This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Bills

Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading


David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

7:00 pm

I want to thank Senator McKim for setting out what's at stake here in this legislation and why the Greens will be opposing it. This slippery slide that the Labor and the coalition seem keen on taking us into, no doubt with the help of their mates in One Nation now, is a kind of dystopian world where you can literally disappear into the security state, without anyone knowing, without legal protections and without clear or any judicial constraint. It's just extraordinary that we see this.

When it comes to the Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Bill, the Greens will be opposing this bill. But I want to point out: in the roadkill that features in most of this legislation, there are a couple of little bits of bouncy positivity. There are some aspects of the bill that are positive, and I'll go to those first. There are proposed stronger protections for UN and humanitarian workers, and that's good. But, of course, those don't really mean much when it's inconvenient to the government to provide those protections. So it's words on paper, but it doesn't seem to be backed in by any clear international commitment to protect UN and humanitarian workers.

A case in point would be the obscene number of humanitarian and UN workers that have been killed by the Israel Defense Forces in Gaza. Despite that, the Labor government is quite content with continuing to buy from Israel weapons being tested by the Israel Defense Forces on UN and humanitarian workers in Gaza. They seem quite comfortable with continuing to supply parts to the Israel Defense Forces so that they can bomb and kill UN and humanitarian workers. We see the words on paper here, but we see the actions of Labor, and we know what's stronger and more powerful in the world as it is. And it's their actions, not their words, as always.

And, of course, this government has said next to nothing about the United States sanctioning the UN Special Rapporteur on the Occupied Palestinian Territories, Francesca Albanese. She's who most people who believe in human rights describe as 'the good Albanese'—the one who actually stands up for rights and the one who actually cares about the rights of the people of Palestine not to be subject to the horrors of the Israel Defense Force, who does her job as the UN has asked her to do. Of course, where has been the government when it comes to this? It's complete silence on backing in the UN Special Rapporteur. And she's been sanctioned by the US simply for doing her job. You could say the same about the appalling sanctions the US has put against members of the International Criminal Court. Direct attacks from the US are trying to undermine some of these protections, and it's complete silence or, worse, complicity from the Labor government.

So we see the words in writing here, but we also—and I think most Australians—judge this government by their actions, not their words, because they are so, so far apart. Of course, when it comes to protecting aid workers, there's Australian aid worker, Zomi Frankcom, who was killed in Gaza in 2024 while delivering food with the World Central Kitchen. Zomi and her family deserve justice. Again, it needs more than just empty words from this government. Sending in a totally compromised individual to do a compromised investigation, where the Israeli authorities would not give access to critical evidence, and then pretending that that action by the government was in any way some kind of meaningful response to Zomi's murder was, again, more of the complicity and the pathetic inability of this government to actually take actions to match their words. This government should be speaking up when humanitarian workers are targeted, and then matching those words with action. This government continues to fail at that, on pretty much every test, every time they're tested. So it's good to see the legislation; it's good to see it in this bill. But, again, we feel this is another one of those moments: let's not watch what Labor says; let's watch what they do. And, each time, they disappoint.

We know why this happens, in relation to that particular conflict—the genocide in Gaza. It's because the toxic hostage relationship that the Albanese Labor government, the coalition and One Nation have decided we should have with the United States means that you don't feel permitted to stand on principle. You don't feel permitted to actually make your actions match your words. Increasingly, the Australian public sees this betrayal of our core national interests—your refusal to actually stand up and seek an independent path from the one you're permitted to run by the Trump administration or whoever is in Washington. We see it, and the Australian public sees it.

When it comes to the balance of this bill, what does it do? Every three years this government comes back and asks parliament to rubberstamp powers that were sold to Australians in 2005 as extraordinary—totally out of character with our common law and traditional rights and liberties—and temporary. We were told in 2005: 'Don't you worry. There's a sunset on them. They'll set after three years.' Then, of course, every three years, Labor and the coalition come together—no doubt, this time, with the support of One Nation—to say, 'The sun will never set.'

Not only do they say that the sun will never set; they make the powers more extreme. They take away more rights. They subject children, in this case, to even more draconian extrajudicial punishment. They continue to expand the concept of future crime—of punishing you for crimes you haven't committed but the government thinks you might. Therefore, without going to a judge, they're just going to whack you in detention, whether you're an adult or a child. And that's what they're doing again today.

This bill puts children on adult-length control orders. It lets police bug people in prison to decide whether to chase an order against them. It strips people of the right to ask for an organisation to be delisted. It also keeps alive secret detention powers that nobody appears to have ever used but which are sitting there on the statute books for a government—a nasty, pernicious government—to use, whenever they choose, to literally pull people off the street, whenever they choose. This is fascist-ready law.

Of course the Greens oppose it. If the government insists on pushing through with this legislation, we will be moving amendments to protect children, at the least; to get some kind of guarantee for a fair hearing; to let these preventive detention powers—which are so contrary to our concepts of the rule of law and of being judged by your actions—finally lapse; and to make sure in those amendments, too, that our terrorism laws stop putting humanitarian workers at risk, when they're going about their business, in some of the hardest conditions on the planet, just trying to keep people alive.

