This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Committees

Scrutiny of Delegated Legislation Committee, Delegated Legislation Monitor


Andrew McLachlan

Andrew McLachlan SA, Liberal Party

6:18 pm

At the request of the Chair of the Senate Standing Committee for the Scrutiny of Delegated Legislation, I present Delegated Legislation Monitor No. 11 of 2026 together with ministerial correspondence received by the committee and move:

That the Senate take note of the report.

I rise to speak to the tabling of the Scrutiny of Delegated Legislation Committee's delegated legislation monitor No. 11 of 2026. This monitor reports on the committee's consideration of 130 legislative instruments registered between 25 August and 20 September 2026. In this monitor, the committee has commented on four new instruments and has concluded its examination of one instrument. The first new instrument the committee has commented on is the Biosecurity Regulations 2026. This instrument sets out a range of matters regarding the management of certain biodiversity risks associated with goods and transport, among other things. The committee has identified a number of scrutiny concerns with this instrument, including in relation to the conferral of discretionary powers on biodiversity officers, the clarity of drafting of certain terms, the availability of independent merits review and the outcomes of consultation undertaken in relation to the instrument. The committee has resolved to seek advice from the Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry about these matters accordingly. The committee has also sought the minister's advice in relation to the inclusion in the instrument of significant elements of offence provisions set out in the Biosecurity Act 2015. Specifically, the committee noted that sections 10 to 13, 44 to 47 and 50 of the instrument appear to contain elements that are necessary for the effective operation of offence provisions in the act. Given that the offences to which these provisions relate carry significant penalties, including imprisonment of up to two years, the committee is concerned that, contrary to its scrutiny expectations, the instrument's explanatory statement does not contain a thorough justification for the inclusion of these matters in delegated legislation.

Furthermore, the committee has commented on sections 97 and 98 of the instrument, which modify primary legislation by exempting certain goods, aircraft, vessels or persons from becoming subject to biosecurity control or other specified requirements set out in the Biosecurity Act 2015. While the committee acknowledges that the instruments explanatory statement provides a thorough policy justification for these exemptions, the committee is concerned that the explanatory statement does not address why it is considered necessary and appropriate for these exemptions to be contained in delegated, rather than primary, legislation. As such, the committee has resolved to seek the minister's advice.

The second new instrument the committee has commented on is the Defence Regulations 2026. This instrument provides for various matters relating to the administration and operation of the Australian Defence Force, including service in the ADF, processes for the redress of grievances, declaration of defence areas and counter-UXS measures. In its scrutiny of this instrument, the committee has noted concerns regarding the conferral and delegation of broad discretionary powers, the availability of independent merits review, reversal of the evidential burden of proof and impacts on privacy and procedural fairness. As these concerns identified do not meet the committee's usual expectations under its scrutiny principles, the committee has sought the advice of the Minister for Defence regarding these matters. Of particular concern to the committee is the inclusion of coercive powers in sections 75, 98, 99 and 100 of the instrument. The committee's view is that coercive powers that have the potential to seriously trespass on personal rights and liberties should generally not be included in the delegated legislation unless a thorough justification is included in the explanatory materials. The coercive powers included in the instrument provide for persons, items, buildings and structures to be removed from the defence related areas in certain circumstances. These powers also enliven monitoring powers in the Regulatory Powers (Standard Provisions) Act 2014, which allow authorised persons to enter premises, inspect documents and take extracts or make copies of documents, among other things. In the absence of relevant detail in the instruments explanatory statement, the committee has sought the minister's advice in relation to why these provisions are considered necessary and appropriate.

The final new instruments that the committee has commented on are the Social Security (International Agreements) Amendment (Oriental Republic of Uruguay and Other Measures) Regulations 2026 and the Water Amendment (Murray-Darling Basin Agreement—River Murray Increased Flows and Other Measures) Regulations 2026. These instruments modify primary legislation to implement changes to certain international and intergovernmental agreements. The committee's longstanding view is that provisions that modify primary legislation should be contained in primary legislation, as this ensures a greater level of parliamentary oversight. While these instruments do not, strictly, meet the committee's scrutiny expectations in this regard, the committee notes that there are limits, set out in enabling legislation, to the extent to which modifications to primary legislation may be via legislative instrument. In light of this, the committee has resolved to draw to the attention of the Senate, under standing order 23(4), the amendments made to primary legislation by these instruments.

The committee has also concluded its consideration of the Aboriginal Land and Waters (Jervis Bay Territory) By-Laws 2026. This instrument sets out a range of matters in relation to Aboriginal land in Jervis Bay Territory, including offences for certain conduct, enforcement measures and permits to undertake certain activities.

The committee sought the advice of the Minister for Indigenous Australians in relation to a number of scrutiny concerns and received a response on 13 November 2026. The minister advised that a number of provisions in the instrument would be amended to address the concerns raised by the committee. For example, the minister stated that certain provisions that reversed the evidential burden of proof would be redrafted or removed on the basis they are not peculiarly within the knowledge of the defendant. The minister also undertook to amend the instrument to correct the definition of EPBC Regulations and to include a new definition that explains the specific regulations that set out the penalties that apply to offences in the instrument. Furthermore, the minister advised that the delegation of discretionary powers upon wardens, including coercive powers, will be amended to limit delegations to Commonwealth authorities and officers or employees of the Wreck Bay Aboriginal Community Council. The committee welcomes these undertakings and considers that their implementation will better align the instrument with the committee's scrutiny expectations.

The committee also welcomes the minister's undertaking to amend the instrument's explanatory statement. In concluding its examination of the instrument, the committee has noted particular aspects of the minister's response that it considers should be included in the amendments to the instrument's explanatory statement. In broad terms, the information the committee seeks to be included relates to the availability of independent merits review and judicial review; the necessity and appropriateness of certain powers; the meaning and interpretation of certain key terms; consultation undertaken in relation to the instrument; and the use of notifiable instruments.

On behalf of the committee, I would like to thank the minister, the Wreck Bay Aboriginal Community Council and the National Indigenous Australians Agency for their constructive engagement with the committee in its scrutiny of the instrument. I would also like to thank the minister and the council for their proactive and prompt undertakings to amend the instrument and its explanatory statement.

With these comments, I commend the committee's Delegated legislation monitor: monitor 11 of 2026 to the Senate.

Question agreed to.