This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Bills

Fair Work and Other Legislation Amendment (Value for Taxpayers' Money) Bill 2026; Second Reading


Jane Hume

Jane Hume Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Employment and Industrial Relations

3:51 pm

I move:

That this bill be now read a second time.

I seek leave to table an explanatory memorandum relating to the bill.

Leave granted.

I table an explanatory memorandum and seek leave to have my second reading speech incorporated in Hansard.

Leave granted.

The speech read as follows—

Thank you, President.

I rise to introduce the Fair Work and Other Legislation Amendment (Value for Taxpayers' Money) Bill 2026.

There is a pretty simple principle behind this Bill.

When the Commonwealth spends taxpayers' money, contracts should be awarded on merit.

Can you do the job? Are you following Australian law? And are taxpayers getting value for money?

Those should be the tests.

Whether a business has a particular industrial arrangement should not determine whether it can compete for government work.

But earlier this year, Labor changed the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Fair Work Act)to create an exemption that allows exactly that to happen.

The Coalition opposed those changes.

When the Workplace Relations Legislation Amendment (Building Cooperative Workplaces No. 1) Bill 2026 came before the Parliament, we moved amendments in both Houses to remove Part 9.

Those amendments were defeated and the Senate will be shocked to hear that the Greens did not support the Coalition.

Labor's amendments have effectively created an exemption from the Fair Work Act's general protections for certain Commonwealth procurement, grants and related activities.

In practical terms, the Government removed a legal barrier that prevented businesses from being treated differently because their employees were, or were not, covered by an enterprise agreement.

That sounds strange, doesn't it?

The exemption was not inserted into the Fair Work Actas an academic exercise. The Government changed the law so enterprise agreement coverage could be taken into account in Commonwealth procurement.

Industry is right to be concerned about where this leads.

The Commonwealth is one of the biggest purchasers of goods and services in the country. Its procurement rules matter.

For many Australian businesses, government is either a customer or a potential customer. The conditions attached to government work affect who can compete and, ultimately, who gets the work.

That gives government enormous power to shape behaviour in the private sector.

And it is why we should be very cautious about using procurement policy to pursue an industrial agenda.

If two businesses comply with Australian law, treat their employees properly and are capable of doing the same work, why should one receive an advantage because of the particular industrial instrument covering its workforce?

Why should a business that complies with every workplace law passed by this Parliament be put at a disadvantage when competing for a taxpayer-funded contract?

Government should not use procurement policy to impose industrial arrangements that the law itself does not require.

Enterprise agreements are a perfectly lawful and legitimate part of our workplace relations system.

So are other workplace arrangements.

This is not an argument against enterprise agreements.

It is an argument against government using taxpayers' money to preference them.

If the Parliament wants to impose a new industrial obligation on Australian businesses, then bring it into this chamber, debate it and legislate for it.

Don't use access to Commonwealth contracts to achieve the same thing through the back door.

That is why the first part of this Bill repeals the exemptions Labor inserted into the Fair Work Act.

It restores the previous operation of the general protections and prevents the Commonwealth relying on these new exemptions to preference suppliers because of enterprise agreement coverage.

Businesses should compete for government work on their merits.

Their price should matter.

Their capability should matter.

Their record should matter.

Whether they can actually deliver the project should matter.

And, of course, whether they comply with Australian law should matter.

Whether they have adopted the Government's preferred industrial arrangements should not.

We have already seen the risks of allowing industrial arrangements to become entangled with access to government-funded work.

This is particularly obvious in construction.

Australia has a housing shortage and major infrastructure needs.

We need more businesses competing for work, not fewer.

We need more investment and more capacity in the industry. We certainly need better productivity.

The answer cannot be to narrow the field of businesses that can realistically compete.

There is another reason we should be particularly cautious about this.

As Geoffrey Watson found in his report, Rotting from the Top, the use of enterprise agreements in procurement allowed the CFMEU to increase its power and control over the market and facilitated corrupt schemes.

That experience should have caused governments to think very carefully before going further down this road.

Instead, Labor has created the legal architecture for enterprise agreement preferencing at a Commonwealth level.

And these changes are not confined to construction.

They potentially reach across Commonwealth procurement and across industries.

