House debates Bills

Appropriation Bill (No. 1) 2025-2026; Consideration in Detail

Wednesday, 8 October 2025 House of Representatives

Ted O'Brien

Ted O'Brien Fairfax, Liberal Party, Shadow Treasurer

10:43 am

I can't believe that we are here for consideration in detail about the budget and the Australian Treasurer decides not to turn up. Where is the Treasurer of the country? This is the opportunity for the parliament to hold the Treasurer to account, and he's gone AWOL! Can any of the Labor members in this chamber explain where the Treasurer is? No-one. Absolute silence. This is the opportunity for this parliament to hold the Treasurer to account. So I look down the barrel of the camera and I say to the Treasurer: Treasurer, get in here! Don't ignore the parliament. By virtue of ignoring the parliament, you are ignoring the Australian people. Treasurer, you are expected to be in this chamber to answer the questions of this parliament. If you disregard this parliament, you are disregarding the Australian people. It's an absolute disgrace! I call on the members opposite to use their phones to personally reach out to the Treasurer and get him into this chamber to start answering questions. There are serious questions to answer, because right now the Australian people are becoming poorer, our economy is becoming weaker and, as a nation, we are becoming far more dependent on foreign supply chains.

Only a few months ago, the Treasurer stood in front of the Australian people—in, I thought, a moment of honesty, and I credited him for this publicly—and conceded his budget was not sustainable. It was a big thing for the Australian Treasurer to admit that, and I gave him credit, because he was right: his budget is not sustainable.

The thing that's confusing, though, is that only a couple of weeks ago the Treasurer then stood up in front of the Australian people and—guess what he said about his budget? He said, 'It's in good nick.' So it had gone from being unsustainable to being 'in good nick', within a matter of months, which begs the question: What have we come to know about the budget over the last couple of months? Has there been some sort of major change? The only major change is that we've received the final budget outlook for the last financial year, and what that tells us is that the budget for the last financial year delivered a deficit of $10 billion.

If you go to the year before that and ask, 'What was the final budget outcome?' the final budget outcome then was $16 billion, but $16 billion as a surplus. Let's do the sums together, shall we? That's a $16 billion surplus, plus a $10 billion deficit. That means that, in one financial year, the budget has deteriorated by $26 billion—a $26 billion deterioration over one financial year.

Then you go to the Treasurer's current budget papers and ask, 'What's he doing this financial year?' This financial year he is forecasting a budget deficit of $42 billion. Let's again build on the sums, shall we? If last year finished at a $10 billion deficit, and now he's looking at a $42 billion deficit, that means we're going to have a further deterioration of $32 billion in this financial year.

To finish off our wonderful mathematical gymnastics here, a $26 billion deterioration plus a planned $32 billion deterioration gives you a $58 billion deterioration over two financial years. Let me state that again for those opposite, given their treasurer decided to go AWOL and not turn up. Over a two-year period, this treasurer is overseeing a deterioration in the federal budget of $58 billion, and he claims the budget is 'in good nick'. The simple question that has to be answered by the Treasurer, if he decides to bless this chamber with his presence, is: how does a $58 billion deterioration in the Australian budget equate to that budget being, in his words, 'in good nick'? I look forward to the Treasurer answering that question.

Matt Gregg

Matt Gregg Deakin, Australian Labor Party

10:48 am

I rise to support Appropriation Bill (No. 1) 2025-2026 and to reflect on the progress that we have made together. Inflation is down, interest rates are down, the deficit is down, jobs are up and wages are growing. Through the efforts of the Albanese Labor government and, more importantly, the efforts of all Australians, we've turned the economy around. Contrast this with what we see from the opposition. They left behind nearly a trillion dollars of Liberal debt for us, weighed down in rorts and waste.

They went to the last election with a plan to lift taxes, to lower wages and to bring bigger deficits and more debt. I think the Australian people's verdict made very clear what they thought of that one. Australians voted overwhelmingly for the plan that is working—the plan of the Albanese Labor government. We've made real and substantial progress on inflation. Headline inflation has been at or below three per cent for more than a year, and underlying inflation has been within the Reserve Bank's target band for nine months in a row. When we came to office inflation on a monthly measure had a six in front of it. That is more than double what it is today.

I know that monthly figures are not as reliable as quarterly figures, so let's take into consideration recent quarterly figures. The official quarterly numbers show that both underlying and headline inflation are now at their lowest rates in almost four years. The progress we've made on inflation has led to three interest rate cuts in the last six months. Those cuts mean that a household with a $700,000 mortgage is saving about 330 bucks a month or $4,000 a year. That is a real and substantial difference in people's lives. It's happening because they resoundingly rejected the coalition's economic legacy—high inflation, high interest rates, declining real wages and living standards, and deficits as far as the eye could see. Importantly Australians also rejected the shallow economic legacy that we saw from the coalition. They left behind a race to the bottom on wages, an approach they called 'a deliberate design feature of their economic architecture'. The Albanese government's approach is for business to compete on the basis of their ideas, their productivity, their capability and their innovation, not a race to the bottom on wages.

One might think that the Liberal Party would have got the message at the last election, but no. We've only been in this place for a couple of weeks, and I've already had to defend the concept of penalty rates. They really show that they just don't get it. Take-home pay matters. The increase in living standards matters. So, like in a lot of the policy areas we're seeing at the moment, the opposition has learned absolutely nothing. They might have a new leader, but it really is the same old script and the same old division. Instead we've chosen responsible economic management. We're seeing inflation lower, interest rates down, and real wages and living standards starting to grow again. We've delivered tax cuts for every taxpayer, with two more to come, and we've overseen the creation of more than 1.1 million jobs. We've recorded the lowest average unemployment of any government in over 50 years. We've delivered the biggest nominal turnaround in the budget of any government in Australia's history, turning two big Liberal deficits into two substantial Labor surpluses, and the deficit in our third year is a fifth of what they left us.

We've also shown that governments don't need to choose between responsible economic management and helping people with the cost of living. The national minimum wage and award wages increased by 3.5 per cent from 1 July. The superannuation guarantee increased to 12 per cent. Paid parental leave increased to 24 weeks. Super is now being paid on all government paid parental leave. Another $150 in energy bill relief will be out before the end of this year, and there is $10,000 incentive payments for new housing apprentices. We're delivering cheaper home batteries, cutting 20 per cent off student loan debts for three million Australians and Commonwealth practice payments, which are going to make a huge difference to people training in important professions like teaching so they can actually complete their courses. Of course, hard-working aged-care nurses will receive the next instalment of their pay rise in October.

The Liberals and Nationals stood against much of this cost-of-living relief, and Australians took notice. At the election, they voted for higher living standards, higher wages and secure, well-paid jobs. That's what the Albanese government is working to deliver every day.

Tim Wilson

Tim Wilson Goldstein, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Small Business

10:53 am

When the Minister for Small Business can't even turn up to defend her legacy as the minister, when the previous speaker for the government couldn't even use the allotted time to defend the legacy of this government—you had your chance, Member for Deakin, but you couldn't even use your full time to defend the economic legacy of this government, particularly in terms of the importance of standing up for small business—it says something and speaks to something directly about this government, about where their priorities are. Despite their boasts and despite their claims, the reality is Australians are living with the cost-of-living crisis—and, more importantly, small business is living with the cost-of-small-business crisis—that this government has delivered. That is why Australia right now has the largest number of insolvencies of small business in its history.

We only need to look at why. We have a consistent problem of inflation because this government continues to borrow from tomorrow to fuel today. We have a record number of jobs that are being created from public expenditure. Four out of five jobs are either directly created from public-sector jobs or by borrowing from tomorrow to pay for today to be able to keep numbers inflated. But who pays that cost? Small businesses pay that cost—your inflated costs—that are being passed onto Australians, through high prices and therefore inflation and higher interest rates. Today's expenditure from tomorrow's debt means that Australians pay higher prices today and, more importantly, higher interest rates.

Small businesses are on the front line of this, and that's why they're experiencing record insolvencies. And the government is not their friend; the government is not doing anything to help. In fact, the Albanese government has declared war on small businesses, who simply want to get ahead and employ more Australians.

The absurdity of the situation is that, in this chamber and this parliament, when we had industries like the retail industry wanting to pay workers more, the government was motivated to pass laws so that they could keep the industrial relations system complex, to favour their union mates, to keep the cartel kickbacks going, so that the money would flow to their friends, at the expense of Australian workers. It was done under the banner, they claimed, of making sure they secured penalty rates. In fact, there was only one penalty rate that was being applied, and it was to make sure that it was going to their union friends. But who was it being paid for by? It was being paid for by Australian small businesses. Any pathway to simplicity—any pathway where there would be less cost on small business by making sure that they didn't have to have their own HR department, their own industrial relations department, their own tax advisers and their own lawyers, rather than that money going to wages and of course the opportunity for small businesses to actually get ahead and profit—was the demonised worst outcome for this government.

So it's a simple proposition that this government has no friends in small business because it is not a friend of small business. If you want a friend, you've got to be a friend. And this government is not a friend of small business. It is continuing to wage its war on small businesses all across this country, because it is not prepared to listen or to understand the consequences of the legislation it is putting forward. Instead—we've said this many times before—it sees no small business, hears no small business and certainly doesn't speak to any small business, because, during the discussion around the penalty rates legislation, the minister couldn't answer a simple question: how many small businesses would be impacted? We've now passed the legislation, and it's being implemented. She's given many speeches in the federal parliament crowing about her incredible achievement. She still can't answer that basic question: how many small businesses are impacted, Minister? We'd love to know the answer.

More importantly, how many small businesses are going to impacted by the soon-to-be changes that you're proposing around same-day payments on superannuation? I can give you a number. It comes from a report from MYOB, who do the payroll systems for a large chunk of the country, Minister. If you'd care to go to page 9 of the report, called Securing Australia's Superannuation: MYOB submission, it says:

This suggests that approximately 22.6% of businesses would be at risk of insolvency—

from the government's legislation.

So another simple question, Minister: how many small businesses will be made insolvent because of your proposed changes? It's a simple question and one to which I've no doubt you can provide some sort of simple answer. Of course we know you won't, because you don't bother looking, because you haven't done the work. I know you've done sloppy, but we need you to actually step up.

Madonna Jarrett

Madonna Jarrett Brisbane, Australian Labor Party

10:58 am

I think it's a bit rough, being lectured by those opposite on how to run a budget and an economy for the people! But let's remind you all that in 2022 the government inherited an economy riddled with deficit and trillions of dollars in LNP debt, all wrapped up in waste and rorts. This government has worked hard to turn the economy around. In our first term, we stabilised and strengthened the economy and got inflation down. Now, wages are up, unemployment is low, and the budget is moving forward positively.

But the work doesn't stop there, because we know that people are still doing it tough. And Labor is delivering a budget for people. We're delivering what we said we would. Here are a few examples: the national minimum wage and award wage increases of 3½ per cent; paid parental leave increasing to 24 weeks; another $150 in energy bill relief; and—one of my favourites—cutting 20 per cent off student loan debts for three million Australians, many of whom live in Brisbane. This also comes on top of—let's not forget—the tax cuts last year and more that are on the way.

But more is being done to help people with the cost of living and to improve living standards—first, in housing. Everyone should have a safe place they call home. The challenges we face here are very complex, but that's why Labor is making the single biggest investment in housing since World War II: $43 billion across the board. Part of that includes the five per cent deposit scheme, which last week was made available to all first home buyers.

Second, there's health and mental health. On this side of the House, we believe access to affordable health care is a right not a privilege. That's why the government is making record investments in Medicare and health. Fifty Medicare urgent care clinics will open throughout the rest of the year, and bulk-billing is expanding. I'm really pleased to say that the new Medicare urgent care clinic for Brisbane's inner north is open for tender. That may even have closed by now, but we're hoping to see that start up early next year. It means that many people, including young people who are putting off seeing a doctor because of the cost, can now go and get the care that they need.

Third, let's look at women and what the government has been doing to support the livelihoods of women across the country. It has been closing the gender pay gap. There have been record investments in women's health, including in contraceptives, menopausal hormonal therapies, endometriosis et cetera. These are now much more affordable. Let's not forget cheaper child care.

While the coalition focus on themselves and pretend that they know how to run a budget, we remain laser focused on delivering for all Australians. The Labor government is working every day to deliver for Australians. We're helping people earn more and to keep more of what they earn, and we're helping to improve living standards across Australia. We've got something to be proud of.

Aaron Violi

Aaron Violi Casey, Liberal Party

11:01 am

I know the member for Brisbane is new, so I don't want to hold her to account. I appreciate she has to repeat the government's talking points. I talked about this a lot last term. I'll talk about it again. It's important. Facts matter. The $1 trillion debt that the government supposedly inherited, which they keep talking about, is not true. Don't take my word for it. Take the word of ABC Fact Check. ABC Fact Check, that right-wing news organisation, has said that the government's claim of inheriting $1 trillion in debt is false. It is not true; it is spin. So I would urge those new members on the government side to not repeat the Treasurer's talking points word for word, because you're misleading your communities and the Australian people.

The reality is that spin won't cut it for the Australian people. Cost-of-living pressures continue to be a challenge for families in my home of Casey and for all Australians across the country. Can the Treasurer explain why the price of food is up 16 per cent? Why is the price of health care up 15 per cent? Why is the price of housing up 18 per cent? Why is the price of insurance up 21 per cent? Why is the price of education up 17 per cent? Alarmingly, why are the prices of gas and electricity both up 38 per cent, impacting every Australian, every business and every community group? This is all under this Treasurer's watch.

The reality—and the answer—is the incompetence of this Treasurer. He's all about spin. He's not able to turn up. I note he is not here today. He does not have any solutions to the challenges that the Australian people face, and the Australian people are facing them every day. We just saw that here. Three-and-a-half years in, this government is still blaming the previous government. We do not want excuses for the incompetence of the Treasurer, who does not even deem the parliamentary process important enough to be here to respect it. I will acknowledge the Assistant Treasurer, who has taken the time to be here. In many ways it is probably better that he is here, given he is a doctor of economics. The Treasurer is a doctor of political spin. As many people know, the Assistant Treasurer is the brains behind the operation, so there might be some small hope, but he will continue to get railroaded by a Treasurer who is insistent on spin.

We know that the Treasurer is distracted. He's been missing lately. It's almost like the Treasurer has been sidelined by the Prime Minister. The Treasurer's a bit MIA at the moment because—

An opposition member interjecting

He could be counting the numbers. He's not counting the budget numbers. He's very quietly counting other numbers, because we understand that's the endgame for this Treasurer.

We saw it recently at the productivity roundtable. The Prime Minister said, 'We're going to have a productivity roundtable.' That was the first time the Prime Minister had mentioned productivity in 3½ years. That's probably why it dropped over five per cent under his watch in the first term. But then the Treasurer's said: 'I've got an opportunity. I can spin it. It's a roundtable for economic reform.' The Treasurer's gone big, and he's gone bold. But the problem is that he's not willing to do any economic reform. He doesn't have the courage, or, potentially, the Prime Minister's not letting him, because the next day the Prime Minister came out and stamped his authority on the Treasurer and said: 'No, this is a productivity roundtable. We're focused on productivity.' He put the Treasurer back in his place. I would warn the Treasurer to be careful because the last two cabinet ministers that really put some pressure on the Prime Minister's authority are no longer in cabinet. To use the member for Chifley's own words, they got the factional assassins to do the work. The Treasurer should be careful there.

But even after all this hoopla and spin of the productivity roundtable—it was so important—what did we come up with? One outcome from three days. One solution: we're going to suspend the building and construction code. Great idea! It just happened to be a coalition policy that this government criticised during the campaign. After three days, they came up with one thing—taking coalition policy. The reality is that it is all spin for this government. They have no solutions to the challenges the Australia people face. (Time expired.)

Daniel Mulino

Daniel Mulino Fraser, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Treasurer

11:06 am

We've seen a lot from the opposition when it comes to very well rehearsed rhetoric and not much when it comes to content. I can only imagine that in the opposition offices this morning there was a great deal of activity, with speeches being practised in front of mirrors for this afternoon's debate. I think it would have been better if the time was spent writing those speeches, rather than practising the ones that were delivered here.

I'll refer to some comments made by the shadow Treasurer in his speech in relation to the state of the budget. That is one of the greatest areas of contrast—what we inherited and what we currently see. When we came to office, we inherited nine years of promised budget repair. We succeeded a government that said it was going to deliver a budget back in the black. We inherited a situation where a government had even made the coffee mugs. That was a government that was very strong when it came to crockery but not very strong when it came to the actual budget.

We turned two Liberal deficits around and delivered two Labor surpluses. We brought the deficit down in our third year to a fifth of what we inherited from those opposite. When it came to the bottom line, this government delivered a substantial improvement. That is reflected in the fact that our overall budget position improved by $209 billion—the biggest nominal improvement in the budget position that has been seen. Debt is $188 billion lower in 2024-25; that represents a saving of $60 billion in interest costs as a consequence. That $60 billion can be spent on services for people. That $60 billion can be spent on cost-of-living improvements, things that those opposite reject. Real payments growth is estimated to average 1.7 per cent per year under this government, which is less than half of that under those opposite. There have been real structural improvements. We have found $100 billion in savings—real structural improvements. Those opposite in their last budget found none.

When it comes to the budget situation, which is what the shadow Treasurer spent most of his speech on, this government has delivered substantial improvements and substantial achievements. That's reflected in the macroeconomic situation. We've seen quarterly headline and underlying inflation at around four-year lows. We've seen annual real wages growth for seven consecutive quarters. That can be contrasted with those opposite and their shocking decade of economic mismanagement, when real wages were going backwards. The economy is expanding. We've seen interest rates cut three times in six months, and 1.1 million jobs have been created since we came to government. That is a record for any government in a single term. We're seeing the macroeconomics results of the government's strong fiscal management.

When we look at what those opposite offered at the last election, they offered higher taxes and they rejected our personal income taxes. It's still not clear what they think of that even now. They offer lower wages—as always—bigger deficits and more debt. No wonder that agenda was rejected. When we see what the Leader of the Opposition offered in her first major economic speech, it can be described only as a terrifying reheat of Joe Hockey's shocking 2014 budget speech.

We know, as previous speakers on this side have indicated, that people are still doing it tough, and that's why we have a range of measures which are providing support to people. Those measures include giving people more in their pay packets. We've seen real wages increasing. We've also seeing measures, starting on 1 July, increasing the national minimum wage and award wages by 3.5 per cent. We've got the super guarantee increasing to 12 per cent—a real, solid, concrete measure which will improve people's retirement income security, and that is after such a long period where every single increase in the SG was opposed by those opposite. Paid parental leave is increased to 24 weeks, and now super is being paid on government paid parental leave. There's $150 in additional support for people's energy bills and $10,000 in incentive payments for new housing apprentices. All of these are concrete measures, like the cheaper home batteries, which are being taken up by tens of thousands of households—more than 75,000 at last measure.

Those measures are worth focusing on for the practical benefits they are providing to people, but I remind the chamber that almost every single one of those measures were opposed by those opposite. More meaningful, responsible cost-of-living help will continue to roll out. Tax cuts for every taxpayer kicked in last year, with two more tax cuts next year and the year after. There are practical measures like urgent care clinics being rolled out right across the country. This government is delivering.

Allegra Spender

Allegra Spender Wentworth, Independent

11:11 am

I would like to question the government today about two critical areas of economic reform—principles for tax reform and fiscal rules. I believe these are interrelated and absolutely critical to sustainable budget management.

First is tax reform. I was very heartened to hear the Treasurer acknowledge the need for the tax system to better help young people build prosperous lives, to drive productivity and investment in our businesses, and to be on a sustainable footing. I acknowledge his openness to taking on a tax reform agenda. This is hard to do. I believe there is an opportunity to work towards challenging but necessary economic reforms that set Australia up for the coming decades. I've been championing tax reform and productivity reform since I got to parliament, and it is heartening to see the government back this approach. I believe that if we fail to act on significant economic reform, we will stagnate—we will lock in stagnating living standards.

I want to question the government on its frame for tax reform. Specifically, I ask the government and the Treasurer whether the government will commit to a revenue-neutral approach to tax reform where the reform—at a minimum—does not seek to increase the overall tax burden on Australians over the short-to-medium term. I believe that model is absolutely critical to successful tax reform in this country, and the reasons for adopting that model are various. Firstly, and very importantly, the Australian people do not support higher taxes on average. This is borne out in survey after survey. They are suspicious of tax reform that they feel is just increasing money to the government rather than to them. Secondly, the current federal tax take is relatively high in historical terms. Thirdly, the history of significant Australian tax reform, particularly the Hawke-Keating reforms and the Howard-Costello reforms, adopted this model of, at most, revenue neutrality and, at best, reducing the tax burden on the country. We should learn from their examples. Finally, because the opposition have also acknowledged publicly that they are open to tax reform that does not increase overall tax burden in the country, this means there is a rare opportunity to get the reform through the parliament—I should hope!

The second area I would like to question the government on is fiscal rules. This pre-election budget passed an important milestone: government spending reached 27 per cent of GDP, the highest point since 1986, outside the COVID-19 pandemic emergency measures. There have been real cost-of-living pressures that the government have sought to address in recent times, and I acknowledge that. However, the growth in government spending has been far too high over the last three years. In fact, nominal expenditure rose more than eight per cent last financial year, and this is unsustainable. Global economic agencies, including the IMF and the OECD are calling on governments around the world—including Australia—to adopt clearer fiscal rules to avoid further burdening future generations with debt and further worsening our intergenerational compact.

The government may well and have historically often pointed to the back-to-back surpluses they've delivered and the significantly improved budget outcomes for the financial year 2024-25 as evidence of their prudent fiscal management. However, in all three years, there has been a structural budget deficit, and at the same time the government has committed to significant off-budget spending that has run into the tens of billions of dollars.

There are going to be further demographic shifts in Australia which are going to put really significant extra burdens on the Australian government's budget. These are likely to be the shift to an older population and Defence requirements. These shifts are real, and they are growing. It makes it even more important right now to better control government spending. I do acknowledge the work that the government has done, in the case of aged care, with the opposition and the House more broadly, and also on the NDIS, acknowledging that there is a problem here in the sustainability of budget spending. But this is not enough.

To drive spending restraints, we need fiscal rules and a proper commitment to a charter of budget honesty. I acknowledge that governments of all stripes have been riding roughshod over the Charter of Budget Honesty over the last 15 years or so. So my second question to the Treasurer and to the government is: will this government commit to implementing key fiscal rules, including spending growth that is less than GDP growth over the cycle, and return to its obligations under the Charter of Budget Honesty?

Proposed expenditure agreed to.

Jerome Laxale

Jerome Laxale Bennelong, Australian Labor Party

11:17 am

Responsible economic management drives the decisions of this Albanese Labor government, now approaching four years in office, and these decisions have led to decreasing inflation, record low unemployment levels and paying down huge Liberal debts while also providing support for Australians for cost-of-living challenges.

The myth that the Liberal Party is best placed to manage our economy has been well and truly busted not only by the past four years of Labor economic management but by comparison of that record against the nine years of rorts, waste and deficits of the Abbott-Turnbull-Morrison government. Let's not forget that it was they that promised us surpluses in 2013 and every subsequent year of their government but didn't deliver one—none from nine. Then we came to government, and, through political and economic discipline, Labor have delivered two budget surpluses, and last year's financial position is around a fifth of what was forecast by the former government. Our $100 billion budget turnaround was the highest nominal budget growth in Australian history.

Our strong economic position has occurred due to decisions we've made. We've strengthened the labour market by building employment opportunities. We've invested in the Australian people through delivering cost-of-living relief that lowered childcare and healthcare expenses and provided energy bill relief. We adapted our spending strategy to meet the needs of this nation and moved far away from the stagnant action of the previous government.

We made this progress knowing that it would lay a strong foundation for our economy. The government understand that long-term sustainability doesn't happen automatically, and our record shows that we've been putting in the work. Despite the huge Liberal deficits that we inherited, our fiscal position remains the envy of the world. Our three final budget outcomes have delivered a cumulative underlying cash balance of $28 billion, which directly benefits the Australian people. We've given every taxpayer a tax cut, and we're going to continue to do so.

The ABS has reported that underlying inflation fell in August and has remained within the RBA's target range for a consecutive nine months, and we've got headline inflation at its lowest rate in four years. This means that we're helping individuals pay off debt, supporting cheaper loans and mortgages and boosting spending that will support our economy. But it doesn't stop there. International ratings agency S&P has endorsed the economic progress of this government by reaffirming Australia's AAA long-term sovereign credit rating under Labor, only one of nine countries to have been rated with this merit. It backs in the confidence that I have in our leaders. S&P have praised the nation's fiscal performance, recognising the strong standing of our government's economic position.

These achievements don't happen magically. They are a result of time, resources and funding invested into the Australian people and our economy. They're supported by practical, reasonable and substantial actions to back key areas of our economy that mattered most. This includes sectors like the care economy and the NDIS and aged-care systems, both of which are undergoing consistent review and reform to fight structural pressures. We fostered the creation of over 1.1 million jobs, and, importantly, women's workforce participation is at a record high. We've made sure that these jobs are supported by living wages, which has reduced the gender pay gap to an all-time low. Women are now earning $255 more per week on average than they were in 2022, all because of a Labor government. We've increased wages in aged care and early education. We've improved paid parental leave, and we announced $790 million to deliver a women's health package that delivers better health outcomes for women and also puts dollars straight back into the pockets of Australians.

Compare that to what the Liberals proposed—a $600 billion nuclear scheme funded in part by cutting the public service, an attack on work-from-home provisions and an outrageous super-for-housing scheme whilst blocking construction of more housing, increasing income taxes and opposing necessary cost-of-living measures. No wonder the electorate rejected that scorecard. The great myth of Australian politics, that the Liberals are the great economic managers, has been nuked. Their economic credibility has been left in tatters.

