This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Bills
Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee
Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism
11:52 am
by leave—I move government amendment (1) on sheet KI120, amendments (1) and (2) on sheet LM133 and amendments (1) and (2) on sheet IN120 together:
SHEET KI120
(1) Schedule 1, page 3 (after line 12), at the end of the Schedule, add:
5 Subsection 122.4(3) of the Criminal Code
Omit "29 December 2026", substitute "29 June 2027".
_____
SHEET LM133
(1) Clause 2, page 2 (after table item 3), insert:
(2) Page 47 (after line 24), after Schedule 7, insert:
Schedule 7A — Annual reporting on special advocates
National Security Information (Criminal and Civil Proceedings) Act 2004
1 At the end of section 47
Add:
; and (g) states the number of persons who, as at 30 June in the year:
(i) meet the requirements specified in regulations made for the purposes of paragraph 38PA(2)(a); and
(ii) have notified the Secretary of the Attorney-General's Department that they are willing to perform the function of a special advocate; and
(h) identifies:
(i) the States or Territories in which the persons ordinarily resided during the year; and
(ii) the States or Territories in which the persons were willing to perform the function of a special advocate during the year.
2 Application provision
The amendments of section 47 of the National Security Information (Criminal and Civil Proceedings) Act 2004 made by this Schedule apply in relation to a report laid before a House of the Parliament on or after 1 July 2028.
_____
SHEET IN120
(1) Clause 2, page 2 (at the end of the table), add:
(2) Page 48 (after line 27), at the end of the Bill, add:
Schedule 9 — Relevant expert
Criminal Code Act 1995
1 Subsection 105A.2(1) of the Criminal Code (definition of relevant expert )
Repeal the definition, substitute:
relevant expert means any person with expertise in, and who is qualified to express opinions as to:
(a) the risk; and
(b) means of ameliorating the risk;
of a terrorist offender committing a serious Part 5.3 or 5.3A offence.
2 After subsection 106.14(9) of the Criminal Code
Insert:
(9A) Despite the amendment of the definition of relevant expert in subsection 105A.2(1) made by Schedule 9 to the Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Act 2026, that definition continues to apply in relation to the following as if the amendment had not been made:
(a) an application for a post-sentence order made before the commencement of that Schedule;
(b) proceedings relating to an application made before that commencement to vary an extended supervision order or interim supervision order;
(c) a review of a post-sentence order, if the application for review is made before that commencement;
(d) a direction made by the AFP Minister under section 105A.18D before that commencement.
I also table two supplementary explanatory memoranda relating to the government amendments moved to this bill.
Dave Sharma NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
11:54 am
Minister, the INSLM delivered his report on the post-sentence order scheme to the government in March 2023, and the government sat on it for 3½ years and didn't release it until it tabled it with this bill in August 2026. Why did you sit on the INSLM's report for 3½ years? Was it because it was so utterly scathing of what you're proposing to do now? Was that why?
Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism
The INSLM's report was tabled in parliament on 30 March 2023, and, in May 2023, the PJCIS commenced a review under the Intelligence Services Act 2001 into the operation, effectiveness and implications of division 105A. On 30 June 2023, the Attorney-General's Department, together with the Department of Home Affairs, provided a joint submission to the PJCIS. On 14 March 2024, the Attorney-General's Department, along with AFP and Home Affairs, provided evidence at a public hearing held by the PJCIS.
The government intended to develop a consolidated response to the INSLM's report and the subsequent review of the PJCIS when the latter was tabled. However, in March 2025, the PJCIS review lapsed without reporting at the dissolution of the parliament and has not been recommenced. The government subsequently and carefully reviewed these powers in close consultation with law enforcement agencies to ensure they remain fit for purpose and protect the Australian community and tabled its response to parliament on 12 August 2026.
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
11:56 am
The Greens believe that the reason the government didn't table the report for 3½ years was that the report was so utterly scathing of what the government is doing now and, if the public had had the chance to read the report and work with civil societies, there would be far broader resistance to what this government is doing now.