So what are the effects of this bill? The first is that it extends control orders; preventive detention orders; post-sentence orders; terrorism stop, search and seize powers—these fascist laws that are contrary to our concepts of basic liberty—for another three years to 7 December 2029. This will be the sixth time that these so-called temporary, extraordinary laws have been rolled over and extended by this parliament. The Greens say: the sun should set on these laws. They are contrary to the concept of a free and democratic society, they are contrary to the concept of us being governed by the rule of law and not the rule of the executive, and they are contrary to basic concepts of freedom that should be underpinning us as a democratic society.

It also rewrites the post-sentence order scheme, so control orders will become the main tool for managing people after they finish their sentence—expanding the role of control orders. It lifts the maximum control order for a child aged 14 to 17 from three months to 12 months, the same as an adult, ignoring the difference in development and ignoring the constraint that was meant to be put in there because we were meant to be treating children different to adults and not throwing draconian control orders on them for 12 months at a time. If you think they need extending, they should have constant judicial review before you do that to children. You want to get rid of those restraints and let the executive have control orders over children for up to 12 months without judicial review. We oppose that. Anyone who believes in basic liberties should oppose that.

This bill lets agencies get surveillance and interception warrants against people in custody to help decide whether they can get a control order against them. They don't have to have any evidence. They can start working up their case. There's not even a requirement for reasonable suspicion. These are going to be issued by ART members rather than judges. This links to other legislation this government is doing undermining the independence of the ART. You want a compliant ART that can issue these kinds of orders for you without having to trouble a judge. Get one of your favourite senior members who the Attorney has bumped up and given a 150K pay rise to to give you one of these orders!

It removes the right of an individual or an organisation to apply to have an organisation delisted, making delisting declarations non-disallowable as well, taking away parliamentary oversight of this and, again, giving more power to the executive to list an organisation and then to prevent the parliament from having any oversight of it. This is what fascist governments do. They pile up powers in the executive, they take away powers from the judiciary, they take away basic rights, they take away parliamentary oversight and they give the power to control and list organisations to the executive. It lets findings of guilt with no conviction recorded be used to control order and post-sentence proceedings. That is totally contrary to our concept of rule of law or being judged on your actions by an independent judiciary and not on some political test put forward by the Attorney-General. That's what this legislation does.

When a weaker version of these powers was first introduced in 2005, there was enormous controversy because they are so contrary to our basic concepts of rule of law. The sunset clauses were put in there, and, again, as I said, if this goes through, it'll be the sixth time.

The government has ignored the parliament's own independent monitor in this. The INSLM, the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor—highly credentialed, highly regarded—reported on the post-sentence order scheme in March 2023. It gave the government the report in March 2023, and what did the government do? They buried it. They sat on it for three years. Having sat on it for three years, you then only tabled it as part of the response to this legislation on 12 August this year, the same day you introduced the bill. This bill ignores all of the recommendations from the INSLM. The review by the INSLM compared parts of this scheme to Alice in Wonderland or a Philip Dick fiction novel. It recommended abolishing continuing detention orders altogether and writing rehabilitation and reintegration into the objects of the law. This government buries the report for three years then brings legislation in at the same time as they give public release of the INSLM's report, and they ignore everything they said. The INSLM was right about how deeply dystopian this scheme is.

Future crime not judged by a judge, being judged not on your actions but on the political views of the government of the day about what you might do in the future, potentially going to jail, being under control, being held in your house, being limited in what you could do because the government thinks you might have some kind of future crime—the INSLM called it out for what it was: Alice in Wonderland stuff. You bury the report for three years and you fail to implement any of it. This is another one of these stitch-ups between Labor and the coalition. You mention national security, and we're all meant to just roll over and say whatever you want—'Whichever rights you can take away, take them; whichever liberties you want to take away, you can take them'—because you mention the word 'terrorism' and the parliament just gets cowed. Well, enough of that. Some of these rights are fundamental to us. Some of these rights are fundamental to any free society. The Greens oppose this Alice in Wonderland dystopian legislation you're bringing through, like we do each time you bring it—surveillance creep stitch-up, taking away the rights.

In the short time that's available to me, I'm going to move the second reading amendment that's been circulated:

At the end of the motion, add "but the Senate:

(a) notes that:

(i) Australian humanitarian organisations operate in some of the world's most challenging environments, including contexts where de facto authorities or armed groups may be listed under Australian counter-terrorism or sanctions regimes, and, that in these settings, humanitarian organisations must negotiate access, move funds, procure goods and services, and work with local partners to deliver food, healthcare, shelter, protection and other forms of assistance,

(ii) Australia has obligations under international humanitarian law to facilitate impartial humanitarian relief for civilian populations affected by armed conflict, and that humanitarian exemptions support compliance with those obligations,

(iii) humanitarian assistance is provided on the basis of humanity, neutrality, impartiality and independence and is not intended to support the objectives of any party to a conflict,

