This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Bills
Online Safety Amendment (Strengthening Enforcement for the Social Media Minimum Age) Bill 2026; In Committee
Sarah Henderson Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Communications and Digital Safety
7:03 pm
Minister, I do want to object very strongly to the way you've just mischaracterised my concerns. I've been a very outspoken critic of big tech and the way the algorithm, particularly the content-recommendation algorithm on some platforms, is driving harm. I just think it's very important that you don't seek to conflate two different issues that are in the digital duty of care bill.
In relation to the content-recommendation algorithm, we have made it very clear that this needs proper consideration and that we have simply warned that rushing a proposal to mandate non-profiled social media feeds, particularly given the potential consequences for Australian small businesses and other online retailers and ecommerce operators, needs proper consideration. I hope and trust that that will occur during the Senate inquiry into the digital duty of care bill. There is a legitimate debate about whether Australians should be able to switch algorithmic profiling on and off. So please don't conflate our concerns.
The concerns I have raised in relation to free speech relate to the minister's ability to make regulations defining categories of harm and categories of serious harm by regulation without parliamentary oversight. This is the misinformation and disinformation bill all over again. I have always strongly called for serious online harms to be expressly prohibited, but that is the role of the parliament. That is not the role of the minister behind closed doors. Many, many Australians do not trust this government, I do not trust this government, and I can assure you that I do not trust the minister and this government to determine what harmful content is in the context of a so-called digital duty of care bill.
Let's not forget that, under the tort of negligence, Australian companies are already liable for harm caused that is foreseeable. There are already some important principles at play that apply to every single company in this country.
But, as I say, we are extremely concerned about laws that raise very serious free speech concerns. While serious online harms require serious action, Australians should not have to surrender basic freedoms in the process. We are concerned about protecting kids, empowering parents, shining a light on big tech and protecting the freedoms that Australians expect.
Minister, I might say that, if the government were serious about putting parents first, the government would have acted back in 2022 in relation to the recommendations in the digital platforms inquiry—opening up the operating systems so that parents could access safety tools, like corporations and government departments. It's profoundly disappointing that there's been no engagement, no interest from the government, in relation to this incredibly important issue.
This evidence and these concerns have been raised in various Senate committees for a couple of years. If the government were interested in holding big tech to account, the government would be supporting our amendment in relation to algorithmic transparency. So we don't need a lecture from you, Minister, in relation to our commitment to kids, to online safety and to parents, when we are bringing forward really meaningful amendments that matter and the government is turning its back on those proposals.
No comments