Just to give those members who haven't had the benefit of reading the INSLM's report on this an insight into how scathing the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor was of what the government is doing now, what Labor is doing now with the support of One Nation and the coalition, this is just the introduction from the INSLM:
Australia leads the world in making laws of a kind discussed in this report.
The law that this report discusses permits people in our society to be imprisoned, not as a punishment for a crime committed but because it is decided that their living freely in our society unacceptably risks them committing a crime in the future.
Only one Australian parliament, and a mere handful of Australian parliamentarians, have resisted these laws, and these laws have made us a coarser and harsher society. I doubt that anyone knows whether they have made us safer.
This is the commencement of the INSLM's report about these very laws, and there's no reference anywhere to the substance of this in the government's response. Of course, the coalition don't touch it. One Nation loves these kinds of laws.
But the INSLM went on further. He said:
In gentler times these kinds of laws did not exist, although some deny it. In times past, people who had committed crimes and served their sentences were thought to have paid their debt to society and lived with us in our communities, even though some reoffended.
In gentler times, the types of laws discussed in this report were the subject of parody. Lewis Carroll had Alice quiz the Queen—
I think it's worth including this quote in the INSLM'S report because it sums up what Labor is doing—
'What sort of things do YOU remember best?' Alice ventured to ask.
'Oh, things that happened the week after next,' the Queen replied in a careless tone. 'For instance, now,' she went on, sticking a large piece of plaster on her finger as she spoke, 'there's the King's Messenger. He's in prison now, being punished: and the trial doesn't even begin till next Wednesday: and of course, the crime comes last of all.'
'Suppose he never commits the crime?' said Alice.
'That would be all the better, wouldn't it?' the Queen said, as she bound the plaster round her finger with a bit of ribbon.
Alice felt there was no denying THAT. 'Of course, it would be all the better,' she said: 'but it wouldn't be all the better his being punished.'
'You're wrong THERE at any rate,' said the Queen: 'were YOU ever punished?'
'Only for faults,' said Alice.
'And you were all the better for it, I know!" the Queen said triumphantly.
'Yes, but then I HAD done the things I was punished for,' said Alice: 'that makes all the difference.'
'But if you HADN'T done them,' the Queen said, 'that would have been better still: better, and better, and better!'
That's what these laws are. This is Labor and the coalition doing their version of better and better—with their mates in One Nation better again—jailing people for crimes they haven't committed. They are putting people in jail, holding them in detention and putting them on control orders for future crimes. As the INSLM said:
In gentler times, although not so long ago, the types of laws discussed in this report existed only in science fiction
The INSLM then went on and said, 'As Philip J Dick's conundrum of "precrime" attests'—and then there was a quote from science fiction. But, of course, this isn't science fiction. You're doing it now. Labor, with your mates in the coalition and your avid support from One Nation, are putting this science fiction in now. This is what Philip J Dick said, as quoted by the INSLM, who urged this parliament not to do this. Philip J Dick wrote:
As they walked along the busy, yellow-lit tiers of offices, Anderton said: 'You're acquainted with the theory of precrime, of course—
Then, Witwer said:
With the aid of your precog mutants, you've boldly and successfully abolished the post-crime punitive system of jails and fines. As we all realise, punishment was never much of a deterrent, and could scarcely have afforded the comfort to a victim already dead.'
… … …
Anderton said: 'You've probably already grasped the basic legalistic drawback to precrime methodology. We're taking in individuals who have broken no law.'
'But surely, they will,' Witwer affirmed with conviction.
'Happily, they don'tbecause we get to them first, before they can commit an act of violence. So the commission of the crime itself is absolute metaphysics. We can claim they are culpable. They, on the other hand, can eternally claim they are innocent. And, in a sense, they are innocent.'
That's what this bill does. That's what you're doing now. You're putting us into this science fiction dystopia.
