This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Bills
Fair Work Amendment (Disqualified Officers) Bill 2026; Second Reading
Kerrynne Liddle SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Health and Aged Care
9:46 am
Well, what is this bill? The Fair Work Amendment (Disqualified Officers) Bill 2026 is a bill about fighting back against serious misconduct, a bill that Labor, if it is serious about tackling organised crime, should support. But we know they won't. This private senator's bill strengthens the power of the CFMEU administrator to deal with serious misconduct. The current law limits the administrator to expelling members or disqualifying officers for a maximum of five years, so they can just come back a little later. This bill would remove that arbitrary five-year limit and allow the administrator to impose a longer or indefinite period where circumstances warrant. It would also ensure that people who are disqualified under the scheme are treated as removed persons and cannot simply move into positions elsewhere in registered organisations. This bill would also allow the administrator to revisit existing decisions where a longer period would have been imposed if the five-year limit had not existed. It's hard to believe that we even have to be debating this in this parliament. It's sensible. It's common sense. There's a history that says we must do this. The government should support the coalition's sensible bill and commit to being serious on crime and corruption. Labor, though, will likely not bring itself to fix this.
Why should we do this now? The need for strong disciplinary powers has only become clearer since the CFMEU was placed into administration in August 2024. The administrator has now publicly identified the five-year limit as a constraint on the action he can take. When the administrator, Michael Crosby AM, was asked on ABC's 7.30 on 30 July why John Setka was only being suspended for five years, he said, 'because the rules limit me to a maximum period of five years; that's as much as I can do'. Well, let's enable him to do more. Let's enable him to do right. The evidence—the history—says it should be done. Parliament should force the administrator to not stop at five years regardless of how serious the conduct is. If the administrator considers that serious misconduct warrants a longer or indefinite exclusion, the law should give that option. This bill includes a transitional provision allowing the administrator to reconsider the length of significant disqualifications imposed before the new provisions commence. Again, it's sensible. This power is limited to existing disqualifications of more than four years, targeting cases where the administrator may have considered a longer period appropriate but was constrained by the existing five-year maximum while avoiding issues with shorter disqualifications that may have already expired. The administrator will have 12 months from commencement to exercise this power, ensuring that there is a reasonable opportunity to review relevant decisions without creating an ongoing and indefinite power to revisit past disciplinary action.
It is one thing for Minister Wong to come into this parliament and say Labor is serious about stamping out crime. In fact, we heard that again in this place this week. But they are not prepared to back their words with actions. These were the words of Minister Wong only on Tuesday this week:
As proud trade unionists, we also believe that the trade union movement and the labour movement should never be tainted by that kind of corruption and criminality.
So do everything you can to stamp it out if you're actually really serious in those statements that we keep hearing in this place.
What have the allegations been? Australians know there's a problem. The only people that don't seem to be listening, that don't seem to be seeing and that don't seem to be taking heed of the evidence are the Labor Party, not just at the state level but at the federal level. The Queensland Commission of Inquiry into the CFMEU and Misconduct in the Construction Industry has received confronting evidence about the CFMEU. This includes evidence that the union maintained a hit list of workplace inspectors that it sought to force out of the state regulator, Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, and evidence of bullying and intimidation so severe that one executive suffered a mental breakdown and attempted to take his own life. How is that caring about workers?
The commissioner highlighted serious allegations of violence and intimidation on Queensland worksites and the CFMEU's relationship with the former Labor government. He was particularly scathing of the Best Practice Industry Conditions policy, a highly favourable enterprise agreement for construction workers. Commissioner Wood estimated, conservatively, that the policy drove up major project costs by 20 per cent, costing more than $650 million. We've heard that before, only in Victoria.
We of course have heard so much from Nine's papers, who have extensively reported about the conduct of CFMEU members and officials on Big Build sites. Their reports include paid delegate and safety representative roles being handed to members of outlaw motorcycle gangs, instances of women being physically abused and intimidated while the CFMEU protected men on government sites, Big Build operations being turned into drug distribution hubs for outlaw motorcycle gangs, and subcontractors continuing to pay underworld figures for site access as recently as 2026. You'd think that would wake anyone up. It should keep every single one of us in here awake at night.
The Royal Commission into the Integrity of Major Public and Civil Infrastructure Construction Projects in Victoria also heard concerning allegations. In just its first week, it has heard evidence of the CFMEU shutting down construction sites, contractors being warned they could lose government work unless they cooperated with the union, union officials boasting of a direct line to Jacinta Allan's office and the CFMEU pushing to get criminal and bikie mates work on taxpayer funded sites—in health and safety positions, no less; the very positions that are meant to ensure the protection of workers. We hear that, again, from the other side, often in this place; well, let's see evidence of some action. Witnesses told the commission that the CFMEU would routinely shut down major building sites not for safety, not for workers' rights, but just to get their way.