We should be making procurement more competitive and more focused on outcomes for taxpayers, not less.

That is why my Bill goes beyond simply repealing Labor's changes.

It also amends the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (the PGPA Act).

The PGPA Act is the central legislative framework governing the use and management of Commonwealth resources.

Under section 105B, the Finance Minister makes the Commonwealth Procurement Rules.

Those rules already recognise value for money as the core rule of Commonwealth procurement.

We want to put that principle beyond doubt.

This Bill inserts an overarching objective into the PGPA Act that Commonwealth procurement is to provide value for taxpayers' funds, efficacy and compliance with all Australian laws.

It also requires the Finance Minister, before making procurement rules under section 105B, to be satisfied that those rules are consistent with that objective.

Existing procurement instruments will have three months to be remade consistently with the new framework.

These are not radical requirements.

In fact, most Australians would probably assume this is how government procurement already works.

Value for money.

Can the supplier actually deliver what it says it can deliver?

Is it following Australian law?

That is what taxpayers should expect when government spends their money.

Governments will, of course, continue to make procurement policies.

There will be detailed rules and those rules will change over time.

But there should be some principles that sit above the policy of the government of the day.

A government should not be able to subordinate value for money and effective delivery to an industrial agenda.

And a business that complies with Australian law should not be punished because the government would prefer it to adopt a different lawful industrial arrangement.

I want to be clear about what this Bill does not do.

It does not say workplace standards are irrelevant to Commonwealth procurement.

Compliance with Australian law is expressly included in the objective we are putting into the PGPA Act.

Businesses seeking taxpayer-funded work should comply with their obligations.

They should pay their employees correctly.

They should provide safe workplaces.

They should comply with taxation law, competition law and workplace law.

Of course they should.

But if a business is doing all of that, government should not then apply another test based on whether it has organised its workforce in a way that suits the industrial preferences of the Labor Party.

That isn't enforcing workplace law.

It is favouritism.

Think about what that means for a small or medium-sized Australian business.

It might be more productive than its competitor.

It might be able to offer taxpayers a better price.

It might have an excellent relationship with its employees.

It might be able to deliver the work faster or to a higher standard.

But it does not have an enterprise agreement.

Why should that business be treated less favourably?

And why should the taxpayer potentially pay more as a result?

There is no public benefit in reducing competition for government work.

Competition puts pressure on suppliers to offer a better product at a better price. It gives new businesses the opportunity to challenge established players. It encourages businesses to innovate and improve.

When government starts putting its thumb on the scale for reasons that have nothing to do with whether a supplier can do the job, taxpayers lose.

And this matters even more in the economic circumstances Australia faces today.

We need productivity growth.

We need businesses prepared to invest and employ.

We need competition.

Government should be removing unnecessary barriers to doing business, not finding new ways to put them in place.

The Coalition supports fair workplaces.

Employees should be paid correctly and treated properly.

Businesses should obey the law.

Unions have a legitimate role in our workplace relations system.

And enterprise bargaining has an important role where employers and employees choose to bargain.

None of that means the Commonwealth should preference one law-abiding Australian business over another because of its industrial arrangements.

The Government is not spending Labor Party money.

It is not spending union money.

It is spending taxpayers' money.

And when you are spending somebody else's money, there is a responsibility to get the best possible result for them.

That is the principle at the heart of this Bill.

If you can do the job, if you comply with Australian law and if you can deliver value for taxpayers, you should have a fair opportunity to compete for Commonwealth work.

No Australian business doing the right thing should be told that following the law is not enough.

And the Commonwealth should not need an exemption from the Fair Work Act's general protections to pursue its procurement policies.

This Bill removes that exemption.

It restores the previous operation of the Fair Work Act and it puts a clear objective for Commonwealth procurement into the PGPA Act.

Value for taxpayers' funds.

Effective delivery.

Compliance with Australian law.

Government procurement should serve the public interest, not sectional interests.

Taxpayers deserve value for money and Australian businesses deserve the opportunity to compete on their merits.

It really should be that simple.

The objective of this Bill should attract support from all sides of this chamber.

I commend the Bill to the Senate.

I seek leave to continue my remarks later.

Leave granted; debate adjourned.

Comments

No comments