This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Bills

Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading


Michaelia Cash

Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate

10:02 am

I rise on behalf of the coalition to contribute to the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026. The coalition will support the passage of this legislation, but that, of course, is following the amendments that were made to it in the House of Representatives.

Australia faces increasingly sophisticated threats from money laundering, organised crime, scams and terrorism financing. These threats, as we know, are evolving, but, more so, they are growing rapidly. Criminal organisations are becoming more technologically sophisticated, more internationally connected and more proficient at exploiting weaknesses in our financial systems. Our legislative and regulatory frameworks must therefore be capable and ever more capable of responding as effectively as possible to these mounting threats. Where there are gaps in those legislative and regulatory frameworks, the parliament therefore has a duty to act. In principle, that is why the coalition now supports the fundamental objectives of this bill.

However, supporting the objectives of legislation, such as this, did not mean that we were going to accept every element of the design of the original form of this particular piece of legislation, nor did it mean giving the government a blank cheque to expand regulatory powers without ensuring that those powers were appropriately targeted, proportionate and subject to proper safeguards. These were the most basic of the tenets that guided the coalition's approach when we were assessing this legislation, and they were also the reasons that we insisted that the bill before us should be subject to detailed examination before it came to the Senate.

One of the most significant challenges that the content of this bill seeks to address is the increasing exploitation of emerging financial technologies by criminal organisations. A particularly striking example of that trend has been the extraordinary proliferation of cryptocurrency ATMs across Australia. In 2019, there were just 23 cryptocurrency ATMs operating in Australia. Today, that number has grown to more than 2,000. Obviously, that is an extraordinary increase, especially over such a short timeframe. While cryptocurrency and other emerging financial technologies also have perfectly legitimate uses, there is growing evidence that certain facets of them are being exploited by criminals on a worryingly wide scale. AUSTRAC has identified that approximately 85 per cent of frequent cryptocurrency ATM transactions are actually associated with scams or money-mule activity. That is a finding that should represent a concern to all of us, not least because these transactions typically take the form of sophisticated criminal operations preying on innocent, unsuspecting, ordinary Australians. It is no exaggeration to say that they have many times ended in people actually losing their life savings or, at the very least, substantial sums of money.

These kinds of financial infrastructure can also make it easier for nefarious individuals to launder the proceeds of other serious offences. We know, for example, that Australian banks recently closed around 22,000 money-mule accounts in a single 12-month period. That figure alone provides an indication of the scale of the challenge facing our financial institutions and law enforcement agencies in this space. Indeed, the criminal exploitation of these new financial channels is not some marginal or theoretical issue. Instead, it is a significant and growing problem that demands an active and effective response. Accordingly, the coalition recognises the importance of providing AUSTRAC with appropriate powers to respond quickly to high-risk financial mechanisms. We will also support measures that genuinely and sensibly strengthen Australia's counterterrorism financing laws.

However, in our consideration of this bill, the question before us has not just been whether those additional kinds of powers are desirable. It has also been about how those powers are conceived and then implemented. In that context, our most fundamental concern in examining the original content of this bill was related to the new and sweeping set of powers that was going to be vested in the chief executive officer of AUSTRAC. Those powers had substantial potential impacts on businesses, financial services and other participants in the Australian economy. We were particularly uneasy about the delegation of those powers away from the minister, especially as concepts such as 'significant harm' and 'the public interest' were not defined, in our view, with sufficient clarity and precision. In short, there were accordingly a number of serious questions for us about how the powers would actually operate in practice. That included questions about the extent to which AUSTRAC would or would not need to consult with affected parties, especially as there were provisions enabling consultation to be bypassed in certain circumstances. There were also other provisions that meant that failures by AUSTRAC to comply with consultation requirements might not necessarily invalidate those decisions.

The coalition, of course, does not oppose the existence of strong powers to combat serious financial crime. We recognise that regulators and law enforcement agencies must have a range of tools at their disposal in order to respond to sophisticated and rapidly evolving criminal threats. But the fundamental point here is that these tools must be accompanied by commonsense application. Strong powers and strong safeguards are not competing objectives. They should actually be complementary features of effective legislation. In fact, it will almost always be the case that powers that are carefully defined and subject to appropriate oversight will better command public confidence and will operate more effectively over the longer term than powers that are devised in a more ad hoc form.

