor's world, everything appears to be just fine, just like that meme of the building on fire with the cartoon—'This is fine.' On the cost of living, the Treasurer wants Australians to believe that they're getting ahead. The Treasurer was recently celebrating the latest wage figures, but here's what he conveniently left out: wages rose 3.5 per cent over the year, and prices rose 4.3 per cent. That means real wages are going backwards. Australians are working harder but buying less at the checkout. While the Treasurer celebrates, families are struggling to pay the bills. We heard about pensioners increasingly accessing food banks today in question time. That's not economic success; that's economic failure. On top of this, unemployment has risen to 4.9 per cent—the highest in five years.
On inflation, the Reserve Bank governor has delivered another sobering reality check for the government. Michele Bullock has made it clear that inflation was already a problem before the Middle East conflict. Labor cannot keep blaming everything on events overseas. They've forced interest rates up five times this year alone to 4.85 per cent, an 18-year high. And who's suffering the most? Renters, low-income households and families with the least capacity to absorb another price rise. The governor spoke of children going to school without breakfast and families cutting back on food and missing electricity bills just to meet their mortgages. Think about that in a country as prosperous as Australia. Yet Labor keeps spending, taxing and making life more expensive. State Labor MP Brian Mitchell, in today's Mercury, thinks the answer to inflation is—wait for it—more taxes.
Nowhere is Labor's approach more damaging than in its treatment of small businesses. Australia's insolvency rate is at its highest-ever level. They are the very businesses that employ Australians, take risks and sustain our regional communities. The impact of Labor's proposed tax on trusts is a case in point. The Business Council now estimates $1.7 billion in additional taxes every year—double its previous estimate—impacting business. Compliance and restructuring costs, in the first-year bill, could reach about $4 billion. These aren't wealthy investors; they're family businesses, farmers, builders and small manufacturers. In particular, on housing, in the middle of a housing crisis it's putting pressure on the people we need to build those houses. We now have 46 businesses going under each day, but all Labor can say is, 'This is fine.'
The contrast couldn't be clearer with the coalition. We believe prosperity comes from backing Australians who work, invest, build and employ. We've identified $31 billion in budget savings over four years. We will axe Labor's proposed trusts tax, aim to cut the federal regulatory burden by 25 per cent and deliver a permanent $50,000 instant asset write-off. We'll scrap Labor's proposed housing tax changes and remove barriers to building more homes. Small businesses don't need more lectures from Canberra; they need Canberra off their backs. (Time expired)
Question agreed to.