This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Adjournment

Women's Reproductive Health


Dave Sharma

Dave Sharma NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

5:05 pm

Every year, around 2,000 Australian women choose to give birth in the privacy of their own homes under the care and supervision of trained medical professionals. Most of those homebirths are supported by privately practising midwives. The choice provided to women—to mothers—and to families by these homebirths is a benefit that is increasingly being recognised by Australian mothers. There were over 11,000 women electing to homebirth in the 10 years up to 2023, with a year-on-year growth in homebirths reported in the last five recorded years.

Having the option to safely homebirth under the care of midwives is particularly important in regional Australia, where the nearest hospital may often be hours and hours away by road. The Northern Territory and Western Australia lead the nation in this respect, with the proportion of homebirths in those two jurisdictions being double the national average and with inner and outer regional areas across Australia opting to homebirth at higher rates than we see in metropolitan areas.

Currently, a planned homebirth requires the attendance of two midwives. That is for good safety reasons—for good reasons of the health of the mother and also the health of the newborn child. These arrangements at the moment typically consist of an endorsed midwife—that is, a midwife with additional prescribing and referral qualifications and a number of hours of experience—and a secondary trained midwife, who is often not endorsed but is in the process of accumulating the professional experience and the hours required to gain that endorsement. For many years, midwives providing these services did not have any public indemnity insurance available, so they provided their services under an insurance requirement exemption that is provided by the federal government. But, as of 1 January, the government will have a professional indemnity insurance scheme available to midwives.

The option is not cheap. It will cost around $2,400 for privately practising midwives that attend a homebirth. More importantly, and more significantly, this insurance is only available to midwives who are endorsed. Only endorsed midwives are eligible for that insurance, despite the fact that a midwife does not need to be endorsed to attend a birth. From 1 January, following a transitional period, this insurance, under regulations the government has passed, will become mandatory. If this change goes ahead, the impact on access to homebirths will be quite significant.

According to a Homebirth Australia survey of over 1,000 people, only one in four secondary midwives attending a homebirth is endorsed, meaning that three in four of the secondary midwives that attend homebirths are unable to be insured under this new scheme. That means midwives without an endorsement will have a stark choice to make: provide their services without insurance, which would be risky and risk their careers in the process, or withdraw their services entirely, which is more likely. Faced with this decision, as you would expect, non-endorsed secondary midwives will be forced to stop attending homebirths, and that means that in many instances primary midwives, who have the endorsement, will stop offering homebirth services altogether. The consequence of this change means that there will be major impacts on women seeking to access regulated homebirth services, particularly in parts of regional Australia, where there are simply not enough endorsed midwives available for some women choosing to give birth at home.

When I raised these changes recently at Senate estimates, Chief Nursing and Midwifery Officer McMillan stressed that birthing without a health professional with you is a very dangerous thing to do, and I agree. But, despite this acknowledgement, that may well be the consequence of this policy because free births, women giving birth at home, are what many women may elect to do if the government does not change its course.

If the government is unable to guarantee women will have access to a midwife should they choose homebirth after the impending changes commence, it needs to listen to the mothers and midwives who are urging it to find a temporary solution, like extending the public indemnity insurance exemption until a form of insurance that covers secondary unendorsed midwives is developed. The coalition is calling on the relevant ministers to extend the existing PII exemption for second midwives and work with the sector to develop more achievable endorsement pathways and an insurance solution that ensures families continue to access safe, affordable home births across Australia and that women and mothers have choice.

Comments

No comments