This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Committees

Community Affairs Legislation Committee, Public Works Joint Committee; Government Response to Report


Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

6:28 pm

I present three government responses to committee reports as listed at item 20 on today's order of business. I seek leave to have the documents incorporated in Hansard.

Leave granted.

RESPONSE TO THE SENATE COMMUNITY AFFAIRS LEGISLATION COMMITTEE REPORT

Aged Care Bill 2024 [Provisions]

Acknowledgment

The Australian Government thanks the Senate Community Affairs Legislation Committee (Committee) for their examination of the provisions of the Aged Care Bill 2024 (Bill), consideration of stakeholder submissions, and information conveyed at the various public hearings which provided a strong voice in favour of the Bill and its aim of ensuring a sustainable, transparent aged care system which focuses on the needs and rights of older people.

Response to Committee recommendations

Recommendation 1

3.198 The committee recommends that the bill be passed.

The Government notes this recommendation.

The Aged Care Bill 2024 was passed by the Parliament on 25 November 2024 and received Royal Assent on 2 December 2024. The Aged Care Act 2024 (the Act) subsequently commenced on 1 November 2025.

During debate on the Bill in the House of Representatives, the Government made 66 amendments and supported 2 non-government amendments, with debate in the Senate resulting in a further 90 Government and 9 non-government amendments.

Many of these amendments address additional commentary and recommendations in the Committee's report as raised by non-government senators.

The then Minister for Aged Care, the Hon Anika Wells MP, also provided a detailed response to the related inquiries by the Senate Standing Committee for the Scrutiny of Bills and the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Human Rights. The Government's response to these Committees is outlined in Scrutiny Digest 14 of 2024 and Report 10 of 2024 respectively.

Response to additional comments—Coalition senators

Recommendation 1

1.12 Coalition senators recommend the System Governor be required to report quarterly on both the current waitlist and wait times from application to service commencement of Commonwealth funded aged care.

The Government notes the recommendation.

During passage through the Senate, the Bill was amended to require quarterly reporting of waiting periods.

Recommendation 2

1.14 Coalition senators recommend the Bill include provision to ensure aged care places.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 3

1.27 Coalition senators recommend that the timeframe for the release of the schedule of rules and the instruments through which they will be delegated be agreed prior to the Bill being passed.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 4

1.28 Coalition senators recommend that upon public release, all relevant rules and subordinate legislation pertaining to the Aged Care Bill 2024 be referred to the Senate Standing Committee for Community Affairs for inquiry and public comment.

The Government notes the recommendation.

During passage through the Senate, the Bill was amended to require the Senate Community Affairs Legislation Committee, or other Senate committee, must begin a review of any rules specified at subclause 602(13) within three months after the day the rules are tabled in the Senate.

Recommendation 5

1.29 Coalition senators recommend that the timeframe for the commencement of the Support at Home Program be revised to allow sufficient time for implementation, following receipt of the transition Bill and all the subordinate legislation.

The Government notes the recommendation.

The commencement of Support at Home and the Aged Care Act 2024, occurred on 1 November 2025.

Recommendation 6

1.30 Coalition senators recommend that in recognition of the cost, both in staff training time and monetary value of these changes, the Government must provide certainty to the sector through a clear transition path including implementation information beyond 1 July 2025.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 7

1.31 Coalition senators recommend that the transition arrangements include a provision that the start date for all changes that require ICT builds be set on a date not less than six months following (a) receipt of pricing from IHACPA, (b) tabling of the chapter 4 rules, and (c) all associated Government ICT changes be in place (or, at least scoped to the extent that would provide certainty regarding the systems interface with providers IT).

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 8

1.32 Coalition senators recommend that the Government adopt an approach ensuring providers are not penalised until full transition has been completed.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 9

1.34 Coalition senators recommend that the design of the CHSP replacement program be expedited to give providers sufficient time to make necessary changes and to prevent the challenges associated with rushed policy implementation as seen with this Bill. This would also enable providers the opportunity to undertake ICT changes for both Support at Home and the CHSP replacement program concurrently.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 10

1.43 Coalition senators recommend that the Government undertakes further consultation on care management fee caps, including with clinicians, to provide greater transparency about the factors that were used to determine the Service Lists.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 11

1.44 Coalition senators also recommend that the Government specifically review their determination to cap cleaning and gardening services and the categorisation of activities such as showering within the Service Lists.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 12

1.46 Coalition senators recommend that an extensive education and information campaign be undertaken to address the understanding gap clearly articulated throughout this inquiry. This campaign should be targeted at both older Australians and their families, and the wider aged care sector.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 13

1.49 Coalition senators recommend that the Bill is explicit about its definition of hardship, including what defines someone as experiencing hardship and what are the obligations of providers regarding the treatment of someone experiencing hardship.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 14

1.51 Coalition senators recommend that clear definitions of terms, including metrics by which they will be measured, be included in the primary legislation.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 15

1.54 Coalition senators recommend that supporter provisions be removed from the Bill to allow additional time for consultation. This would help to address concerns about the practical application of these provisions, and their interaction with existing State and Territory legislation, notably power of attorney practise.

