This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Fatima Payman WA, Australia's Voice
3:05 pm
Pursuant to standing order 74(5), I ask the Minister representing the Minister for Home Affairs for an explanation as to why an answer has not been provided to Home Affairs question SED25-092 of the 2025-26 Supplementary budget estimates relating to the Australian Border Forces purchase of fishing boats for certain purposes.
Slade Brockman Deputy-President
Senator Watt, do you have a point of order?
Murray Watt Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Environment and Water
It's very well known by all senators that if a senator wishes to ask a question like this, they provide notice of that so that the relevant representing minister can come to the chamber ready to answer the question. In this case, I am the representing minister. I'm not aware of any notice having been provided to this. This is not the first occasion that Senator Payman has done this. I'd ask for your direction as to how we should proceed from here. I'm not sure why it is that every other senator in this chamber is able to provide notice but Senator Payman is not able to provide notice.
Slade Brockman Deputy-President
As I said last time, it is a matter of courtesy, as you have raised, that such matters are notified. However, from the position of the Chair, it is impossible to enforce that effectively. It's in Senator Payman's hands whether she extends that courtesy or not. I'm happy to give you the call if you wish to say anything further. Otherwise I do have to give Senator Payman the call.
Murray Watt Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Environment and Water
Again, as you have suggested, I'd ask Senator Payman to reflect on what you've just said. You're correct that this has been pointed out to Senator Payman before. A senator is much more likely to get a more complete answer if they provide notice. I can foreshadow right now I'm not going to be in a position to provide Senator Payman with much of an answer, because, of course, I haven't had an opportunity to get any information from the minister who I represent.
Fatima Payman WA, Australia's Voice
I move:
That the Senate takes note.
The government speaks of courtesy and convention. I'm told that I should provide a heads-up when I intend to ask a question about an overdue question on notice. My question is: how much notice do you need? Because this question is almost a year old. Is a year's notice not enough, Minister? Should I come back in 2027? I would suggest that, when the government makes the decision to deliberately not answer a question, it should not expect the Senate to tolerate this refusal. It should expect the house of review to follow up on things using all procedural tools at its disposal. Now this question relates to reports that the ABF has been buying up fishing boats around the north coast of WA and the Northern Territory to give to illegal fishers and asylum seekers. It asks the ABF about the expenditure it has incurred in purchasing these boats, whether there was a tender process and what purposes these boats are used for.
Now, before I go any further, let's get something clear before the spin machine of the government gets into operation. I do not disagree with this policy.If our government has to choose between buying a boat to get people, including illegal fishers, back home safely or risk letting them drown at sea, I choose the boats. I do not want to live under a government that would choose to let a person die. This is obviously unacceptable when it comes to asylum-seekers, but, even in the case of illegal fishers, if they break Australian law, it must be dealt with through the proper legal processes.
What I have an issue with, when the taxpayer is paying for these boats, is all the secrecy around what is being done with these boats and how much is being paid for them. As the Senate can see, this is not an issue on which the government has been forthcoming. This question is nearly a year old, and it still remains unanswered. Why? Why is it taking so long to explain how much was spent on fishing boats, Minister?
In another question on notice on this topic, I asked, 'Is it the case that the ABF is giving illegal fishing crews boats to return home in?' That was followed by a series of supplementary questions. The response to that first question was no, and the supplementary questions were left unanswered. I want to note that Senator Shoebridge has also asked about this issue at estimates. He was told at a hearing in December 2025 that reports of these fishing boats being given away to illegal fishers and asylum-seekers was disinformation. Apart from that, officials were not willing to discuss the issue at all in front of the committee and took on notice Senator Shoebridge's questions about where these boats are going. The response to the question on notice, which arrived 71 days after the due date, did not use the word 'disinformation'. It said, 'A public interest immunity claim was made by the Minister for Home Affairs, the Hon. Tony Burke MP, on 9 February 2026, which was accepted by the Legal and Constitutional Affairs Committee on 4 March 2026.'
