This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Committees
Community Affairs References Committee; Report
Penny Allman-Payne Queensland, Australian Greens
3:56 pm
by leave—I present the report of the Community Affairs References Committee on the Social Security (Administration) Legislation Amendment (Income Management and Enhanced Income Management) Instrument 2026, together with accompanying documents, and I move:
That the Senate take note of the report.
When chairing this inquiry, one thing that struck me was how little has changed since the 2024 inquiry by the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Human Rights. That was a Labor controlled inquiry that produced a 142-page report detailing the many ways that compulsory income management is incompatible with human rights. It was Labor who recommended a transition to a voluntary system, but it seems they're not even listening to themselves. Compulsory income management still unjustifiably violates the rights to self-determination, an adequate standard of living, equality and nondiscrimination. By 'unjustifiable', I don't just mean morally or from a principled point of view, even though that is certainly true; it's also unjustifiable because there has never been any evidence that this policy even works.
The policy of quarantining people's social security payments and restricting how they can use them just because they happen to live in a certain area is a policy founded in racism. Income control originated during the 2007 Northern Territory intervention. It was just another way for the government to exert control over First Nations peoples, and it's still mainly targeted at the places First Nations people live across the Territory and Queensland.
This Labor government has now ensured that this form of discrimination and state control extends at least until 2033. That is shameful. If the government actually cared about ending child poverty and helping people who can work into jobs, then they'd get rid of income control and meaningfully increase social security payments. Imagine that you're living on $300 a week, below the poverty line, and the government comes in to dictate how you can use half your payment. Then you get hit with something that's not a preapproved expense, like your kids' sporting equipment, school fees or unplanned travel to escape domestic violence. That is the reality for so many people forced into income management. It worsens financial hardship. It restricts access to low-cost goods, and it makes life that much harder for you and your children. Children benefit when their parents and carers have enough income, accessible services, stable housing, culturally safe support and meaningful control over family decision-making. Communities benefit most when they have control over how services they use are designed and delivered.
Representative bodies like the Central Land Council, the Tiwi Land Council and the Anindilyakwa Land Council are deeply embedded in their communities and know better than anyone here what their community needs.
For nearly two decades now, they've told governments that forced income control doesn't work and that they are ready and willing to design a voluntary system that is responsive and rights based. But it seems Labor isn't playing ball. They haven't even done anything to move away from a compulsory system since mid-2025. Labor says they're still committed to ending compulsory income management, but it's been a full year of dust collecting on whatever secret plans they may or may not have.
The Australian Greens are calling for Labor to live up to their 2022 election promise, work with communities to abolish all forms of compulsory income management as equal partners, uplift the experts who already live there, not just rely on bureaucrats in Canberra who have never lived in the Territory, and immediately increase all social security payments and the remote area allowance so that people can focus on leading full lives for themselves and their families instead of worrying about the bills. I seek leave to continue my remarks later.
Leave granted; debate adjourned.
No comments