House debates Bills

Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024; Second Reading

Thursday, 28 November 2024 House of Representatives

Colin Boyce

Colin Boyce Flynn, Liberal National Party

10:31 am

I rise to resume my contribution to the Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024. We were talking about Stanwell Corporation in Gladstone, which is proposing to build a liquefied hydrogen and gaseous hydrogen production plant in Gladstone. This is in conjunction with several international consortiums—among them, Iwatani, Marubeni and Keppel. Recently we've understood that the Japanese Kansai Electric Power Company has withdrawn from the proposal. You would have to ask yourself: why is that? They continually quote the same things—the economic cost of producing hydrogen, liquid hydrogen, and transporting hydrogen. We've seen other companies, such as Fortescue, Origin, Woodside, Krupp steel—the German steelmaker—and so forth also withdraw their support from these huge proposed hydrogen projects, purely based on the economic costs of them.

With respect to the Gladstone proposal, Stanwell Corporation is proposing to make an 800-tonnes-per-day liquid hydrogen facility and also to produce 1,200 tonnes of gaseous hydrogen. They also intend to build an ammonia plant there. The problem with all of that is that, if you actually analyse what their proposals are, they are going to be enormous. Global installed hydrogen liquefaction capacity is around 355 tonnes per day right now. The largest plant currently in operation has a capacity of 34 tonnes per day. The all-time largest hydrogen liquefaction plants were constructed at NASA during the 1950s and 1970s, and most recently-constructed plants are small in comparison. Nonetheless, even if specific energy demand of liquefaction can be significantly lower, the capital costs of liquefaction are still a significant part of the overall cost of liquefaction—even for larger plants. It is estimated that the capital investment consists of around 40 to 50 per cent of the specific liquefaction costs of these plants.

We know that the largest liquefaction plant is at Cape Canaveral, at the Kennedy Space Centre—34 tonnes a day. What Stanwell is proposing is to build a plant that's capable of producing 800 tonnes per day. The storage capacity at Cape Canaveral is about 800 tonnes, so you would imagine that Stanwell would be proposing to build its storage capacity for at least 10 days production; therefore, we would need to have a storage capacity of something like 8,000 tonnes. The reality of this project is that it could possibly be 10 times bigger than the liquid hydrogen facility at Cape Canaveral at the Kennedy Space Center right here at Gladstone. That then raises questions of the enormous capital cost involved in doing this, like why is that these large international companies are withdrawing their support? As I have said before, Fortescue, Origin, Woodside, Krupp Steel in Germany and now Kansai—a Japanese electric company that was part of this original consortium—have now withdrawn their support and it is all over money, the economic cost of it.

Saul Kavonic, energy analyst at MST Marquee, said 'green hydrogen economics are so uncompetitive that even with generous government subsidies and a captive buyer, it still struggles to work'. For me, I would ask the question: why is the federal government supporting a Queensland government GOC along with the previous state government investing millions and millions of taxpayers' dollars in projects that are economically unviable? We have people living in cars, people living in tents, families that can't send their children to sporting practice yet here we have governments continually wasting money on what is clearly economic madness.

The government's Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024. proposes to bring about a regime where they will give tax credits to try and alleviate the cost of producing things like liquid hydrogen and gaseous hydrogen and, once again, the numbers simply don't stack up.

I want to talk about another point—that is, First Nations procurement—which I outlined earlier in my contribution. We know from the documents that Stanwell has put before the EPBC office that already there have been agreements for reparations and inclusion of First Nations people and so forth in these projects. In the documents it says that memorandums of understanding agreements have been made; however, these agreements will not be made public because of their sensitive nature. Well, I take great exception to that. This is taxpayers' money we are dealing with, with both state governments and the previous federal government, who are dealing with a Queensland government GOC with taxpayers' funds. Why can't we be transparent and accountable about who is doing these deals with the First Nations proponents? What exactly are they and how much money is involved? This is, once again, why I call for Aboriginal corporations to come under Australian corporate law so that we can see where all of this money is going, who is making these deals and the numbers involved.