Ted O'Brien

Ted O'Brien Fairfax, Liberal Party, Shadow Treasurer

11:22 am

I wish to acknowledge the Assistant Minister for Productivity, Competition, Charities and Treasury, who's in the chamber today. I also want to acknowledge the Assistant Treasurer, who was here for the debate just passed. The reason I want to acknowledge both of these gentlemen is that the Treasurer himself has decided not to turn up today. On one hand, I sort of get it. His performance has been absolutely dreadful as the Treasurer. But I also get it because both the assistant minister for productivity and the Assistant Treasurer actually have PhDs in economics. They understand numbers. We know the Treasurer, to his credit, also has a PhD, albeit in political communications. So, where there is a well-scripted speech about the economy, it is important to have the Treasurer there because he is best in class when it comes to the government's front bench on political communications. Indeed, he has a PhD in it. But, when it comes to these sorts of debates in the chamber, you often see him missing from action, and that's for good reason—he actually doesn't understand the economy itself. So I do give credit to those opposite who are here who actually do have some training in economics.

What they understand as much as the coalition does is the Australian people are feeling poorer, because they are. The Australian economy is looking weaker because it is. Australia as a nation is becoming increasingly dependent on foreign supply chains because we are losing our own sovereign capabilities. A lot of this has to do with the budget position. In particular, we have seen debt go up. Debt is forecast by the Labor government to hit $1 trillion this financial year, up to $1.2 trillion by the time of the next election. To put this in context, every single minute of the day, an additional $50,000 is spent on interest payments on this government's debt. That is the situation we have today. If indeed the government had been acting prudently, responsibly, we would have $100 billion less debt today than we do. But they haven't done that.

The thing is the more the debt grows, the more they are effectively placing a burden on the next generation of Australians. There is a moral aspect—or should I say 'immoral' aspect—to the government's actions here. The more they bump up debt, the more the next generation will be slugged with it to pick it up. We're talking here about younger Australians who already, thanks to the government, cannot find a house. Young Australians are struggling to find homes because this government has failed on all of its targets. Those few who have homes and have an average mortgage are paying about $1,800 more every single month thanks to this government. And that's just on interest payments. It's quite extraordinary. That's over $21,000 every single year due to this government. These are young Australians who are being lumped with so much debt.

Here's the problem. It's only going to get worse from here. It's only getting worse. Right now, younger Australians are struggling, but as they go through their life they are not only going to have more debt; they are, thanks to this government, going to have more tax. We can see that because the only tax proposal on the table from this government is to tax unrealised capital gains in superannuation funds. We know very well that that breaches a red line in tax law, and, of course, they're not indexing this, which means that more and more young people are going to be hit by this tax over time. Paul Keating himself has made his views on this very clear. This is unfair. There is a moral obligation here.

The problem is that this government will not stop its spending spree, and it will not start to grow the Australian economy. Government spending is growing at four times the rate of the Australian economy. They are spending $160 billion more this financial year than the coalition's last budget. They just can't help it. The Treasurer, who's not here, just can't help spending. This is a problem. I feel for the two assistant ministers underneath him, who actually understand how the economy works. My question is: Will the government stop the spending spree? Will the government start growing the economic pipe? Will the government introduce quantifiable fiscal rules?

Sally Sitou

Sally Sitou Reid, Australian Labor Party

11:27 am

I first would like to congratulate the previous speaker for his election to the positions of deputy leader of the Liberal Party and shadow Treasurer. Given that he was the architect of the nuclear energy policy that those opposite took to the last election, a failure of a policy that would have cost $600 billion and increased energy costs, one might say that he failed upwards in this case!

Good luck to those opposite. They've chosen a shadow Treasurer who wanted to give the Australian public a $600 billion bill for a policy which was going to increase energy prices. But good luck to them. Certainly the shadow Treasurer did not bring very much, in terms of policy offerings, to the previous campaign. Maybe the one thing the shadow Treasurer will now do is provide policy offerings. Those opposite are going through an identity crisis at the moment. They're going to go through their Eat Pray Love moment of discovering themselves, what they stand for and what policies they want to bring forward, but let's hope they ditch their nuclear energy policy.

Certainly on this side of the House, we have been singularly focused on the Australian people. We're not fighting amongst ourselves for the spoils of office. Instead, we are singularly focused on helping the Australian people because we want to deliver for them. That's the whole point of us being in this place.

When we came into government we inherited $1 trillion of Liberal Party debt and two Liberal deficits. Now, under Labor, our debt is $188 billion lower and we've turned those two Liberal deficits into back-to-back surpluses. Inflation is now under control and within the Reserve Bank's target band. We've been able to do all of this while providing cost-of-living support to Australians, including cheaper medicines, tax cuts for all Australians, free TAFE so that we can get more people trained up into areas where we have desperate skill shortages, real wages growth and cheaper child care. These are all measures that those opposite voted against, unfortunately.

Let's contrast that with what happened in the last election campaign. The Liberal Party had their nuclear energy policy. The other policy offering they had—and it was a very bare cupboard indeed—was to cut 41,000 Public Service jobs over five years. It felt like Groundhog Day. The one policy they ever pull out is to cut Public Service jobs. We've been there; we've done that, and it didn't work. The Liberal Party cut Public Service jobs when they were in government. Veterans had to wait years and years to get their claims processed. I note that those opposite always claim to be on the side of veterans. They are the first to stand up at Anzac Day services and talk about how they want to support veterans, but, when it came to actually processing their applications so that they could get the funding that they legitimately deserved, you failed them.

You failed to properly staff our passport offices, so Australians couldn't even get their passports when they wanted them. You failed to adequately staff our immigration department, so there were gaping holes allowing known human traffickers into this country, including into my electorate. A gentleman by the name Binjun Xie was allowed to sex traffic in my electorate because of the gaping holes you left.

Tim Wilson

Tim Wilson Goldstein, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Small Business

11:32 am

In the five minutes allotted to me in this speech, 2.4 Australians' entire income will simply go to financing the nation's debt—$50,000 a minute. With $104,000 as the average income, 2.4 Australians' entire income will just go to financing the nation's debt. If the limit of the contribution towards financing the nation's debt was limited to the extent that I was speaking, I can assure you that I would be silent. The reality is that it will go beyond those five minutes and will continue in perpetuity. The reality is that this government has no capacity or will to constrain its spending because it is addicted to making sure it spends other people's money. If you've ever seen it—

A division having been called in the House of Representatives—

Sitting suspended from 11:3 4 to 11:41

As I was remarking before we were rudely interrupted by the incompetence of the Leader of the House—

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Government Members:

Government members interjecting—

Tim Wilson

Tim Wilson Goldstein, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Small Business

it's a five-minute speech—the entire income of 2.4 Australians will go to financing the nation's debt, and that is material because it is going to continue for the next five minutes and the next five minutes and the next five minutes in perpetuity. When you have $50,000 per minute going towards financing the nation's debt and the only response from the government is to palm out more cash and continue the spending spree in perpetuity, without any sense of fiscal restraint, this is only going to become a bigger problem, where the rate of expenditure is going to increase and the volume of debt is going to increase. And, of course, we're going to borrow more from tomorrow to spend today. We're going to have more debt, it's going to fuel inflation, and Australians are going to pay higher interest rates, and it's going to be directly connected to the consequences and the decision-making of the Albanese government.

Even worse than that, at every point that this government is given a choice about whether it wants to pull in the belt, whether it wants to show economic responsibility and restraint—simple things, like when we've seen hard evidence in the public domain now that public money is being used to facilitate cartel kickbacks to the CFMEU and where Australian taxpayers' dollars are finding their way into brown paper bags to facilitate cartel kickbacks to criminal and organised gangs. You'd think the federal government would say: 'No, that's Australian taxpayers' money. It shouldn't be given to organised crime.' You'd think they'd say, 'No, we're not going to borrow from Australians and future generations—and, more importantly, your children—to facilitate payments to people like Mick Gatto.' But the federal minister, Amanda Rishworth, will not even audit the volume of money that is currently going to projects, to ensure that that money is not going to criminal gangs.

Last night in the Senate it was revealed that three state government projects have reported to the federal government concerns about corruption and cartel kickbacks. Twenty-eight days after, we have contacted both the federal minister for infrastructure, Minister King, and the federal minister for industrial relations, Minister Rishworth. They have refused to commission an audit to make sure that Australian taxpayers' dollars are not going to fuel and fund organised crime. So we're not talking about esoteric matters; we're talking about very serious matters. Right now, Australian taxpayers' money is at risk of financing organised crime. And you are not just paying the debt; you are paying and financing the interest on that debt, and it is pushing up the cost of the interest on your house. This is the fundamental immoral position of this government—that they will not even take a casual interest or put proper resources in to make sure we have a crackdown on organised crime and whether there's a direct connection to what you the Australian taxpayer are paying.

So the simple question I have for this government is: will you commission an audit to assess whether Australian taxpayers' money—not just taxes you have today, not just money and revenue you have today, but the debt you're borrowing from future generations—is going towards financing cartel kickbacks and corruption? Will you question whether it is going to go into brown paper bags?

A division having been called in the House of Representatives—

Sitting suspended from 11:45 to 11:5 7

It's quite clear. The government simply will not answer whether or not any federal money is going towards cartel kickbacks and brown paper bags through public-sector projects. If the minister will not answer these simple questions, then how can we have confidence that they're not going to not just those projects or the CFMEU but her own account?

Sharon Claydon

Sharon Claydon Newcastle, Australian Labor Party

11:57 am

I welcome the opportunity to speak to Appropriation Bill (No. 1) 2025-2026 with a special focus around women's economic equality, because it's never an afterthought for the Albanese Labor government but rather the centrepiece of our economic plan. If you're going to talk economics, you need to talk about how you achieve gender equity, and you are never going to get there, on the other side of the chamber, so listen up. Since 2022 women's total employment has increased by 193,400 positions, with more women now in fulltime work with greater security, higher pay and the opportunity to build long-term financial independence. Importantly these achievements are much more than just statistics. They mean women are able to earn to their full potential, reduce reliance on insecure work and provide stability for their families, as well as boosting our nation's productivity.

We've also taken real steps to close the gender-pay gap. Labor has legislated to make gender pay equity a core principle in workplace relations. We've pushed for stronger wage outcomes in industries where women dominate, like aged care, health, education and social services, and we have delivered four consecutive increases to the minimum wage, lifting the pay of nearly three million Australians, most of them women. Women on average are now earning $255.10 more per week than they did in May 2022, when we were elected.

Labor's doing work right across the economy to lift women's pay. Closing the gender-pay gap is a key ambition of Labor's Working for women: a strategy for gender equalitythe first national strategy for gender equality this nation's ever seen, I note. While we've achieved the lowest gender-pay gap on record and the highest record of women's workforce participation, we know there is more to do, and we will keep going. We know the unequal burden of care is one of the biggest drivers of women's economic disadvantage, and that's why we've expanded paid parental leave to six months and, for the first time, we are paying superannuation on that leave. We've made child care more affordable for more than a million families, making it possible for more women to stay in or return to work. These changes mean that caring is no longer an automatic penalty for women's economic participation and that women's retirement savings will no longer suffer because they took the time to raise their family.

A division having been called in the House of Representatives—

Sitting suspended from 1 1 : 59 to 12:11

Proposed expenditure agreed to.

Ash Ambihaipahar

Ash Ambihaipahar Barton, Australian Labor Party

12:12 pm

I rise to speak on the appropriation bill. I have had the opportunity to practice as an employment industrial relations lawyer for about 10 years. I've had the privilege of helping workers with underpayments, unfair dismissals, general protections, enterprise bargaining and much more. This experience has traversed various industries, such as construction and health. I've also been able to support employers in navigating workplace relations law, ensuring that they are compliant whilst providing the advice and representation that balances our operational challenges and the rights of workers. This was primarily in the hospitality sector, working for small-business hotel operators and also for large employers.

I come into this chamber having a wealth of experience and a good grasp of what good employment and industrial relations reform can do to help workers. I come into this chamber having a good understanding that good policy that supports workers can also support employers, what good wages growth means to workers and how that plays a role in the retention of workers but also in providing stability for employers.

The Albanese government is committed to workers keeping more of what they earn and supporting Australians with the cost of living. When I was campaigning in my electorate of Barton, I know people voted for higher wages, and that is exactly what this Labor government is doing. Real wage growth is pertinent to helping workers with the cost of living and making sure that they can get ahead. This government has delivered the strongest annual real wage growth in five years. We can see that the reforms for enterprise bargaining are having a practical impact, where there are a record 2.8 million Aussies covered by an enterprise agreement.

One thing I learnt during my time in the union movement is that people covered by an enterprise agreement tend to have much higher wage growth than those who are on the award. Under this government, enterprise bargaining agreements are delivering average annual wage increases of 4.2 per cent. This is above inflation and average wage increases in the broader economy. Furthermore, as of 1 July this year, all minimum and award wage employees got a 3.5 per cent wage rise. This Labor government has consistently advocated sustainable rises for the minimum and award wages at the Fair Work Commission to ensure we protect our low-paid workers from the pressures of the cost of living.

I know how important penalty rates are both to my community of Barton and across the country, especially for young workers. The recent legislative changes guarantee that approximately 2.6 million people who are award reliant, who slog it hard on public holidays and weekends at the cost of not being with their family and friends, have their penalty rates protected. Penalty and overtime rates are crucial to ensuring people who rely on these entitlements have them protected by law. These are generally the young workers who work in retail and hospitality and in the caring industry. We also understand that workers who tend to be award reliant are more likely to be women. This is an important reform to protect not only young workers but also women.

Furthermore, this Albanese Labor government has focused on reform to remove barriers from bargaining that have been especially significant for workers in low-paid female dominated sectors like childhood education and aged care. That's because, unlike those on the other side of the chamber, we recognise the historical gender based undervaluation of workers in these industries. Because of the Albanese Labor government, the gender pay gap is now at its equal lowest level on record of 11.5 per cent. We have placed gender equality at the heart of the economic management approach by passing legislation to enable that principle in the Fair Work Commission's decision-making process.

We on this side of the chamber understand that this policy reform is what Australians and the people of Barton voted for. When we talk about wages, workplace laws and fairness, we are really talking about people—the nurse finishing her multiple night shifts in a row; the hospitality worker spending every Saturday night behind the bar, instead of with their family; and the construction worker who just wants to get home safely after a long day on the site. These are the Australians who trust us to get it right—to deliver a system that values their contribution and rewards their hard work. That is exactly what this Labor government is doing.

Tim Wilson

Tim Wilson Goldstein, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Small Business

12:17 pm

One of the things that Australians always held their head high about was that we were supposed to be a nation free of corruption. We were supposed to be a nation where good, honest, decent people got themselves into positions of public office, and where, when there was corruption, people of good, decent, honest reputation called it out. The problem we now have is that the government has become the enabler of corruption. This is a systemic problem now across not just the federal government but the state governments as well.

Every day this is being revealed across the country, whether it's the Wood inquiry in Queensland or in media reports in New South Wales, Victoria, Western Australia or South Australia. It is explicitly clear that government projects are being commissioned where the CFMEU, in concert with the government, is ensuring brown paper bags of public money are being transferred to the few, for their benefit, and these are being paid for by the Australian worker. This is the problem. The cartel kickbacks that are going through and are funded by your Australian taxes are now part of the systemic nature of the increased costs of Australian projects funded through the industrial relations system.

You are not just paying for it through higher taxes and debt into the future but increasingly paying it through higher costs for projects across the country and, of course, through lower returns and lower values. This is the disaster of the Albanese government, the Allan government and so many other governments across the country. The only state in this nation that's been prepared to call it out has been the LNP government in Queensland, where they've commissioned an inquiry, the Wood inquiry, that's directly called out the cartel kickbacks that have existed in the CFMEU. In doing so, they've directly exposed what is now happening. Millions of dollars are being funnelled through the facilitation arrangements established through the industrial relations system enabled by the Labor Party. They are making sure the money makes its way into organised crime and the trade union movement so it can then, of course, be kicked into the ALP campaign coffers. That's being paid for by average Australians.

This is the most disgraceful episode in this nation's history, and I note the silence on the government benches right now. They know that, if they stand up and protest, they protest too much, because they know how much they're complicit in this crime. It is time to stand up and it's time to call it out. Every time they sit there in silence and do nothing, they continue to be complicit. Last night in the Senate—only last night—three states, Victoria, New South Wales and Queensland, reported to government their concerns about corruption and cartel kickbacks across three projects in their states.

We've made a simple request of the Minister for Employment and Workplace Relations and the Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government to do an audit to make sure that public money is not going towards cartel kickbacks and brown paper bags or into the CFMEU and organised crime, and they're refusing. The simple question is: is public money going to finance organised crime? It should be an easy answer, but the minister refuses to look, and there's a simple reason why. It's because she knows that, if she shuts down the cartel kickback supply chain, at some point it'll stop feeding people within the Labor Party ecosystem and the cartel they have operating.

Of course, we see this consistently across the industrial relations system, whether it's with the industry super funds that use marketing expenses to shower money onto the trade union movement, which miraculously makes significant financial contributions to the Labor Party so they can stay in office and they can keep taking money out of Australian workers' wages and showering it upon themselves; whether it's with the trade union movement so that they can campaign for Labor to be in a position to change the laws to favour them at the expense of ordinary Australians; or whether it's making sure that they suppress wages for Australians so that they can take advantage and strongarm them and use their muscle. Wherever it is, the only people who are winning are the Australian Labor Party, because the industrial relations system in Australia today is not about empowering workers. The industrial relations system in Australia today is about control. It's about controlling Australian people and Australian workers and making sure that they do the Labor Party's bidding.

This is the immoral nature of this government. They simply do not have the best interests of Australians at heart and they are not interested in how they're going to empower them to be part of the future success of this country. So my simple question to the minister, though she hasn't bothered to turn up, is: when are you going to stop the kickbacks, when are you going to start to focus on the Australian people, and when are you going to stop the money flows to organised crime?

Carina Garland

Carina Garland Chisholm, Australian Labor Party

12:22 pm

Australia has always led the way on some pretty important workplace reforms that empower workers and make life fairer for our communities. Before coming to this place, I had the honour of working in the oldest continuously operating trades and labour council in the world. This is where the eight-hour day was first won, and it is where campaigns for equal pay have been led from. As Australians, we still have a very important role to play in pushing workplace relations into the future to have more empowered workplaces and more-equal pay. In an increasingly, volatile global economic environment, it's really important that we maintain and build upon the high standards that workers have fought for throughout Australian history.

Workers deserve secure employment that is founded upon the values of enterprise, opportunity and fairness, and the Albanese Labor government is delivering just that. In 2022 we made a commitment to Australians that we would repair the horrible damage of the previous coalition governments who, in nine years, achieved nothing but wage stagnation and growing gender pay inequality. Three years after we were elected, we've delivered upon our commitments, and we are continuing to make structural reforms that will serve working families for decades to come. I want to acknowledge the many workers and their families and communities who have really led a lot of this work, often through their trade unions.

Our agenda is built upon a commitment to getting wages moving again and to improving employment outcomes. Unemployment is low, with more than 14.6 million people in work, which is a record high. But it's not enough to simply put people to work; as the government, we have a duty to ensure that Australians feel confident about their future. That's why our government has made getting more workers under an enterprise agreement that works for them, not against them, a priority. Enterprise agreements, when they provide a level playing field for both parties, reduce disputes, offer fairer compensation and increase productivity. Constructive dialogue between employers and workers keeps our workplaces healthy, and it is clear that only Labor will facilitate this dialogue. It's why more Australians are covered by enterprise agreements than ever before, and the reason why industrial disputes are at a historic low.

Our assurance that no Australian be left behind is also why we are closing loopholes in the modern award safety net, protecting the 2.6 million Australians who rely on them. Current laws allow employers to roll up penalty and overtime rates into a single rate of pay, leaving employees without the compensation they're owed, and Labor is changing that.

It's also well known that the face of workplace culture is changing. Fewer workers are sitting in the office for five days a week; instead, they are opting to work from home. I think the Australian people have made very clear that they deeply value the ability to work from home and have that flexibility for their families and communities. Of course, this extends to the right to disconnect, and Labor is legislating provisions that promote sensible discussions about work-life balance. Unlike those opposite, who went into the election with the bizarre plans to make life harder for working families, we believe in making work as flexible as possible rather than turning back the clock.

The clock moves forward too on gender equality under our government. We have put gender equality at the heart of the workplace relations system, ensuring that the Fair Work Commission must consider pay equity in its decision-making. Under our government, women are earning more and keeping more of what they earn. Australian women working full time are, on average, around $250 better off weekly than they were when we first came into office in May 2022. It's because of our reforms that we have been able to narrow the gender pay gap. It's now at a record low of 11.5 per cent. We still absolutely have work to do, but that is certainly better than the 14.1 per cent that we inherited from those opposite—standing in the way of progress as always. Women have been undervalued in our workplaces for far too long, and that's why we've made it easier for workplaces in historically lower paid, female dominated industries to bargain collectively, delivering a pay increase of 15 per cent for early childhood educators.

Our government knows there is more work to be done to make sure we have fair workplaces for everyone, and Australians have always led the way on progressive workplace reform and will continue to do so under our Labor government.

Scott Buchholz

Scott Buchholz Wright, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Skills and Training

12:27 pm

It's always a privilege to make a contribution on the consideration in detail process. Traditionally, I would come and make a contribution, the other side would be adorned with the coinciding ministers, and we would ask a series of questions. On an issue as important as workplace relations, skills and training, you would think the minister would have put in an appearance. Geographically, his office is closer to this chamber than mine—but nothing! There is nothing from that on the other side. But guess what? These cameras here are broadcasting right around the country—

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Honourable Member:

An honourable member interjecting—

Scott Buchholz

Scott Buchholz Wright, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Skills and Training

Keep up, cowboy. That's not the part of the thing that we're up to. We're on workplace relations and skills at the moment. It's the second speaker. Minister Giles should be here. The sector has asked me to ask questions, and I have those questions. Minister, this is the time when you answer the questions that the skills and training sector need to have answers to. We both want to see young Australians employed. We both want to see apprentice numbers improved. We are joined at the hip with our motivation in wanting to get those outcomes. He is doing his best, but I want to work more closely with the minister to ensure that we get outcomes better than what Labor are producing at the moment.

When we left government, the NCVER stated that there were 428,000 apprentices in the system. Today, there are 100,000 fewer. What's gone wrong? We need those apprentices. We need those apprentices to build the houses of the future that need to be built. We need those apprentices to build the industries that we need to thrive. We need those apprentices to build the pipeline of work that's coming. There are 100,000 fewer apprentices and trainees. There are 100,000 fewer plumbers, chippies, electricians, roofers, plasterers, glaziers—all skills we need to build the infrastructure of the future. With the pipeline of infrastructure our country needs, particularly in my state of Queensland, given we've won the Olympic Games and the infrastructure that's needed to host them, we need to be training those apprentices now so that they are job-ready for the task ahead.

It's interesting to contrast the completion rates of the pay system against the private registered training organisations. Under Labor's watch, the TAFE completions are less than satisfactory. When you aggregate certificates I, II, III, IV and the diploma levels that the TAFE system provides, and then aggregate their completion rates, they're at around 40 per cent. And they command 70 per cent of the funding. Leave it to the private sector and the registered training organisations. They're well ahead with a completion rate of around 50 per cent. My question to the minister is: why don't we give more equity, more money, to those we get a greater benefit from as a government?

Employers right across the country, from builders and tradies to healthcare and aged-care providers, are saying the same thing. They can't get the workers they need. It's not just the sector saying it; it's the Business Council and the peaks bodies saying that there are not enough people in the system. This government has its priorities wrong. Apprenticeships and trainee commencements have fallen sharply under this government, meaning fewer young Australians start the training needed to fill the jobs required in the future. Employers are being left without the required staff, projects are being delayed and opportunities are slipping through Australian fingers. It's not just an inconvenience for business; it's a drag on the economy. If you want to have a close look at why your productivity numbers are in the toilet, this is a great place to start, Labor.

I have some questions for the minister. There are over 100,000 fewer apprentices in the system. Why? Minister, how can Labor claim to be rebuilding the workplace and the workforce when industries like construction and aged care are facing record shortages of skilled workers? Minister, before the election, Labor promised to rebuild the skills pipeline and you have failed to do so. Minister, you've spent over $1.5 billion on fee-free TAFE. Why has that funding not produced more apprentices and trainees today than what we had when we left office? Minister, why hasn't Labor properly managed the targeted fee-free TAFE in areas like plumbing, mechanics and electrical trades where the skill shortages are most acute? A large scale of TAFE students are not completing— (Time expired)

Matt Burnell

Matt Burnell Spence, Australian Labor Party

12:32 pm

In May this year, the Australian people voted for higher wages, more cooperative workplaces and responsible economic management. They voted for fairness. They voted for security. They voted for a government that would stand up for working people and deliver on the promises it made. From the very beginning of our second term in government, we acted on our commitment to enshrine penalty rates in law. Penalty rates are not a bonus or a luxury. They are a critical part of the safety net that underpins fair wages and decent conditions. They are recognition of the sacrifices made by hardworking Australians who keep this country moving late at night, on weekends and during public holidays. For many, penalty rates are the difference between getting by and falling behind. That is why this legislation matters. It protects the safety net. It ensures that those entitlements cannot be undermined or traded away. It does all of this while maintaining flexibility in individual workplaces.

