This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Adjournment

Women's Reproductive Health, Commonwealth Procurement


Barbara Pocock

Barbara Pocock SA, Australian Greens

5:10 pm

I have a speech to make on another matter, but I want to speak to the speech that Senator Sharma has just made and endorse his words 100 per cent. As a mother who was lucky to have the choice to birth at home and who recently attended one of my own children's births, which commenced at home, I, like so many Australian women, value the choice that is available to us through a proper insurance system for our midwives who choose to practice in the home. I have heard a lot of testimony from midwives in recent times about what the impact of the change that's proposed by the government will have on their practice. It will mean increased risks for women who choose to birth at home without a professional midwife there attending to them, so-called freebirth. That is an extremely dangerous practice that women who are very committed to birthing at home undertake at times, which puts themselves and their babies at risk. It reduces choice for so many women, especially in regional Australia. I endorse what Senator Sharma has said to the government. We call on the relevant minister to extend the existing arrangement until a satisfactory arrangement to support that second midwife, who is absolutely critical to safe birth, is available to keep them at that birth and until we work our way to a proper insurance arrangement which gives women the choice they need, reduces the risk, improves the safety of birth and especially advantages women in the regions.

Now I want to turn to another matter, and that is the question of a recent decision by the Standing Committee on Public Works that waves through the Australian Taxation Office's proposed $73 million fit-out at Festival Tower 2 in Adelaide. At a time when the majority of South Australians are counting every single cent at the supermarket checkout, struggling to keep a roof over our heads and paying their taxes in good faith, the ATO want to hand over $73 million of public money to fit-out multiple floors of what could be the single most expensive commercial office tower in Adelaide. The public works committee think that's fine. A lot of the rest of us don't. That report notes that the committee does have concerns about the ATO's overall approach to identifying new sites and its exit strategies from leases of existing sites, but it would appear to not be enough concern to hold off on this contentious re-allocation or relocation.

Public confidence in the government is failing, and nonsensical decisions like this don't help. Voters look at something like this, the enormous costs it creates without a real benefit that any of us can see—a wasteful decision—and they disengage again and again from politics. How can people believe that the ATO is making decisions in the public interest and that taxpayers' money is spent well and with careful consideration when an appalling decision like this is made? It's so wasteful. Australians are losing patience with decisions that are justified through commercial-in-confidence dealings which we don't have a good oversight of. They're too opaque, too unknown and very hard to justify.

While some have tried to argue that the scope of this inquiry was strictly to consider only the proposed fit-out of the new premises, the terms of reference are clear the committee must consider the need for the work in the first place. We have a building here, which the ATO is moving into, that is extremely expensive, and the central question is why this building? Festival Tower 2, where this movement is going to be made to, is not an ordinary office building. It's one of the most controversial developments ever proposed in Adelaide. Backing onto a South Australia's national heritage listed Parliament House is the tower that's proposed to occupy a parliamentary plaza. The community wants this space to remain an open civic space. Instead it is a 38-storey commercial skyscraper, a monument to big developers and a waste of money. We know Adelaide's CBD continues to experience significant commercial vacancies at around 15 per cent.

There's another question: why move at all? Right now, the ATO is in perfectly serviceable modern office accommodation. The ATO expect the Australian parliament and our public to swallow the line that a 14-year-old building that they're in right now is suddenly at the end of its useful life, and they want to be the core anchor tenant in a very controversial 38-storey building right next to our Parliament House. What are we actually doing here? We don't have the full details on the payment, the building is the wrong spot to go to, and South Australians want better value for their taxpayers' money and more honesty about what's really going on.

Comments

No comments