To those watching, just to clarify what happened, the Labor Minister for Home Affairs did not want to answer this question. So he asked the Labor controlled committee if he was allowed to not answer the question, and the Labor controlled committee said, 'Yes, no worries.' That's an absolute joke of process. The answer itself is strange too. If these claims were disinformation as the Legal and Constitutional Affairs Committee was told by officials, why would a public interest immunity claim need to be made? Could it be that there is more truth to this disinformation than we thought?
I presume Senator Shoebridge was not satisfied by that response, which I again note came 71 days after the deadline. I know it's not a competition, but at least he got an answer. My question on this topic still remains unanswered and is now more than 290 days overdue. We've got the government talking about convention and courtesy. Where's the courtesy in answering my question that is 290 days overdue. When the due date for this question first passed, I liked to imagine that there was a room in some government office where, at any hour of the day, public servants were sitting there, brows furrowed, stroking their chins and going, 'Hmmm'—thinking about their response to this question. After several months passed without an answer, I began to suspect that there were no government officials pulling double shifts in the thinking room.
In September, I put in a freedom of information request to see what work has been done on this question. The government immediately requested a 30-day extension and then missed the extended deadline anyway. So the documents which relate to the overdue question also became overdue. Do you see a pattern here, people? They love extending questions that need to be answered, and, when it's overdue, they sit there saying, 'Well, there's courtesy; give us notice.' Again, you've had 290 days.
When these documents were finally released, I was disappointed but not surprised to learn that, since February, there has not been so much as an email related to developing a response to this question. Did they think the Senate would just allow this question to go unanswered? That's a shocking attitude to have. In the documents, one official declares that no boats have been provided to illegal fishers, but another suggests that this isn't certain and that they should confirm with Maritime Border Command.
We still don't know who was right, because, as I mentioned, the question remains unanswered. Ironically, in the most recent email on this issue, an official writes: 'Wonderful. Thanks for the fast response.' Well, I'm glad someone is getting a fast response, even if it isn't the Senate. In another email dated 6 January 2026, an official from the Operation Sovereign Borders joint taskforce notes in relation to this and another question which was eventually answered: 'From an OSB perspective, I think they can be dealt with fairly quickly.' Just to run that past everyone again, that is an official saying in January that this question, which is still unanswered 10 months later, can be dealt with fairly quickly, so it's really disappointing that I'm having to raise this in the Senate. Questions should be answered on time. That's a basic expectation. When they are answered, the answers should provide clarity on what taxpayer money has been spent on. It's not rocket science; it's basic maths.
We know through the grants rorts saga that the government see taxpayer dollars as their money that they can use for whatever they want. I'm here to set the record straight. It isn't. Taxpayers' money should be used effectively and transparently. Because they haven't answered the question, I don't know if the government are being effective, but they sure aren't being transparent. Lift your game.
Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party
3:16 pm
I'd like to make a short contribution in relation to this. I think all of us are sent to this place by our constituents in our home states to ask questions in a house of review, and this is a house of review. Every single senator, including Senator Payman, has a right to ask questions in this place and has a right to reasonably expect that those questions will be answered within a reasonable period of time. Over how many days are we—
Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party
290 days? For goodness sake! That is just appalling. We've heard from the Centre for Public Integrity. The Centre for Public Integrity has said that this government's record on transparency is worse than the previous government. It is falling down. This Labor government is falling down in terms of integrity, in terms of transparency and in terms of being accountable to the Australian people. We don't just come to this place and ask questions for our own entertainment. We're asking questions on behalf of the Australian people who send us here, because we want those answers in order to keep the executive government to account. It doesn't matter who's in power and it doesn't matter who asks the questions; these processes should be followed as part of transparency, as part of integrity of our process and as part of the objective of the Senate as a house of review.
Question agreed to.