This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Questions without Notice: Take Note of Answers
Answers to Questions
Ross Cadell NSW, National Party, Shadow Minister for Water
3:25 pm
After hearing that, I feel I should almost apologise for taking note of answers, because things are going so great! People are getting their pay, things are going great, the economy is in good shape and we're fixing the cost of living, according to this government. They accuse this side of talking the economy down. But there's no need to talk it down when the other side is sending the economy down the gurgler. Every day in every way, this place is getting worse and worse for Australians. This is what's happening. Forget about the answers. We hear times are tough, that 'the rest of the world is doing it tough'. We have higher interest rates than the rest of the world, we have higher inflation than the rest of the developed world and we are now getting more unemployment than the rest of the world, but somehow this isn't our problem, this isn't contained here, this is everywhere else.
If this government was a person it would have narcissism traits throughout. Why did the narcissist cross the road? They didn't; you saw it wrong. Why is the economy down the gurgler? It isn't; we got it wrong. This is what happens here. And what they're forgetting: 11.3 per cent youth unemployment. They are selling the future of our country with bad decisions. We heard a minister on TV two days ago announce, consult—backflip. Is that the normal way government works? This is what we've got here. Poor decisions have led us here, and it is not good enough, when the only thing government is doing well is exceeding their own poor targets. The Reserve Bank said we would reach 4.9 per cent unemployment in December 2027. You're ahead of target—well done! You've beaten it by a whole year, getting to 4.9 per cent unemployment a year early. And how's your housing target? Not even close. How's your emissions target? Not even close. How are your interest rates? Not even close to target. The only thing you are beating to target is failure. What a great way to run a country. What a great way to build hope.
What we need is a way forward that gives people a chance. When we hear the stories—when we hear about Qantas offloading jobs, when we hear about Bunnings and Wesfarmers offloading jobs—they're saying it's because you have made it too hard to do business in Australia. The big employers out there are giving you a message loud and clear: you are making it too hard to employ. But you come in here and say, 'But it's okay, because wages have gone up.' And sure, the numbers in pay packets might have gone up, but what that money buys is so much less. That is real wages, and real wages have fallen since this government has come in. So don't look at the numbers and say, 'We're doing well.' Don't listen to the spin that says you're getting paid more and you are doing well. Look at what you can buy with your pay packet, and that is less, because it is spending and economic control that this government has no idea on.
We've got a wheelbarrow full of problems and a wheelbarrow full of excuses over here, but we've got a thimbleful of answers. It should be the other way around. We should be talking to the community more. We should be talking to people more. They're willing to throw copyright rules out the window, throw out anything to get the AI investment, to keep this economy going, because we have had a per capita recession ever since this government came in. There were just one or two quarters when that didn't happen. Nothing in the economic frame is working. The Australian people deserve better and the Australian economy needs better, because it will not be fixed in a year; it will not be fixed in two years. What this government has done will take a decade to fix. And they come in and say, 'Oh, but this is the same employment rate as five years ago'—a global pandemic. That was a pretty good reason to have some unemployment out there, but they've managed to get it today. Congratulations! Without a pandemic, you have got there. Well done! (Time expired)
No comments