Margaret Atwood was quoted by the INSLM in their effort to stop this parliament doing what it's now doing. They said:
Margaret Atwood has told us of a 'surprise piece of information':
'The future doesn't really exist. Therefore it's up for grabs because unlike the past nobody can fact check the future. If you're a novelist that is a good thing.'
But—bloody hell!—it should be a restraint on legislators. It should be a restraint on this parliament. When the INSLM puts that in the report, is it any wonder that this government buried it for 3½ years. Then, at the last moment they could, they brought it out with this ugly piece of legislation that is putting us into the dystopia that Lewis Carroll, Philip J Dick and Margaret Atwood spoke about. Is it because you found that too much to stomach, Minister? Is that why Labor hid the report for 3½ years?
Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism
12:02 pm
In responding to Senator Shoebridge, I just want to make a couple of points. First of all, this is a time-critical bill, and this is the third day now that the Senate has had an opportunity to discuss this bill. It is time critical because we require the operation of laws that protect Australians, and that is why this is a time critical piece of legislation. So I will be brief in my answer, but I do need to respond, because it is really important to put on the record a clear fact, which you, Chair, appreciate, those across the chamber appreciate and the Australian public appreciate: we do not live in 'gentler times'. I wish we did, but we do not. And this is not science fiction. As much respect as I have for Lewis Carroll, I think quoting Alice in Wonderland right now is deeply disrespectful to the law enforcement agencies that work so hard every day to protect Australians.
It is crucial that Australia's counterterrorism legislation remains effective, proportionate and responsive to the challenging and evolving terrorism threat environment that Australians face. Terrorism is a unique threat in its capacity to impact not only its direct victims but the Australian community as a whole. The devastating terrorist attack at Bondi Beach in December 2025, almost a year ago now, demonstrated the profound harm that terrorism can inflict on individuals, families and communities. This bill makes a targeted set of reforms to key counterterrorism powers, which has been informed by operational experience to ensure that Australia's legislative framework to combat the threat of terrorism remains available, effective and proportionate in the face of a dynamic threat environment.
On the INSLM recommendations, the central recommendation of the INSLM report was that continuing detention order framework be repealed. The government does not accept this recommendation, and it is open to the government to not accept that recommendation. This bill establishes control orders as the primary Commonwealth mechanism to manage serious terrorist offenders in the community as is required. This is in line with recommendations of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security. The government has introduced these amendments to the bill that would implement two of the INSLM's recommendations. Specifically consistent with the recommendations of INSLM and the committee, the amendments would amend the National Security Information (Criminal and Civil Proceedings) Act to expand the annual reporting requirements and amend the Criminal Code to insert a new definition of relevant expert.
There are safeguards in this legislation and in the framework in our criminal law system, but there are also powers in these laws and the amendments that we are making today that ensure that law enforcement officials have the powers that they need to keep Australians safe. That is something that this government takes incredibly seriously. It's something that the parliament should take seriously, and it is why we ask the Senate to support this legislation without delay.
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
12:06 pm
There is a complete lack of engagement from this government with the issues raised by the INSLM. I quoted the INSLM and I will correct the INSLM on one thing. It's Philip K Dick, not Philip J Dick. I quoted the INSLM directly because there was that clear sense of just utter frustration coming from the most senior person appointed at a Commonwealth level to oversight these laws, who's seen every time one of these laws has been tried and who's seen the evidence that we don't get to see, because the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor can see the affidavits, the secret affidavits and the police reports. The INSLM has actually gone behind and seen more than I've seen. It's seen more than the minister's seen. It's seen more than any member of this parliament has seen, and it's seen the way these things work and has said: 'Stop doing these things. They don't work. They degrade our civil society.' For the government to just dismiss them, to not even engage with them and to bury the report shows just how little regard Labor and their mates in the coalition and their cheer squad in One Nation have for basic rights and civil liberties.
Now would be a convenient time to move Greens amendments on sheet 4146, and I think I may need leave to move amendments (1) and (2) together.
Slade Brockman Deputy-President
There being no objection, leave is granted.
