This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Deborah O'Neill NSW, Australian Labor Party
4:55 pm
The Senate will now consider the proposal, under standing order 75, from Senator Lambie, which is also shown at item 13 of today's Order of Business:
That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:
The need for the Albanese Government to immediately pause the divestment of Defence Estate assets because the plan is based on incomplete and flawed information and will negatively affect the ability of the Australian Defence Force to raise, train and sustain an effective force.
Is consideration of the proposal supported?
More than the number of senators required by the standing orders having risen in their places—
With the concurrence of the Senate, the clerks will set the clocks in line with the informal arrangements made by the whips.
Jacqui Lambie Tasmania, Jacqui Lambie Network
4:56 pm
I move:
That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:
The need for the Albanese Government to immediately pause the divestment of Defence Estate assets because the plan is based on incomplete and flawed information and will negatively affect the ability of the Australian Defence Force to raise, train and sustain an effective force.
The Australian government is getting rid of 67 Defence sites either fully or partially. This is out of 68 properties identified in an independent audit. I don't have a problem with Defence looking at sites and working out if Defence and therefore the Australian people are getting the best bang for their buck. But what's become quite clear from the current Senate inquiry is that this decision is based on incomplete and flawed information. I was shocked from Defence—no, actually, I wasn't really shocked at all.
Here's what we know. There are no costings for site remediation. There are no costings to effect removals and transfers. There are failures to appreciate the full usage of the site. There's even more failure to properly consider the impact on retention by moving personnel north again, and actual terms of leases and conditions seem to have been overlooked. That means that the defence department wants to sell off these assets, but, as usual, they haven't done any of their homework and they don't have any analysis of the risk of divesting estate assets that Defence needs before—before—suitable alternatives have been identified, costed and secured. My goodness me, the cart is surely before the horse.
That includes both of Tasmania's live firing ranges, at Stony Head and Buckland. That'll leave us with none and with reserve bases with no appropriate storage for their equipment, weapons or ammunition. There is no real understanding of the likely impact on recruiting, and Defence's financial argument is based on incomplete and flawed information. Seriously, it's bloody embarrassing for Defence, and you should be ashamed of yourselves again. Defence also seems to have overlooked the terms and conditions of the leases. Do your homework!
The Senate inquiry is still underway, and Defence is already selling off these properties. Seriously, you have no morals left either. The Senate inquiry is due to deliver its report on 15 September. I've got a feeling we're going to need an extension for that, because this isn't over by a long shot. The inquiry highlights yet again the ongoing failure of Defence to properly manage Defence estate or pretty much anything else.
On top of this, Defence's strategic review has not considered exposure or obligations to Australia's south. That's Antarctica and the Southern Ocean. That's just gobsmacking in itself. They're supposed to be in charge of our national security.
China established its first permanent Antarctic station in 1985. They're now up to five—five research bases, as they call them. China claims there is no geopolitical motive—oh jeez, fair dinkum—behind the ongoing expansion of its operations in Antarctica. Open your eyes, Defence. Open your eyes! That includes newly lodged plans for a seasonal station on the icy continent. China has now submitted a draft environmental evaluation to the secretariat of the Antarctic Treaty for the construction and operation of a new summer research station—they call them research stations—at Marie Byrd Land. So China is increasing its presence, and our Defence Strategic Review didn't even consider Australia's southern approaches. Yet they're rushing to get 'for sale' signs up across the Defence estate.
The Mercury last week had a beautiful two-page spread about more than 120 Army cadets who had gathered in Tasmania for the nation's most demanding military youth challenge—a challenge that pushed these kids to their limit over a gruelling 72-hour wilderness test. The Defence estate asset sale is a slap in the face of those cadets. We recently heard that there are 220 cadet units across the country. Nine of their sites are being divested, and eight of these are in Tasmania itself. You're wiping out Tasmania; you're wiping us out. Jesus. I guess cadets won't be happening in Tasmania either, because you've got no forward plan, no forward thinking. What's new for the top of Defence?