That is why the coalition considers it essential that the original legislation be examined through a parliamentary committee inquiry. The Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security provided an important forum for testing the government's proposals as well as examining their practical consequences. It also gave industry representatives, consumer groups and other stakeholders an opportunity to express their concerns directly to the parliament. That scrutiny was not an unnecessary impediment to reform. It was an essential part of getting the reform right.

To add to that, our concerns about the original bill needed to be understood against the broader background of the Albanese government's approach to anti-money-laundering legislation and regulation. That's because, sadly, the Albanese government has an atrocious record when it comes to introducing major regulatory changes. When it comes to this bill, the anti-money-laundering changes legislated in 2024—including the substantial expansion of the regime commonly referred to as tranche 2—provide a particularly important and relevant example. As the coalition warned repeatedly, even from the time those changes were in their infancy, they have subsequently come to impose new major obligations on thousands of Australian businesses—and, sadly, poorly designed and poorly implemented new obligations at that.

In particular, legal practices, accounting firms conveyancers and real estate businesses have all now faced the prospect of implementing incredibly complex compliance arrangements, often with little previous experience of operating under the anti-money-laundering framework. Overwhelmingly, the most affected entities have not been large corporations with extensive regulatory and compliance departments; they have been small and medium enterprises. They also typically operate in regional communities. And, like other enterprises right across the country, they already face a raft of stifling regulatory and administrative pressures. Yet they are now being expected to implement new risk assessment, anti-money-laundering programs, compliance arrangements, staff training, customer due diligence processes, suspicious-matter reporting systems and—wait for it; there's still more—additional record keeping obligations.

What wasn't recognised by the government, despite the fact that this was raised by businesses and by the coalition at the time, was that these new responsibilities have involved additional cost, additional administrative burdens and far-reaching legal complexity—not to mention, when you talk to these businesses that are now struggling under the burden of the additional regulatory compliance, considerable anxiety and annoyance. Indeed, the government's own impact analysis estimated the additional regulatory burden associated with its broader anti-money-laundering reforms at a staggering $13.9 billion over 10 years. Naturally nobody, other than the criminals themselves, would seriously dispute the need to prevent people from exploiting legitimate businesses and professional services. However, there is a Grand-Canyon-like gulf, or difference, between imposing necessary, proportionate safeguards and creating an excessively burdensome compliance regime that captures law-abiding businesses without sufficient regard for the practical consequences that these businesses are now feeling.

Those concerns are not confined to the financial cost. One of the most troubling aspects of the government's earlier reforms was the extent to which businesses were expected to prepare for substantial new obligations before much of the practical detail had been settled by the government. Since the passage of the 2024 changes, AUSTRAC has repeatedly amended and then had to clarify its guidance. As recently as August and September this year, further guidance was still being issued or updated on matters including real estate, professional services, customer due diligence and reporting timeframes. That is absolutely unacceptable. Businesses should not have been expected to make major investments in compliance systems while essential elements of the rules that they are required to follow were still being clarified, if not written, nor should they have been expected to absorb unnecessary costs because the government had failed to adequately sequence the implementation of what is a substantial regulatory change.

There is a fundamental principle here. It is a responsibility of government to make the rules clear, workable and proportionate before expecting people to comply. The coalition's concerns about this bill were therefore, sadly, informed in part by those earlier experiences. We do not want to see another round of significant regulatory changes in relation to anti money laundering introduced without adequate consideration of their practical consequences. Within that general setting, the scrutiny undertaken by the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security was particularly valuable. The committee process reinforced the coalition's view that the original bill required amendments to at least two important aspects. The first concerned the proposed new powers of the AUSTRAC chief executive officer. The second major issue concerned the timing of the commencement of certain measures. The coalition therefore advocated amendments to address both sets of matters. I am pleased to say that the government listened to the coalition and addressed the legislation. That is why we are now in a position to support the legislation.

We need to get the balance right. The bill is rightly directed towards protecting Australians from scams, disrupting organised crime and strengthening our national security. However, its original composition, sadly, like so much that this government sloppily puts on the table, could have been better. The coalition is therefore pleased to have aired out what were our very legitimate concerns, insisted on appropriate scrutiny and advocated for changes to positively address those concerns. Ultimately, the measure of legislation like this is not simply the number of additional powers it creates. It is whether those powers actually help stop criminals, protect Australians and strengthen our national security, all without imposing unnecessary burdens on those who are doing the right thing. It is on that basis—that the government did accept the coalition's amendments to the legislation—that we are now in a position to support the bill. (Time expired)

Comments

No comments