This week, we will also deliver on another important election commitment—baby Priya's bill. This bill will guarantee that parents dealing with the tragedy of stillbirth or early infant death will continue to access their employer paid parental leave. It's such a devastating time. It certainly matters. Time matters. Compassion matters. By safeguarding these entitlements, we give grieving parents the space they need to mourn and to heal. These reforms reflect the values we bring to government, the values of fairness and equality for all Australians.

That is why we have placed gender equity at the very centre of our workplace relations system. We are addressing the findings of the Fair Work Commission's historic gender undervaluation review. No woman should ever be paid less simply because of who she is or because of the sector she works in. We are committed to ensuring Australians can earn more and keep more of what they earn. This is why we put the case for a sustainable real-wage increase to the Fair Work Commission, and we won. From 1 July almost three million of Australia's workers saw their pay rise by 3½ per cent—a pay rise that put more money into their pockets, easing cost-of-living pressures at a time when every dollar counts.

We know that higher wages are only one part of the task. It is why we are banning unfair non-compete clauses; they hold workers back, suppress wages and put a handbrake on productivity. It's why we are modernising our workplace laws to reflect the reality of work today. The simple truth is the nature of work has changed, and our laws must change with it. For too long the gig workers, the drivers, the riders, and the people delivering our Uber Eats and parcels have been left behind. They have faced insecure incomes, limited rights, little bargaining power and the constant fear of being cut off by an app without notice. That's why our government has acted. We have introduced a new category of employee-like workers, ensuring the Fair Work Commission can set minimum standards for those working through platforms, standards that cover pay terms, deductions, record-keeping and protections against unfair treatment.

From February this year gig workers have had new safeguards against unfair deactivation. These safeguards were seen in the case of Mohammad Shareed Hotak. Mohammad is an Uber driver who had his account unfairly deactivated after he was attacked while working in his vehicle in Adelaide this year. After a review from Uber and a court case, Mohammad was reactivated on the Uber app. He will be paid nearly two months in lost wages for unfair deactivation. It is the first time a gig worker has won an unfair deactivation and had lost income repaid under national legislation that was passed earlier this year to better protect Australian workers. For gig workers, these reforms mean greater security, stronger protections and a fairer future. For all workers, they mean a government that will not let modern technology be used as a tool to strip away fairness. Every worker, no matter how they are employed, no matter which platform they use, deserve respect, protection and a fair go.

Step by step, reform by reform, we are delivering on the commitments we made to the Australian people: higher wages, stronger protections, fairer workplaces. That is the Labor way, that is our promise and that is exactly what we are delivering.

Ben Small

Ben Small Forrest, Liberal Party

12:37 pm

Our industrial relations system is failing Australians under this government. The Australia I once knew was a place of hard work that rewarded effort, a place that granted flexibility to workers as well as bosses. Yet we have seen the CFMEU bosses enjoy pay rises of 25 per cent in five years, while construction workers' pay is down five per cent. That's how sick our system has become, but it is what we have come to expect. When union donations go into the Labor Party, union policy comes straight out. Donations in, policy out, and the only losers are ordinary Australians.

Industrial relations are no longer about fairness; they are about control. We continue to walk away from the principles that underpinned three decades of growth in this country—a simplified industrial relations system that protected and fostered flexibility and created harmonious partnerships between employers and employees. Unfortunately, we've got a government that treats small businesses like ATMs, unions that behave like cartels and super funds that feed the beast. The people who pay the price for this aren't union bosses—they're small businesses, workers and everyday Australians who are seeing the cost of living increasing while their motivation is disappearing. Why would a hardworking Aussie put in an extra few hours if it simply means this government gets a bigger slice of the pie?

The Treasurer is busy splurging the biggest budget take in history, and yet small businesses are being left behind or dying. Every month they have been in office Labor have added some form of new compliance onto small businesses. The result is businesses face record levels of insolvency and rising costs, and are suffocating under new industrial relations laws. We've already had more insolvencies this financial year as compared to last financial year, even though that was the very worst year on record. In cafes, on construction sites and in salons and farm sheds across this country, people are losing trust—trust in the idea that, if you work hard and do the right thing, you'll get ahead. Instead, they're feeling punished by paperwork, by rigid and inflexible awards and, in fact, by this government. This isn't just bad economics; it's bad faith, and it runs against our national character.

We understand the reality that small businesses face. Why does this government continue to ignore the reality that family businesses do their accounts around the kitchen table because they don't have the luxury to afford legal teams or a finance department and yet they're drowning in red tape, regulation and restriction? The minister has made it clear that this government is fixated on protecting their cartel mates rather than hardworking Aussies. Donations in; policy out. When businesses and workers came together recently and were offered a deal to pay staff more, Labor blocked it because their union mates wouldn't get a cut. These unions demand that their rules are adhered to, and this government, as always, complies. It has nothing to do with the rivers of workers' money being funnelled into the Labor Party through donations, and yet the implications of this are evident. This cartel behaviour is driving up project costs, locking out competition, and it favours union bosses being paid more than ever. Time and time again, it's small businesses and ordinary Australians who are punished, and those in regional electorates like mine even more so.

Let me be clear: we're not anti union, but we are anti union corruption. It should be those who subscribe to the values of the idea of Australia that are cared for, not the union Labor super cartel. The coalition's vision is one of simplification. We don't want to see those who have a dream suffocated as this government continues to do so. We want a system that is pro worker and pro small business, because when we do well we should all do well together. We must empower those who take risks, apply effort and back themselves, whether they're pulling beers, cutting hair or building new homes. We all want a prosperous nation where Australians back themselves, so let's reward risk and resilience. The beating heart of Australia is really in small business. Almost one in two workers in Australia are employed in a small business. And yet, when four in five jobs are being created that are dependent on taxpayer funding in some way, you know that our economy is really crook. And it is really crook because small businesses are dying at a record rate. The coalition will always back practical reforms, reward for effort and the incentive to strive.

Claire Clutterham

Claire Clutterham Sturt, Australian Labor Party

12:42 pm

Employment gives us purpose. It helps us build self-respect. It forms part of our identity. It makes us productive and is a means for us to make a productive contribution to society. It gives us agency and direction over our lives. It helps us network, to make connections and to build friendships. Not every day, I accept, but sometimes it even makes us happy because we can leave a legacy through our work, even a small one. Work allows us to learn and develop skills. Work is a tool to help us create meaning in our lives. Supporting work, supporting jobs growth and supporting workers and employers are the bread and butter of the Australian Labor Party. The dignity of work and the creation of opportunity for long-term, meaningful employment will always be supported by this government.

That commitment is demonstrated by the creation of more than 1.1 million new jobs since we came to government across the public sector and across the private sector, in industry, defence, mining, education, health and, yes, the care economy. Employment has risen by 8.6 per cent. There are 10 million Australians in full-time employment. The gender pay gap is at record lows, and women's participation in the workforce is growing, currently standing at just under 64 per cent. Unemployment is also at record lows. Employers, employees and unions are sitting down at the table together to have constructive discussions, to negotiate positive outcomes that work for everyone. Encouraging collaboration and partnership and negotiation between all of these stakeholders was a large part of the point of this government's industrial relations reforms, which have proven to be good for the economy, good for the community and good for individual Australians.

We are also growing the workforce. Importantly, as of January this year, there have been almost 40,000 enrolments in the government's free TAFE program in the building and construction industry and just over 150,000 enrolments in the care economy. For so long, the care economy, where ordinary Australians dedicate themselves to serving others, has been undervalued and dismissed as unproductive—something to be valued less than other industries. But aged-care workers, disability carers and early childhood educators have been recognised by this government as providing a service that is truly valuable, and recognised through the delivery of consistent pay rises that are designed to encourage people to stay in these valuable industries to continue to serve their fellow Australians. That is the whole point of the care economy which is deeply valued by this government.

Workers in the care economy are valued by this government—including the wonderful and tireless early childhood educators that work in my electorate of Sturt, whether it be at Goodstart Hope Valley on Grand Junction Road, Wattle Park Kindergarten at Wattle Park, or Kozy Kids at Glenside, all of whom I've had the pleasure to meet, and I've seen firsthand just how challenging their work is. So I say to Rachel at Goodstart and Emma at Wattle Park kindy: your work is valued.

Another sector of our economy that this government values is workers with a disability. I recently met Ben and Josh, who work for Jigsaw, a not-for-profit social enterprise, and who wouldn't otherwise be considered, ever, for mainstream employment, because of the characteristics they didn't ask for but were born with. Ben, who is a paid administrative trainee, told me that he couldn't wait for his alarm to go off in the morning on his working days because he couldn't wait to get to work. Performing administrative work in a supportive environment with his colleagues gives Ben purpose, a pay cheque and a chance to grow and develop. And Josh, a digital trainee, also derives satisfaction from getting up and contributing to his community through his work. Ben and Josh deserve this opportunity. The companies that Jigsaw partner with, that provide meaningful work for Australians with a disability, include DXC Technology, a business based in my own electorate of Sturt that assists global companies with IT and AI challenges. This is the very demonstration of the dignity of work, where all work is valued, no matter what industry it is in and no matter who performs it.

This government believes in the dignity of work and will always strive to create an environment that reflects that and facilitates stable and sustainable employment opportunities for all Australians. More people are in work than ever before, in secure, well-paying jobs that help them, their families and their communities.

Proposed expenditure agreed to.

Fiona Phillips

Fiona Phillips Gilmore, Australian Labor Party

12:48 pm

I was born and raised on the New South Wales South Coast. I grew up on a dairy farm, and I am from six local generations of dairy farmers. From a young child, I've seen the impacts that severe droughts, floods, storms and bushfires have on the land. I've watched my family and my neighbours struggle to keep their cattle alive and their businesses afloat, and, during hard times, some have been forced to make hard choices—choices no-one should ever have to make. Over the past 50 years I've seen firsthand the devastation caused by natural disasters and what happens when farmers live through these times and, sadly, give up hope.

In my first speech in this place, I spoke about my dad, a dairy farmer. I still remember his visible distress when he thought he might have to sell the family farm. My family is lucky, through hard work, that that farm is still going. But I know there are farmers and food producers across our country facing these same struggles.

As a regional member, I know how important our agriculture, seafood and forest industries are to towns on the New South Wales South Coast, to our country and to the world. I'm proud to say that I'm a member of the House Standing Committee on Primary Industries, which allows me to gain a more detailed understanding of issues that impact farmers and farming communities in all corners of Australia.

Following the last few years, when relentless drought, unprecedented bushfires, floods and a string of coastal storms impacted my electorate, it's no surprise that the relationship between agriculture and climate change is something I am very passionate about. Farmers in my region have felt and are still feeling the impact of climate change, and they want real action. I'm proud that the Albanese Labor government is improving on-farm climate resilience to equip our producers with the tools, the knowledge and the support they need to adapt and thrive in the face of our changing climate. Our government is working hand in hand with farmers to ensure they get the support they need and where it's needed most.

Supporting our producers through hardship is crucial, but so too is building a more resilient future. That's why we're broadening the scope to support climate resilience, productivity and the transition to net zero. We're providing $519 million for the Future Drought Fund to help communities manage climate risks through practical, locally led projects. We're backing farmers through the Agriculture and Land Sector Plan, backed by more than $2 billion in investment, to ensure our farmers and producers can confidently face our climate future. This is in addition to our other investments to support climate resilience and sustainability, including the $302 million Climate-Smart Agriculture Program, $87 million for the zero net emissions CRC and $60.8 million to support emissions reductions efforts.

The Albanese Labor government is investing in the agriculture, fisheries and forestry sectors and securing our food security for generations to come. The National Farmers' Federation has set a goal for Australia's agriculture sector to grow its farmgate output to $100 billion by 2030. By working closely with the industry, we are closer to that goal than ever before. New data released by the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics and Sciences forecast that the value of agricultural production will rise to $95 billion this financial year. When you include our fisheries and forestry sectors, that figure rises to more than $100 billion.

The Albanese government is opening up and diversifying trade opportunities, including through entering into a new free-trade agreement with the United Arab Emirates, which came into force on 1 October, and we're providing new pathways for our organic producers to export to Japan and India. These opportunities mean more jobs and economic security for regional communities.

Of course, at the heart of a successful agriculture sector is also a strong biosecurity system to protect our farmers, our environment and our economy from pests and diseases. That's why we've committed more than $2 billion in additional funding to strengthen our biosecurity walls since coming to office. As a farm girl through and through, I'm proud to be part of a government that is delivering for primary industry, regional communities and all Australians.

Jamie Chaffey

Jamie Chaffey Parkes, National Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Agriculture

12:53 pm

One in three Australians live outside a major city, but as far as the Albanese Labor government is concerned they are the forgotten Australians. Regional Australia is critically important to our nation—critically important. It is where the food is grown, it's where the fibre originates and it's where the minerals are harvested. Beyond that, it is the home of hardworking, dedicated, pioneering, innovative and enterprising Australians.

This government's track record in serving regional Australians is appalling. Not only primary producers but the whole supply chain is facing challenge after challenge, from crippling red tape to compliance costs and acute labour shortages. I've seen firsthand the problems associated with a severe workforce shortage in our agricultural sector. Across the Parkes electorate, which covers half of New South Wales, primary producers and the entire supply chain desperately need workers. Multiply this to the rest of Australia and you have an acute picture of an industry struggling to bring food and fibre to the rest of our country.

In the lead-up to the Albanese government's Jobs and Skills Summit back in September 2022, our peak food industry bodies estimated the food supply chain was at least 172,000 workers short. In the three years since that celebrated summit, I ask what's changed. This government has scrapped the dedicated agricultural visa, relied solely on the Pacific Australia Labour Mobility scheme for workers and has tried to make changes to the PALM scheme which makes it unworkable for our farmers. The agriculture visa was the biggest structural reform to the agricultural workforce in our nation's history. Under the agriculture visa, workers would be recruited to fill vacancies across a range of agricultural sectors, including horticulture, dairy, wool, grains, fishery, forestry as well as support services and primary production. Under this government it's all gone.

Having scrapped the agricultural visa, Labor turned its attention to the PALM scheme and announced a new federal deed and guidelines that would include workers getting a minimum of 30 hours a week. We warned them it wouldn't work. Our farmers live and know the fluctuation of seasons and weather cycles and the impact this has on the availability of work on farms. Labor backed down but now has instituted a 30-hour average requirement over four weeks that will come into effect on 31 March next year. It's more meddling and more uncertainty. Since April 2022, there has been a 16.8 per cent decline in the PALM workers in agriculture in our country. The deconstructed PALM scheme no longer works for primary producers or for the countries under the PALM scheme.

Another of the significant challenges facing our primary producers and the supply chain is the substandard road network they must use to get their products from the farm to the table, the port or, in some cases, just down the road into the local town. Apart from the fact that many roads have been damaged in the past few years by natural disasters, regional-road funding as a whole has gone backwards. I look at the NRMA figure showing the road infrastructure backlog for the 20 councils in my electorate between 2017 and 2021—the last four years of the coalition government—averaged at $86 million. Recurrent road funding grants over the past seven years averaged $102 million. The end result for those four years under the coalition was that the roads were being funded, and the dollars were there, ready for the works to be done. In contrast, for the last three years of the Labor government, the backlog figure has blown out to an average of $222 million. I'll repeat it again—according to the NRMA figures, we are now looking at an average backlog of $222 million in road infrastructure each year across my electorate. That's an increase of more than 250 per cent in the Parkes electorate alone in the years of this Labor government. My councils have advised me that they're being knocked back millions and millions of dollars in disaster relief funding—in fact, it's $150 million in my electorate.

What does it look like on the ground for our farmers, who rely on the road transport? It looks like detours for many expensive kilometres. It looks like delays of many expensive hours. It looks like damage to vehicles that have been travelling on these roads that are getting worse and worse every single year. My questions is: why has this government treated our farmers with such contempt? (Time expired)

Meryl Swanson

Meryl Swanson Paterson, Australian Labor Party

12:58 pm

We're here talking about agricultural sector in Australia, a sector that truly is the backbone not only of our economy but many of our regional and remote communities. It's great to have the minister in the chamber, and I want to commend her on the work she's done since taking up the portfolio. We set ourselves a bold target a few years ago to grow the value of our farm production to $100 billion by 2030. Today I'm proud to say that we're closer to reaching this than ever before. In fact recent forecasts from the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics and Sciences show that this financial year the value of what our farmers produce is expected to reach $95 billion. Congratulations to them. That's a huge leap forward and proof that the hard work of our farmers, supported by sensible government, is paying off. This success didn't happen by chance. It's the result of genuine partnership between an agricultural sector that continues to deliver exceptional results and a government that listens and delivers.

Our farmers, fishers and foresters are amongst the most productive in the world, and we stand behind them all the way. We've been opening up new markets overseas and making sure our trade relationships are stronger and more diverse than ever. I was talking to the minister moments ago about the incredible comprehensive economic partnership agreement with the United Arab Emirates that has just been delivered. In the first 12 months, that partnership agreement, also known as a free trade agreement, is going to deliver $50 million in savings to our agricultural sector and close down some trade barriers. It's not just about being able to ship out the goods and the incredible produce that we have; it's about some of the trade barriers, some of the technical things and the measures that get in the way. We have been able to deal with those as well, and that's an important thing. Those barriers are sometimes a bit difficult to work out, but, when you crack that nut, it's a sweet nut indeed, and we've done that.

We've also focused on growing the agricultural workforce, helping farmers build resilience against climate change, and supporting the research and innovation needed to keep our industry competitive and biosecure. This year our agricultural exports are expected to hit around $75 billion, which will be the third highest on record. What's more, our export markets are now more varied than ever before, which helps protect us from the ups and downs of the global economy. Farmers know this better than anyone. They face not only the ups and downs of weather and climate and local and domestic economies but also that ever-present global economy fluctuation.

When we came into government, we faced $20 billion worth of barriers that were holding back trade, including stalled access to key markets. But, since then, we've opened the doors to new opportunities in more than 230 cases, whether that's Australian honey now heading to Vietnam, better access for our table grapes in Japan, crayfish going into China or queen bees being exported to Canada. These are really important developments, and each of these achievements translates into real income, real money, for our farmers; more secure jobs in rural and regional communities; and a stronger Australian economy.

We know that our world-class biosecurity system is the major reason why our trading partners trust us. They know that we care about the detail and we're serious about implementation. That's why we've committed more than $2 billion to keep strengthening our biosecurity defences. This is serious. It's a long-term investment, and we protect our nation with it.

While these numbers are exciting, we understand that not every farmer's story is the same, and that's why we continue to work closely with state governments to make sure that support reaches those who need it most. I know that in this Chamber today there are members who have faced extraordinary weather events in recent months. I'm also a part of that. We've had farmers in my electorate who have been flooded out. I know the member for Gilmore has spoken about her electorate's experiences, and I know the member for Lyne will talk about the terrible experiences just north of my electorate. To all those farmers: like you do every day, keep on keeping on, and we'll be with you every step of the way.

Alison Penfold

Alison Penfold Lyne, National Party

1:03 pm

I welcome the opportunity to speak today on the government's investment in agriculture, fisheries and forestry. I thank the member of Paterson for her words regarding the impact of the terrible weather event in May this year on primary producers across the Mid North Coast and Hunter regions, and my thoughts and prayers continue to go out to them. They're still very much struggling with the aftermath. Many can't get onto paddocks because they're still too wet. So there's a long way to go for farmers.

But today I want to focus on the simple fact that the Albanese government is failing agriculture and failing regional Australia. Labor's first term in government was one defined by ignorance, neglect and incompetence—ignorance in particular, because this government and recent Labor governments never take a 360-degree policy perspective on agriculture. It's one sided, activist led and anti primary producers. There's no better example of that than live exports and the live sheep export ban.

I'm more familiar with this issue than most, having been the chief executive officer of the Australian Livestock Exporters Council from 2012 to 2016. I came into that role six months after the 2011 live export ban and I worked with the industry through the implementation of the Exporter Supply Chain Assurance System and the changes to the trade. The impact and the threat of that decision lives with us today. The changes that the industry made back then were hard fought. Out of 130 exporting countries, Australia still remains the only country that regulates animal welfare from the farm to the point of slaughter through the Australian Standards for the Export of Livestock and the Exporter Supply Chain Assurance System.

One of the things I noticed during my time running the live export industry was that the government never truly understood why we have live exports from Australia. Understanding why this trade is so important, not only to Australian primary producers but to the markets that we supply, is a critical issue, because there's clearly a cultural differentiation. I know that many people in Australia are used to going to a supermarket or a butcher and picking out some meat. If it's in a cellophane pack in a supermarket, they think that is fresh meat. They trust the process. But in the Middle East, Indonesia and other countries they don't have the same view. In my time, I had the privilege of visiting a number of abattoirs in the Middle East and Indonesia and I saw a father and a son come up to a pen of Australian merino sheep and select one of those sheep because it looked healthy, and they translate that to the quality of the meat. That is not something that we understand here in Australia, but we need to respect the cultural differences that other countries have before we make decisions on banning and threatening other country's food security.

The other impact that the live sheep trade and the live export trade have had is on training in animal welfare. In the Middle East, a lot of the workers in the feedlots and the abattoirs came from the Subcontinent. They didn't have education. They were often the lowest-of-the-low workers. With our training programs, we actually showed them respect and value for the first time in their lives. Can you imagine what it feels like the first time somebody says to you, 'You've done a great job. I value what you've done,' and how that changes your practices? That's the sort of impact that we had, yet with this ban that has now gone in the Middle East.

There's going to be none of the impact that Australian exporters have had. What will happen instead is that the sheep will be coming from other countries without the same standards and without the same concerns. The impact on Australian sheep producers is extensive, and no amount of compensation will ever make up for the impact of this ban. Allowing this policy to be implemented sets a precedent for any lawful agricultural industry, so my question to the minister is: which industry will Labor sacrifice next? (Time expired)

Matt Smith

Matt Smith Leichhardt, Australian Labor Party

1:08 pm

I wish to speak on the appropriations for the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry. I grew up in the regions with the sons and daughters of dairy farmers in East Gippsland and with the sons and daughters of forestry workers further in East Gippsland. Now, as a regional MP, I know how important agriculture, fisheries and forestry are not just to our national identity but to our economies.

Far North Queensland has a proud history and a large history, and a big part of that history is our agricultural and fishing destinations. Farming, fishing and grazing works throughout Leichhardt. It is a way of life for many of the people in my electorate. They grow up wanting to be farmers or fishers like their parents or their parents' parents, or possibly even further back than that.

Much of the economy of the islands of the Torres Strait relies on the fisheries in the waters above the Australian mainland. It is an integral part of their connection to culture and a way of interacting economically with the outside world. The gulf produces amazing prawns. Some of those gulf tigers are as big as my hand, and I'm proud to say we've got the best bananas in the world. We've got a massive and world-class produce sector in the Atherton Tablelands just up on the coast and, of course, we have our sugar industry.

As in all things, the Far North punches above its weight. If you think about the Far North, part of the imagery that you get is of the cane paddocks rolling into the vistas of the hills and of the banana farms along the highway. People write songs about working the prawns in the gulf. And, of course, as Goanna said, 'We watch the lightning crash over cane fields.'

Agriculture is a critical and indelible part of the Far North Queensland identity. As the local member for much of Far North Queensland, it's my job to keep our regions strong. We do this through a strong agricultural sector. It's something that we all want. The National Farmers' Federation has set a goal for Australia's agricultural sector to reach $100 billion from its farm-gate output by 2030. I was happy to hear the minister say in a speech that, thanks to the Albanese Labor government, 'New data released today by the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics and Sciences forecasts that the value of agricultural production will rise to $95 billion this financial year.' When you include our fisheries and forestry sectors, that figure rises to over $100 billion, forecast for the first time ever. Like the minister said in her speech, and I do as well, I want to pay particular credit to the blood, the sweat—there's a lot of sweat in Far North Queensland—and the tears that our farmers, fishers and foresters put into their work. Their dedication embodies the Australian spirit—hardworking and delivering for the community.

It's for this reason that I'm proud that the Albanese Labor government has been working to back their hard work on the land with government action. Our government works hand in hand with state governments to ensure farmers get the support they need. We are listening to those on the ground to ensure that help gets to where it is needed most.

We know that the climate is changing. We are producing packages of assistance that are responsive to the new challenges brought on by extreme weather events. We're working with our farmers to deliver solutions that allow for improvement in yield and embracing technology for the identification and eradication of pests, meaning that we empower the industry to find new ways to improve their bottom line while improving climate resilience and protecting the environment, because no-one loves the land like a farmer.

But that's not all. We're opening up and diversifying trade opportunities. We're boosting the agriculture workforce, providing skilled and dedicated staff for farms, processing plants and forestry operation, and we're supporting the research and development needed to drive Australian agriculture, fisheries and forestry into the future. There is no future without agriculture.

As the only electorate in the country that borders another country—as Albo said, 'You could swim across to it'; I wouldn't, but you could—it would be important for me to raise a key part of our agricultural sector and that is our strong biosecurity protections, protections that Labor strongly supports and will continue to support. Any failure in our biosecurity could punch a $92 billion hole in our economy, putting at risk all of the hard work of the agricultural sector, not to mention threatening the livelihoods of hundreds of thousands of Australians. Our biosecurity rules keep our food supply safe, our farmers' livelihoods secure and support so many regional communities. That's why we've committed over $2 billion in additional funding to strengthen our biosecurity walls since coming into office.

The other is Labor's work to help support the sector to manage the challenges of climate change that farmers are forced to face. The minister herself said:

Our farmers and producers are among the best in the world. They're smart, tough, innovative, and deeply resilient.

The Albanese Labor government will continue to listen, continue to work with, and continue to back them.