And where is the defence minister? Goodness me. The commander of the Australian Army Cadets, Brigadier McCammon, told the Mercury that the challenge was a highlight:
Australian Army Cadets offers amazing avenues for youth to build their fitness, skills, resilience and confidence to become Australia's leaders of tomorrow.
But not the young people in Tasmania. They feel betrayed watching as Defence rushes to sell off their venues and move them somewhere—where, they have no idea, because there is no plan. The sale of the Defence estate must be paused to sort out the financials and correct the deficiencies that Defence couldn't do on their own two feet. They couldn't actually consult with the communities. Don't put it down our throats in Tasmania and think you can come in afterwards and consult. You seriously are shameful. You are absolutely shameful. Here's a good idea: actually do your job, just for once, Defence—just for once. (Time expired)
Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party
5:01 pm
From the outset, I want to say, as a member of the committee that's looking into this matter, that I think as senators we'll be looking forward to the committee's report and looking at all the facts that will be presented to this fine institution when that time comes. As I understand, we are due to report soon, and hopefully senators will have an opportunity then to look at the entirety of what is presented for us to consider with respect to the Defence estate audit.
I've had the privilege, with many of the committee members, to visit a number of sites. Obviously certain sites have a lot of heritage associated with them, and I'd say that there's a lot of proud history—that men and women before us have used those sites to defend our great country. But it's wrong to suggest that the Defence estate process is one that cannot and should not be reviewed on a regular basis by the government of the day. The previous Howard government looked at this issue, because our defence needs to remain modern, needs to remain capable, needs to be vigilant and needs to be capable of taking the opportunities we have to present ourselves, particularly on the current geopolitical issues that we are currently facing as a country and as part of the region that we live in. We cannot put our head in the sand and pretend that the dynamic, the environment around us, has not changed over the last couple of decades.
It is important for every senator in this place to also ask the question: for our defence force, for the fine men and women who serve in the ADF, who put on that uniform every single day, what do we—as a government and as a parliament—want to present them in terms of our infrastructure, in terms of the capability that we give them to defend our great country? It's important, when we look at the highest priority that we could impose on the men and women who put on that ADF uniform every day, that it's the national security of this country that is front and centre of our minds. We are elected to protect the people. We are elected to protect this country. We are elected to protect the interests of this nation, and as federal members of parliament our national security has to be No. 1.
But we also need to make sure we have a defence force that is modern and has the equipment, has the sites that are adequately serviced and maintained. There is no point having sites that are lacking any real infrastructure or lacking in maintenance.
We have heard a lot of evidence before the committee, and I don't want to pre-empt what the committee will present in its report to this place. I think it's important—and I must say a bit premature, Senator Lambie, through you, Acting Deputy President O'Neill—that we wait for this report of the committee to come before the Senate for us to look at the evidence that is presented. I should note it is a committee that is run and chaired by the opposition and the crossbench. So you should have faith, Senator Lambie—through you, Acting Deputy President—in the process. The process is that the committee—
Jacqui Lambie Tasmania, Jacqui Lambie Network
There are for sale signs. There's no process.
Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party
Let the committee do its job. Then let's debate those facts here once the report has been tabled in this chamber. I do worry about where this process is heading. Are we really prepared to put this report into the chamber and have every single senator look at the evidence before it, acknowledging that it is a committee that is chaired by the opposition? I know you and many others have made a wonderful contribution to that process so far, but let's have that debate once the report has been provided to this chamber. There is no point prematurely having a debate about something that we can't talk about because the Senate committee that has been tasked by this Senate has not had an opportunity to present its report for senators to consider where we are heading.
I'd simply say, Senator Lambie, it is important that you have put this motion to the Senate—I 100 per cent agree—but we also need to be mindful that we have processes in place for a reason. The Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade References Committee, will present its report on the defence estate audit, hopefully, soon for all of us in this place to consider and then properly scrutinise and then make the very points that you are wanting to make. There are a couple of committee members who are here, present, but others are not. They're not privy to that at the moment. I just wish we were able to have that conversation in some weeks. (Time expired)
Leah Blyth SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Defence Infrastructure
5:06 pm
I commend Senator Lambie for bringing this motion to the Senate today. Labor has a terrible plan to partially or fully divest 67 Defence sites across Australia. It's reckless, it's short-sighted and it is a complete betrayal of not just our defence forces but also our national security. In my home state of South Australia, four sites are scheduled to be fully or partially divested, with approximately 400 cadets, 150 reservists and 50 full-time ADF personnel affected by these sales.
