This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Statements by Senators
Workplace Relations: David Jones
Varun Ghosh WA, Australian Labor Party
12:15 pm
I rise today to speak for the workers of David Jones, particularly for the 1,689 people whose jobs are now on the line. As of today, just 170 redeployment opportunities have been offered. That is roughly one in 10. For the others, there is uncertainty about their wages, their mortgages, their families and their futures. All of this is happening weeks before Christmas. On 5 November, David Jones entered a voluntary administration for the first time in its 188-year history. This is a business that predates Federation. It has lived through depressions, wars, recessions and a pandemic. Generations of Australians have shopped there and have worked there, and now receivers have identified 19 of its 38 stores for closure. In Western Australia, that includes the Hay Street flagship in the heart of Perth, along with Garden City and Carousel. Across the business, more than 6,000 directly employed staff face an uncertain future, as do thousands of people working in concessions.
It is a mark of decent societies that we recognise that labour is not a commodity. Workers are not line items to be written down when a deal goes sour, but, when I look at what's happening at David Jones, I see a familiar pattern, a depressing pattern and an infuriating pattern. There may be no other stores like David Jones, but there is nothing unique about what is happening here. It happened to the workers at Dick Smith. It happened to the workers at Scott's Refrigerated Logistics. This is the third high-profile collapse of an Anchorage owned businesses.
In an administration, secured lenders have legal protections. Landlords and creditors have rights and processes that they are owed. Workers have statutory rights too, and, in this case, they have the strong representation of a union, but none of these protections can guarantee them a job. The Fair Entitlements Guarantee provides a measure of financial support, but it cannot give these workers a future. It cannot give them the security of a regular wage or reasonable expectations about future employment. It is wrong that the people with the least influence over these decisions, who have brought the business to this point, have the most to lose. It is wrong that people who have given so much to David Jones should now be among those made most vulnerable by its administration, but that is the inequality of bargaining power that sits at the heart of every employment relationship, and at no time is it starker than when a company goes insolvent or goes into administration. Secure lenders get a seat at the table. Landlords get a seat at the table. Unsecured creditors in the ATO have a seat at the table. If they have support—and these workers do have support; they're represented by a very good union in the Shop, Distributive & Allied Employees' Association, or the SDA—they have a seat at the table too, but they rank as unsecured creditors. At the recent creditors meeting, administrators revealed that $11 million is owed to employees, $180 million to suppliers and lenders, $33 million to DJs gift-card holders and over $200 million to secured lenders and creditors. The workers are unsecured. They're exposed, and that is wrong.
I want to talk a little bit more about those workers today. I want to talk about who these workers are, because they're people we see in shops all the time but rarely notice. They are hidden in plain sight. They're the people who helped you find a suit for your job interview and who wrapped presents for a child's birthday when they were a toddler and when they turned 18 and 21 and, now, when they are an adult. They're always there to help. They're loyal to the company—far more loyal than the company's various recent owners have been to them. They work hard. They've worked hard their whole lives, and they do it to support their families. We often never know their names. We take their service for granted. Now, through no fault of their own, they're being told that they no longer have a job.
The figures tell us who these workers are in our society. Approximately four in five David Jones retail workers are women—it's about 79 per cent—two in five are over the age of 45, half of them work part time, more than 43 per cent are casual, and 86 per cent of those paid in the lower-middle quartile are women.
Many of them have given decades. In Western Australia, at least 22 workers have been with David Jones for more than a decade, and five have been there for more than 20 years. In Perth, a loyal worker in her 70s has worked at David Jones for more than 31 years. Think about that. She started there in the mid-1990s. She served customers through the dotcom boom, the global financial crisis, the mining boom and its aftermath and all that's come since—31 years of turning up, of service and of loyalty. And what becomes of her entitlement? Where's her financial security for the rest of her life? She deserves better than to learn about her future from a news report, and she deserves better than the indignity of what is happening to her and other workers at David Jones.
We should be clear eyed about what this means for workers, too, because this country has learned this lesson the hard way. In the recession of the 1990s, unemployment rose by about five percentage points, and the Reserve Bank has found that it took around a decade for unemployment to return to its prerecession level. It hit hardest in the regions, and it hit hardest in terms of participation. Long-term unemployment peaked at around four per cent. But behind those numbers there were hundreds of thousands of Australians, many of them older workers, who lost their jobs and never worked again. They didn't choose to leave the workforce. But when a worker in their 50s or 60s loses the job that they've held for two or three decades, they don't simply walk into another one. Their skills are real but specific. Their experience is a deep asset, but it's often undervalued. Mature jobseekers spend more than twice as long on the unemployment lines as younger jobseekers. Once they lose their attachment to work, they find it very hard to get it back.
Older women will suffer most in this collapse. They are now the fastest growing group on the JobSeeker program. Women over 50 on JobSeeker now spend an average of 242 weeks on that program, more than 4½ years of relying on that support. That's up from 198 weeks in 2019. For every entry-level job advertised, there are around 39 people on the JobSeeker program competing for it, and women over 55 are among the fastest growing groups experiencing homelessness in this country.
None of this is an accident. It is structural unfairness. It is economic power at work. Women in retail have spent their working lives in lower paid and part-time work, often juggling the care of children and then of ageing parents. They have taken career breaks that are longer than those taken by men. They've taken career breaks that men, by and large, have not, and they retire with less superannuation. They're less likely to own their home and more likely to rent. So when restructuring comes to a company like this, they bear the brunt. These women did everything that was asked of them. They turned up, they worked hard and they looked after their families and their customers. And they're now paying the price. They shouldn't be the ones who pay for decisions made in boardrooms and in private equity offices.
There's a broader truth about insecure work here, too. Casual workers are not generally entitled to redundancy pay, and part-time workers' entitlements reflect their reduced hours. It makes them more vulnerable in a situation like this. That insecurity, which has defined so much of retail work, is particularly exposed when a business fails.
It's in moments like this that workers need someone in their corner, and the David Jones workers have the SDA. The SDA—its members, its delegates, its organisers, its industrial officers and its leadership—has been with these workers from the first hour of this ordeal. The SDA's national secretary, Gerard Dwyer, has been clear about the union's priorities: keep people in work as long as possible, keep as many people in work as possible and protect every legal and financial entitlement if jobs are lost. In Western Australia, the SDA state secretary, Ben Harris, has spoken about how distressing and stressful this has been for the SDA's members—people who are loyal to the brand, proud to work at David Jones and, in so many cases, long-serving employees.
This isn't the first time that the SDA has stood up for retail workers when a business has failed. Mosaic Brands is a good example. There's been the $28 million in compensation for KFC workers denied rest breaks, a proposed $55 million settlement from Aldi, the Super on Every Dollar campaign for young workers and the advocacy that helped lead this government to make wage theft a crime. But that's what a strong union does. It protects individual vulnerability through collective strength. Because this government listened to unions, like the SDA, payday super has been law since 1 July this year. That means David Jones workers will not lose up to three months of unpaid superannuation in this collapse, like so many workers and retail workers have done in the past. That's a change driven by the union movement, and it's a change made possible by a Labor government.
So what do we owe the workers of David Jones? We owe them honesty. We owe them information about their futures. We owe them their entitlements—every dollar of wages, leave, super and redundancy. We owe them a serious effort to keep as many stores open as possible, particularly in Western Australia. And we owe the workers who lose their jobs, particularly older women, real support in finding new work, not a lecture about upskilling. They have kept the faith. It is now time for everyone else to keep the faith with them, and I commend the SDA for standing with these workers.
No comments