(iv) current Australian laws create uncertainty and potential exposure to criminal or civil liability for Australian humanitarian organisations, their board members and other office-bearers, and Government decision-makers approving humanitarian funding, and that leads financial institutions and donors to de-risk,

(v) Australian humanitarian organisations have long advocated for a standing humanitarian exemption, the absence of which from Australia's counter-terrorism financing and sanctions frameworks remains an urgent gap in Australian law,

(vi) Australians have consistently shown remarkable generosity in responding to humanitarian crises through their support of Australian humanitarian organisations and expect their donations can be used to deliver life-saving assistance to vulnerable people wherever needs arise,

(vii) under the current Criminal Code Act 1995 ('Criminal Code'), humanitarian organisations may be required to choose between delivering life-saving assistance in some of the world's most complex crises and exposing themselves to potential criminal liability; as a result, civilians affected by conflict, disaster and displacement may experience delayed, reduced or foregone access to essential assistance, including children, older people and people with disabilities,

(viii) legal uncertainty contributes to risk-averse practices by financial institutions, donors and other funders, increasing barriers to the transfer of funds and the delivery of humanitarian assistance,

(ix) a humanitarian exemption would bring Australia into line with the United States of America, United Kingdom, European Union, and Canada, which have all adopted humanitarian exemptions, and would implement United Nations Security Council (UNSC) Resolution 2664, which Australia is required to implement, but has not yet legislated,

(x) inconsistent exemption standards across Australia's counter-terrorism and sanctions regimes create confusion and compliance uncertainty,

(xi) the Declaration for the Protection of Humanitarian Personnel, as led by the Minister for Foreign Affairs, commits endorsing States to work with States to ensure that humanitarian activities carried out by humanitarian organisations are not criminalised where those activities are consistent with international law, and that measures are taken to prevent harassment, arbitrary arrest and detention and reprisals against humanitarian personnel for carrying out their mission,

(xii) recommendation 5 of the Joint Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade report, Australia's Thematic Sanctions Framework: A Legislated Review of the Operation of the Autonomous Sanctions Amendment (Magnitsky-style and Other Thematic Sanctions) Act 2021 (March 2025), called for a standing exemption from all sanctions measures for legitimate humanitarian assistance, consistent with the approach taken in UNSC Resolution 2664, and found that sanctions permits are not an effective or efficient substitute for such an exemption,

(xiii) the reform sought by the humanitarian sector is a clearly defined exemption for qualifying humanitarian actors and activities that enables humanitarian assistance while leaving the underlying prohibitions on terrorism financing and material support in place for all other conduct,

(xiv) Australian non-government organisations (NGOs) with Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) accreditation undergo a rigorous assessment of governance, financial management, risk management and program quality, and are subject to ongoing oversight,

(xv) these existing mechanisms provide Parliament and the Australian public with confidence that Australian humanitarian organisations are professional, accountable and well placed to manage risk in complex operating environments,

(xvi) these safeguards demonstrate that a humanitarian exemption can be implemented in a way that facilitates life-saving assistance while maintaining strong protections against terrorism financing and other forms of wrongdoing, as comparable exemptions overseas already do, for example, by requiring reasonable efforts to minimise any benefit to terrorist groups,

(xvii) the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security, in relation to this Bill, recommended that the Australian Government conduct engagement with relevant humanitarian organisations to consider further reform for a broader humanitarian exemption across the Criminal Code and other relevant federal legislation and that any humanitarian exemption reform to the Criminal Code should be informed by the national intelligence community to ensure that changes protect genuine humanitarian personnel whilst avoiding providing legal protection to terrorists or other criminals; and

(b) calls on the Government to introduce legislation for a humanitarian exemption in the Criminal Code, including an offence specific carve-out or defence to sections 102.6, 102.7 and 103.1 and 103.2, with the same subject-based and activity-based test applied consistently across sections 102.6 to 102.8, to reduce barriers to effective, principled humanitarian assistance in line with proposed sanctions reform by 1 October 2027, that:

(i) is both subject-based and activity-based, and applies to humanitarian activities carried out by eligible humanitarian actors in accordance with international humanitarian principles and at a minimum in line with UNSC Resolution 2664, including DFAT-accredited Australian NGOs,

(ii) extends to the financial institutions, donors and local partners that fund and enable humanitarian assistance, and to the provision, processing or payment of funds and the provision of goods and services necessary for the timely delivery of humanitarian assistance, including necessary and incidental costs such as administrative fees and taxes,

(iii) is coordinated across both counter-terrorism and sanctions measures to ensure clarity and reduce uncertainty for Australian humanitarian organisations, and

(iv) is accompanied by clear Government guidance, communicated to the banking sector and AUSTRAC, to address financial de-risking".

I really want to thank the humanitarian and aid sector for bringing this through, because this second reading amendment calls upon the parliament to amend these laws so that aid workers, when they're going into some of the most dangerous parts of the world, where there's conflict, where some of the control is done by listed organisations, are allowed to continue to do their work without being subject to criminal offences. It's essential if we're going to live up to the promise, and I commend that second reading amendment to the chair.

Comments

No comments