This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Statements by Senators

Gender Dysphoria


Leah Blyth

Leah Blyth SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Defence Infrastructure

1:36 pm

The NHMRC has recently provided a conditional recommendation that puberty blockers can be used on children and that distress need not be present before prescribing. The advice directly contradicts the landmark Cass review, the first large-scale government review of medical treatments for children with gender dysphoria, which found that evidence for using puberty blockers on children was surprisingly weak. Following the Cass review, Queensland and the Northern Territory took a more cautious approach, banning the use of puberty blockers in children under 18 years of age.

How did Australia's NHMRC advice, based on similar clinical evidence, come up with radically different recommendations to the Cass review? Last year, the NHMRC created a gender guidelines development committee to oversee the guideline and development process. There are 14 expert members of this committee, some of which have made no secret of their support for using puberty blockers on kids, despite there being little evidence to support it. Professor Simon Denny advocates that puberty blockers are safe, supports five-year-olds exploring their gender identity and has stated that puberty blockers 'provide time' for individuals to explore their gender identity—an argument not supported by the Cass review. Professor Kenneth Pang was a signatory to a letter criticising the Queensland government for banning puberty blockers for children, calling it 'dangerous and damaging'.

This independent review seems handpicked to conclude the exact opposite of what the Cass review has concluded, which risks children's long-term health and safety here in Australia. Given this stacked committee, is it any wonder that they graded the likelihood of undesirable and anticipated effects of puberty blockers, including on fertility, as 'trivial'? Ideology has no place in medicine and clinical practice. A sensible approach is to follow the evidence, not the ideology, and to keep our kids safe.

Comments

No comments