Rick Wilson

Rick Wilson O'Connor, Liberal Party

1:13 pm

I acknowledge the minister for being here today and I thank her for taking an interest. Not every minister has. My home state of Western Australia—and, in fact, my electorate of O'Connor—is the region most affected by the government's disastrous live sheep export ban. With the end of the summer shipping moratorium, the Middle East market would normally be clamouring for livestock, but there is not one single export vessel in Gage Roads. There is not one single order for WA sheep prior to the end of the year.

Labor will maintain that the ban does not come into effect until May 2028 and that there is adequate time to transition. But, effectively, the ban has already started. Shearers are out of jobs, transporters are selling their crates and stockies and exporters are waiting for orders for shipments that may never come. WA sheep numbers have fallen from 12.5 million in 2023 to 9.4 million today and are forecast to hit 7.6 million by 30 June next year. This will have a dramatic effect on the price of sheep and sheep meat for export as well as domestically and a collateral negative effect on wool production. If anyone thinks this is just a WA problem, think again. Where do you think the sheep to restock eastern states farms after the current drought will come from? WA, that's where. With part of this phase-out package earmarked to investigate long-distance land transport, and with the government putting animal activists before producers and consumers, you may not have that option for much longer on the east coast.

With respect to the dramatic decrease in confidence and sheep numbers as a result of this ban, can the minister outline what the impacts, implications and repercussions will be for our farmers and the whole supply chain if this deeply concerning trend continues? Can the minister outline what contribution the policy ban on live exports has made to this significant drop in WA sheep numbers?

The Albanese government's decision to forcibly shut down Australia's live export industry is blatantly ideological and not predicated on any available evidence or science. From the moment this government were elected more than three years ago to when Labor rammed through their disastrous legislation in July last year to ban the industry by May 2028 and announced their woefully inadequate 'transition package', not one minister has been able to cite any data which justifies the end of this lawful and sustainable industry. Government decisions on agriculture need to be based on facts, not extreme animal-activist agendas which hurt innocent people. Will the minister stop treating WA sheep producers with cruelty and contempt and please explain any scientific or animal welfare data which supports this government's policy to end live sheep exports?

Labor's legislation to shut down live sheep exports, which was rammed through the Senate in a guillotined debate in July 2024, was followed by an announcement of a $139.7 million live sheep exports transition package in October 2024. It is now October 2025. The policy has inflicted a devastating human toll across impacted regional communities in WA. Shamefully, it has thrown many livelihoods into uncertainty and turmoil. Minister, has even $1 been received by any farmer, transporter, shearer or exporter from this package? Why has it taken so long for any funding to go out the door into the pockets of impacted farmers? Why have we seen such a contemptible lack of urgency from this government? Has the government done any investigation into the mental health impacts this live sheep exports ban has caused for farmers and families?

The Labor government's transition package sets aside $30 million for the Farm Business Transition Program. These grants supposedly encourage sheep producers to increase on-farm adoption and uptake of alternative farming systems and practices. They require a matching co-contribution for the grants, which are capped at $75,000. This grant program opened yesterday, 15 months after the government rammed through its bill to ban the industry and a year after announcing the $139.7 million package. Minister, in relation to these grants, can you answer the following questions? How many impacted producers in WA is the government expecting to apply for these grants? Why are impacted farmers and applicants required to provide a co-contribution to access this funding? How is it fair to those who've lost their livelihoods to have to find up to $75,000 of their own money to receive some assistance from the federal government? Where are they expected to find this sort of money? There is a glaring lack of detail in terms of the sorts of projects or proposals the Farm Business Transition Program grants would actually go towards. Can the minister please provide examples on the specific activities an impacted farmer could reasonably undertake in order to access these grants?

Anne Urquhart

Anne Urquhart Braddon, Australian Labor Party

1:18 pm

Since coming to government in 2022 we have been delivering for Australian farmers and producers. We're strengthening biosecurity, with more than $2 billion in new funding to keep Australia free from the world's most invasive pests and diseases—a very important issue not just for us down in our island state of Tasmania but for the whole country—and boosting the agricultural workforce, bringing employers, unions and government together to tackle the workforce challenges impacting Australia's agriculture and processing industry.

We've been opening new trade opportunities, through 231 market-access achievements since July 2022, and building a climate-resilient agriculture sector through the Agriculture and Land Sector Plan, backed by more than $2 billion worth of investment, to ensure that our farmers and producers can confidently face our climate future. We are steadfast in our support of industry's ambition to grow the agriculture sector to $100 billion in farmgate value by 2030.

I guess I'm not different from a lot of people in this place. My grandparents ran a dairy farm nestled under the Great Western Tiers, and I've many great memories of growing up there. My other grandparents ran a contracting business out of Kindred, many years ago. So I think we all have a bit of that soil—beautiful Tasmanian soil—running through our veins.

The Tasmanian salmon- and trout-farming industry currently creates around 5,103 full-time-equivalent jobs and has gross production value of over $1 billion. The Tasmanian salmon industry, while supplying just 1.6 per cent of the world's salmon, is the largest fishery in Australia by both volume and economic value.

In Tasmania the forest industry is a critical and fundamental part of the economy and social fabric that make our island state unique. In August, Minister Collins and I visited Forico Nursery in Somerset, Tasmania, to announce funding of $19 million for 15 plantation sites around the country, including five in Tasmania. Forico and the nursery supply seedlings to some of those plantations.

Tasmania supplies the nation with some of the highest quality fresh and frozen vegetables. Tasmania is also a prime location for the production of cereal and seed crops. Some of our farmers are doing it tough in negotiations with local food giant Simplot, who are trying to cut prices for potatoes due to their global procurement policy, and I stand with the farmers in that fight.

The recently released data from ABARES has forecast that the value of agricultural production will rise to $95 billion this financial year. When you include our fisheries and our forestry sector, that figure rises to over $100 billion—forecast for the first time ever. I know that's been said by previous speakers, but it's worth repeating. This result has not been achieved by accident. It is the direct result of a deliberate and focused partnership between a government that is listening to an industry and an industry that constantly delivers.

Australia's farmers, fishers and foresters are some of the hardest-working, most sustainable and most productive in the world, and, since coming to office, the Albanese government has backed them every step of the way. We're opening up and diversifying trade opportunities. We're protecting and investing in our world-leading and robust biosecurity systems. We're boosting the agricultural workforce, providing skilled and dedicated staff for farms, processing plants and forestry operations. We're improving on-farm climate resilience, to equip our producers with the tools, knowledge and support that they need to adapt and thrive in the face of a challenging climate. And we're supporting the research and development needed to drive Australian agriculture, fisheries and forestry into the future.

Our government has committed to assisting the sector to act on climate and on reducing emissions, and we've announced $63.8 million to commence this work; that includes $28.7 million over 10 years, inclusive of $0.9 million ongoing from 2028-29, to improve greenhouse gas accounting in the agriculture and land sector, and $30.8 million over four years to accelerate on-ground action to reduce agriculture and land emissions; the funding will build on the existing Carbon Farming Outreach Program. And there's $4.4 million to DAFF to become a partner in the Zero Net Emissions Agriculture Cooperative Research Centre that was established on 1 July 2024. We are proud to be supporting our vital agricultural— (Time expired)

Bob Katter

Bob Katter Kennedy, Katter's Australian Party

1:24 pm

As an Australian, I tell a very sad tale. Our national anthem says 'Advance Australia fair'. All I can say is: we've advanced Australia rear—backwards. The greatest and most dramatic economic disaster outside of the Great Depression—and the mistake that was made there was not listening to Ted Theodore. If he'd been listened to, we'd have had no depression in Australia. Set that aside. The greatest disaster ever in the nation's history was when Paul Keating, then a minister in the Labor government, said, 'We in the ALP never get rid of jobs. We'll never, ever do that.' The timber industry in North Queensland was closed down by Graham Richardson. The wool industry was closed down by Paul Keating. Some 70,000 hardworking shearers, roustabouts and other people working in the wool industry lost their jobs. They were living in small towns in Australia, their houses were worth nothing, they were bankrupted and a lot of them ended their lives in the most terrible way. Who was that attributable to? Totally the Labor Party and Paul Keating.

There's the cattle industry. If you're in the Liberal Party or the National Party and you're saying, 'Yeah, the big bad ALP did that,' well, hold on a minute. Your leader advocated a total ban on all live animal exports, and, in fairness to her, she still does. I saw her on television the other night, and she said, 'I don't resile from my principles, and I will not abandon my own personal principles. But that's not the party, and I'm the leader of the party, so I will be subject to that.' She's still in favour of banning all live exports.

Now, when live exports were banned by mistake—and I respect and I like Julia Gillard, the then prime minister, but she made a very bad mistake. She realised her mistake and, in fairness to her, two weeks later reversed the decision. Well, you don't go telling a country of nearly 300 million people, 'We'll give it to you now, we'll turn it off tomorrow and we'll turn it back on.' No, that does not happen. They quite rightly said, 'No, you turned the tap off and it will be left off.' I could clearly see that there were only two votes in this parliament. If I made a move—that was one of the two votes—I could get rid of Julia Gillard, which I hated to do because she's a very nice person, and put Kevin Rudd in her place. So I called a press conference for 10 o'clock that morning, much to the screaming abuse of my staff because they said I was committing political suicide. I didn't think that I was, but, as it turned out, yes, I went from 72 per cent two-party preferred down to 52 per cent for what I did. But, in this place, surely you've got to do the right thing.

Ted Theodore's picture is on my wall. He knew that he was destroying himself by saying, 'You have to spend money in a depression to work your way out of a depression.' He was torn to pieces and he was completely destroyed. He walked into his grave with his eyes open. That's probably why he's the greatest man in Australian history. I didn't say that; Malcolm Fraser said that. I didn't say that; Paul Keating said that. I disagree with those two blokes on just about everything but not on that.

Let me move on. The Liberal leader wants live animal exports banned. When the cattle export industry was banned, the price dropped more than clean in half. There were a thousand Wandilla cows that went for a dollar a head. They'd been $200 a head the year before. We got the cattle market reopened, and I must put on the public record my praise for the Prime Minister—and I'd played a role in putting him back in there. Within nine days he was in Indonesia, because it wasn't just the live cattle decision; it was throwing dung beetles at our nearest neighbour, with one of the biggest populations on Earth— (Time expired)

Julie Collins

Julie Collins Franklin, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry

1:29 pm

I know that there's very little time left for this debate, but I do want to acknowledge all of the speakers and contributions and the support for our farmers. As I've said repeatedly in this building and in many other places across the globe, our farmers are people we should be incredibly proud of. Our farmers, our fishers and our foresters are producing some of the best product across the globe. It's globally renowned for a reason, and that's our biosecurity and our food safety. What we want to do is work with farmers to ensure that they can continue to feed Australians and export their product right across the globe. I want to thank everyone in the room for their contribution, but I really want to thank Australian producers for the great Australian product that they produce that so much of the globe wants.

Proposed expenditure agreed to.

Sitting suspended from 13:30 to 16:00

Angie Bell

Angie Bell Moncrieff, Liberal National Party, Shadow Minister for Youth

4:00 pm

Australians have lost trust in this government. That's absolutely the truth, because actually only one in three Australians voted for Labor at the last election. And why is that? Well, uncertainty, lack of accountability, soaring inflation, record government spending, foreign-policy failings and inaction on the environment—inaction that can be seen firsthand, as the harmful algal bloom in South Australia continues to ravage coastal communities.

Department officials told the Senate inquiry last month that they were not aware of the impact of this devastating bloom until the end of May. But wasn't the first detection back in March? That's quite a few months. Didn't prominent South Australian scientists first raise the alarm and request funding for monitoring with then Minister Plibersek two years ago, and again when Minister Watt entered the portfolio? But Senator Watt wasn't formally briefed on the issue until two months later. The waters off the South Australian coast may be murky, but this timeline that the department and the minister were working on is even murkier, so let's look back at the events of March and clear up that murky timeline.

Surfers started to report falling ill after visiting an affected beach in mid-March. Towards the end of March, numerous reports surfaced of dead fish washing up on beaches. It was devastating for the locals. South Australia's Environment Protection Authority confirmed the bloom and that Karenia mikimotoi had been detected. But wait—didn't the department say that they weren't aware of the impact until the end of May? So it's no wonder South Australians have lost trust in this government. It then took 10 days—10 days—for the minister to even visit the state, following the formal briefing. I know you've all seen the PR shot of him at West Beach. For those who are not from South Australia—as I am, or was, originally—West Beach is not very far from the airport; in fact, it's around three minutes in the car.

Since that desperate, last-minute dash and abysmal funding package, let's take a look at some of those sea-creatures that have suffered: 61 leafy sea dragons—beautiful creatures; 604 Port Jackson sharks; 2,000 fiddler rays; 287 bluespotted goatfish. These are just a fraction of the thousands upon thousands of dead marine creatures, including dolphins, that have washed up on South Australian beaches. The death toll has now ballooned to over 34,000 creatures. This algal bloom can cause suffocation and death.

But it isn't just marine life suffering; it's the people of South Australia: the tourism operators, the small businesses, the fishers. They've all been let down by the state and federal governments. Skin irritation, rashes, coughing fits and sneezing—that's the reality for most who come within 300 metres of their tainted beaches.

Just last week the government announced an algal-bloom hotline. Can I ask the minister representing the environment minister: how much is that hotline costing taxpayers, and is that coming out of the existing funding allocation that was meant to support the clean-up and scientific research and to keep businesses afloat? I have some news for you, Minister: those affected cannot even access the available financial relief because of the layers of bureaucracy. Bart Butson, who I met with twice, is just one of the many fishos who cannot access financial support due to the ridiculous criteria. Their spin doctors are working overtime to have you think that this Labor government is the saviour for South Australians. But—newsflash, Minister—South Australians are not mugs. No, they're not. They can see right through your spin.

This bloom is double the size of the ACT and can now be seen from space. It's clear that South Australians have been hung out to dry by their governments. This environmental catastrophe is being completely and utterly mismanaged by this government under this minister. Governments at both levels failed to act for months, and, when they did take notice, it was too little and too late. When they did act, it was evident that there was a major gap in communications between state and federal governments, as evidenced in last month's Senate inquiry.

Why did it take the department over two months to become aware of the issue, and why did it then take another two months for the department to brief the minister? This is mismanagement. This is an utter disgrace. All Australians, including by the minister for Adelaide's beaches, Mark Butler, have been let down. What else will be mismanaged in the environment portfolio this time? I call on the minister representing the Minister for the Environment and Water to front up and answer these questions. The minster could at least be in this chamber, as coalition ministers were during consideration in detail under our government.

Jerome Laxale

Jerome Laxale Bennelong, Australian Labor Party

4:05 pm

In my electorate of Bennelong, people expect their government to act on climate change. They're not interested in the climate wars, they're not interested in the dithering and delay of the former government and they're not interested in the arguments that the former government are having amongst themselves right now. They want a government that takes clear action and makes progress, and I see that will from people in Bennelong every day. Families are adding rooftop solar to their houses. Small businesses are investing in renewable energy technology. They're taking up some of the grants of the Albanese Labor government to help them. Schools are teaching kids about sustainability. It's part of what Bennelong is. They're practical, forward looking and determined to leave their climate and environment better than they found them.

That's why in 2022 and again in 2025 Bennelong voted for a government that would take climate change seriously and had a plan for climate action that was grounded in science, not in politics—and for a government that would deliver on that, not delay it. Since coming to office, we've upheld our end of the bargain. We've done more for emissions reduction and climate change in three years than the coalition did in a decade. We lifted our emissions reduction target from 26 per cent to 43 per cent by 2030 and we've set an ambitious target of up to 70 per cent reduction by 2035, with that range of 62 to 70 per cent.

Of course, we believe and are working towards net zero by 2050, because that's the absolute, bare minimum. The science and the experts tell us that the absolute, bare minimum is net zero by 2050. I know my community want us to get there sooner than that. I certainly want to get there sooner than that, but net zero by 2050 is the minimum. You just need to read the papers and the speeches in this place to see that many of those opposite don't even agree with that. They don't even get to the bare minimum, and we have members sitting here laughing at this.

The bare minimum is net zero by 2050. We have to get there, and to get there we've got a plan. We've rolled out our New Vehicle Efficiency Standard. We've got the EV discounts, a tax cut for people getting low-emissions transport. This is incredibly important. We know that the transport sector is hard to abate, and switching people to low-emissions vehicles is incredibly important. Since we've come to government, low-emissions vehicle sales have risen from two per cent to 10 per cent. That is in just three years, and we know that there's more to do.

We've approved over 100 renewable energy projects. That milestone was reached just a week or two ago. That's enough to power over 11 million households. It will reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 53 million tonnes every year. As for the detail, there are 43 solar farms, 22 onshore wind farms, 13 large-scale renewable-energy storage systems and some hybrid systems where you've got the solar farm and the battery on the same site, which is what the 100th approval was. We're transforming Australia's energy grid because we have to. We know that coal is exiting the system.

We need a government that takes energy policy seriously. That's not what we had for nine years. We had a government that had more energy policies than they had underwear in their top drawer. They couldn't pick which one they'd go with, and they then tried another one, the nuclear policy, at the last election. Well, the electorate nuked them. It absolutely wiped out that policy.

They told us to go further with renewable energy, and that's what we will continue to do. The Capacity Investment Scheme is unlocking 32 gigawatts of renewable energy generation, and we see that being taken up at the household and small-business levels with our home battery subsidy. More than 80,000 home batteries have been installed from 1 July—which is incredible—because households understand the transition. It's like the only ones who don't understand the transition are others opposite, those who tried to laugh our projects out of here. They don't get it. Households get it in the regions and the suburbs. Communities understand it. Bennelong understands it. The government understand it but the opposition do not. The last update I had from the minister was that across our community 321 new home batteries have been installed. I would like to ask the minister if I can please get an update on the rollout of Commonwealth funded EV chargers.

Dan Tehan

Dan Tehan Wannon, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Energy and Emissions Reduction

4:10 pm

The arrogance of the Minister for Climate Change and Energy knows no bounds. Here is one of his own side asking him questions and he is not even here to answer them. What arrogance! What a disgrace! When we were in government, ministers turned up and had the respect to answer the opposition's questions—and to answer the questions from their own side. He won't even come here and answer the questions from his own side. One of his members has asked him a question and he is not even here to answer it. What absolute arrogance!

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Hon. Members:

Honourable members interjecting—

Dan Tehan

Dan Tehan Wannon, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Energy and Emissions Reduction

No, this is consideration in detail and the minister for climate change should be here. That's what we did, and it's an absolute disgrace that he isn't here. That sort of arrogance is what we are hearing about right out in the community as well, because the arrogance of the minister means he does not listen. Do you know why he does not listen? It's because he is achieving nothing. Energy prices have gone up by 79 per cent since you have been in government, and there's not even an apology for the fact that you went to the 2022 election saying they would go down by $275. What did you do instead? You ripped up the RepuTex modelling and said, 'It's worthless; let's blame that.' What's the modelling that you're basing everything you are trying to do on now? Emissions are flatlining—completely flatlining. Energy prices are up by 39 per cent, emissions are flatlining and industry is beginning to collapse. The only reason it's not collapsing is you've had to bail it out, and we've seen that again today. Huge taxpayer moneys are being used to bail out industry, because everything you are doing is a complete and abject failure.

I say this to Minister Bowen who isn't here because he's so arrogant: will you release modelling that the basis of your climate change target is based on? Will you give us the Treasury modelling? Will you produce it here? This is meant to be a government that's transparent. Let's see that transparency. Let's see the Treasury modelling that all of your assumptions are based on. Let's see the CSIRO modelling that your cost gen figures are based on. That's our leading scientific—

Helen Haines

Helen Haines Indi, Independent

I remind the member to address the minister rather than to use the term 'you'.

Dan Tehan

Dan Tehan Wannon, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Energy and Emissions Reduction

Will the minister release the CSIRO modelling that his cost gen prices are built on? And, if he won't, why not? CSIRO just recently released modelling when it came to what you're doing with your 2035 targets, so why won't you release the other modelling? The minister should be here to answer that question, because the lack of transparency in this area from this government beggars belief. This was a government that came in saying that transparency was absolutely vital to the functioning of the country.

We now know why emissions reduction is such a disaster and why people like Ross Garnaut have stood up and just said, 'You're not going to reach your 82 per cent renewables target.' He's been as factual as that. That means you're not going to reach your 2030 target. That means you're not going to reach your 2035 target, because it's built on you achieving your 2030 target. The whole thing is a house of cards—a house of cards that was propped up by RepuTex modelling, which you've torn up, and now you won't show us the basis for anything else you are doing. That's why it's such a farce.

You're failing on the three key factors. Energy prices are up. Emissions are flatlining. Industry is being crippled. Not only that; when it comes to innovation and the technology that could drive this change, what are you saying? You're saying a big, fat no to it. You won't even look at uranium exports to help the US, which might then help us to secure an AUKUS deal. That is how backwards you are as a government and how you are failing.

Josh Wilson

Josh Wilson Fremantle, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Climate Change and Energy

4:16 pm

The Albanese government is doing the responsible thing that Australians expect from their government, which is to lead a transition with respect to our energy sector, to tackle dangerous climate change and to deliver greater protection for our environment. The most recent budget continues our work in that area with a number of measures. I'll touch on some of them as I try and respond to the questions that have been asked, and I'll do that in reverse order.

The contribution from the member for Wannon just then veered between incoherent and—I don't really know what to say—unhinged perhaps. He constantly refers to the 'cost gen modelling' or 'cost gen'. No-one's ever heard of that. It is, of course, the GenCost set of energy models and analysis that the government has rightly responded to and respected, because we respect the science and we respect the experts, which is something that the coalition might like to try at some point.

We have done what the coalition could never be bothered doing. We have a national energy strategy, which they couldn't be bothered to do for nine years. We came to government and instantly increased Australia's emission reduction ambition by more than 60 per cent, and we're on track to deliver that. We're on track to deliver it because we've put in place all of the programs and the policies that will get us to both 82 per cent renewables by 2030 and 43 per cent emission reductions on 2005 levels by that time.

That includes, of course, reforming the Safeguard Mechanism and making it work, which is something the coalition couldn't be bothered doing, implementing the Capacity Investment Scheme and Rewiring Australia, introducing the first national EV strategy with vehicle emission settings for the first time and implementing the first national energy performance strategy, with $2.2 billion in associated programs. All of those things, which are seeing emissions come down, are seeing Australian businesses and households have the benefit of shifting to cleaner, cheaper, more self-sufficient, more self-controlled and more reliable energy. We're never going to back away from that, apologise for that or get dragged into the madness that the member for Wannon was spruiking in relation to his ongoing love affair with incredibly expensive and risky nuclear energy and with various strange, geopolitical uranium arrangements and other things. That's not what the Australian community expects, and we'll have no part of it.

I come now to what the shadow minister for the environment was saying. There was the opportunity here to ask questions about the budget, but there was no question about the budget. She was playing political games about a very serious natural disaster event in South Australia, with respect to the algal bloom. We know why the algal bloom has occurred. There are a range of factors—increased nutrients, outflows in South Australia and rising sea temperatures—which are a consequence of climate change.

Just before, at the end of question time, it was interesting that the member for Flynn stood up and said that he accepted climate change from time to time. The issue that he had, and that presumably his coalition colleagues share, is whether or not humans are contributing to it—whether or not greenhouse gas emissions, carbon dioxide, methane et cetera have anything to do with it. That's the open question as far as the member for Flynn is concerned. He said that there were two sides—and there are two sides. On the one hand, there are scientists and people who respect science who can be described as reasonable and adhering to common sense. There are those people on that side. On the other side, there are people who are, frankly, fruitcakes—people who might want to make a hat out of tin foil or go in for some other kind of behaviour by trying to pretend that all of the overwhelming evidence that climate change is real and is occurring and presents a massive risk to Australia is somehow a figment of other people's imaginations. That is incredibly dangerous. The fact that the member for Flynn stood up and said that and nobody on the coalition side shook their head or looked at him and said, 'Old mate, sit down; that's not helping,' effectively endorsing what he had to say as if some credence should be given to it, should make people worried about the fitness of the coalition for government.

We have acted with great, concerted and effective effort when it comes to the environment. We now protect more ocean than any other country on earth. The latest budget adds $262 million through the Saving Australia's Bushland program to meet our commitment to protect 30 per cent of Australia's territorial and oceanic domain. That is the work of a serious government that takes both climate change and environmental protection seriously.

Simon Kennedy

Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party

4:21 pm

We just heard the member talking about how well this government is doing on energy and climate. We've just heard how well they're doing and how much they're doing. They have the National EV Strategy, the performance strategy and the energy strategy. We've heard how much they care about emissions and climate change. All that effort, all that work in 3½ years, and emissions are barely down one per cent. Doesn't that alarm you? Given your strategies, the amount of capital and the amount of energy you are putting into this, emissions are down by one per cent. Doesn't it alarm you that Tony Abbott lowered emissions more than you, that Malcolm Turnbull lowered emissions more than you? They didn't even serve full terms. Scott Morrison lowered emissions four to five times more than you. I would be alarmed. Don't you question whether your policy is actually built on a house of cards? The last three Liberal prime ministers lowered emissions far more than you. Yes, take your notes, but it's true. Go and check it out and come back and explain to the Australian people why that's the case.

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Honourable Member:

An honourable member interjecting—

Simon Kennedy

Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party

Was Tony Abbott there during COVID? I'll take the interjection. Why did Tony Abbott lower emissions more than you?

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Honourable Member:

An honourable member interjecting—

Simon Kennedy

Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party

From whenever.

Why did Malcolm Turnbull lower emissions more than you? Why did Scott Morrison lower emissions more than you? You've lowered them by one per cent. It's pathetic.

