This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Adjournment

Aukus


Raff Ciccone

Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party

7:39 pm

Acting Deputy President, it is good to see you in the chair. Earlier this month, the so-called independent public inquiry into AUKUS delivered its report. It proved the point that I had already made in this chamber a few months ago—that vague questions and concerns are not constructive and that, if you oppose a plan, you owe Australians an alternative. I was in Tokyo at the time, leading a delegation of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security, and, back home, a report landed calling on Australia to walk away from the most important defence commitment that we have made in a generation. Serious people can disagree on AUKUS, but a serious argument must meet its own standards, and this report simply does not.

Let's start with the word 'independent'. The inquiry was coordinated by the Australian Peace and Security Forum. Its secretariat was headed by one of the forum's founding members, a former chief of the Defence Force and a former member of this chamber, a former senator. Both had campaigned against AUKUS long before the inquiry began. Four of the five commissioners had publicly criticised AUKUS, and the fifth co-leads the Australia Institute, which clearly has been campaigning against it for some time. This clearly is not an independent inquiry. Let's also consider the evidence that was heard before the inquiry. Three weeks before the first hearing, a group of Australians gathered at the Chinese consulate in Melbourne to praise the study tours that they undertook recently in China. According to the Chinese state media that reported, they gave the trips 10 out of 10. Wow! The tours were organised by an adviser to a Chinese provincial government. Three members of that group then gave evidence to this so-called independent inquiry arguing against AUKUS, with one suggesting that AUKUS was a product of foreign interference. Can you believe it?

Australians rightly have a question front and centre of their minds: who paid for these tours? Australians deserve to know. None of this is a defence of our sovereignty. In fact, it is an insult to it. Meanwhile, the inquiry heard from a former Labor defence minister who went on to serve as an ambassador to Washington and in fact a leader of the Labor Party. We also had a former department secretary and two former Liberal defence ministers appear. Between them, they carried decades of experience at the highest level of government from both sides of politics. In the 113 pages of that report, each is quoted just once. The report claims that our Navy could be forced to act on Washington's orders. It never explains how an Australian submarine with an Australian crew and an Australian commander would stop answering to Australia. It also claims to be worried about nuclear risk, yet it would abolish the very regulator that would be responsible for nuclear safety in this country. Let me be clear once again: a nuclear-powered submarine is not a nuclear-armed submarine. The report demands a plan B and then says choosing one is beyond its scope. What a cop-out! It ignores the 68 per cent of Australians who, according to the Lowy Institute, support acquiring these very submarines.

But what troubles me the most is what the report leaves out. The word 'deterrence' does not appear anywhere in the findings. Deterrence is the whole bloody point. These submarines exist to ensure that no-one is ever tempted to test us or our partners or our allies or friends. We are an island trading nation. Our fuel, our exports and our way of life all travel by sea, and, beneath the sea, around 99 per cent of our internet traffic runs through just 15 cables. So, if we walk away, who's going to protect these cables? As I said in June, nuclear-powered submarines are the boltcutters that ensure that Australia is never wrapped in chains. Nothing in this report changes that. AUKUS followed years of submarine programs that were started, changed and abandoned. If we walk away now without a plan, we leave a massive gap in our defences in the 2030s. We also send a message to every partner that Australia's word comes with a use-by date. So let us continue scrutinising this program on costs, workforce and delivery. That is our job, and we must keep doing it. But Australians deserve a debate that is honest about the threats that we face. This report preaches transparency but does not practice it, demands answers but refuses to provide them and claims independence it cannot show. AUKUS remains the right plan for the security of our country.

Comments

No comments