As I've outlined, these projects are economically not sound and green hydrogen as a viable alternative into the future is a long, long way off. We just simply do not have the technology to do that. The World Steel Association in their fact sheet have said the world produces about 70 million tonnes of hydrogen right now. Three-quarters of that hydrogen is produced from natural gas, about one-quarter produced from coal. If we were to change that and produce that 70 million tonnes of hydrogen through green energy and so forth using wind turbines, solar panels and batteries, the amount of energy required to do that would be 3,600 terawatts hours of energy—renewable energy. That is more than the entire generating capacity of the EU.

So, once again, I would question building an 800-tonne-per-day liquid hydrogen facility in Gladstone, 1,200 tonnes a day of gaseous hydrogen, building ammonia plants and so forth. How many wind turbines, solar panels and batteries will be required to be installed in Central Queensland to make this thing work? It simply doesn't make economic sense, and that is why I and the coalition do not support this bill.

Meryl Swanson

Meryl Swanson Paterson, Australian Labor Party

10:40 am

A Future Made in Australia is the flagship policy for the Albanese Labor government, but, more importantly than that, this $22.7 billion investment guides and positions us towards a shared goal of rebuilding our nation's domestic manufacturing base and also participating in a new global economy that is upon us right now. If we are not fleet footed, sure footed and front footed, we will be last in this global race. We have everything we need to be part of it, and we must lead the way. We are going to be securing good jobs for blue-collar workers. We're going to be part of this emerging world market for new forms of energy like hydrogen.

The Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024 is a vital element of ensuring the success not only of this policy but, quite frankly, of our country in a world that is ever hungry for energy and ever innovating. We have the critical minerals. We have the things that are absolutely required to take us on this journey. This is the way of the future, and it is the future of Australia. We must be part of it. We know our short-term and immediate policy initiatives have been strong and effective: tax credits for every taxpayer, energy bill relief and cheaper medicines, just to name a few. Through these measures, we have put more money back into the accounts and pockets of every Australian taxpayer, and that counts. This piece of legislation is going to help secure the future of our economy.

We know we can't click our fingers and arrive at the finish line in that global race straightaway. We know that things take time. But, like all good governments, we have put in the hard yards to build responsible policy. We're now building long-term policy, and we are future focused, and that's what these production tax credits are about. They are about saying to companies, 'We are going to give you a credit because you are paving a new way and charting a new course for our future.'

Yes, some of the technology is still emerging, but we have to be part of it. We can't get left behind. Our government has been clear and transparent about our ideals, our intentions and our aspirations in designing a road map for a more resilient Australia, and we saw this during COVID. We saw very clearly that there is a delicate balance between trading with the rest of the world and having that trade reduced by something like a viral pandemic. We do need a certain amount of resilience in our own manufacturing sector, so we have to strike that incredibly important balance between what we can mine and manufacture here and what we, importantly, trade with the rest of the world. This is what smart governments do. We don't turn our back and face in one singular direction. This is a multifaceted, multidirectional and, quite frankly, multitechnology world that we live in, and we must be part of it.

For many decades, we were considered world leaders in energy, and we still are. We keep the lights on in places like Tokyo, Taipei and Beijing with our incredible coal, which is mined in places like my electorate and that of my friend and colleague the member for Hunter, and we know that that's an enormous part of our current energy mis. But we also know that, as the Minister for Resources has said time and time again in this parliament, the road to net zero runs through the Australian resources industry, including things like critical minerals. This bill is going to deliver targeted economic investments in key industries such as renewable hydrogen and critical minerals, and it's going to unlock private investment. I couldn't be prouder to support this bill today, and I just say to those opposite: get on board, because we cannot be left behind in this race.

Anthony Albanese

Anthony Albanese Grayndler, Australian Labor Party, Prime Minister

10:44 am

These production tax credits are central to our government's vision for a future made in Australia. They are part of our economic plan to create good jobs, drive new investment and deliver stronger growth, because our government understands that building Australia's future is about making more things here; adding value here, investing in skills and training and in science and research here; turning the resources under our soil and in our skies into products on our shores; and building an economy where manufacturing is as strong as mining—an economy connected to the boundless opportunities of Asia and one where we make things here in Australia, make the most of the world-leading advantage we have in clean energy, critical minerals and rare earths, and use that advantage to power a new generation of secure, well-paid jobs in our regions and in our suburbs.