The irony is not lost on the coalition that this government claims that we are living in the most dangerous strategic environment since the end of World War II and they are selling off critical defence assets on a short-term, money-raising measure. Defence land is not something that a future government can simply recreate in 10 or 20 years time, when we may need it. Once this strategically located metropolitan land is sold off, it will be near impossible to get back, and this is at a time when Australia needs to be looking to extending its reserve force and looking at how we will deploy in a case of conflict near our shores. Senator Lambie went into some detail on what is happening in the strategic environment that we're living in.
In terms of what is surplus to need, the coalition realises that underutilised assets certainly should be divested where they are not used. There are empty blocks of lands that are included in these 67 sites, but there are also deeply historic and symbolic sites included in this that have a huge amount of Australia's defence history attached to them. Simply selling them off and expecting that history to be able to be put somewhere else so that we can have what the Labor government is calling a modern defence force is simply farcical. History is a huge part of our defence forces. Going to war is not something we should ever take lightly, and we should always have those reminders on hand and in sight.
Not only is the historical significance of these sites vitally important; strategically, these sites sit in very, very important parts of metropolitan Australia. As Senator Ciccone mentioned, the committee had the privilege of traveling to see some of these sites. Some of them are strategically located to protect assets. Maybe it's other defence sites or maybe it's capital cities. We need to make sure that we have the capability in Australia to defend not only our defence assets but also where people are living.
In times of crisis, we must be able to draw on that strong sense of national identity. That's hard to do if cadets can no longer go to bases that are close to their homes. In Tasmania, we heard of the closure of a whole lot of defence assets there in the sell-off and that cadets would have to travel an extra couple of hours to participate in a cadet program. That is unacceptable. Why would we make it more difficult for young people to get involved in a cadet program and why would we make it more difficult for everyday Australians to join the reserves when we are living in the most dangerous strategic times since the end of World War II?
Australia has been very lax in its own national security. Australia doesn't have the manufacturing capability that we once had during the Second World War. We are not going to be able to go into refrigerator manufacturers, washing machine manufacturers or textile manufacturers and utilise that space. We just don't have it. It is incredibly important that we take this very, very seriously. Once these assets are sold, once they are sold off to become dense housing, we will never ever be able to get them back. We will lose a generation of cadets and we will lose a generation of reservists when we need them most.
Charlotte Walker SA, Australian Labor Party
5:11 pm
I understand why there is a lot of feeling around defence sites, particularly in communities where they've been part of the landscape for generations. People have worked, trained and lived there. Families have connections to the sites. Some have significant military history attached to them. Those connections deserve to be treated with respect as this process continues, but they also can't be the only consideration when we are deciding what the Australian Defence Force needs for the future.
The independent Defence estate audit found more than 50 underutilised sites across Australia. Maintaining those sites over the next 25 years is estimated to cost more than $2 billion, despite them making no direct contribution to defence capability. Some of the examples in the audit really paint a picture. More than $4 million has been spent over the past four years on Spectacle Island in New South Wales, despite there being no personnel there. Ten defence sites around Australia are currently—
Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this
Hon. Senators:
Honourable senators interjecting—
Deborah O'Neill NSW, Australian Labor Party
Senator Walker, please resume your seat. This is such an important matter. It's hardly orderly for a conversation to be happening across the chamber in the way that just happened. I call all senators to order, and I give you the call once again, Senator Walker.
Charlotte Walker SA, Australian Labor Party
Ten defence sites around Australia are currently vacant but still require money for upkeep and security. Another 14 are basically vacant or only occasionally used. The Penrith Training Depot has been vacant since 2016, regularly experiences vandalism and theft and has cost nearly $1 million over six years. At Kowandi North, in the Northern Territory, around $1 million has been spent over two years on repairs and sustainment associated with security incidents. We have to be able to look at that and ask whether continuing to spend Defence money in this way makes sense.