Helen Haines

Helen Haines Indi, Independent

Order! The assistant minister will resist. I cannot hear the member for Cook. Could you proceed, please?

Simon Kennedy

Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party

They have not lowered emissions at all. It's a pathetic record. And you've got a blank cheque. You said that you haven't been asked a budget question. Well, here's one, and answer it. Tell us what the capacity investment mechanism is going to cost? I'll take the interjection. Crickets! Australia, that's what we've just heard. I asked the question: what is the capacity mechanism going to cost? This was the response I received, 'Pff!'. Well, that's not good enough, Australia. That's not good enough. You've got people spending blank cheques. You've got people actually flatlining emissions. You've got people who don't have any credible way to get to a 2030 emissions target or a 2035 emissions target. Well, Australia, we've had enough.

Not only are we not getting anywhere near the emissions target; we are paying through the nose. Energy prices are up 40 per cent—up 40 per cent! I'm one of the few electorates that still has a few manufacturing businesses clinging to life. FJP Manufacturing, a local metal manufacturing firm that I visit, has declining revenues. They're hanging on. They're trying to manufacture. They're employing trade-skilled workers—people you should care about, or at least pretend to care about, with free TAFE or whatever else you're virtue signalling. Well, their electricity went up 25 per cent last year, and it's going up 41 per cent this year. What message do you have for them?

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Honourable Member:

An honourable member interjecting—

Simon Kennedy

Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party

I'll take the interjection. With their electricity going up 76 per cent, what is the message you would like to give to them? What about HF Powdercoating? Another company whose electricity is going up 46 per cent this year, with a 44 per cent increase on gas the year before. What message do you have for these manufacturers? Where's your future made in Australia? Where's the help—where is it? Where's your capacity investment mechanism? That's been my interjection of the day—'What's the capacity investment mechanism going to cost?' Do you have an answer?

A government member: Of course!

What is it? Oh, you don't have it. Why is this government deliberately driving up costs, strangling Australian businesses like FJP Manufacturing and HF Powdercoating in my electorate? They don't have answers for them. They don't have answers. They have policies that are driving up the cost, and this whole energy strategy, this whole emissions-reduction portfolio, is built on a house of cards. That is why every day in question time we listen to Chris Bowen. What's the only thing he talks about? His battery program—

Helen Haines

Helen Haines Indi, Independent

The member for Cook will use the minister's correct title, please.

Simon Kennedy

Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party

Sorry. We listen to the Minister for Climate Change and Energy—I forgot who he was, since he wasn't here today! He can't even turn up to his own budget or appropriation hearing in the Fed Chamber. It's pathetic. Neither can the minister for energy. We turn up there every day, and, instead of actually talking about how emissions are going and instead of talking about what's happening to energy costs, all we hear about is how many batteries he's been able to sell because he's jacked up the energy prices in those electorates like it's some great achievement. Guess what? If you jack up energy prices 40 per cent in 2½ years, you're going to sell a few more batteries. That's not an achievement. It's something you should be embarrassed about.

Ged Kearney

Ged Kearney Cooper, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Social Services

4:26 pm

Climate change is not some weird distant threat. It's actually here with us now. Do those on that side of the House believe that? How about you get your own party in order before you start ordering this side of the House. Climate change is the smoke we're breathing while our summers are burning hotter and longer, and it is the floods that are tearing through our communities across the Mid North Coast. Climate change is the droughts that parch our farms in Coleraine, and it is the fear that I see in young people's faces right across my electorate of Cooper. Climate change is not an inner-city issue, like some of those on that side proclaim. Climate change is affecting all of us, but they don't care. They simply don't care on that side of the House.

When the Albanese Labor government was first elected, we inherited a wasted decade, and they dare to come into this chamber and try to pick holes in a government that is dedicated to fixing climate change, that the entire caucus believes in, and the entire caucus is behind our minister, who is working his guts out, along with the assistant minister. Years of coalition fighting continues about whether climate change is real or how real—a little bit real, not real enough to actually do anything seriously about.

Frankly, they were an international laughing stock, and that continues. We had the member for Wannon come in just before, railing against some apparently secret Treasury modelling that he's demanding that we table. He's demanding that we—

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Hon. Members:

Honourable members interjecting—

Helen Haines

Helen Haines Indi, Independent

I ask that members lower their voices so that I can hear the member for Cooper's contribution.

Ged Kearney

Ged Kearney Cooper, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Social Services

The member for Wannon was demanding that we table some so-called secret Treasury modelling that is so secret it's actually available freely online for everyone to see! If he weren't just hopping across in a fantasy trip around the US looking at some nuclear-energy pipedream, he might have noticed that that was actually there.

We are lifting our country's 2030 emission reduction target from 26 to 43 per cent and enshrining those in the law of the land. We set our 2035 targets from 62 to 70 per cent on 2005 emission levels. In setting this target, we accept the independent Climate Change Authority's advice. We've also given the Safeguard Mechanism teeth; cut the cost of home batteries by 30 per cent, with nearly 80,000 batteries being taken up; and introduced new vehicle efficiency standards so that Australians finally have access cheaper-to-run, cleaner cars. We have a Net Zero Economy Authority to ensure no community is left behind in this transition. We've got our six sector decarbonisation plans too—detailed practical roadmaps for how every part of the economy will do their part.

All these changes have led to renewables delivering enough energy to power six million homes, and yet they laughably say, 'Nothing is happening.' We're putting our money where mouths are by investing in a new $5 billion net zero fund in the National Reconstruction Fund to help industrial facilities decarbonise and scale up more renewables with low-emissions manufacturing. There are $2 billion for the Clean Energy Finance Corporation to continue to drive downwards pressure on electricity prices, $1.1 billion to encourage more production of clean fuels here in Australia, $40 million to accelerate the roll out of kerb-side and fast EV charging to help up roll out up to 10,000 public charge points by 2029. This is not nothing. Contrary to every dollar we invest is the cost of doing nothing.

Treasury modelling finds that a disorderly transition would make Australia's economy at least $1.2 trillion worse off, cumulatively, by 2050. That's what we'd get with the other side. Let me be clear. The coalition kept us behind, and now they want to take us backwards. Many of them wanted to scrap action on climate change and net zero and waste hundreds of billions on nuclear fantasies—the most expensive form of energy, mind you. They keep arguing while the rest of the world races ahead, and for whom?

The CSIRO found it would take 15 years before a single nuclear power plant produced a single watt of power—15 years! We can't wait that long. They don't have any answers. They want to play politics while the planet burns. Senator Duniam said there would be a mass exodus from the frontbench if the coalition committed to acting on climate change and kept net zero targets. And it goes on.

The opposition is a mess. We on this side of the House have our house fully in order. We are acting on climate change, we are doing the hard work and we are going to make sure we get there.

Monique Ryan

Monique Ryan Kooyong, Independent

4:31 pm

We're anticipating a bad summer for bushfires. I ask the assistant minister to commit to going to the regions at the end of the summer and explaining to those Australians who have just lost their home how this government can possibly justify its active, ongoing and generous support for the fossil fuel industries which are driving the escalating human and economic cost of climate change. Our reefs are bleaching, our forests are burning, our seas are choking with algal blooms and our communities are bearing the brunt of extreme weather events, but over the forward estimates this government proposes to spend five times more on fossil fuel subsidies than on environmental protections and climate resilience.

Australia is the third-largest exporter of fossil fuels in the world. We continue to expand our fossil fuel extraction and export industries. In fact, this government supports them with subsidies of over $14 billion every year. The government has announced inadequate targets, but it doesn't intend to legislate them. To date, it has never legislated a policy which will actually force emissions reductions. Other than via some dubious land sector accounting, we haven't significantly reduced our domestic emissions since 2005. The Safeguard Mechanism allows our biggest polluters to buy offsets instead of actually decreasing their emissions. We don't accurately measure or enforce emissions standards or limits on highly polluting industries, and, in those instances where underreporting is identified, our environmental protection agencies, such as they are, generally fail to act.

The great stupidity of our climate policies is exemplified by the billions of dollars we spend on conservation efforts for the Great Barrier Reef and for Macquarie Harbour while we actively facilitating the expansion of the industries which are responsible for their degradation. In the same week that the government released its terrifying national climate risk assessment, it approved the North West Shelf extension, the most polluting project in the southern hemisphere.

This brings us to the transport industry. According to the National Greenhouse Gas Inventory, transport emissions actually increased by 0.5 per cent in the year to March 2025. This was driven by record consumption of road diesel and domestic aviation fuel. Transport accounts for over 20 per cent of our national emissions. It will become the largest source of our emissions by 2030. That trajectory is utterly incompatible with our climate targets and demands urgent intervention. At the moment EV sales are stuck at less than 10 per cent of new vehicles sold, which puts a serious question mark over the Climate Change Authority's recent advice to the government that half of all cars sold between now and 2035 need to be emission-free. Without a shift in how we move people and goods we risk undermining our national climate commitments. Instead of the big build, our cities need slim-build, low-cost infrastructure which reduces emissions and improves health. It's a better model for urban Australia and it will be a more efficient allocation of our tax dollars.

In my own electorate of Kooyong, the proposed Hawthorn to Box Hill bicycle path is a local solution with national relevance. Strategic cycling corridors transform urban commuting. They link suburbs and business centres, and they connect integrated cycling networks. The benefits of the Hawthorn to Box Hill path to Kooyong residents would be substantial. They would include safe, car-free commuting for thousands of residents every day, reduced traffic congestion on our major roads, lower transport emissions, increased physical activity and reduced air pollution, and the economic savings that we'd see with reduced fuel and vehicle management costs.

The choices that we make in this parliament will shape Australia's environmental legacy for generations. We have to stop subsidising fossil fuels. We have to redirect our precious tax dollars to clean energy, to conservation and to the preservation of our biodiversity. We need proactive and preventative investment in climate resilience and nature protection, and that has to include scaling up investment in active and public transport to have any hope at all of meeting the bare minimum 70 per cent emissions reduction by 2035. This government needs to back up these targets with action.

Sally Sitou

Sally Sitou Reid, Australian Labor Party

4:36 pm

It is a real shame that the member for Cook is no longer in this chamber, because I wanted to address some of the points that he tried to raise and which were very misleading, like his assertion that emissions have fallen under coalition governments. The key point here is that they fell not because of the policies that the coalition introduced; they fell despite the lack of policies they introduced. The fall in emissions was because of the Gillard government's carbon price. It was because the market was already moving in this direction, so the industry was already doing a lot of the heavy lifting in reducing emissions. The third reason emissions fell was a pandemic—a total shutdown of our economy.

My hope is that the coalition do not see a future fall in emissions under them based on a total shutdown of the economy. My hope is that they will come up with policies to help drive down emissions, because at the moment the only policy that they do have on the table—and it's hard to imagine whether it's going to continue or be wound back—is their nuclear energy policy. This is a reminder to everyone that that policy was one that cost $600 billion and was going to jack up the price of electricity for ordinary Australians. So it's of great interest that they have now become focused on reducing emissions and they have become focused on energy prices. My hope is that they will actually start to generate some policies that will address both.

When we came to government in 2022, we laid out a very clear plan to cut emissions and transition to cleaner, cheaper, renewable energy, and we got to work straightaway, on day one. In 2025, voters delivered a clear message at the election. They support Labor's plan to tackle climate change and seize the biggest economic opportunity in our history. And our plan is working. Emissions are down and renewables are up. That's exactly where we want to be. Conversely, those opposite tried many, many times to land a climate change policy or an energy policy, but they failed at each and every turn. Their biggest failure was at the 2025 election campaign, when the Australian public gave them a resounding mark for their terrible nuclear energy policy. It was an 'F'—a big fail. So I hope that they accept some of these lessons from the failures that they've had and that they get to work and come together, get behind net zero by 2050 and get behind the idea of acting on climate change like we have.

We know that, when it comes to addressing climate change, some of the key points are around fairness, because it's important that we bring everyone with us on this journey of moving towards cleaner energy. It's important that we bring households, workers, businesses and communities with us. We need a fairer deal on power bills, fairer access to clean energy and a fairer share of opportunities from the clean energy transformation. That's why we're implementing policies to make the transition more accessible for all.

We've reduced the cost of a home battery by 30 per cent. That has delivered 80,000 home batteries across Australia. As well, we've delivered community batteries across communities and we've supported renters and people who live in units through our Community Solar Banks Program. Through our Energy Savings Package, we've provided financial support to households, businesses and local councils to invest in renewable energy and energy efficiency measures. We're also making cars, both EV's and petrol cars, cheaper and cleaner. That is what a responsible government—a government that believes we need to act on climate change, drive down energy prices and bring in more renewable energy—does.

Josh Wilson

Josh Wilson Fremantle, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Climate Change and Energy

4:41 pm

It is good to have been part of this consideration-in-detail debate. From the most recent budget and the budgets that the Albanese government has previously delivered, I think Australians know that we are focusing on the sensible transition of Australia's energy system because we know it's in our best interests. We know it's necessary because we know that the consequences of failing to do it or of seeing it done in a disorderly way are enormous costs, fewer jobs, lower GDP and, certainly, a worse environment. So we continue to focus on that, as we focus on climate action, which is related to the energy transition, because we need to reduce emissions in order to be part of global cooperative action to achieve net zero by 2050. We're also doing that in relation to the environment, as I said before, both through delivering reform to our national environmental protection framework, which the independent review of Graeme Samuel told the former government that they ought to do but which they never managed to get around to, and through providing funding to protect Australia's threatened species and our vulnerable ecosystems.

I just want to pick up on some of the questions that have been put by members in the course of the debate. The member for Cook shouted at everyone and said a few baseless and silly things along the way. Emissions are coming down. He knows that, in the year to March, there was a 1.4 per cent decrease in Australia's emissions. Preliminary data suggest that the emissions to 30 June are down 2.4 per cent over the previous financial year. That's what we would expect. It is in keeping with our trajectory to 43 per cent emissions reduction on 2005 levels by 2030. I remind people at home that that was a 65 per cent improvement on the target that the coalition set in government, which bore no relation to the science and wasn't consistent with what we need to keep global warming at safe levels and to get to net zero by 2050. We are making progress, and we're doing it in a clear and transparent way.

The member for Cook suggested that the government wasn't upfront about the cost of the programs that are involved in the energy transition. We've been perfectly clear about that. There's $75 billion worth of cost in the programs. I think the Australian community would reflect on the $75 billion that we've been very clear about in terms of detailing contributions to the CEFC and ARENA—great Labor legacies that helped the coalition to achieve some of the emissions reduction that occurred whilst they were doing nothing else—as well as the investments in the Capacity Investment Scheme, the National Electric Vehicle Strategy, the National Energy Performance Strategy and all of those things. Compare that $75 billion to the $600 billion that would have been put on the tab by those opposite in pursuit of their strange nuclear fantasy.

I did find it interesting that both the member for Cook and the member for Wannon keep repeating the term 'house of cards'. You could only think that this is a Freudian expression of the trauma that's going on over there on the other side at the moment. They're a current soap opera—three different prime ministers in nine years. It's barely been five or six months since the election and the Leader of the Opposition's in trouble because people are either walking the plank or jumping overboard from the good ship Coalition. The House of Cards references tell a story. There's definitely a similarity between that famous television series and what's going on on the other side of the chamber. It's not doing the Australian community any great help.

I'll turn to the questions that have come from the member for Bennelong, the member for Kooyong and, to some degree, the member for Cook about transport. Transport is an important area of progress. We have seen the number of EV sales triple as a proportion of new car sales. We have doubled the number of charging points around Australia. We've just provided an additional $40 million to support our new 2035 target to add a further 10,000 charging points, which will include kerbside charging for the first time. We've also delivered $1.1 billion to support clean fuels because we know that Australia has enormous potential to lead that work globally. When you get the production of clean fuels—whether that's biofuels, green hydrogen or other alternatives—you get to move off existing liquid hydrocarbons. Not only does that reduce emissions; it helps deal with one of our enduring problems, which is liquid fuel and security.

That work is happening. Australians can see it. Australians are backing it in. They're backing it in at the ballot box. They're backing it in on their roofs with solar panels. They're backing it in with home batteries. We will continue to deliver for the Australian community.

Proposed expenditure agreed to.

Julian Leeser

Julian Leeser Berowra, Liberal Party, Shadow Attorney-General

4:47 pm

When Australians think about the justice system, they think about the safety of their community. They think about the desire to keep family safe, and, if something were to happen, our government would look after them. As I've said many times, all law-abiding Australians deserve the full protection of the law, and that's the task of the Attorney-General's portfolio. Legislative responsibilities, the front-facing government employees and the independent statutory agencies that fall within its remit are meant to uphold the rule of law and protect Australians from abuses of power. They're meant to ensure that justice is neither delayed nor denied.

Australians have a deep sense of fairness, and, when that fairness is undermined, the confidence of the community is shaken. Justice isn't some abstract concept; it's the difference between safety and fear, stability and uncertainty, and accountability and chaos. Under this government, we've seen these mechanisms flounder and weaken.

Take the Administrative Review Tribunal. Labor abolished the Administrative Appeals Tribunal and rebranded it as the ART. They spent more than a billion dollars on this so-called reform. But what has it delivered? Slower outcomes, growing backlogs and a justice system that's failing ordinary Australians. When the coalition left office, the AAT had around 67,720 cases on hand. The median time to finalisation was 30 weeks. Today, under Labor, the ART has 111,755 cases on hand and a medium finalisation time of 68 weeks. That's a backlog blowout of more than 44,000 cases and an additional nine months of waiting. Attorney, why has a billion dollars of taxpayers' money delivered nothing more than a shiny new nameplate and slower justice for Australians? When pressed on this, Labor point to the spike in student visa refusals, as if that's not also their responsibility.

The figures are damning. When we left office, there were 2,725 student visa cases before the AAT. Now there are 40,275 before the ART, with an average resolution time of 62 weeks. That's not reform; it's failure. The same is true for refugee matters. When the coalition left office, there were 37,025 cases before the tribunal, with a medium finalisation time of 113 weeks. Now there are 41,846 cases, with a medium time of 175 weeks—that's three years. Yes, that's three years for Australians and those seeking protection to get a decision.

On transparency, the picture's no better. This is a government that's talked a big game about open government, but it has instead entrenched secrecy. FOI refusals have spiked. Non-disclosure agreements are now routine. Senate orders for the production of documents are being ignored. Standing orders in the House have been changed to limit scrutiny. Staff who hold governments accountable have been slashed. And now the government wants to introduce a truth tax. The Freedom of Information Amendment Bill is nothing more than a cash grab to curtail Australians' right to know what their government is doing. Attorney, can you honestly say your bill is about reform rather than revenue? Can you explain why, when every major transparency group says this bill should be withdrawn, your government insists on pushing ahead?

Then there's the Human Rights Commission. Under this government the commission has been stacked with activists who are failing to do their jobs. The ANAO reported at the start of this year that the timeliness of the complaints-handling function, the commission's most important function, has been declining. At a time when antisemitism has reached unprecedented levels in our country, the commission has been MIA. We've seen shops trashed, cars burned and synagogues attacked. We've seen the mobs at the Sydney Opera House steps chanting 'gas the Jews' or 'where's the Jews', while law-abiding Australians were not able to go to their opera house. We've seen gangs driving through Caulfield boasting about hunting for Jews. We've seen the survivors of October 7—survivors of the worst loss of Jewish life since the Holocaust—abused on Australian soil. And what has the commission done? For months it could barely bring itself to mention antisemitism. It was more interested in the rights of protesters. The Race Discrimination Commissioner continues to refuse to condemn the antisemitic phrase 'from the river to the sea'. Its contractors and staff made shocking prejudiced remarks about Jewish Australians. Attorney, why is a commission that costs nearly $16 million failing to provide the very protection for the Australians it was created to defend? Why should taxpayers pay commissioners $400,000 salaries to ignore the needs of law-abiding Australians and instead undertake ideological pursuits? With the Jewish and Muslim communities now having their own specific antiracism envoys, and the Hindu Council of Australia calling for a Hinduphobia or Indiaphobia envoy, what is the ongoing purpose of the Race Discrimination Commissioner? Isn't this an indictment on the Race Discrimination Commissioner and the Human Rights Commission broadly? And does the Attorney maintain confidence in this Race Discrimination Commissioner?

I end with some important questions. Across the Attorney's portfolio, the story is the same: delays and disappointment. Attorney, will you fix the tribunal backlog? Will you withdraw your truth tax? Will you reform the Australian Human Rights Commission into a body that protects all Australians equally? And will you confront the failures you've inherited from your predecessor?

Tania Lawrence

Tania Lawrence Hasluck, Australian Labor Party

4:52 pm

Legal assistance is essential to ensuring access to justice and equality before the law, especially for vulnerable people facing disadvantage. The Albanese Labor government understands this, and I'm really pleased that, through the advocacy of our Attorney-General, the Albanese government will be investing $3.9 billion in support for frontline legal services, to be delivered over the next five years through the National Access to Justice Partnership. This new partnership with the states and territories commenced on 1 July this year. I was delighted to learn that this is the biggest single Commonwealth investment in legal services ever. I was even more delighted to learn that every part of the legal assistance sector will benefit from this new agreement. This includes the legal aid commissions, community legal centres, women's legal services, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander legal services and family violence prevention legal services.

In my electorate of Hasluck, we are lucky to have many organisations providing these vital supports to our community. One of these is the Midlas community legal centre. Based in Midland, Midlas provides legal assistance to the north-eastern Perth region. I meet with Angie Perkins, the CEO, on a regular basis, to talk about their work and to learn about the pressures that they are seeing in our community. Midlas has been providing legal assistance to the people of Perth for over three decades, and they are in a unique position to judge the challenges and the needs of people under stress. They talk to me about the challenges they face, not just with individual cases but with attracting and retaining staff, and about their caseloads and the importance of what they do to support some of those most vulnerable in our community.

Minister, community legal centres help some of our most vulnerable, and there are almost 200 community legal service centres operating across Australia. They provide the legal assistance and other advice to some of the most vulnerable in our community. Importantly, they are at the front line of working on prevention, particularly for those facing financial stress or having concerns about their status within their home where they may be renting as to understanding their legal rights. I think that preventive effort can't be underestimated in terms of its power in preventing escalation to, ultimately, what we see as violence. To that end, women who have escaped a violent partner can, with assistance, move on with their life safely. This is the kind of scenario that support services like Midlas provide. They also provide support to the older person who is being helped to address abuse from a relative and to the person who is being rehoused after being unfairly evicted. They have supported young people who have sought assistance to address mounting debt from unpaid fines. All of these people would agree that community legal centres are changing lives; they've changed their lives. We know that they're just one part of the legal assistance sector.

Domestic violence support services have also received further support. Domestic violence is a scourge that this government has been active in addressing and one that we must continue to hold in the light so that over time its incidence can be reduced. I'm proud to have initiated the DV Safe Phone program in my electorate office, where we've already received a steady flow of phones from constituents who understand the need and are happy to assist. There are more than 22 million unused phones in people's desks and drawers, and the more that offices of MPs and senators, at both the federal and state level, can be places where people can easily drop off those phones the better. The DV Safe Phone program repurposes used phones so that DV survivors can access communications in situations where they can't use their old phones. I've been amazed and honestly genuinely grateful for the response from my own constituents who have rallied to this cause and from the many federal members across the political spectrum who have joined in the effort in their own electorates. They are making a difference, and Midlas have reported to me that being able to have phones that they can provide to those who are fleeing domestic violence has been life changing.

An investment by government to combat domestic violence, of course, does make a difference. The work of our government is proving its worth. But, Minister, my question is: how will the National Access to Justice Partnership help reform the legal assistance sector, and, by extension, how does it help our community?

Henry Pike

Henry Pike Bowman, Liberal National Party

4:57 pm

I start by thanking the Attorney-General for being here today, in stark contrast to some of her colleagues. It is good that she is here because I've got an issue to raise in her portfolio in relation to a matter that is of great importance to my community. When you scan through the appropriation of the Attorney-General's portfolio, you'll see expenditure related to the native title system. You'll see new investments in the Native Title Tribunal and you'll see references to the goal of supporting native title representative bodies and native title service providers and proscribed body corporates within the native title system.

But what you won't find is any reference to supporting those entities that find themselves on the receiving end of a native title claim. In the previous coalition government's last budget, you would have found a very modest amount of funding for the Native Title Respondents Scheme, but you won't see that allocation within this appropriation. Why is this? Because of the ideological decision made by this government to abolish Commonwealth funding for respondents in native title claims. This was an ideologically driven decision and an unfair cut to achieve the longstanding pet policy objective of the former attorney-general, the member for Isaacs. It is a decision I implore the new attorney-general, if she's committed to representing all Australians equally, to revisit.

The Native Title Respondents Scheme provided grants of financial assistance to respondents in native title claims to help them meet their obligations under the federal act. Since the inception of the scheme, support has been provided to 469 pastoralists, 375 local governments, 319 fishers, 91 miners, eight recreational users and many others. In the grand scheme of the federal budget and even within the AG portfolio, this would be a small appropriation, but it is one that would make a significant difference to the community that I represent.

Redland City Council in my electorate is seeking clarity from the federal court to determine if native title has been extinguished on 2½ thousand council owned or managed sites within the Quandamooka coast native title claim area. The land in question includes some of my city's most iconic sites, such as the Wellington Point Reserve, the Cleveland Point Reserve, the Cleveland Cemetery, the Redlands Performing Arts Centre and even the council chambers themselves. It also includes countless nature reserves, playgrounds and other community assets.