Our plan is about building an economy that is more resilient and more diversified, more productive and more prosperous, more self-reliant and more secure—because being more secure depends on becoming more self-reliant. One of the defining lessons of the pandemic and its economic aftershocks is that if you're always the last link in the global supply you will always be vulnerable. The fewer things we make here, the more exposed we are to international uncertainty, whatever form it takes—be it a pandemic, conflict or economic and strategic competition.

I was speaking with other nations at the G20 and APEC last week. None of us know exactly what the next shock will look like, but all of us know that there will be another one—a new challenge to meet. In an interconnected global economy, distance is no barrier to this uncertainty, and isolation is certainly not an answer. We can't cut ourselves off. We have to build ourselves up, by strengthening our economic and energy security, boosting Australian manufacturing, driving new investment in critical minerals and green hydrogen, and unlocking new green industries of the future. That is what this legislation, the Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024, is all about.

Our plan aims to do much more than shield us from international adversity. This is about creating future prosperity as well. It's about seizing the generational opportunity of the global shift to net zero, because that's not some distant prospect. The biggest economic change since the Industrial Revolution is underway already, and it's happening here in our region—the fastest-growing region of the world in human history. Australia can shape this change. We can seize this opportunity. We can power it with our resources. Above all, we can make sure that our workers and communities benefit from it, for this generation and the next.

We have an unprecedented chance to create a new source of comparative advantage for Australian industry. For decades, we've been told that other nations with large populations and low wages have the comparative advantage when it comes to manufacturing. But, in a world where we're moving to net zero and where the nature of production has changed so that the costs of labour are far less a proportion of the inputs compared to the rising costs of issues such as transport, we are in a position where we have a unique set of national strengths that we can turn to our advantage. We have the critical minerals and materials to drive global decarbonisation, not just here but offshore as well. We have the best solar resources in the world. We have the skilled workers. We have the space; we have the room to grow and to co-locate extraction, refining and processing and to co-locate energy generation and storage with manufacturing. That is the opportunity that we have to support global emissions reductions while creating new jobs and prosperity here at home. It's an opportunity we have as a nation, but only if we move now and act with purpose and urgency. That's why this decade is so critical for Australia in defining the success or otherwise of our economy for decades ahead. This will only occur if we back our job-creating industries and our skilled and productive workers, and that's precisely what these tax credits are about. They reward companies that move first—that invest, build and seek out new sources of growth and new markets.

Importantly, these tax credits pay on success. This is a point that seems to have escaped the opposition from day one. The clue is there in the name. If there's no production, there's no credit. That's why this model is good for business and good for the taxpayers. Production tax credits create certainty for investors. They bring forward value, they build in a guaranteed level of return, and they make projects bankable earlier than otherwise, meaning more initiatives get past that initial barrier—they get over the hump. This is about attracting private capital, not replacing it, aligning our national security and our economic security and making government a catalyst for new investment in critical minerals and green hydrogen at every stage. It will create new mining jobs, processing and refining jobs and technology and manufacturing jobs, moving Australia up the global value chain and forging new links in that chain right across our nation.

The Treasurer announced these tax credits in this year's budget speech, and barely five minutes after he had sat down the opposition leader and the shadow Treasurer announced they'd be opposing them. They said it that very night. It took them five minutes to write off a whole new generation of prosperity. Talk about reckless! It took five minutes to say they weren't interested in creating new jobs in ports, mines and processing and manufacturing centres all over Australia. It took five minutes to dismiss the aspirations of millions of Australians who want to know that their children can hope for good jobs with decent pay and a secure future. Talk about arrogant! Now, when parliament rises, those opposite have to go back to their communities and tell the people whose interests they are supposed to represent that they voted against them. They voted against new investment, new jobs and new industry in the regions.