Australia is facing the most challenging strategic circumstances since the Second World War. We are investing in the people, equipment and facilities that our ADF will need in the years ahead. Maintaining empty or obsolete properties can't continue indefinitely because making a decision about them is difficult. The test used by the audit was straightforward: does continuing to retain and invest in a site best meet Defence's current or future capability needs?
There is also a proper process underway before any divestment occurs. Defence and finance departments are engaging with local communities, First Nations stakeholders, state and local governments and other interested parties. Community town halls, walk-in sessions and stakeholder roundtables have been underway since April. Organisations and existing tenants that use Defence sites are also being consulted about their needs. ADF personnel and their families are obviously a part of that process, too. Where personnel need to transition to alternative sites, that will be managed on a site-by-site basis and in consultation with the affected workforce.
There has also been understandable concern about heritage. Many of these sites carry a great deal of Australian military history. Heritage protections, including obligations under the EPBC Act, will continue to apply throughout the divestment process. There is also an opportunity to make some of that history more accessible. Defence currently maintains at least 130 museums, history rooms and displays, but 80 per cent of them are not accessible to the public. At Victoria Barracks in Sydney, for example, the intention is to improve public access to the heritage of the site.
It's also worth remembering that governments of all political persuasions have made decisions to divest Defence property where the sites were no longer required for operational or strategic purposes. Bulimba Barracks was sold as a part of a commitment to unlock surplus Commonwealth land in 2020. That was under the former coalition government. In 2015, the Pontville Small Arms Rifle Range Complex was identified for sale because Defence no longer needed it for training or operations. Leeuwin Barracks was also slated for sale in the same year because there was no ongoing operational or strategic need for the site.
This broader principle is not a new one. Defence needs change. Technology changes. The way our ADF trains and operates changes. The strategic environment certainly changes. Our Defence estate cannot be frozen in time. There will be difficult decisions throughout this process, and communities deserve the opportunity to have their say about the sites they have lived alongside for decades.
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
5:17 pm
Isn't it extraordinary? Labor comes in here and says communities have a right to have a say. Do you know what really drives communities absolutely to despair? It's when the government has already made a decision and then invites you in for a cup of tea and some biscuits and says, 'Now we're consulting with you about it.' That's what's happening with this Defence estate.
They decided to flog off 67 sites and, having made the decision, they consulted nobody outside Defence. I'll get to who they didn't consult in Defence as well. They had two of these so-called auditors come in—neither of whom are auditors, which we found out in the opening salvo of this inquiry—and deliver a Defence audit that is not an audit; it's just a report done by two chosen consultants for Defence. And it looks like they got the list from inside Defence. We're still trying to find out how they got the list of 67. We've been trying for months. We keep getting dodges and weaves from Defence. Defence are dodging and weaving repeatedly, giving us word salad answers. We find out today that, apparently, there are some costings for the maintenance—some $2 billion figure that's popped out. We've been trying to get that from Defence officials: 'Show us the costings. Show us the numbers.' They can give it, it appears, to their Labor senators quietly, behind the scenes; when we ask these questions in parliamentary inquiries with the officials in front of us, we get word salad.
Get this: Defence officials, who are having the community watch these nonanswers and word salads, then say, 'Oh, no, we might be being paid two or three times what the senators are, but we don't want our evidence to be shared, because that's awkward and hard.' When their nonanswers and their refusal to answer direct questions and their word salads are exposed and when the community sees it and they hate it, they don't like that. Well, if you're getting paid double what a senator gets paid—if you're put forward to be a public servant in the public interest, paid for by the public—and the public don't like what you're doing, maybe think about what you're doing and what the government's making you do. Maybe think about your answers. Maybe be frank and direct and honest. I'll tell you what: all of this messaging coming out of Labor about what is a massive privatisation of public lands is spin. That's what this is.