Understandably, there is a growing level of community consternation about what a change of ownership on these land parcels would mean for how they are maintained, accessed and enjoyed by locals. The mounting costs of Redland City Council as a respondent to the Quandamooka Coast native title claim continues to place unreasonable pressure on planning and land use certainty and on the limited capacity of Redland City ratepayers and services. There are many sporting and community organisations who currently lease land off Redland City Council which now have had their tenure called into question due to this claim. There is a real risk that the Redlands native title claim will drag out in the courts for years, costing both sides millions and ultimately delivering poor outcomes for both our Indigenous and broader communities.

Two weeks of hearings took place last month, and more are due in December. But, as the matter progresses, the legal costs are growing and growing for Redland ratepayers. Figures from the Parliamentary Budget Office reveal that in the last decade there has been a huge funding discrepancy between Commonwealth money given to support claimants and money provided to assist with the legal obligations of defendants. Over the last decade, the federal government has provided $1.028 billion to support native title claimants but only $9.78 million to respondents, such as local governments, farmers and other organisations. Of course, this government has now abolished that funding altogether.

Will the Attorney-General appreciate the scale of this imbalance and take the action required to correct it? Unfortunately, there is clearly a sense from within the Labor government that stacking the deck in favour of native title claimants is a compassionate and progressive thing to do. I don't doubt the sincerity of their motives, but I simply can't agree that seeking to precontrive these outcomes is in the best interests of our communities across the country or even in the spirit of the act.

This should not be about ideology; this should be about fairness. The government's role should be ensuring that all stakeholders can meet their obligations under the federal act. In order to ensure a fair and equitable outcome, I ask the government to provide equal funding to support both claimants and respondents. Will the Attorney-General continue the ideological obsessions of a predecessor or reconsider the scrapping of the native title respondent funding scheme?

Susan Templeman

Susan Templeman Macquarie, Australian Labor Party

5:02 pm

I'm very pleased to be here to ask the Attorney-General to outline the importance of making sure the Administrative Review Tribunal is properly funded to fully support Australians who rely on our system of administrative review. The former government trashed the ART's predecessor, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. This is the body that reviews decisions of other government departments and agencies, critical decisions that impact on people's lives really profoundly. But, when the coalition was in government, it appointed 85 former Liberal MPs, staffers, candidates and mates to the AAT. Administrative review is an important part of our legal system. It's not a coalition consolation prize—something to be bestowed on people who may be past their use-by date in any other forum. The coalition didn't fund the AAT, and they didn't care about the AAT. They simply saw it as an opportunity for employment for their failed Liberal and National candidates—the hacks, the cronies, the mates. We saw this clearly, and that made the AAT dysfunctional. It did not give Australians confidence that their rights of review were being properly upheld.

Complaints from my constituents about how the AAT operated included the lengthy unacceptable delays, with some cases taking years to resolve, and a massive backlog awaiting hearing and consideration. In late 2022, the Albanese Labor government announced that we would completely transform Australia's system of administrative review by abolishing the AAT and creating the new ART. The ART reform progressed throughout 2023, and the new body commenced operations on 14 October 2024, almost a year ago today. The new tribunal has been designed to make sure that there is improved accessibility for users, that funding responds to demand and that there are more flexible procedures and more consistent processes across different case types. Mechanisms to effectively identify and deal with widespread issues are embedded in it, and there's funding for a new case management system.

I need to point out that appointments to the ART are also done very differently. Each recommended appointee has to be assessed as suitable for appointment by an independent assessment panel, through a transparent and merits based process conducted in accordance with guidelines for appointments to the tribunal. I was very much involved in this important reform and, along with the member for Curtin, who's in the chamber, I chaired the House committee that led one of the inquiries into the legislation. In a series of hearings, we took evidence about the need for the changes but also how the changes would work, and we examined how the legislation would meet the policy ambition.

The ART is built on more than 50 years of experience, learning and consultation. It draws on what we know works in a tribunal and it looked at what doesn't work. It fulfilled recommendations from the robodebt royal commission and several other inquiries, including the one I led and the 30 detailed submissions we considered.

I want to give one example of the feedback that the new ART has received. Now, no-one is suggesting that the process is flawless, but this comment came from Victoria Legal Aid during Refugee Week. They described it as providing fairer and more transparent decision-making. Victorian Legal Aid said:

Through the ART, all asylum seekers now have the opportunity to be heard. And importantly, all asylum seekers have the same rights as every other person to seek a full review of the merit of immigration decisions made about them.

Our Migration team has seen the immense impact of the establishment of the ART and investment in legal assistance on the lives of refugees and asylum seekers.

Building a merits review system that is fair, efficient and proportionate to the issues in contention is in Australia's best interest. Attorney-General, why were these reforms so important, and what is the government doing to progress further reform to ensure the efficiency of the ART?

Kate Chaney

Kate Chaney Curtin, Independent

5:07 pm

As part of these budget discussions, I'm going to focus on a part of the Attorney-General's portfolio that may seem dry but that strikes at the very heart of our democracy—that is, protecting and resourcing our accountability institutions. In the US at the moment we're seeing democratic institutions being undermined at an alarming rate. This includes executive overreach, independent agencies being white-anted and defunded, attacks on judicial independence, intentional weakening of civil society and the media, and the politicisation of law enforcement. I'm sure I'm not alone in watching on with horror and wondering how a proudly democratic country can change so fast.

Most Australians I speak to feel very grateful for our democracy, but in a time of global upheaval we must safeguard our own democratic institutions. We're fortunate to have a range of integrity agencies within the Attorney-General's portfolio that provide checks and balances to protect our democracy. These agencies are an essential part of our democratic architecture and make up the fourth arm of government—bodies such as the Ombudsman, the Auditor-General, the Information Commissioner and the National Anti-Corruption Commission. These agencies are safeguards against secrecy, overreach and corruption, but they cannot do their jobs if they're underfunded, politically stacked or denied access to the information they need, and unfortunately we're starting to see some signs of this.

This budget, while addressing many pressing needs, has failed to adequately fund and empower the agencies that were established with the mandate to keep government honest. Despite being in a better position than the US, we are facing what some experts have called an integrity deficit, a decade-long decline in funding for the agencies responsible for securing good governance. This budget was an opportunity to reverse that trend, but that opportunity has not been taken.

I want to talk about three aspects that need to be protected—independence, resourcing and oversight—and why we can't afford to put this off. Firstly, on independence, for us to trust that integrity agencies are doing their job, we must know that they're independent and unable to be influenced by government. How do you ensure that independence? Part of it involves looking at who these agencies report to. In Australia, many integrity agencies sit under a minister. They're part of the Public Service that reports to the executive, and this creates a conflict. These agencies should be staffed under legislation that reflects their independence and their role as offices of the parliament. If they reported to the parliament rather than the executive, there would be greater trust that they could hold the executive to account.

Second is resourcing. This is the part that's most directly relevant to the budget before the House. Integrity agencies cannot undertake their work if they're not funded to do so, and we're seeing too many examples of integrity agencies with declining resources. For example, the Ombudsman's funding will fall from $48 million this year to $37 million in 2028-29. Funding for the OAIC is also set to fall, from a high of $40 million to $26 million by the end of the forward estimates. Funding for the Human Rights Commission is set to fall, from $32 million last year to $28 million this year, with funding not expected to recover over the forward estimates. The DPP will see funding fall from $128 million this year to just $101 million next year, and even less in subsequent years. This decline in funding is absolutely unacceptable and should ring alarm bells.

The third element is oversight. We also need to acknowledge that parliamentary committees and oversight groups are often dominated by the government of the day, and that limits their effectiveness. But, if integrity agencies are truly independent and well resourced, they can then do what committees cannot—investigate fearlessly, speak truth to power and protect the public interest. These institutions should report to the parliament, not to the executive.

I've met with a range of experts, including the former Commonwealth ombudsman, Allan Asher, and the former head of the Consumers Federation of Australia, Robin Brown, who, along with academics, judges, advocates and former integrity practitioners, have developed a five-point reform plan. They have published an open letter—which I hope the Attorney-General has seen—which outlines a clear path forward. Some of the actions these experts have identified include making integrity agency offices of the parliament protected from government interference and guaranteeing sustained resourcing so they can hold government to account and are protected from retaliation. This is not about attacking anyone government; it's about futureproofing our democracy. I urge the Attorney-General to read, consider and respond to these asks.

Michelle Rowland

Michelle Rowland Greenway, Australian Labor Party, Attorney-General

5:12 pm

It is an incredible privilege to be here as first law officer in my first debate on the appropriations bill, and I do so with a profound sense of responsibility. At a time when democracy is being challenged, trust in our legal institutions and upholding the rule of law has never been more important. I thank the member for Hasluck for her questions and her comments on the National Access to Justice Partnership. I know she cares deeply about support for her community.

I want to comment for the information of the House that my first actual public facing engagement I wanted to be at a community legal centre, which I did up the road in Fremantle. I was delighted to do that. Shortly after, with the member for Melbourne, I visited a women's advocacy centre which also assists with legal rights. Along with my long-time friend the member for Macquarie, keeping our most vulnerable safe is a top priority, which is why we have engaged with her local community on important matters to do with the online environment and that space. It is absolutely correct, I'm sure you'll agree, that access to justice should not be determined by your postcode or your position in society. I want to foreshadow that I'll take a particular interest in the upcoming 12 months in particular in visiting rural and parts of Australia and understanding their specific needs when it comes to legal assistance. I will be delighted to visit the members electorate, if that can be accommodated, to understand those needs.

On 1 July this year, the Albanese government's $3.9 billion National Access to Justice Partnership commenced, and that's delivering critical support for frontline legal assistance services. It is the single biggest Commonwealth investment in legal assistance ever, representing a funding increase of nearly $800 million over five years for legal assistance. It is a landmark agreement. It will help to drive critical reforms in the legal assistance sector. It will also strengthen data capability and maturity of the sector, create a stronger and more sustainable workforce, and establish a robust framework to help progress actions towards closing the gap.

I also thank the member for Macquarie for her questions on the Administrative Review Tribunal, because as she rightly points out unlike the former government the Albanese government has done the hard work to clean up our system of administrative review by establishing the ART and restoring probity to the appointments process. There is a restoration at last on integrity into merits review. However its operational experience since October last year has shown that measures can be taken to further improve its efficiency while still preserving the ability of applicants to make their case. That's why I've brought forward amendments to the ART Act and the Migration Act to do a number of things, including requiring that student-visa refusal matters are considered by the tribunal on the papers—that is, without the need for an oral hearing. It allows the minister to prescribe other temporary visa classes for review on the papers, but I would note that reviewable protection decisions are expressly excluded. It provides the tribunal with a new broad discretion to dispense with oral hearings subject to a number of important caveats.

These measures will seek to provide the tribunal with the operational tools and flexibility it needs to progress merits reviews in a fair and efficient way. I would again point out that we are only now nearing the first anniversary of the operation of the ART. I'm sure that in the years to come we will see even more substantial outcomes as a result of those changes.

Finally I want to touch on another important reform that I introduced to parliament this morning. That is the establishment of a Commonwealth parole board. Australians rightly expect the release of offenders from custody into the community will be managed as safely as possible, and this measure that I have introduced will make the community safer. It will strengthen the Australian public's trust and confidence in the federal parole system by ensuring that decisions are made by experts who are best placed to make assessments of risks when considering the protection of the community, and that will be the highest priority for the board. For the information of the House, there are actually around 1,200 federal offenders serving sentences right across every state and territory, and that is actually more than the prison populations of the ACT and Tasmania combined. We are the last jurisdiction, as the Commonwealth, to have an independent adult-parole board, and the time for that has come. Decisions about parole should be made by panels of independent experts, not by politicians or bureaucrats. I look forward to the parliament supporting that.

In the short time I have available, I will continue to engage, as I am always very happy to do with the honourable member when it comes to the matters that she's raised. My colleagues from the opposition who asked other questions aren't here to hear the answers, but I will take that up with them separately. Thank you very much.

Proposed expenditure agreed to.

Melissa McIntosh

Melissa McIntosh Lindsay, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Women

5:18 pm

I rise to talk about the mismanagement and broken promises littered across the communications portfolio thanks to this Albanese Labor government. The Australian public are waiting on multiple responses to reports from the government in the communications portfolio. The Labor government has put the Murphy report into the harms of gambling on a shelf, gathering dust for more than two years now. We haven't heard a peep when it comes to the review of the Online Safety Act. It has been almost a year since the News Bargaining Incentive was announced. There's still no consultation paper. It seems the government is too scared of the US to want to make a move. We also have a failing NBN, with customers dropping off and prices rising in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis. Minister, what are you doing to get government responses published, and what work are you taking to ensure the NBN and all of your projects that you promised the Australian people are on track?

I want to raise the most critical issue on Australian families' minds, the state of the triple 0 network. It is our nation's most essential telecommunication service. Four people lost their lives during the triple 0 crisis on 18 September. As the shadow minister for communications, I will ensure that this Labor government takes this tragic event seriously. I note, in particular, that today the government voted down a select House committee inquiry into the triple-0-network ecosystem. That is shameful. We also had the Albanese Labor government vote down important amendments to the triple-0-network legislation today. Our coalition amendments would have doubled the maximum financial penalties for triple 0 outages from $10 million to $20 million; established a public triple-0-outage register to keep telcos accountable and to keep the public informed—transparency is so important; put the triple 0 system on the critical infrastructure list as the essential service which every Australian knows it is; and reduced the reporting times from six months to every three months and had those reports published so the public can see what is going on.

Not only did Optus fail but so did the minister, her department and the regulator, the Australian Communications and Media Authority. The minister says she didn't hear of the Optus outage until 19 September, but her office has an email from Optus on 18 September, as has ACMA and the department of communications. Government agencies didn't speak with each other, and they didn't pass on any information. And it gets worse. The minister and the chair of ACMA then finally held a press conference days later.

This plethora of failures, with a regulator being one party in this careless process, is why I find it completely inappropriate that the communications minister has appointed ACMA to review this Optus triple 0 outage and the triple 0 network. Essentially, the minister is allowing a government body to investigate itself. That's a joke. How can the minister have confidence in ACMA, given their failures and their involvement in the failed process?

The Bean review was ordered to look into the Optus 2023 outage to make sure it would never happen again. There were 18 recommendations, all of which were agreed to by the Albanese Labor government. We are now a full year and a half on from the report's handing down, but the minister evaded questions on which of the 18 recommendations have been implemented.

One recommendation was to have a triple 0 custodian with powers to ensure the entirety of the system is operational, effective and responsive. It's a pity that today she voted down my amendments in the House to safeguard our triple 0 system. The minister can blame everything on her being a new minister in this portfolio, but the fact remains that she, and she alone, was the custodian, and is still the custodian, of the industry. Her No. 1 job as communications minister is to ensure our most vital lifeline in anyone's time of need, right across the country, is in service.

Why was the minister in New York, doing a promo tour of another policy, when the PM was there representing our country? Minister, do you not think that you should have stayed to deal with the pressing matter of the public's complete lack of confidence in the Australian telecommunications industry's ability to provide the triple 0 services? And, Minister, will you promise the Australian people that you will never leave your post again as a minister in a time of national crisis?

Susan Templeman

Susan Templeman Macquarie, Australian Labor Party

5:23 pm

I'm very proud to be part of a government that places creativity back where it belongs, right at the heart of Australian society. I'm going to question the minister, who's responsible for this very large range of portfolio areas, and I'm going to focus on the arts part of the department. I want to ask for their thoughts on securing the future for Australian artists and other creatives.

Creativity is not a hobby or a luxury. It's essential to who we are as Australians. The arts enrich our wellbeing, bind our communities together and tell the story of who we are as a nation. It's why the Albanese government takes its responsibility to support the creative industry so seriously.

These appropriation bills embed that commitment in our national finances. They deliver crucial investments in people, in creativity, in memory and in imagination. When Revive was launched in 2023, the government committed to 85 actions. Seventy-one have already been delivered. The impact of that is being felt on the ground. In our first term, we allocated $199 million to Creative Australia to reverse funding cuts by the previous government and to expand its functions. This support allowed 50 per cent more small- to medium-sized organisations secure multiyear funding. Music Australia, First Nations Arts and Writing Australia are providing valuable new support and strategic leadership to the sector, while Creative Workplaces is addressing bullying, harassment and unfair pay.

We've also supported our national cultural institutions, which hold our collective memory and reflect our identity. Under the previous government they were left in crisis, with threadbare budgets and leaky roofs. We've provided $535.5 million to secure their future and the collections they safeguard. This funding has allowed them to plan with purpose and ambition, rather than worry about keeping the lights on. Through the Sharing the National Collection program, 21 suburban and regional galleries now display long-term loans from the National Gallery of Australia, including four extraordinary video works at the Blue Mountains Cultural Centre in my community.

Our screen industry not only gives voice to Australia's great stories; it provides thousands of jobs across acting and technical roles and in the small businesses who support them.

A division having been called in the House of Representatives—

Sitting suspended from 17:25 to 17:45

In our first term we boosted support for digital games developers, modernised the producer offset and increased the location offset to secure international productions.

These appropriation bills also deliver on our promise to restore funding to the ABC and SBS, with new five-year funding cycles, giving them the stability they need to commission Australian drama, comedy and children's shows. The central ambition of the National Cultural Policy is that there be a place for every story and a story for every place. That's why we established artist residencies at World Heritage sites across Australia. The Blue Mountains will host one of the first, with Jonathan Jones working on Wiradjuri country in the Gardens of Stone.

These bills deliver on the additional commitments that we made in the arts portfolio during the election. Live music venues are fundamental to our cultural life. During the election campaign we committed an additional $25 million to the Revive Live program, which has already supported 112 live music venues and festivals. The program provides practical support, such as funding for soundproofing, equipment upgrades and artist fees. When visiting Howler in the member for Wills's electorate recently, I saw the difference these grants are making to the versatility and viability of venues.

During the election campaign we also committed $12.5 million to restore South Melbourne Town Hall as the home of the Australian National Academy of Music. This builds on the $136 million uplift in funding for our national arts training organisations, who do the vital work of nurturing the next generation of Australian creative talent, and $35 million to support the transformation of the National Gallery of Victoria. We know there's more to do and we will do more.

Next year the National Cultural Policy will be evaluated and updated. This is the first time that a national cultural policy will have been delivered across its full plan term and updated in its second iteration. So I ask the minister: what opportunities does that create? Too often creative workers have been told to accept insecurity as the price of their calling. We don't accept that.

Anne Webster

Anne Webster Mallee, National Party, Shadow Minister for Regional Development, Local Government and Territories

5:47 pm

This evening I rise to speak about the Albanese government's failings within my portfolios, which have been further illuminated through the Senate estimates process. As the shadow minister for local government, I've met with local government representative bodies and councils from many parts of the country. Councils appreciate having a listening ear and a heart on this side of the House, to understand their issues, find solutions and advocate for them. Councils do not feel heard by the Albanese government and struggle to see a minister, let alone get a meeting with a staff member.

Local government is in peril. Smaller rural and remote councils face financial sustainability challenges that can seem insurmountable. They suffer considerable cost-shifting from the federal and state governments, resulting in ever-increasing responsibilities for programs and services that are not funded. This occurs in the context of limited sources of revenue, ageing infrastructure portfolios and many thousands of kilometres of roads. Councils are burdened by regulation and have limited access to untied, uncontested funds under this Labor government—and, for funds that are available, they require considerable co-contributions.

When the coalition asked the department how many councils were operating in deficit in the most recent financial year and how many were under administration, they responded that they don't have that information on hand, that they don't have that data, and that they would need to take it on notice. They admitted they have worked with state and territory governments on this sort of data in the past. Why, then, are they not doing it now? It is a question for the minister.

This sort of data is critical to understanding the differential financial challenges faced by local government. The Labor government's failure to extend funding of the Local Roads and Community Infrastructure Program, the LRCI program, a program overwhelmingly supported by local governments, further illustrates their failure to prioritise the needs of local government. Funding for this program ceases at the end of June 2026. Questioning in Senate estimates yesterday made it clear that the minister has not sought nor been provided with any advice by the department on an extension of the LRCI program.

A division having been called in the House of Representatives—

Sitting suspended from 17:50 to 18:02

Small rural and remote councils in electorates like Mallee and, indeed, other regional areas are desperate for untied, uncontested funds that don't require them to make huge co-contributions so that they can stay afloat and deliver the basic community infrastructure and road maintenance and upgrades that are sorely needed.

In regional communications, another part of the portfolio, it is tragic that it takes fatalities, like in the recent Optus triple 0 outages, to elevate an issue that many people in the regions face every day: inconsistent and unreliable mobile phone service—that's if there is any coverage at all—and the inability to contact emergency services when required. Regional Australians are still reeling from a botched 3G shutdown, which also sits squarely on Labor's shoulders after they failed to plan the shutdown appropriately with telcos. Minister for Communications Anika Wells is clearly out of her depth, with the Albanese Labor government's woefully inadequate response to regional telecommunications issues released in mid-September under the cover of 2035 emissions reductions targets.

Regional Australians have been insulted and disconnected by the overdue government response to the Regional Telecommunications Independent Review Committee report and the short consultation timeframe on its universal outdoor mobile obligation, UOMO, proposal. Minister Wells committed no new funding to improving regional connectivity in her response to the RTIRC report and kicked the UOMO can down the road till 2028. Regional Australians have been left with no clear signal on whether Labor will fix regional connectivity at all in this term of office.

Proposed expenditure agreed to.

Alex Hawke

Alex Hawke Mitchell, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Industry and Innovation

6:05 pm

I rise today to speak to the industry appropriations. Clearly, the government's announcement today of the bailout of Glencore shows its ongoing instinct to continue using the taxpayer's balance sheet to bail out companies across Australia that are struggling to keep their operations open in many important sectors like smelting, manufacturing and heavy industry. The problem with this approach is that it isn't the last of the bailouts that the government will have to do. They have already committed billions of dollars for Whyalla, there have been hundreds of millions of dollars for Nyrstar, and today there is $600 million for Glencore. The Prime Minister outlined today in the House that that's 600 direct jobs. By any analysis, that is $1 million per job. That's an expensive bailout.

What the government is failing to do, through its programs in the industry portfolio, is outline its plan to reduce costs for important industry players in Australia. The cost structures are what is driving the process. And it hasn't stopped with Glencore. Other companies, we now know, have their hands out, saying to government, 'We need large amounts of taxpayer money to continue our operations in Australia.' We ask: why is the government ignoring industry's No. 1 concern? The No. 1 reported concern over a long time now has been and continues to be energy pricing for industrial and manufacturing users in Australia. That's the No. 1 concern. If they cannot solve their cost-structure problem with energy, they will not be able to compete.

Then there are considerations like the tax settings in Australia, the regulatory settings, the cost of doing business in Australia. We won't talk today about the industrial framework—I'm sure that will be talked about at another time—but we have the world's highest wages and we have high costs in other areas. We need competitive areas as well so that businesses and their operations can compete in Australia. That's what's required. Energy used to be our competitive advantage. The government, by not addressing domestic gas reserves and competitive energy pricing for industry, is causing the ongoing need for companies to come to government.

Of course, we understand there are world factors. The government will talk about world factors and say, 'There are state actors manipulating particular metals.' Well, sure, that may happen, and it may come about, but we can only control what we can control here domestically, and what we can control are things like energy pricing, availability, affordability and reliability. What we can control is our cost structures here that allow industry to compete against things like state-sponsored manipulation of different metals and other markets.

While we accept the government has to bail out companies, the numbers are getting staggering in terms of money and value proposition. And, as many people have pointed out, the corporations behind many of these operations are highly profitable corporations internationally. They're paying large dividends. There is a grave responsibility that comes when the government hands out this much taxpayer money to highly profitable corporations, and that responsibly must be a return for the Australian people. So we ask the government to outline what they are actually going to do. Why are they ignoring industry's continuing advice that energy pricing is their No. 1 concern? What is their actual plan for industry to make them compete better so that we don't have to use taxpayer money to bail them out? One million dollars per job today is a very expensive bailout from the taxpayer.

In other areas, the government continues to repurpose the money in the National Reconstruction Fund. We ask the government: how can the National Reconstruction Fund meet its charter or mission given to it in legislation if the minister takes $5 billion out of it for its climate target program? That wasn't the purpose of the money in the National Reconstruction Fund. And it's not the first time the fund has been raided, directed, changed or modified. How will the National Reconstruction Fund do its job when $5 billion of its mandate is removed by the minister and allocated elsewhere?

Clearly Labor has no plan. Clearly, when we look at the Future Made in Australia program, we're now seeing not only the traditional industries like aluminium smelters needing bailouts and all of the things we're seeing in the matters I spoke about but also, as we saw recently, advanced manufacturers, like lithium ion battery manufacturers with government handouts, going into receivership. We say to the government: where are the new green jobs if we cannot manufacture advanced lithium ion batteries and have those companies succeed? We're paying out both ways. We're paying out with the collapse of our industry but also with the bailouts. The government needs to have a plan for cheaper operations in Australia, and we ask the government: what is that plan?

Tom French

Tom French Moore, Australian Labor Party

6:10 pm

When you talk about the strength of the Australian economy, you cannot look past the resources, industry and science sectors. They are the envy of the world. These are the engines of productivity, the creators of jobs and the foundation of our national resilience. Let's be blunt. These things don't run on opposition critiques. They run on investment, planning and a government with the backbone to build the future, not just romanticise the past. Mining is not just about holes in the ground and high-vis. It is about prosperity, schools, hospitals and roads, paid for by the royalties and taxes from our resource sector. More than 317,000 Australians are employed in mining, including over 5,000 people in my electorate of Moore. It's a big reason why the Western Australian economy is so strong.