But, when parliament is here in February, those opposite in the Senate will have to determine what their position is. I've heard strong support from the crossbenchers in the House and Senate, including the Greens political party. I haven't had anyone except for the Liberal Party and the National Party say they're against this—apparently because it's got something to do with the new economy! Change happens, and you can either shape change or be shaped by it. You can be passive while the world changes around us, but the shift to net zero is happening. It's up to those opposite to see whether they vote against new investment, new jobs and new industry in the regions, which is primarily where this will be focused. Their opposition leader has some kind of pathological objection to fair wages and secure work in Australian manufacturing—so much that he's prepared to sacrifice all these jobs and all this opportunity in the name of his fixation on nuclear power sometime into the 2040s. This is an opportunity right now. Instead of seizing this chance here and now, the Liberals and Nationals say we should burn hundreds of billions of dollars on the most expensive form of energy there is to build nuclear reactors sometime in the 2040s, which will produce less than four per cent of Australia's energy needs. Never has so much taxpayer money offered so little to so few.

For our Labor government, and every member on this side of the House, this vote is straightforward. Our Western Australian members will be voting for this legislation because they know it's fantastic for jobs in WA—and I suspect the member for Curtin is in here to say exactly the same thing. Our Queensland members will be voting for this because they know it's great for jobs in Queensland. The member for Solomon and the member the Lingiari will be voting for this legislation because it's fantastic for the Northern Territory. And our MPs from right across the country will be voting for this legislation because it's good for jobs, wages and new opportunities in every part of our country. We're the party of jobs, and we want to represent all Australians and the national interest. We're not frightened of the future; we want to seize the future. That's the difference between the two approaches we see in this chamber.

Our government is acting on the cost of living to help people here and now, but we're also building the future. We are navigating the rough seas without taking our eyes off the horizon, because you have to be able to do both. If you think about Curtin and Chifley, their great Labor government established the Department of Post-War Reconstruction in December 1942. Just think about that. At the height of the Second World War, they were dealing with the challenge of defending our country in our darkest hour but looking towards the future. When the fine men and women who'd defended our nation returned home postwar, what was going to happen to give them a future and give them jobs and prosperity? They understood that planning for a stronger and fairer economy after the war couldn't wait until peacetime.

In the same way, we can't wait for a time when all is calm and quiet in the global economy. If we hesitate and we hang back, this opportunity will pass us by. If we fall back into the delay and denial of the past decade, the world will leave us behind. If we turn our backs on all the advantages our nation has in order to chase after a nuclear obsession that costs too much, takes too long and delivers far too little way too late, then the chance to make our future here in Australia will be gone for good. That's the choice the House has when it votes today. I'm confident that the Future Made in Australia legislation that has already passed this House will pass the Senate today with the support of all the non-coalition members, who have indicated their support for that legislation. They know that a future made in Australia is about the jobs, wages, conditions and living standards of the people who send us here.

If they're not for a future made in Australia, I just wonder where they think the future should be made for Australians. It is frankly astonishing that the National Party—whatever differences I would have with them—once stood up for nationalism. You could count upon them to vote for Australian jobs and for defending Australian industry. They have walked away from this and have adopted some rather strange positions. They somehow think that they should just sit back and watch these opportunities drift away.

The House will have a choice today. It's a choice the Australian people will have next year. In standing against this legislation, those opposite make it clear that they stand for higher power bills, lower wages and fewer opportunities for future generations. By contrast, today, our Labor government is voting for cheaper and cleaner energy. We're voting for new jobs in new industries and new projects in the regions. We're voting to make things here. We're voting to make the most of this moment. We're voting for a future made here in Australia. That's what we'll be asking Australians to vote for in 2025 as well. I commend the bill to the House.

Adam Bandt

Adam Bandt Melbourne, Australian Greens

10:59 am

The best job for a coalminer is very often another mining job. As we transition away from coal and gas—because we know that coal and gas are the causes of the climate crisis—we owe a debt to the workers and the communities who have delivered coal and gas, who have helped power this country up to this point and who have helped deliver prosperity. We know something about coal and gas that we didn't know before: we know that coal and gas are causing the climate crisis. That is not the fault of coal and gas workers. We owe coal and gas workers a debt of thanks.

