Senate debates Bills
Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Reconsiderations) Bill 2025; In Committee
Jonathon Duniam Tasmania, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Environment, Fisheries and Forestry
9:46 pm
I move the opposition's amendment on sheet 3338:
(1) Schedule 1, page 3 (after line 24), after item 1, insert:
1A After paragraph 78A(2)(b)
Insert:
(ba) be made within the 12-month period starting on the day the decision was made; and
1B Subsection 78C(1)
Omit "As soon as practicable", substitute "Within 12 months".
This amendment is related to the timeframes for the period of time a request for reconsideration can be made and the period of time relating to the assessment of the request put before the minister. Our amendment is to shorten those periods of time, at least in the case of the period of time a request for reconsideration can be made, from five years to 12 months—a one-year window in which a request can be made. We feel that, of course, with the amount of information that is available in the public domain, for members of the community to be able to assess that, that is an adequate period of time. Similarly, we don't think that within the act, as it stands today, 'as soon as practicable' is an adequate and tight enough definition about how long the minister can take to make a decision, hence the insertion of 'within 12 months' to substitute the 'as soon as practicable' terminology in the legislation.
Timeliness is a big problem with the EPBC Act. It has been for a very long time now. Nearly every sitting week in this place, during this term of parliament, there have been issues raised with regard to projects that are currently before the minister or being assessed in the department where timeliness is an issue. It can be about the time taken to provide information, the time taken to assess information and the time taken by a minister to make a decision about a reconsideration request. For heaven's sake, we have been on this issue now since the tail end of 2023. A reconsideration request was lodged nearly 18 months ago, and we still don't have a decision.
I don't know where the minister was going to go on the question that was before her, and we never will know, because the laws we're passing today, the workaround legislation to get around a minister who chose not to do her job but was forced by the Prime Minister to introduce legislation to work around her intransigence. We don't know what the end result of this minister's work would have been. We don't know whether the claims by the Bob Brown Foundation, the taxpayer funded Environmental Defenders Office or the Australia Institute were legitimate. We'll never know whether the department's advice to the minister validated those claims or not. Here we are, 18 months on, and, if anyone thinks that 18 months is a good enough period of time and it's acceptable, then I would love to hear the reasons for that. I don't think it's acceptable, which is why we are moving these amendments to build in some timelines and some timeliness. Certainty is something that has been talked about ad nauseam in this debate. Certainty is something that proponents of projects and, of course, the community are seeking with regard to reforms to environmental approval laws in this country. The minister said, back in December 2022, in response to the State of the environment report where we had this massive promise to reform the EPBC Act, that these laws would be better for business and better for the environment. In fact, I think we heard that catchcry again just now from the government—that the reforms that this government intends to bring in sometime in the future will be better for the environment and better for business.
I'm afraid I've seen nothing that would address the concerns around timeliness or that would deal with the fact that you go into this black box for decisions and assessments to be made. There are stop-the-clock provisions as well; there's a whole raft of issues relating to timeliness and the complexity of process. So we don't think that it is unreasonable to seek to put timeframes around the window of time in which any community group or any other individual in the community can lodge a request for reconsideration, nor do we think it's wrong to curtail the time taken to make a decision—18 months is too long.
The open-ended nature of what we have in the act today, before the bill we're debating now becomes law, is ridiculous. And the fact that, at any point in the future, anywhere in the country, someone can make a request for reconsideration, upending permits that have been in place, in the case of the Tasmanian salmon industry, for 13 years now—I find it astounding that there is no stepped process through this, where there are checks and measures before the minister is forced to initiate a reconsideration, one that has created such immense uncertainty. There have been claims made that there are just 22 salmon workers in Strahan. I can tell you now, there are more than 22. I challenge my Tasmanian Greens Senate colleagues to come with me to Strahan and meet the more than 22 workers and tell them why you think their jobs don't exist. Tell them why you think their jobs aren't important or why it doesn't matter that a decision is never made. Come and see them and tell them they're imaginary.
The point being that the open-ended nature of the current situation, which the government is going some way to try to fix with their five-year window, as I said, I don't think is good enough. But, if the Greens were to have their way—and I suspect and fear that, perhaps, after an election if the pollsters are to be believed, the crowd down the end there, the Australian Greens, may well be in partnership with the Australian Labor Party, and anything we do this side of an election may well be moot—they may seek to reverse the changes that are being made today and revisit—
They will be. Senator Whish-Wilson confirms for the Senate tonight—thank you for doing that; I've been wondering all day about this—that the Australian Greens, after the election of course, will be demanding, in a partnership agreement with the Australian Labor Party, that these changes be unpicked. That is a revelatory statement, and I'm pleased you provided it to the Senate tonight, Senator Whish-Wilson, because it does unpick the certainty that the government is telling us this legislation will provide, and that is very concerning. This is why it's important that we get it right—because, I tell you what, the coalition will be opposing any plans to try and bring back this open-ended nature of the ability of vexatious groups in the community to try and launch these requests for reconsiderations. Of course, some of—
No comments