But the future isn't just digging and shipping. It's about value-adding here in Australia. That's why the Albanese Labor government has committed $17.5 billion to a new Critical Minerals Production Tax Incentive. Lithium, cobalt and rare earths—these aren't just rocks. They are the backbone of clean energy technology and defence capability. For Moore, that means more secure well-paid jobs and a future made right here in WA. That's investment in training, renewables and cultural infrastructure—more on that in my first speech.

To those opposite who sneer at government investment, let's remember this. It wasn't the free market that built Australia's steel industry. It wasn't the free market that anchored our aluminium smelters. It was Labor governments with the guts to back industries essential to national strength. Today, it is Labor again backing the next wave of nation-building industries.

Global supply chains for these minerals are volatile. We've seen it with nickel and lithium. That's why we're establishing the $1.2 billion Critical Minerals Strategic Reserve. This is not a nice-to-have. It's about sovereignty. It means Australia won't be left at the altar when international markets get cold feet. Let's not forget: WA is the world's largest lithium producer. Towns like Greenbushes and Kwinana are living proof of what's possible when we do more than just dig and ship—we refine, we process and we create jobs at home. Labor's vision is clear—a future made in Australia. By investing in advanced manufacturing, we're ensuring that Western Australians don't just dig up the raw materials but also capture the downstream industries. That's how we build resilience and opportunities.

Stakeholders from across Moore, from the Chamber of Commerce and Industry WA to local business in Carine and Kallaroo, see it. They know it's not just about mines. It's about making sure our kids and grandkids have industries to work in that don't even exist today. That takes a government that thinks ahead, a government with grit. That takes a Labor government. The other side can talk about letting the market decide, but we've seen what that means: jobs offshored, industries hollowed out and communities left behind. Not on our watch!

Before I came to this place, I was an industrial lawyer fighting for workers, and I'll tell you this: only Labor governments back workers. Backing workers means investing in the jobs of tomorrow. You can't build a future without science. Our partnership of nearly half a billion dollars with the US Geological Survey on the Landsat Next satellite project will ensure Australia remains a global leader in earth sciences. Closer to home, Edith Cowan University in Joondalup is driving breakthroughs in cybersecurity, medical research and space science. They are training the next generation of Western Australians for high-skilled jobs that we haven't yet imagined.

Digital transformation is not a buzzword. It's the battleground for competition. If you fall behind, you don't just lose contracts; you lose industries. Whether it's innovation in Joondalup, med-tech breakthroughs at ECU or small-business growth across suburbs like Currambine and Kingsley, the digital economy is creating real jobs, right here in Moore, and that's why we're backing R&D hubs and international partnerships.

Why are we doing this? Because it delivers for people, for families, in my electorate of Moore. It means a kid in Woodvale can study at ECU, step straight into a high-paying job in cyber or advanced manufacturing and build a life without leaving their community. It means local businesses can diversify, compete and thrive. That's the difference. Labor builds the future; the opposition just comments on it. We're not here to sit on the sidelines and wring our hands. We're here to make sure the benefits of Australia's resources industry and science flow to every community, including Moore.

Andrew Willcox

Andrew Willcox Dawson, Liberal National Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Manufacturing and Sovereign Capability

6:15 pm

Australia's strength is in the resources sector, in which 1.1 million Australians work directly or indirectly. Labor have presided over three years of resources projects, manufacturing hubs and industrial capacity closing down, thanks to their anti-investment, anti-jobs resources policy and their reckless race-to-renewables energy policy. The safeguard mechanism has only weakened Australia's ability to compete, and companies are now making conscious decisions to cease investing in Australia and, even worse, to close their doors.

Alongside this, Labor's reckless race to a renewables-only policy is driving mining and manufacturing projects offshore. In the last three years, we've seen Australia's nickel industry collapse, industrial smelters and refineries pushed to the verge of collapse, gas prices skyrocketing, energy costs going through the roof and coalmines closing their doors. And Labor fails on securing future supply chains for our critical minerals. Nickel West, Nightstar, Mount Isa Mines, BMA, Bowen Coking Coal—these are just some of the crucial resources companies that have suffered under Labor's anti-mining agenda. In fact, just last week, Alcoa shut their alumina refinery in the resources minister's own backyard—a damning indictment of her government, which is killing Australian industry.

This is costing thousands of Australian jobs. We should be, rightly, concerned about the current approach from the Albanese Labor government. It is clear that they are either asleep at the wheel or wilfully allowing our industrial and economic base to go offshore. The minister for climate change and the minister for industry must explain why their policy decisions, supported by their cabinet colleagues, have come at the cost of Australian jobs, investment and prosperity.

Minister, how many more Australian jobs will be lost before you take action? How many more industries will collapse before you update our Critical Minerals Strategy? When will the price of Australian gas be lower than $12 a gigajoule? Will you guarantee no gas blackouts on the east coast? Can our allies and trading partners like Korea and Japan continue to rely on Australia to deliver our crucial coal and gas supplies?

The Bruce Highway is more than just a road. It is the backbone of our regional economy and a critical link for manufacturing, freight and sovereign capability right across the state. Yet it remains one of the most dangerous and unreliable transport corridors in the country, especially in my electorate of Dawson, where we see flooding, accidents and closures. These events bring industry and supply chains to a grinding halt. They leave communities stranded and businesses counting the cost. This government made a promise of $7.2 billion for the Bruce Highway, but, as Senate estimates have revealed—we've learnt the truth—only $432 million is actually on the table over the next three years. So I ask the minister: will you commit to a clear, transparent timeline for the delivery of the $7.2 billion for the Bruce?

Our sovereign capability is being neglected. In 2023 the Labor government stripped more than $1.2 billion from the space industry. This government has abandoned the programs that would have built Australian satellites, created advanced manufacturing jobs and strengthened our national security. That's not just short-term thinking; it's a reckless gamble with our nation's future. In Dawson we're already showing what's possible. In Bowen, Gilmour Space Technologies have launched their first rocket, the first launch ever from Australian soil. It's proof that we can design, build and launch right here at home. It's proof that we can lead in the most advanced industries in the world. But imagine what we could do if the government backed this industry. When will the government restore the vital funding it stripped from our space industry and seized the opportunities to secure the future? Given the news today on the Glencore bailout, when will the minister commit to an inquiry into the health of the metals manufacturing industry in Australia? We've asked for a Senate inquiry in the past, and that was voted down when Labor teamed up with the Greens. We need this to happen. (Time expired)

Zaneta Mascarenhas

Zaneta Mascarenhas Swan, Australian Labor Party

6:20 pm

I'd like to let the Federation Chamber know that the proud Australian Labor Party back workers, we back jobs and we do that by backing industry. That includes mining and manufacturing. We are doing this in buckets and spades. We believe in a future made in Australia with Australian industry, Australian innovation and Australian resources. And you know what? We haven't just learnt that manufacturing is fashionable, unlike some coalition backbenchers in recent history. This is something that we fundamentally believe. We believe it because we believe in a future made in Australia. It's not a slogan. It's backed by real investment, real jobs and real opportunities, especially for my state in Western Australia. I'm proud to be here with the Minister for Resources, who is also a proud Western Australian.

Speaking of the resources sector, it is the engine room of our economy, so much so that across Australia we see over 300,000 Australians working in mining. Their hard work helps with our national prosperity. WA is leading the way in critical minerals like lithium and rare earths—minerals that are essential for a clean energy transition. To support this, the Albanese government is investing $28 billion into the critical minerals sector. This includes $5 billion for the Critical Minerals Facility and $17 billion for the deduction tax credits. These funds will help Aussie businesses process minerals right here in Australia while creating secure, well-paid jobs, making us a key player in global supply chains.

We're also setting up a critical minerals strategic reserve with $1.2 billion to make sure that Australia stays strong during market disruptions. This is a smart policy that is thinking about how we participate in global markets while protecting Australian jobs. This also includes national agreements and stockpiling to make sure that we look after our stockpiles.

Let's talk about manufacturing. The National Reconstruction Fund is about backing a future made in Australia. Companies like Myriota are receiving federal support to grow satellite technology and create highly skilled jobs. It's about keeping talent and technology right here in Australia.

We're also investing in green industries. The $500 Green Iron Investment Fund will help WA use its renewable energy and iron ore to produce green iron, cutting emissions and creating new job opportunities. Let's think about it—this is really smart. We've got amazing resources under the ground, as the mighty Minister for Resources has said before, but we've also got resources above the ground. It's about connecting these things together. Australia can play a really important role in the green iron industry. Also, it's not just about iron. It's also about aluminium. This goes along with our $2 billion in the green aluminium production credit to assist Australia's aluminium smelters as they transition.

Battery manufacturing is another big win. With $500 million going through the Battery Breakthrough Initiative, WA can lead the way in supplying the world with clean energy storage using our critical minerals and renewable power. We're already seeing federal investment take shape in many exciting areas. Batteries are getting faster and safer and are lasting longer thanks to Australian innovation backed by this government.

Some opposition MPs have described electric vehicles as soulless. I tell you, when you get behind an electric car and you feel the torque, not only does it have soul; it's got speed as well. We're not stopping there. The Industry Growth Program is helping over 1,000 local businesses scale up. Science and research are key as well. We've invested $14 billion in R&D this year, including $45 million to support CSIRO's world-class research. We're reviewing our R&D system to make it more connected and more effective, because innovation drives productivity and resilience.

The thing I believe about Australia is that not only do we have the ingenuity; we also have the resources. But we have to make sure that we have a government that backs manufacturing, backs workers and backs the resource sector.

Simon Kennedy

Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party

6:25 pm

It's good to hear the member for Swan there—an engineer. She has a lot of learning. Perhaps the Prime Minister, if he's watching, could put the member for Swan in the energy portfolio, because God knows we need an engineer in that portfolio. They call it the Future Made in Australia, but I worry it's more like the 'future bailed out in Australia'. Unfortunately we've been unable to supply affordable reliable power to so much of Australian manufacturing, be that FJP Manufacturing in my electorate, where they've seen their energy prices go up 41 per cent last year alone, or HF Powdercoating in my electorate, who have seen their gas prices go up 45 per cent. Both of those businesses have seen their energy prices increase over 60 per cent in the last two years alone.

We're not just seeing it in the local businesses in Cook. We're seeing it right across Australia, because at the moment taxpayer cheques are being used to keep companies on life support. We've just seen that recently in Queensland, where the Commonwealth has had to cobble together a package of up to $600 million to keep Glencore's Mount Isa copper smelter and the Townsville refinery open. This is something that should be competing on low-energy prices. It should be competing on it's own two feet, but this government has crippled industry. It's crippling SME businesses in my electorate. They're coming to me. I've toured both of those facilities, seen what they do. I've seen the tens of apprentices they employ every single year. They're working hard with slimmer and slimmer margins to keep these things open, but unfortunately they are up against it and almost closing, as is this big refinery in Queensland.

The refinery in Queensland supports about 600 jobs. That's 600 people who would be out of work if it weren't for government subsidies. Unfortunately we're not investing in sovereignty. We're investing in subsidy dependency. We are training Australia's businesses to be dependent on this government, to be dependent on the government teat. These businesses want to stand on their own two feet. They want to compete internationally, but unfortunately they've got one hand tied behind their back. They're fighting the good fight, but this government is not helping them. Even the Productivity Commission and industry stakeholders have flagged the Future Made in Australia and said it has vague criteria and has a protectionist tilt. We should be competing on productivity, cost and reliability, not on bailouts. Reports indicate that the combined federal and state support aimed at starving off the closure of the smelter and refinery in Mount Isa and Townsville are tied to costs and market conditions. If we had globally competitive energy and if we had globally competitive industrial relations, we would not need emergency public money to keep these businesses open. We wouldn't need subsidies for households or small businesses just to pay their energy bills.

It's not only manufacturing that's suffering. There are reports that energy could double in the next few years for artificial intelligence, and it's going to be a defining force for this century. I think everybody can agree on that, and it's going to be every bit as transformative as the internet was. Could you imagine the competitive position Australia would have been left in if we had invested more and faster in the internet when it came about? Unfortunately with AI we actually look like we're being left behind. This entirely new frontier of economic growth is not being embedded in Australian workplaces as fast as it is in the US or parts of Europe. It's going to disrupt and grow manufacturing, health, logistics and finance, and it's happening now. The pace of change is accelerating. The only question is: how much will Australia participate in that versus being left behind?

The Tech Council of Australia estimates AI could deliver $115 billion to our GDP by 2030. It could increase productivity by a percentage point. But it's a contest. This is a globally competitive contest, and what is this government doing about it? The uncomfortable truth is that, under Labor, we're slipping behind. The reality is that AI can't be powered by speeches, it can't be powered by slogans and, unfortunately for Chris Bowen, it can't be powered by press conferences either. It depends on hard infrastructure, a skilled workforce and, again, reliable, low-cost energy.

This is one of the big reasons that, at COP29—we're trying to get the next COP—31 nations, including the US, the UK, Canada, France, Germany and Korea, all signed up to tripling nuclear power by 2050. And it's not just these countries; it's some of the most progressive and innovative companies in the world, from Google and Microsoft to Amazon. They are all looking at investing in and building nuclear. (Time expired)

Andrew Charlton

Andrew Charlton Parramatta, Australian Labor Party, Cabinet Secretary

6:30 pm

It is very difficult to sit here and listen to the Liberal Party give us a lecture on Australia's economic policy. That's because the Liberal Party, over their recent history, have always got the big calls in Australian economic policy wrong. Let's remember that it was the Liberal Party that opposed the floating of the dollar in the 1980s. They opposed superannuation in the 1990s. They voted against the fiscal stimulus that saved Australia from recession in the global financial crisis. It was the Liberal Party that voted against the NBN in the 2000s. It was the Liberal Party that allowed the car industry—indeed, they dared the car industry—to leave in the 2010s. It was the Liberal Party that failed on any measure of budget repair during their nine years in office. They were unable to deliver a single budget surplus. It was the Liberal Party that opposed the energy transition and, in fact, were only able to produce 22 discarded energy policies.

When it comes to looking for Liberal Party bad calls on the economy, it is, as they say, a target-rich environment. You might think that it would've learned its lesson, but, unfortunately, the Liberal Party is still damaging Australian industry from opposition. Like one of those zombies that never dies, it's still reaching from two horrific electoral defeats to continuing to oppose the Labor government's policies in a number of areas.

Firstly, the Liberal Party has been opposing the NRF. This is despite the fact that the NRF has invested $660 million in local manufacturing. We are yet to hear whether the coalition support or oppose this support, despite the fact that the NRF has allocated $1 billion to critical technologies for Australia's future. The second way in which the coalition have been damaging Australian industry policy is by undermining investment certainty. This is nowhere more significant than on energy policy. You can't promote investment in Australian industry with uncertainty in energy policy. It's impossible for businesses to invest if they don't know the energy policy settings and they don't know the price of subsequent energy. But in this country, at the moment, we have a Liberal Party that is reducing the certainty that Australian business has on energy policy. On the one hand, they've got the leader, who is talking about sticking with net zero. They've got Barnaby Joyce, who is talking about leaving net zero. Today, just after question time, the member for Flynn gave us a highly entertaining but factually very bereft lecture on the causes of climate change. The member for Flynn told us that climate change is happening—he'll accept that; he does have a thermometer—but that it's not caused by humans. In his words, it's caused by 'natural fluctuations'.

How can Australian industry plan for the future if they have absolutely no certainty about the energy policy that would be coming from the alternative Australian government and if they can't even see the alternative Australian government agreeing on whether climate change is caused by humans or not? This uncertainty has real consequences. The uncertainty in energy policy that the coalition has produced over the last 15 years has reduced investment in the energy sector in generation and in transmission. The member for Cook came into this chamber just a few minutes ago and explained to us that many businesses in his electorate are suffering higher energy prices. Well, he should ask his colleagues why they failed to invest in generation and transmission during the nine years that they were in office.

Today, the minister for industry made an important decision to protect Australian smelters, specifically the Mount Isa smelter. What we've seen just in the last 10 minutes has been extraordinary disarray on the part of the coalition. I was sitting in this very seat listening to the member for Dawson, who said it was a good idea that finally we had stepped up and the government was supporting the smelters but we needed to outline our plan for the rest of the sector. It is terrific to have the member for Dawson's support. I just wish he'd remained in the chamber for five minutes to listen to his colleague the member for Cook, who said these industries should be standing on their own two feet. He described today's announcement as a symptom of subsidy tendency and opposed the support that the government has provided to the Mount Isa smelter. Again, on issue after issue, the coalition is in absolute disarray. (Time expired)

Nicolette Boele

Nicolette Boele Bradfield, Independent

6:35 pm

This is my first opportunity to participate in a detailed debate regarding Appropriation Bill (No. 1) 2025-2026, and in fact I was not a member in this place when the bills that are currently being debated were introduced. I approached this debate in the spirit of what the people of Bradfield have sent me here to do, and, very specifically, that is to hold this government to account. This very debate could not be more appropriate for setting about that task.

First, here is a bit about me and where I come from in my line of questioning: I have been appointed to two parliamentary committees because the scope of those committees is so close to my professional work of 35 years and because it's where I believe we can achieve outcomes to strengthen our economy and our national security now and help set up Australia in our region for this century. Those committees are the Standing Committee on Climate Change, Energy, Environment and Water and theStanding Committee on Industry, Innovation and Science. My professional choices have been based around my learned belief that, with the appropriate government signals, such as what we choose to tax and how we de-risk capital, and appropriate competition and consumer protections, science industry and business can and should be the engine room for our economy.

I want to use this opportunity to commend the government for designing and passing the Future Made in Australia set of laws last term. It was both defensive and opportunistic—defensive because of the actions of the then Biden administration, which sought to retool its economy via the Inflation Reduction Act. The North American act saw businesses from Australia, already in this depleted secondary sector, leave our shores for the United States because the conditions for investment and government offtakes were more favourable there than here in Australia. The FMIA was designed to help keep our nascent clean industries here in Australia, and, with the Trump administration curtailing the IRA and adding tariffs, the FMIA has proven to be an opportunistic move, where we are now in a position to welcome those businesses back and, indeed, new ones to our shores. I don't have to tell you, Assistant Minister, that the beauty of the FMIA is that, done well, we can build the scale of clean industrial power needed to decarbonise our critical and other mineral commodities ahead of export. In doing so, we not only deliver ridiculously cheap and reliable energy for our nation; we also help to decarbonise the global resources economy.

The FMIA feels to me like the opposite of approving the extension to the North West Shelf gas project. That project will see our nation export decades of unmitigated climate pollution to our region whilst the FMIA in contrast is about substituting the export of raw resources, such as iron ore, to South Korea, China and Japan for boatloads of green iron to those same countries. This green iron will be built on low-emissions renewable energy, free from the price shocks and supply constraints caused by international conflict and also built by Australians participating in meaningful, clean regional jobs. When I say that I want to hold the government to account on this, what I mean is that I really want to make sure that these good ideas—the FMIA, the Reconstruction Fund, the National Battery Strategy, the Industry Growth Program, the Cooperative Research Centres Program and the Research and Development Tax Incentive—are delivered to the maximum benefit of the people of Bradfield and, in fact, all Australian communities. That's why I've chosen to ask these questions of you today, Assistant Minister, and there will be many more of these during my remaining term in the 48th Parliament.

This question is aimed at understanding how we can utilise the National Battery Strategy and the FMIA to build domestic manufacturing capabilities in cooperation with international partners: Firstly, how can this government use the NRF to partner with world battery manufacturing leaders to build both battery manufacturing and battery recycling capacities here in Australia? Secondly, how can the government, through increased manufacturing, leverage the massive demand pull for battery electrification of the mining equipment fleet here in Australia? Thirdly, how does the assistant minister plan to work across portfolios, such as with Treasury, to raise awareness and advocate for remedies to current government policies that run counter to the objectives of these otherwise laudable industry initiatives—namely, the $12 billion annual subsidy for expensive, high emissions, imported diesel, where it's used by local and multinational miners in mining equipment? If the government is to truly deliver on the opportunities that are latent within these industry initiatives, these are the sorts of cross-departmental roadblocks that need your attention and stewardship, Assistant Minister.

Madeleine King

Madeleine King Brand, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Northern Australia

6:40 pm

I just want to quickly acknowledge the contribution of the member for Parramatta. I won't repeat it, but I do appreciate his efforts in pointing out the evident cognitive dissonance that persists across the Liberal and National coalition in relation to the Department of Industry, Science and Resources and its budget and what it is endeavouring to do for this country. We saw the member for Mitchell point out, in the finest traditions of the Liberal Party, how they would clearly rather abandon Mount Isa copper, just as they abandoned the car industry in Victoria and South Australia and just like they abandoned the workers of the BP oil refinery in Kwinana, and no doubt that is just what they would like to continue to do.

But that is not what this government will do. We will continue to deliver on our commitments to Australia, and the budget that we are presenting builds on measures in our government's first term by supporting our industry, science and resources sector. The government is determined to make sure Australia can seize opportunities for new industries and the technologies and investment they bring as part of a global shift to net zero. We are backing our resources sector and we are backing our manufacturing industries. We will make Australia stronger, at a time of global uncertainty, by developing our critical national assets and by adding value.

In my resources portfolio, no Australian government has committed more to strengthen the resources sector. We have introduced the $17.6 billion Critical Minerals Production Tax Incentive. Of course, the coalition voted against that. That incentive will provide a refundable tax offset of 10 per cent for eligible Australian processing and refining costs for those minerals on the critical minerals list. We're establishing a critical minerals strategic reserve. That will mean government has the power to purchase, own and sell critical minerals found here in Australia, and it will take more risk out of investment in that all-important sector. Our Critical Minerals Strategy makes it clear that we want to process critical minerals and rare earths here, to boost manufacturing and jobs here at home and diversify global supply chains. Australia and the world need our critical minerals and rare earths if we are to curb greenhouse emissions and avoid catastrophic climate change. It is really important to understand that these commodities are also essential for defence technologies. Australia and our partners need critical minerals and rare earths to build the latest submarines, the latest aircraft and, indeed, the upgraded Japanese Mogami-class frigates that this government has selected for the Royal Australian Navy. I am determined and this government is determined to ensure Australia can build our sovereign capability to process those minerals and metals for the benefit of the Australian people but also for the security of our partners in the region. As we know, positioning our resources industry for a brighter, more sustainable future also depends on discovering new deposits, and that's why we've committed $3.4 billion to support one of the finest institutions in this country, Geoscience Australia, through the Resourcing Australia's Prosperity program. It's literally showing us what this country is made of. It will give us a clearer picture of our mineral, energy and groundwater potential. Now, all of these measures, combined with our extra contributions to the Northern Australia Infrastructure Facility, the Critical Minerals Facility, Export Finance Australia and the National Reconstruction Fund add up to $28 billion of investment by the Australian government in the future of Australia's critical minerals.

On gas, we are currently reviewing the regulations around the gas market. It is a very important body of work in which there is great interest and much participation. We need to make sure there is adequate supply of affordable gas for the east coast so that there is stronger energy security for households and for industry. We are working on those regulations and the critical minerals reforms in a calm, methodical way in consultation with industry trading partners and all stakeholders.

The $15 billion National Reconstruction Fund will continue to invest in firms and projects to drive diversification and transformation across the seven priority areas of the economy. I note the very successful equity investment by the NRF in the Liontown Kathleen Valley lithium mine in the Northern Goldfields of Western Australia—the world's first underground mine of such a magnitude. It's a remarkable achievement by Liontown, and the NRF has been a very important part of it.

The Albanese government believes in Australia, our people and our industry. Our geological endowment, combined with the know-how, work ethic and ambition of our people, is the deep seam from which we will extract our future prosperity. This will be made possible by this government's policies and by the investments we're making in the budget papers here today.

Proposed expenditure agreed to.

Andrew Wallace

Andrew Wallace Fisher, Liberal National Party, Shadow Cabinet Secretary

6:46 pm

I rise to speak on the systemic failings of the Albanese government in the Home Affairs portfolio. This portfolio should be the foundation of our national security, our border integrity and the public's confidence that their government can keep them safe. That is government's first and most important responsibility. Instead, it has become a symbol of mismanagement, confusion and weakness.

The Department of Home Affairs was created in 2017 by the coalition. It was designed to bring together our key domestic security agencies. It coordinates counterterrorism, immigration, border protection, law enforcement, cybersecurity and emergency management under one strategic umbrella. I'm very privileged to be the deputy chair of the PJCIS, which oversees many of these agencies. Home affairs was designed to ensure information was shared, decisions were swift and Australia's defences were united. It worked because it had focus, discipline and accountability. But, since Labor took office, that discipline has been dismantled. The government has treated home affairs like a political experiment. It's rearranging its structure without strategy and without purpose. What was once the cornerstone of national security has been reduced to bureaucratic chaos.

The clearest example of this incompetence was the High Court ruling on indefinite detention known as the NZYQ case. It was an avoidable legal and political disaster caused by this government's own actions. You'd remember that over 150 detainees were released into the community, including convicted rapists, child sex offenders and murderers. Some have reoffended since they've been released into the community. The then minister made a reckless concession to the High Court that these individuals were being held in indefinite detention when he did not have to make that concession. His decision tied the hands of the High Court and triggered a chain of events that endangered communities across this country. Whether that was through arrogance or incompetence, the outcome remains the same. It was a serious public safety failure that should never have happened. What was the government's response? It was confusion, panic and the ultimate—albeit very long, slow and painful—reshuffle. The member for Hotham and the member for Scullin were quietly shifted on to new portfolios as if Australians would forget the consequences of their actions. That is not accountability; it is political cowardice.

Fast forward to now. The Prime Minister has handed the Home Affairs portfolio to the member for Watson, who's already carrying a pretty heavy load, one would think. The member Watson is now responsible for Home Affairs, immigration, cybersecurity, the arts and still serves as Leader of the House. He is, by definition, a part-time Home Affairs minister. That is not a serious model for national security. It is a recipe for divided attention and diminished leadership.