The Government notes the recommendation.

During passage of the Bill through the Senate, the Government amended the legislation to remove 'decision-making supporters' to ensure that the will and preferences of older people are paramount in decision making.

The amendments also ensured there was no conflict between state and territory appointed decision-makers (those with guardianship, enduring power of attorney or similar) and individuals appointed under aged care legislation by the System Governor to make decisions on behalf of an older person about their access to aged care services.

Recommendation 16

1.58 Coalition senators recommend that the Bill clarifies who within an aged care organisation should be authorised to receive a disclosure, including the provision for an employee to opt out of being required to receive such disclosures.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 17

1.60 Coalition senators recommend a time-based obligation for complaint determinations to be specified in legislation and urge the Government to

explore additional measures to ensure the integrity of complaint reconsiderations and reviews.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 18

1.68 Coalition senators recommend allowing greater flexibility in use of care minutes so that residential aged care homes can deliver individualised, fit for purpose care that is within the limitations of their market, while still ensuring high quality care.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 19

1.71 Coalition senators recommend that further consideration is given to regulatory requirements to ensure that dignity of risk is never removed from the centre of high-quality care.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 20

1.72 Coalition senators also recommend that the Bill mandates that no aged care resident is ever denied access to the person that they designate, or the

person designated under appropriate authority.

The Government acknowledges the recommendation.

During passage through the Senate, the Bill was amended to provide that an individual has a right to access, at any time the individual chooses, a person designated by the individual, or a person designated by an appropriate authority.

Recommendation 21

1.76 Coalition senators note that consideration should be given to the exclusion of a RAD from aged care asset testing provisions where the person has sold their family home to pay the RAD. This would align the treatment of a RAD to its treatment in the age pension assessment and recognise that residential aged care is an individuals' home.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 22

1.79 Coalition senators recommend that the review of the Accommodation Supplement be brought forward to report by 1 July 2026 and that this requirement and timeframe be contained in this Bill.

The Government notes the recommendation.

The Bill was amended to include provisions for the review of accommodation pricing.

Recommendation 23

1.81 Coalition Senators recommend that the review of the new Aged Care Act, 2024, be brought forward to three years and that this requirement and timeframe be included in this Bill.

The Government notes the recommendation.

The Bill was amended during passage through the House of Representatives to provide that the Minister must cause an independent review of the operation of the Act to be conducted within 6 months after the third anniversary of the commencement of the Act.

Recommendation 24

1.85 Coalition senators acknowledge it was a recommendation of the Aged Care Taskforce that agreement for additional services be made after a participant has entered care. However, we recommend that this provision be removed from the Bill to allow further time to resolve concerns about the practical application of the measure.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 25

1.87 Coalition senators recommend that worker screening provisions should be amended to ensure flexibility and increase local community workforce participation particularly for Indigenous communities.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 26

1.90 Coalition senators remain committed to YPIRAC targets and recommend that any exemptions for people under the age of 65 to enter aged care should be granted on a case-by-case basis, with regard to exceptional circumstance provisions, allowing for an assessment of the individual's specific circumstances.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 27

1.92 Coalition Senators recommend that greater emphasis is placed on

the additional value that is provided by organisations, such as Meals on Wheels, when determining contracts and pricing for services.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 28

1.98 Coalition senators recommend that the Government immediately assess the scale of risk in relation to unrecoverable debts and makes provision to ensure that the liability for any unrecoverable debts' rests with the appropriate entity.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 29

1.100 The Government has publicly acknowledged its intention to remove the worker voice provisions, and accordingly, Coalition senators require the removal of these provisions prior to the Bill being debated in the Senate.

The Government notes the recommendation.

During passage of the Bill through the House of Representatives, these provisions were removed.

Recommendation 30

1.102 Coalition senators recommend the Inspector-General of Aged Care review the reporting requirements in-line with the Royal Commission recommendations to ensure red and green tape is fit for purpose, proportionate and delivers real value.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Recommendation 31

1.106 Coalition senators recommend that any condition sufficiently important to require a civil penalty should be subject to the scrutiny of the Parliament.

The Government notes the recommendation.

Conditions which may attract a civil penalty are set out in either the Act or the Rules. Both are subject scrutiny by the Parliament and the relevant parliamentary committees, such as the Scrutiny of Delegated Legislation Committee.

Recommendation 32

1.107 Coalition Senators recommend that the Bill be passed with amendment.

The Government notes the recommendation.

The Aged Care Bill 2024, as amended during passage through the House of Representatives and the Senate, was passed by the Parliament on 25 November 2024 and received Royal Assent on 2 December 2024.

Response to dissenting report—Australian Greens

Recommendation 1

1.18 That the Government address many of the serious concerns raised throughout the inquiry, as well as provide the outstanding rules to enable a clearer assessment of the impact of the legislation in its totality.