I want to give credit to those communities who have said that this is public land and should be used for public purposes. Some people can understand that maybe it's time it wasn't for a defence purpose. Maybe it should be a public park. Maybe it should be public housing. Maybe it should be a community centre. I'll give you one example: the Australian National Veterans Arts Museum—a bloody good bunch of people down there in Melbourne. They want the former repatriation clinic, right next to Victoria Barracks Melbourne on St Kilda Road, to be for a public purpose not flogged off to a private developer for whatever the hell the private developer wants. They want to put a museum and an art space installation in there for veterans to come and display their art and work through what is sometimes the trauma, sometimes the injury and sometimes their experience of being veterans. They've been trying for that for decades; they didn't even get a look in. No-one spoke to them. No-one talked to them. And now Labor, without doing anything, wants to flog it off to the next developer.
Get this too: we found out just last week that they never asked the Army, the Navy or the Air Force: 'Actually, do you want to keep this property? Do you have a purpose for it?' They never asked. They just said to the services, 'We're going to flog it off, and can you suck it up.' That is not leadership. I say the community is in revolt because what's happening is bloody— (Time expired)
Malcolm Roberts Queensland, Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party
5:21 pm
I thank Senator Lambie for this motion, which One Nation supports wholeheartedly. British prime minister Thatcher made the famous comment that socialists always run out of other people's money. Australia's federal debt under Labor has now passed $1 trillion, yet this government continues to run deficits to fund their big spending agenda. Australia will shortly be unable to keep borrowing at affordable interest rates. We recently just barely avoided a downgrade to our credit rating, yet rates are rising anyway. Ten-year government bonds have gone from 4.85 per cent in the budget to 5.22 per cent—the highest level in 15 years. This means our borrowing will cost more, the deficit will get worse and we will have to borrow even more to pay for it.
Printing money is not an option. During COVID, the Liberal government printed so much money and ever since we've been living with the inflation this caused. More printing will cause more inflation. This means Treasurer Chalmers had two choices: reduce spending and live within our means or sell off the silverware. He chose selling off the silverware. One Nation would have chosen living within our means. One Nation's alternative budget listed savings of $90 billion, costed, turning a deficit into a surplus. We would then put $40 billion back into people's pockets through tax and duty cuts and still balance the budget. One Nation does not need to sell off public assets, and we will not. Treasurer Chalmers is flogging off 67 Defence sites, worth $3.5 billion, including sites that are in use or would be in use under a One Nation government because he needs the money. Selling off Victoria Barracks is insane. They defend our capital cities and should have an integral part of defence training and support. Selling any site weakens our defence capability and reflects this government's pathetic attitude to defence and to veterans. One Nation's advice to the Treasurer is simple: don't sell these sites; use them.
David Pocock ACT, Independent
5:23 pm
Here in the ACT, hundreds of Canberrans have contacted me with concerns about the divestment of the Fairbairn golf course. These are real and genuine concerns. First, the course could be lost to the community for good. Second, the club signed a new five-year lease with Defence in just July last year, when they would have known that they were going to divest this piece of land. Third, there are very serious questions about PFAS contamination, which remain unanswered.
Ther is a community petition to secure the future of the golf course, which now has more than 4,000 signatures. This is a beloved community asset. The primary concern raised with me, which will shock no senators here, is the total lack of consultation with the club or the broader defence and veterans community about plans for the site. A community session was finally held in May, three months after the decision was announced. Consultation after the fact is not consultation. That, to me, seems like box ticking. And it appears that this has been repeated across the country, from what I'm hearing from senators from other states and territories.
Divestment may make sense in some cases, particularly where it includes affordable housing. I have a bill before the Senate that goes to exactly this issue. When the government is divesting land for housing, at least 30 per cent of it needs to be truly affordable housing. We may not be able to lower the prices of building materials, but the government can lower the price of land when they are selling and ensure that we have a 30 per cent minimum of affordable housing. I agree that we should pause this while we work out what is actually happening and until we have a very firm commitment for 30 per cent of dwellings to be social and affordable housing.
Sue Lines President
The question is that the motion as moved by Senator Lambie be agreed to.