Since his appointment, we have seen this government approve the entry of almost 3,000 people from war-torn Gaza without appropriate ASIO vetting. Visas were issued in as little as 24 hours, when such checks can take weeks, if not months. Some have since had their visas cancelled after proper screening. That is not compassion; that is negligence. Minister, for those who have allegedly committed offences since being released from detention by this government, what does the government plan to do with them after they are released from prison, assuming— (Time expired)

Gabriel Ng

Gabriel Ng Menzies, Australian Labor Party

6:51 pm

I rise to speak on the Albanese Labor government's commitment to multicultural Australia. When we on this side speak about multicultural Australia, we are not treating minorities as an afterthought when we make policy. We govern for modern Australia in all its diversity and richness. We govern for all Australians, regardless of their background. Australia has always been a multicultural country. Aboriginal Australia has a rich diversity of nations, with over 250 mobs. Australia has been built by British settlers, Chinese miners, Afghan cameleers, Sikh Anzacs and Italian, Greek and Indian migrants—people from every country on earth.

The Albanese Labor government believes that Australia's diversity is one of our greatest strengths. It brings ingenuity, wisdom, fresh perspectives and competition. It expands the marketplace of ideas. You only need to look at this side of the House, particularly at the new members of parliament, to see that our government is committed to reflecting the diversity of our community. We are one of the most successful multicultural countries on earth, and this did not happen by accident. It has been shaped by decades of policy, by communities who have worked tirelessly and by Labor governments who have recognised the value of inclusion and social cohesion.

Last week I was fortunate to have the Minister for Multicultural Affairs in Menzies, the electorate I'm lucky enough to represent, meeting with some of our local business associations and owners. For the first time, this government has appointed a dedicated minister for multicultural affairs to cabinet. This elevation shows how seriously this government takes its responsibility to multicultural Australia. The creation of the Office for Multicultural Affairs within government further strengthens our ability to coordinate policy and deliver tangible outcomes across all levels of government—federal, state and local. They are not just symbolic gestures. They are structural changes designed to ensure that multicultural policy is embedded in the heart of decision-making. They mean that the experiences, challenges and aspirations of multicultural communities will be heard where it matters most—in the cabinet.

We have also initiated the 2024 Multicultural Framework Review—the first in-depth examination of Australia's multicultural policies and programs in 50 years. This review will help shape the next generation of multicultural policy. It will ensure that our frameworks respond to emerging challenges and continue to promote social cohesion and mutual respect. We're also committing $15 million to support community language schools across the country. This investment supports over 600 community language schools, helping more than 90,000 students to learn and preserve 84 different languages spoken in our communities. In addition, we are investing an additional $25 million to expand access to community language education. These programs are about more than just learning a language. They are about passing on culture, history and identity from one generation to the next.

In my own electorate of Menzies, we have already seen this commitment in action. Our government is supporting multiculturalism and inclusion through $200,000 of local funding delivered through the Asian Business Association of Whitehorse for local cultural festivals. This includes $150,000 of support for the Box Hill Lunar New Year Festival, one of the largest and most loved multicultural events in Victoria. Each year the festival attracts more than 100,000 people, who come together to celebrate culture, family and community. A further $50,000 will go to the Manningham Asian Cultural Festival, a newer celebration in the northern part of the electorate that is already making its mark with vibrant music, delicious food and energetic performances.

Events like local festivals are so important in building understanding and connection between cultures. While others might seek to divide us for political gain, the Labor government chooses unity over division and inclusion over fear. We believe that every Australian, whatever their race or religion and wherever they or their parents were born, should be able to feel safe, respected and proud to call this country home. That is the Labor way.

Cameron Caldwell

Cameron Caldwell Fadden, Liberal National Party

6:56 pm

Whilst it's great to see you, Mr Deputy Speaker Small, I was really hoping to see Minister Burke here this evening. I think that the least he could probably have done with his evening was to come and share it with a few of us here in the Federation Chamber.

You see, of late, the minister has really enjoyed getting around and seeing the sights of Australia and making his presence well known. Last week he was welcoming refugees at the airport, and then, while the Prime Minister was overseas, he was talking about modern Australia on the steps of the Opera House, just gently raising his profile. But today, in parliament, when we are in the middle of consideration in detail on the appropriation bill, the minister is not here. The only person in this portfolio who has a track record of going missing more often is the former minister, Minister Giles, who we know was punted unceremoniously. Whilst Labor talks a big game on their national security credentials, the reality is far from it.

I wanted to see Minister Burke here tonight because he is a very, very experienced parliamentarian. He's been in this place for 21 years, and I am sure he would know the answers to some of these questions that we will pose here tonight. He is the Minister for Home Affairs, the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and the Minister for Cyber Security, so I reckon he'd be the one to know the answers, but I appreciate the fact that he has sent along the Assistant Minister for Citizenship, Customs and Multicultural Affairs, and I suppose that, on balance, that's better than nothing.

In following on from the contribution of my good friend from the Sunshine Coast, the member for Fisher, I think it is right to point out that the first obligation of every government is to keep its citizens safe. On that very basic point, one has to call into question whether or not this Albanese Labor government has what it takes to defend our citizens and make sure that they are safe as they move around their communities. The most recent example that I can recall happened just this week. It was when Australians were shocked to hear that six people—two ISIS brides and their four children—had smuggled themselves out of Syria and had returned to Australia. This is a highly dangerous cohort of individuals who were members of the barbaric Islamic State regime.

If it's not bad enough that these people are in our country, there are questions that I really want Minister Burke to answer. Or perhaps Assistant Minister Hill, in his stead, will answer these questions: Where are these ISIS brides now? Does the assistant minister know where they are located? Are our communities safe from these people—because I question whether or not, given the track record of this Labor government, it will have in fact carried out some pretty basic security screening on these people? Will there be some sort of program of deradicalisation to ensure that, if they've brought their extreme ideology back to Australia, it will be impressed on them that that is not the Australia that we support? In fact, I'm pretty sure that, by the very nature of their support for an international terrorist group, they have committed offences. So perhaps the answer from Assistant Minister Hill will be that they're in jail. That'd be a great answer, because then we would know where they are and we'd know that the government has been able to keep Australians safe. But I suspect that's probably not going to be the response. Minister Hill would perhaps also like to explain what support the government provided to these people in their returning to Australia and how much it has cost Australians.

All of this is pretty bad, but the inconsistency in the explanations from the Prime Minister has been quite interesting. You see, initially, back in question time on 3 September, he said that the reports of the return of these so-called ISIS brides were not accurate, but interestingly enough it appears that they have now landed in Australia and that the New South Wales police had been right. They were coming, and now they are here, and Minister Burke and this Labor government must explain it. (Time expired)

Zhi Soon

Zhi Soon Banks, Australian Labor Party

7:01 pm

The Home Affairs portfolio includes responsibility for Australia's multicultural affairs. I am proud to be part of the most diverse, multicultural parliament in Australia's history. Any young person in this country should be able to look at the parliament and see themselves in this place and, if they so choose to, aspire to be a part of it. My family came from Malaysia, but there are members of this House with heritage from all over the world. They include Chinese Australians, Indian Australians, Sri Lankan Australians, Lebanese Australians and many, many more.

The Albanese Labor government believes that every single Australian, whatever their race or religion, wherever they or their parents were born, should be able to feel safe and at home without prejudice or discrimination. This part of our social fabric has been tested recently, and, while, unfortunately, there will always be people seeking to divide Australians, this government, our government, the Albanese government knows that multiculturalism and understanding one another are what bring Australians together.

There is perhaps no better demonstration of the success of Australia's multiculturalism than the citizenship ceremonies we all have the opportunity to attend as members of this place. Since being elected I have been able to attend a number of ceremonies and have witnessed people from dozens of backgrounds become Australian citizens. Seeing the pure joy on the faces of the newest Australians as they take their pledge is incredibly heartwarming—every single time I see it.

For the first time our government has appointed a dedicated minister for multicultural affairs and has elevated that position into the cabinet. Together with the new Office for Multicultural Affairs we have the means to drive a comprehensive approach to multicultural policy that will work across all three levels of government. The minister has well and truly hit the ground running, and I had the pleasure of welcoming her to my electorate last month to visit a number of constituents in the suburb of Padstow where I live.

The 2024 Multicultural Framework Review was the first in-depth examination of Australia's multiculturalism in Australia in 50 years. The Albanese government remains committed to the review, which will continue to influence our understanding of multiculturalism in our communities and will help shape the future policy and investments of this government.

Community language schools are so important for multicultural communities in this country, and this government has invested $15 million since the 2023-24 financial year, supporting 600 community language schools across the country. This support has helped more than 90,000 students across 84 languages. The government is continuing to build on this with an additional $25 million, which will see thousands more children take up another language and feel pride in their heritage, wherever their families may have come from, as well as strengthen their sense of identity as Australians.

I want to take this opportunity to highlight some of the funding provided in the multiculturalism space for the electorate of Banks. I am so proud that this government will deliver $10 million to help with the construction of the United Muslims of Australia Community Centre. The UMA is an important organisation for the Muslim community in Western and south-western Sydney, supporting young people and fostering a deep sense of belonging to our community. The commitment made to fund this project will complete the construction of the UMA precinct that integrates sports, education and social services all in one place. It would include a state-of-the-art sports complex, a youth centre and parking to allow many people to participate—truly a one-stop shop for all of the programs that UMA delivers. The organisation have been working towards this for a long time, and it will enable them to continue the great work that they do.

In closing, I want to recognise the work being done in the multiculturalism space. It is so important not just for highlighting the incredible diversity of our country and all the benefits that come with that but for building a more cohesive and united society. I look forward to continuing to contribute to this government's agenda in this very important area.

Andrew Wallace

Andrew Wallace Fisher, Liberal National Party, Shadow Cabinet Secretary

7:06 pm

The member for Watson has overseen the return of ISIS brides and their children. The PM this week has continued to dodge questions on the government's role in this. I hope the minister can explain to the Chamber what the definition of 'assistance' might be a little bit better than the Foreign Minister has. Minister, what assistance did the government, the Australian Border Force or other government agencies provide to facilitate the return of the ISIS brides and/or their children to Australia?

This government confuses sentiment with strategy. It governs by reaction rather than principle. It dismantled the Home Affairs superdepartment in 2022 only to rebuild it again in 2025. It removed ASIO and the AFP from its remit, then brought them back under the same roof. Each restructure has slowed decisions, blurred accountability and weakened Australia's readiness to respond to threats. Under the coalition, the process for listing a terrorist organisation took days. Under Labor it now takes months. In an age of fast-moving threats, that delay is unacceptable.

The same dysfunction runs through our immigration system. Net migration has exploded. In two years, more than one million people have been added to Australia's population. That has placed enormous pressure on housing infrastructure, health services and schools. There are now close to three million temporary visa holders and almost 400,000 people on bridging visas in Australia. The Administrative Review Tribunal, which this government played with, is buried under more than 110,000 cases. When the coalition left government, there were 67,000 cases. That's not sustainable. It is not fair to migrants waiting for certainty, and it is not fair to Australians struggling to find a roof over their heads.

Despite these pressures, the government still has no clear migration strategy. The 2025-26 Migration Program was not even set in the budget. Instead we got more reviews, more talking points and no plan. When will the government set a coherent migration strategy?

Inside the Department of Home Affairs, the picture is no better. The 2025-26 corporate plan is full of buzzwords and bureaucracy. It lists overlapping responsibilities, constant restructures and yet another so-called transformation program that changes nothing. The same department was responsible for 43 per cent of all Commonwealth FOI requests. This is the same FOI requests that the government seeks to make even harder and more costly to make—so much for transparency! In 2025 the agency tasked with guarding our borders and data is still managing sensitive information on spreadsheets.

Then there's cybersecurity. Every Australian understands the importance of protecting our digital systems and critical infrastructure, yet this government's cybersecurity record is as weak as its record on detention and immigration. Businesses continue to be hacked through years-old vulnerabilities. The minister admits many of these breaches are preventable, yet there's no enforcement, no guidance and no support for small businesses. The coalition built the foundations for a strong cyber strategy. We strengthened the ASD and invested in its critical infrastructure protection with a $9.9 billion investment. Labor has squandered that momentum. It talks tough on cyber but delivers delay after delay. In the face of growing foreign interference, this complacency is unacceptable.

At the heart of this failure lies a deeper truth. Australia still does not have a national security strategy. The coalition and I have been calling for one for years, as have defence leaders, experts and allies. Our AUKUS partners in the US and UK each have national security strategies. Australia does not. We cannot keep patching our national security framework with quick fixes and bumper-sticker bills. Security should be built in not bolted on. The late Jim Molan put it perfectly when he said:

… how can there be a defence strategy without an overarching and comprehensive national security strategy?

The Home Affairs portfolio touches every Australian life. This government needs to do— (Time expired)

Basem Abdo

Basem Abdo Calwell, Australian Labor Party

7:11 pm

I rise to speak on Appropriation Bill (No. 1) 2025-2026, which delivers a budget that continues the Albanese Labor government's unwavering commitment to multiculturalism, to fairness, to inclusion and to belonging for every Australian. I have not heard the speakers opposite mention anything today about how proud they are of Australia. It's all threats and fear. Our vision and our approach—an approach we are delivering for Australia—is instead about inclusion and opportunity, things that actually contribute to our national security. I'm proud to serve in the most diverse government this parliament has ever seen. This matters.

This government believes that every person, regardless of background and faith, wherever they're from or wherever their parents may have been born, deserves to feel safe, values and respected, free from prejudice and free from discrimination. It puts multiculturalism at the centre of our body politic, our institutions, so that it's not an add-on but an essential part of the formulation and delivery of policies and programs, particularly under the Home Affairs portfolio. Since 2023 the Albanese Labor government has invested $15 million to support 600 community language schools, reaching 90,000 students learning 84 languages nationwide. This budget adds a further $25 million, giving thousands more children the chance to learn another language, connect with their culture and grow their sense of pride and identity as Australians. Language is not just a communication form; it is about culture, connection and belonging for communities and actually adds to our people-to-people links and our relationships with the world and with our region.

That belief runs through this budget, backed not just in principle but in practice. For the first time in Australia's history, the Albanese Labor government has elevated the standalone position of the Minister for Multicultural Affairs to cabinet. I want to thank the Minister for Multicultural Affairs for her work in this space and for her engagement on matters which really go to the heart of our approach to this issue—not as a marginal side issue but as one that goes hand in hand with who we are as a country and equally our place in the world. That goes for other ministers in this portfolio—international education, multicultural affairs, small business, international development and immigration with foreign affairs. We take a holistic approach to this important portfolio.

This budget continues to fund that work, investing in programs that strengthen social cohesion, counter racism and celebrate the cultural and linguistic diversity that defines modern Australia. This includes over $190,000 that's been provided for community language schools in my electorate of Calwell over the last two years. I had the opportunity to attend one such school through my visit to the Craigieburn Nepalese Community, an organisation which does a mountain of work helping the community in various aspects, from sports, recreation and schools: through to initiatives such as support for new arrivals and parents, and the prevention of family violence.

For us, multiculturalism isn't just about celebratory occasions. We fight for multiculturalism because we fight for modern Australia. As the Minister for Home Affairs has said, 'modern Australia and multicultural Australia are the same thing'. We've seen the Liberals do their best to undermine our multiculturalism. They talk about safety but use every opportunity to make Australians feel less safe. I'll give you a tip: marginalising, demonising and ostracising members of our community does not enhance national security. We've seen them demonise our proud Australian Indian community. We've seen it in those who speak about being 'estranged' but won't utter by whom. But I suspect they're more estranged from the shadow frontbench now instead. We've seen it by those who've said that Islamophobia is 'fictitious'—it's not real—and by others who say it doesn't exist in society.

The Liberal Party of today is being rightly described as being governed by the far right and the further right. What we, the Albanese Labor government, are proud to defend in this place is social cohesion and to protect our multiculturalism so that all Australians feel safe, valued and recognised.

Zali Steggall

Zali Steggall Warringah, Independent

7:16 pm

The Home Affairs portfolio is responsible for the National Emergency Management Agency, NEMA. They are, in essence, our domestic security when it comes to escalating climate risks. Many talk of defending and keeping Australians safe, but there is certainly a side of politics that doesn't want to acknowledge this very increasing and real risk. While the costs of disaster recovery climbs, we are still failing to invest adequately in adaptation and resilience, and that was visible in the appropriation bill.

In Warringah, we see firsthand the impact of extreme weather events. From coastal erosion along our beaches and rising home insurance costs, extreme weather losses are up 67 per cent from the previous five years. The Northern Beaches is now one of the most climate risk exposed areas in the country, carrying the highest emergency services levy, through the LGA, in New South Wales. Australia is now one of the most exposed continents in the world to natural disasters. Since 2022, there have been 166 declared natural disasters, impacting more than half of our local government areas. Cyclone Alfred alone is estimated to have cost $13.5 billion for about a week of disruption.

Each year, natural disasters are costing Australians around $38 billion. Communities are being devastated again and again, and insurance is becoming unaffordable. If we want to protect lives and livelihoods, as the Home Affairs portfolio is tasked to do, we need to be ambitious and accountable in investing in adaptation and resilience, and that is what NEMA is for.

In 2022, the government created the National Emergency Management Agency to bring together disaster response, recovery and resilience into one agency. NEMA leads the Commonwealth crisis management efforts, coordinates emergency responses, funds disaster recovery and community support, and overseas resilience initiatives such as the Disaster Ready Fund. It was intended to be the Commonwealth centre of excellence for disaster resilience and management, yet the funding does not match the scale of the challenge.

In the 2025-26 budget, NEMA received $188 million over four years for operations. The Disaster Ready Fund will provide $200 million per year for resilience projects—totalling $1 billion over five years. Think about that: $200 million per year to address the costs of some $38 billion in damages per year. The contrast is stark. The budget also includes $1.2 billion just for disaster payments following Cyclone Alfred, with overall recovery costs expected to reach $13.5 billion. The imbalance is just so stark. We're spending billions after disasters occur but only a fraction on preparation and risk reduction. Less than 13 per cent of NEMA's budget is in fact directed towards preparedness, yet CSIRO research shows that every $1 spent on disaster preparation will save $11 on recovery costs. This would be good economic management. Without scaling up NEMA's resilience funding, we are condemning communities to relive the same trauma, disaster after disaster.

My question to the minister is: given the escalating costs of disasters, which are now $38 billion a year, can you clarify the government's decision-making process in allocating funding to NEMA, and will you commit to increasing the proportion of funding directed to disaster preparedness and resilience so that we invest in adaptation upfront rather than paying many times over in recovery?

Secondly, in my time remaining, I'd like to address immigration. There is much scaremongering done in this place around immigration. The reality is that it is too often a political attack line or a scapegoat for economic challenges that are due to poor management over the years. The reality is that immigration is a driver for growth, innovation and community strength. We need migration systems to be fair, efficient and focused on supporting Australian businesses and communities. I've met with many local businesses that are struggling under the cost, the delay and the lack of timeliness when it comes to sponsored visas and having an immigration system that will work to address skill shortages. So I urge the government to really address that. The high operating costs, critical labour shortages and long visa-processing times for small businesses that need immediate relief when it comes to staff are simply untenable. We have complex visa rules and we have slow processing, so I urge the government to assist with that and I ask the minister, given the importance of migration, what the government will do to improve the system. (Time expired)

Alice Jordan-Baird

Alice Jordan-Baird Gorton, Australian Labor Party

7:21 pm

I rise today to speak on the Albanese Labor government's commitment to multiculturalism. My electorate of Gorton in Melbourne's west is incredibly diverse. My community has one of the highest populations of first- and second-generation migrants in Australia. More than 33 per cent of my electorate were born overseas. More than 30,000 of my constituents speak a language other than English at home. And we are growing fast. In Fraser Rise and Plumpton, you'll find the second-highest population growth rate in the country. I'm incredibly proud to represent an electorate with so many families that have made the difficult decision to pack up and start a new life in Melbourne's west. Many of these families are settling in suburbs and estates like Aintree, Fraser Rise, Deanside, Mount Atkinson and Thornhill Park. While they settle down in our wonderful suburbs, they continue to carry with them vibrant cultures and rich histories of migration.

Unfortunately, we have to acknowledge a difficult reality: that those experiences are not always met with open arms and open minds. The anti-immigration protests we saw in recent weeks across Australia, targeting our Indian Australian communities, were abhorrent. On the day of those protests, I had local temple leaders telling their community not to leave their homes because it was safer to stay indoors. In Australia, no-one should have their personal safety compromised. No-one should have to be told that it is unsafe to be in public places because they don't belong. Our community will not be divided by people seeking to intimidate and to hate, because no-one in Australia should have to justify their belonging. Yet we have opposition members in this chamber who continue to tug at that question of belonging with offensive and racist remarks—remarks those members refuse to apologise for but we on the side condemn. What we do and what we say in and outside this chamber as a lasting impact.

On this side of the chamber, we know that it is not just what we say and what we do that matters; it's who we are. For the kids in my electorate sitting at home watching parliament and the news on TV, it means so much to see their own experiences reflected back at them and to hear names like Ambihaipahar, Soon, Ng, Ananda-Rajah, Abdo, Aly, Lim and Sitou. Having those names representing their country means so much. This representation is a statement: you belong here. It's part of the reason I couldn't be prouder to stand in this chamber as part of our Labor government beside the Ambihaipahars and Alys of our Labor caucus, because in this, the 48th Parliament, we have the most multiculturally diverse government this nation has ever seen. We believe that every Australian, whatever their race or religion and wherever they or their parents were born, should be able to feel safe at home, without prejudice or discrimination. That's why, for the first time, we have appointed a dedicated Minister for Multicultural Affairs and we have elevated that position into cabinet.

In 2023-24 we invested $15 million to support 500 community language schools, helping over 90,000 students learn 84 languages across Australia, and we're investing an additional $25 million which will see thousands of children take up another language, fostering pride in their heritage and strength in their Australian identities. In my electorate of Gorton we have committed $5 million for the construction of a brand-new community and education centre at the Sri Durga Temple in Deanside. Sri Durga Temple is the largest Hindu temple in the Southern Hemisphere. It's more than a place of worship; it is a cornerstone of our local community. I was proud to attend their recent Dussehra festival on Sunday, celebrating the triumph of light over darkness. This $5 million investment will help the temple expand its vital work from food relief to cultural education, but it'll do more than just that; the $5 million investment in the Sri Durga Temple in Deanside will tell our constituents who attend the Sri Durga Temple across Gorton, Melbourne's west and all of Australia that you belong here, and our diverse wonderful Labor government will always send that message home.

Julian Hill

Julian Hill Bruce, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Citizenship, Customs and Multicultural Affairs

7:26 pm

I thank government members for their contributions. I also acknowledge the contribution of the member for Warringah, and I will pass on the questions regarding NEMA funding to the Minister for Emergency Management so she can respond directly in a different forum. As for the rest of the contributions, I was listening carefully; I was trying to write down questions. My friend the member for Fisher made two contributions but asked no questions; it was just a bit of a rant. As for the rest of them, though, their hearts were so in it. They were so deeply committed to finding out what's in the government's budget that they ran away. They quit. They cut and ran. They're following the fine example of the immediate past shadow minister for home affairs, who also quit his job on Friday, leaving the former shadow minister for home affairs to front Senate estimates this week. They're so committed to national security that they literally quit and ran away. Small mercies, Deputy Speaker Small—I recall fondly your contribution yesterday, which seemed to revolve around students being Furbies, cats and dogs in the education debate, so they're following in a fine tradition.

With respect to the one question that was posed—does the government have what it takes to keep Australians safe—the answer is, yes, we do. As to the obsession with Australian citizens returning from Syrian IDP camps, if you want the answer to that, I refer you to my interview this morning on Sky News and I refer you to the Minister for Home Affairs' extensive answer on this in question time today. The government has not provided repatriation or assistance for these people to return. The answer was the same a month ago, it was the same yesterday, it's the same today and it'll be the same tomorrow, because that's the truth of it. Our security agencies are constantly watching this cohort offshore. If, as Australian citizens, they under their own steam return to Australia, as is their right as citizens, then we watch them here. We take advice from the security agencies.

The member for Fadden, I think it was, is relatively new, so we will give him the benefit of the doubt. Maybe he hadn't cleaned out his ears in question time and didn't hear the answers that were given: exactly the same scenarios occurred multiple times under the former government. What it boils down to is this: if the opposition don't trust our security agencies and the people who lead them, the same people who led them when they were in government, the same people they know—the member for Fisher and I served on the intelligence and security committee—then they should just say so. If they don't trust the work of Australia's security agencies, then say so. Otherwise the bizarre kind of 'members after dark' echo chamber that we heard over there should go back to whatever weird WhatsApp chat group they like to hang out on and hate on each other, because that's their main sport, the far right and the further right of the now Liberal Party. I don't call them the modern Liberal Party; it is today's Liberal Party—I wouldn't ascribe the word 'modern' to them.

As for the rest, we do have a migration strategy, a fundamental difference between our government and the previous government. We have a migration strategy. We did a review, we put out a strategy, and we're implementing it. You can't point to that in the nine or so years—a decade really—of decay and disfunction and division that we saw from those opposite.

I'm happy to answer questions, but there really were no questions; it was just miserable rants, and they ran away. So here we are. Anyway, there you go! It's a matter for them, how they choose to use their time in opposition. They weren't a very good government, and they're not a very good opposition.

Proposed expenditure agreed to.

Ordered that consideration in detail of the bill be made an order of the day for the next sitting.

Federation Chamber adjourned at 19:31