The Government notes the recommendation.

_____

AUSTRALIAN GOVERNMENT RESPONSE TO THE PARLIAMENTARY STANDING COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC WORKS:

Inquiry into Point Wilson Waterside Infrastructure Remediation, Point Wilson, Victoria

October 2026

Recommendation 1

3.46

The Committee recommends that the House of Representatives resolve, pursuant to Section 18(7) of the Public Works Committee Act 1969, that it is expedient to carry out the following proposed works: Point Wilson Waterside Infrastructure Remediation project.

Response:

The Government agrees to this recommendation.

The Hon Alan Tudge MP, then Minister for Population, Cities and Urban Infrastructure, spoke in the House of Representatives on 19 September 2019 following the publication of the Committee's report and moved: "That, in accordance with the provisions of the Public Works Committee Act 1969, it is expedient to carry out the following proposed work which was referred to the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Public Works and on which the committee has duly reported to Parliament: Department of Defence, Point Wilson Waterside Infrastructure Remediation Project, Point Wilson, Victoria."

House of Representatives Hansard, 19 September 2019, Public Works Joint Committee—Approval of Work.

The House of Representatives agreed to this expediency motion on 19 September 2019.

Recommendation 2

3.48

The Committee requests that the Department of Defence provide the Committee with an annual progress report for the Point Wilson Waterside Infrastructure Remediation project as well as detailed reports which provide the final costs of each element once completed. Defence should also provide the detail of any commercial sharing opportunities or use that it has been able to pursue.

Response:

The Government notes this recommendation.

Construction commenced in March 2020, with updates provided to the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Public Works in May 2021 and October 2022. The project completed construction in April 2023 entering the 12-month defect liability period in the following month.

The Post Implementation Report was submitted to the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Public Works in November 2024.

Given the passage of time since this report was tabled, a substantive government response is no longer appropriate.

_____

AUSTRALIAN GOVERNMENT RESPONSE TO THE PARLIAMENTARY STANDING COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC WORKS REPORT:

Cocos (Keeling) Islands—West Island, Seawater Reverse Osmosis Plant Project and other works, 5/23

Australian Government response

The Australian Government's response (the department) to the Cocos (Keeling) Islands, West Island—Seawater Reverse Osmosis Plant and other works recommendations is set out in detail below.

Recommendation 1:

2.35 The Committee recommends that the House of Representatives resolve, pursuant to Section 18(7) of the Public Works Committee Act 1969, that it is expedient to carry out the following proposed works: Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications and the Arts, Cocos (Keeling) Islands—West Island, Seawater Reverse Osmosis Plant Project.

The House of Representatives approved the public works on 10 May 2023 and the recommendation is resolved.

Recommendation 2:

3.48 For future projects that fall within the oversight of the Public Works Committee, the Committee recommends that the Australian Taxation Office conduct broader staff consultation during the design phase.

The ATO has a longstanding commitment to consulting with staff on workplace design and capital works projects. In response to the Committee's recommendation in 2023, the ATO has further strengthened this approach by commencing consultation earlier and embedding more structured and transparent engagement throughout both the design and delivery stages of property projects.

Since 2023, the ATO has introduced early-stage design discovery workshops as a core element of its consultation framework. These workshops are held at the outset of projects to test design assumptions and to identify work practices, functional needs and work health and safety requirements before concepts are finalised. This earlier engagement has enabled design solutions to better reflect how spaces are used in practice and to reduce the need for later design changes.

Consultation continues to be supported through site working groups (SWGs), comprising representatives from all affected business lines. SWGs provide structured input on business-specific requirements and local ways of working. Following the Committee's recommendation, the ATO has enhanced the role of SWG representatives, clarified their responsibilities and increased the visibility of the role to staff. This has improved the flow of information between project teams, business lines and staff, and supported more consistent communication of feedback and project updates.

In addition, the ATO has expanded opportunities for broader staff engagement through practical initiatives such as on-site display centres and visual mock-ups. These initiatives support staff understanding of proposed designs and provide accessible forums for feedback, strengthening confidence in both the design and delivery of property projects.

Recommendation 3:

3.50 The Committee recommends that the House of Representatives resolve, pursuant to Section 18(7) of the Public Works Committee Act 1969, that it is expedient to carry out the following proposed works: Australian Taxation Office—Australian Taxation Office Fit-out—Proposed Fit-out of Existing Leased Premises at 200 Collins Street, Hobart, Tasmania.

The House of Representatives approved the public works on 10 May 2023 and the recommendation is resolved.

Recommendation 4:

4.56 The Committee recommends that the House of Representatives resolve, pursuant to Section 18(7) of the Public Works Committee Act 1969, that it is expedient to carry out the following proposed works: Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade—Proposed Construction and Decommissioning of the Australian Pavilion at the World Expo 2025 Osaka, Kansai, Japan.

The House of Representatives approved the public works on 10 May 2023 and the recommendation is resolved.