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
Thanks very much, Chair. I move:
(1) Clause 2, page 2 (table item 4), omit "Schedule 8", substitute "Schedules 8 and 9".
(2) Page 48 (after line 27), at the end of the Bill, add:
Schedule 9 — Terrorist organisation offences: exceptions for humanitarian aid
Criminal Code Act 1995
1 Subsection 102.1(1) of the Criminal Code
Insert:
aid of a humanitarian nature includes, but is not limited to, activities relating to the following:
(a) food, water or shelter;
(b) medical, health, first-aid, hospital or rehabilitation goods or services;
(c) protection activities, including immigration detention monitoring and international humanitarian law training;
(d) emergency education or family tracing goods or services;
(e) sanitation and hygiene goods or services;
(f) nutrition goods or services;
(g) early recovery, livelihood, agriculture or infrastructure goods or services;
(h) payment of salaries, taxes, fees, import duties, permits or utilities;
(i) the support of basic human needs;
(j) other operational and financial matters necessary to enable humanitarian aid.
designated humanitarian entity: see section 102.1AB.
2 After section 102.1AA of the Criminal Code
Insert:
102.1AB Meaning of designated humanitarian entity
(1) An entity is a designated humanitarian entity if the entity is specified by, or is in a class of entities specified by, the regulations for the purposes of this subsection.
(2) The following are also designated humanitarian entities:
(a) the United Nations;
(b) an agency of the United Nations;
(c) a non-governmental humanitarian organisation that has observer status at the United Nations General Assembly;
(d) a non-governmental organisation participating in any of the following activities conducted by the United Nations:
(i) a Humanitarian Needs and Response Plan;
(ii) a Refugee Response Plan;
(iii) a humanitarian appeal;
(iv) an activity covered by or part of the Humanitarian Cluster System;
(e) the International Committee of the Red Cross;
(f) the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies;
(g) an entity accredited (whether at full or base level) by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade for the purposes of funding eligibility under the program known as the Australian NGO Cooperation Program;
(h) another entity engaged by an entity mentioned in paragraphs (a) to (g) (the principal entity) to provide aid of a humanitarian nature on behalf of or in partnership with the principal entity;
(i) an entity that operates for the sole or dominant purpose of providing aid of a humanitarian nature;
(j) an entity providing grants or other financial assistance to an entity mentioned in paragraphs (a) to (i).
Note 1: A list of entities accredited by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade for the Australian NGO Cooperation Program could in 2026 be viewed on that Department's website (https://www.dfat.gov.au).
Note 2: A list of international organisations granted observer status by the United Nations General Assembly could in 2026 be viewed on the United Nation's website (https://www.un.org).
3 At the end of section 102.6 of the Criminal Code
Add:
(4) Subsections (1) and (2) do not apply if:
(a) the person's receipt, making available or collection of funds is only for the purpose of providing aid of a humanitarian nature; and
(b) the aid is provided, or to be provided, by, on behalf of, or with the authority of a designated humanitarian entity.
Note: A defendant bears an evidential burden in relation to the matters in subsection (4). See subsection 13.3(3).
4 At the end of section 102.7 of the Criminal Code
Add:
(3) Subsections (1) and (2) do not apply if:
(a) the person's provision of support or resources is only for the purpose of providing aid of a humanitarian nature; and
(b) the aid is provided, or to be provided, by, on behalf of, or with the authority of a designated humanitarian entity.
Note: A defendant bears an evidential burden in relation to the matters in subsection (3). See subsection 13.3(3).
These amendments legislate a humanitarian exemption across the terrorist organisation offences in sections 126 to 128 and the terrorism-financing offences in sections 131 and 132 of the Criminal Code. The exemption would be both subject based, covering qualifying humanitarian organisations and their financial and implementing partners, and activity based, covering the funds, resources and services needed solely to deliver humanitarian assistance in time. This is 100 per cent consistent with and is as a result of the UN Security Council resolution 2664 in 2022, which I understand the Australian government has supported.
