This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Bills
Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
11:56 am
The Greens believe that the reason the government didn't table the report for 3½ years was that the report was so utterly scathing of what the government is doing now and, if the public had had the chance to read the report and work with civil societies, there would be far broader resistance to what this government is doing now.
Just to give those members who haven't had the benefit of reading the INSLM's report on this an insight into how scathing the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor was of what the government is doing now, what Labor is doing now with the support of One Nation and the coalition, this is just the introduction from the INSLM:
Australia leads the world in making laws of a kind discussed in this report.
The law that this report discusses permits people in our society to be imprisoned, not as a punishment for a crime committed but because it is decided that their living freely in our society unacceptably risks them committing a crime in the future.
Only one Australian parliament, and a mere handful of Australian parliamentarians, have resisted these laws, and these laws have made us a coarser and harsher society. I doubt that anyone knows whether they have made us safer.
This is the commencement of the INSLM's report about these very laws, and there's no reference anywhere to the substance of this in the government's response. Of course, the coalition don't touch it. One Nation loves these kinds of laws.
But the INSLM went on further. He said:
In gentler times these kinds of laws did not exist, although some deny it. In times past, people who had committed crimes and served their sentences were thought to have paid their debt to society and lived with us in our communities, even though some reoffended.
In gentler times, the types of laws discussed in this report were the subject of parody. Lewis Carroll had Alice quiz the Queen—
I think it's worth including this quote in the INSLM'S report because it sums up what Labor is doing—
'What sort of things do YOU remember best?' Alice ventured to ask.
'Oh, things that happened the week after next,' the Queen replied in a careless tone. 'For instance, now,' she went on, sticking a large piece of plaster on her finger as she spoke, 'there's the King's Messenger. He's in prison now, being punished: and the trial doesn't even begin till next Wednesday: and of course, the crime comes last of all.'
'Suppose he never commits the crime?' said Alice.
'That would be all the better, wouldn't it?' the Queen said, as she bound the plaster round her finger with a bit of ribbon.
Alice felt there was no denying THAT. 'Of course, it would be all the better,' she said: 'but it wouldn't be all the better his being punished.'
'You're wrong THERE at any rate,' said the Queen: 'were YOU ever punished?'
'Only for faults,' said Alice.
'And you were all the better for it, I know!" the Queen said triumphantly.
'Yes, but then I HAD done the things I was punished for,' said Alice: 'that makes all the difference.'
'But if you HADN'T done them,' the Queen said, 'that would have been better still: better, and better, and better!'
That's what these laws are. This is Labor and the coalition doing their version of better and better—with their mates in One Nation better again—jailing people for crimes they haven't committed. They are putting people in jail, holding them in detention and putting them on control orders for future crimes. As the INSLM said:
In gentler times, although not so long ago, the types of laws discussed in this report existed only in science fiction
The INSLM then went on and said, 'As Philip J Dick's conundrum of "precrime" attests'—and then there was a quote from science fiction. But, of course, this isn't science fiction. You're doing it now. Labor, with your mates in the coalition and your avid support from One Nation, are putting this science fiction in now. This is what Philip J Dick said, as quoted by the INSLM, who urged this parliament not to do this. Philip J Dick wrote:
As they walked along the busy, yellow-lit tiers of offices, Anderton said: 'You're acquainted with the theory of precrime, of course—
Then, Witwer said:
With the aid of your precog mutants, you've boldly and successfully abolished the post-crime punitive system of jails and fines. As we all realise, punishment was never much of a deterrent, and could scarcely have afforded the comfort to a victim already dead.'
… … …
Anderton said: 'You've probably already grasped the basic legalistic drawback to precrime methodology. We're taking in individuals who have broken no law.'
'But surely, they will,' Witwer affirmed with conviction.
'Happily, they don'tbecause we get to them first, before they can commit an act of violence. So the commission of the crime itself is absolute metaphysics. We can claim they are culpable. They, on the other hand, can eternally claim they are innocent. And, in a sense, they are innocent.'
That's what this bill does. That's what you're doing now. You're putting us into this science fiction dystopia.
Margaret Atwood was quoted by the INSLM in their effort to stop this parliament doing what it's now doing. They said:
Margaret Atwood has told us of a 'surprise piece of information':
'The future doesn't really exist. Therefore it's up for grabs because unlike the past nobody can fact check the future. If you're a novelist that is a good thing.'
But—bloody hell!—it should be a restraint on legislators. It should be a restraint on this parliament. When the INSLM puts that in the report, is it any wonder that this government buried it for 3½ years. Then, at the last moment they could, they brought it out with this ugly piece of legislation that is putting us into the dystopia that Lewis Carroll, Philip J Dick and Margaret Atwood spoke about. Is it because you found that too much to stomach, Minister? Is that why Labor hid the report for 3½ years?
No comments