Every day we learn how the CFMEU called the shots, Labor signed the cheques, and the Australian taxpayer footed the bill. You are kidding yourself if you think that these issues were only confined to Victoria and Queensland. There is a risk on every major project, and there should be a focus on managing risk on each and every project. This is taxpayers' money—ordinary Australians who go to work every day, hardworking Australians who give their money through taxes. The Labor Party should be taking much better care of it.
I draw your attention to who the Labor Party truly represents. The Labor Party is the unions. We hear that often. There is no separation. Unions are their masters. Union membership has been up since the Labor Party has been in government—from only about 11 per cent to, now, 13 per cent. Even so, it's pretty clear that they're not representing all the working people, just some of them. Labor would have you think that, after years of unbridled spending causing Australians to suffer through one of the highest inflation rates in the developed world, alongside the highest interest rates amongst comparable developed economies, Labor still represents working people. It should be no surprise that, in a time when Labor statistically represents a lower proportion of Australians than ever before, so many Australians are doing it tougher than ever before. This is why this bill is so important.
I want to turn now to South Australia. What South Australians are currently seeing unfolding around the Torrens to Darlington Project should concern every Australian, but it's a story we've seen before in Queensland and in Victoria. This is not just another infrastructure project; this is the largest infrastructure investment the South Australian government has undertaken in my state's history: $15.4 billion, with the Commonwealth contributing an estimated $7.2 billion, one of the largest jointly funded infrastructure projects in Australia. South Australians and Australians alike have contributed billions of dollars towards it, and they have the right to expect that every single contract, subcontractor and labour hire arrangement meets a robust standard of transparency, accountability and scrutiny. The Australian people deserve no less. They deserve confidence in how their taxpayer dollars are being spent. The concern for Australians is not simply just the criminal allegations that have been raised; it is whether the warning signs were identified early enough and whether due diligence processes were robust enough. They are reasonable questions when billions of dollars of taxpayers' money is at stake.
Private developers would be managing for risk, particularly when the evidence confronts them even before they put pen to paper, but, just like the Albanese Labor government, the Malinauskas Labor government cannot keep their stories straight. The common actors here are state Labor, Commonwealth Labor and the CFMEU—and big bill projects. We have heard who knew what, when they knew what and what action was taken. They're reasonable questions. However, as time has passed, South Australians are now left with more questions than answers. Liberal opposition leader Ashton Hurn has rightly argued that any responsible government and any responsible premier would immediately commission an independent audit into every single contract associated with the Torrens to Darlington Project. The history is there. The evidence is there. Why not do it? You only have to look across the border to Victoria—those allegations of organised crime figures, intimidation, criminal conduct and coercive influence operating within the construction industry. And we've seen the failure of Victorian Labor and of the administration to take decisive action at the earliest opportunity, which has allowed that to fester for years.
This is precisely why Senator Hume's Fair Work Amendment (Disqualified Officers) Bill is so important. It removes the arbitrary five-year limit that currently applies to the expulsion of members and the disqualified officers within the CFMEU administration scheme. Under existing arrangements, individuals who engage in serious misconduct cannot find their way back into positions of influence. The coalition believes Australians expect stronger consequences. There is enough evidence for this Labor government at the Commonwealth level to take stronger action. The evidence is they could have and should have done more. Five years is not near enough. It shouldn't be enough for taxpayers. It shouldn't be enough for any Australian, even if they have no association with the building site. They went to work; they did the hard work. They paid their taxes. Not only do they expect governments to be mindful of how every dollar is spent; when there is clear evidence that dollars are leaking where they shouldn't be, they expect that loophole to be closed. That's why we are in this place: to close those loopholes. That's why we come here. We shouldn't just come here—fly here on jets or drive here—and spend the week arguing these points. We should come in here determined to do better for the Australian people. I finish with this: there is enough evidence this Labor government should have and could have done more, and it can do more in supporting this bill. The union masters must not be in control of construction sites that benefit Australia and which are paid for by Australian taxpayers, just as unions should not be in control of the people's parliament. Government should support the coalition's sensible bill and commit to being serious on crime and corruption.
When I first came into this place in 2022, the Malinauskas government got money from the CFMEU, and you know what Mali did? He gave the money back immediately. He gave the money back—full merit to him. What we have in this place is a prime minister—he's not doing the same. He comes up with excuses—sounds familiar—and can't find a way to give the money back to the CFMEU. How does that work? You can do it in South Australia, but you can't do it federally. But they can all do better and must do better. The government should support the coalition's sensible bill and commit to being serious on crime and corruption. They would do it if they were serious about protecting public money and the interests of taxpayers and doing the right thing.
No comments