Why do we need this? I particularly want to thank ACFID and many of those humanitarian organisations who have been asking for this exemption for a significant amount of time. Aid workers in places like Gaza and Afghanistan have to deal with whoever controls the ground in order to reach people who are starving, who are dying, who need life-saving care. That can mean paying a checkpoint fee or a local tax or a utility bill to an authority linked to a listed organisation. There is no other way to save people's lives. There's no other way to provide the food, to provide the medicine, to provide the shelter. Under our current laws, that can expose an Australian aid organisation and its staff to the risk of terrorism charges, carrying extremely long prison terms—simply for the act of giving someone food when they're starving.
The Criminal Code already recognises this problem in a narrow way, with a defence to the association offence for providing humanitarian aid. But there's no equivalent protection for the funding and support offences, which is exactly where aid groups face the most risk. They've told us, they've told the coalition and they've told the Labor Party. They've said it, and they've asked for this help. Not doing this will have a chilling effect: organisations pulling back, banks refusing transactions, help not arriving and people dying. That's the effect of not doing this: people dying. The UN Security Council recognised this in 2022 when it adopted resolution 2664, a standing humanitarian carve out for UN sanction regimes. In September 2025 this government signed the Declaration for the Protection of Humanitarian Personnel—and we welcome that—and committed at a ministerial level to implementing humanitarian exemptions to sanctions and counterterrorism measures. But where are they?
This amendment just delivers on that government promise. And there's a real consistency here. This bill expands criminal protections for UN and humanitarian personnel, and the government says it reflects Australia's leadership on humanitarian protection. That part of the bill we welcome. But you cannot claim to be protecting aid workers with one part of the Criminal Code while leaving them exposed to prosecution under the other part. For those reasons, I commend these amendments to the Senate.
Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism
12:11 pm
I thank Senator Shoebridge for that contribution. With the very short amount of time available I want to respond as briefly as I can, even though this is a very important issue to the government. The government acknowledges the concerns expressed by humanitarian organisations about the application of terrorism offences to humanitarian activities. The government is carefully considering the PJCIS recommendations to engage with humanitarian organisations so that any reforms should be informed by the national intelligence community so that they do not provide legal protection for terrorists. The design of any such exemptions would need careful consideration and consultation, including with law enforcement agencies and the national intelligence community to ensure that they are not available to individuals with malicious intent acting under the cover of humanitarian work. There are existing humanitarian exemptions for a number of terrorism offences in the Criminal Code, including an exemption for associating with a terrorist organisation or state sponsor of terrorism. The amendments we've put forward in this bill would implement the optional protocol focused on threats to physical safety and the security of UN and associated personnel. This is, though, of course distinct from requests for humanitarian exemptions from terrorism offences.
The government acknowledges the incredible work undertaken by humanitarian organisations in some of the most difficult and complex environments. I'm sure that's a sentiment shared by senators across the chamber. We are deeply committed to ensuring that humanitarian workers are protected and afforded the access they need in order to carry out this life-saving work. That's why we led the Declaration for the Protection of Humanitarian Personnel, launched in September 2025 in New York and now with more than 130 signatories. And we will continue to work across government and with the sector to ensure that we can uphold the principles we committed to in that declaration.
I note that representatives from the sector have met with the Attorney-General and with the Minister for Foreign Affairs to discuss this issue, and I understand that they are meeting with other parliamentarians. There are existing humanitarian exemptions, as I said, and the government is carefully considering the recommendations of the INSLM report and is engaging with the sector. It would not be appropriate to progress humanitarian exemptions in this bill before the government has concluded detailed consultations on this issue. The design of any of those exemptions would need to be carefully considered.
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
12:14 pm
I appreciate the government's statement, and I appreciate that there are moves afoot, but the aid community in Australia is asking when. It's been years that they've been asking for this exemption, and their key request is when.
Slade Brockman Deputy-President
Given that it's 12.15 pm, the committee will report to the Senate.
Progress reported.