In the past we've moved away from harmful industries like asbestos, and we're now trying to move away from others. We know that we can't keep opening new coal and gas mines and have any chance of having a safer climate. That is the science. Every primary school student understands that coal and gas are driving pollution and that pollution is driving the climate crisis. We need to ensure that we provide good, secure, well-paid, high-paid jobs for people who now work in coal and gas communities and for the other people and businesses around them that rely on that. That's why the Greens have said very clearly for years now—and have been pushing this very hard—that we need a plan in this country to ensure that we grow those industries, including critical minerals, that will not only give Australia jobs and things to sell to the rest of the world in a zero pollution society but will also provide well-paid, secure work for the workers in the coal and gas communities.

In many places—for example, in Queensland—the people who work in coal and gas are not necessarily that far away geographically from the places where almost exactly the same skills are going to be relied on, in areas like critical minerals and, potentially, green steel—even green hydrogen. In other words, if we do our jobs right in this place, we can ensure—in places like Queensland and Western Australia—as the country moves away from coal and gas, that industries and businesses will be grown to take their place. In many cases, they will be physically quite close by, or close enough, and they're going to need the same skills, the same services and the same industry support.

Australia is actually blessed with a lot of the critical minerals that are going to be needed in a zero pollution world. We've got—I stand to be corrected—something close to the second-largest supply of vanadium, for example; if it's not exactly that, it's up there. There are products that are going to be used in, for example, industrial sized batteries and also in batteries in cars and in other products. We've got a lot of those products here. A lot of people around Australia are asking, 'Why aren't we investing more towards processing some of these minerals here instead of just digging everything up and shipping it offshore?'

Luke Gosling

Luke Gosling Solomon, Australian Labor Party

That's what Middle Arm is about, mate.

Adam Bandt

Adam Bandt Melbourne, Australian Greens

I know the Labor member who interjects thinks the only way you can do that is with gas, by fracking the Beetaloo.

Luke Gosling

Luke Gosling Solomon, Australian Labor Party

Have you heard of SunCable?

Steve Georganas

Steve Georganas Adelaide, Australian Labor Party

Order! The member on my right is not in his chair.

Adam Bandt

Adam Bandt Melbourne, Australian Greens

The Labor member from the Northern Territory says that we've got to frack the Beetaloo, and that that is apparently the only way in which we can have a future. Well, that is wrong. We know that under the Beetaloo is a massive climate bomb that we cannot allow to be lit even though Labor and Liberal desperately want to light it. The member's walked out of the chamber because he knows that what I am saying is right.

What we can do instead is accept that we need a transition plan to ensure that workers in communities don't lose incomes and that jobs and sustainable jobs are there. That's why, going to the last election, the Greens outlined a very detailed and comprehensive plan not only for a transition authority but also for job guarantees to ensure that workers who transitioned across didn't lose money and, in fact, that businesses were supported. We also outlined a comprehensive plan to support green metals and to call for exactly the kind of support that I've been talking about to support critical minerals.

This bill, the Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024, is a step towards that. And because it supports the growth of critical minerals that are going to be needed in a zero-pollution society, the Greens support it. I say very clearly to the people of Western Australia and to the people of Queensland, we would like to see this support, and more, flowing as quickly as possible to critical minerals.

Of course, as the Greens, we say that we need to ensure that we have very good standards, world's best practice standards to protect our environment and to ensure that First Nations people have their position absolutely respected. We have seen it done very poorly in the past, in this country, and we have seen the rights of First Nations people and the rights of the environment be overridden. But I think we can do it all. We can respect First Nations people and our environment and also ensure that we grow the critical minerals sector in this country. That's why we will be supporting this bill.

People in Western Australia and people in Queensland should know that the Greens are strong supporters, as we have been for many years now, of growing critical minerals, of green metals, of ensuring the industries are there in order for us to make the transition.

But what I would say to the government is you have to stop sending mixed messages. You have to stop saying that the transition needs to happen and then backing new coal and gas projects. That's what the government are doing. In many respects, they're just talking out of both sides of their mouth. They bring in important legislation like this, and then they approve 28 new coal and gas projects. That leaves workers and communities confused. It leaves investment confused.

One of the things we know, and we've heard the government say this about housing, is the government says, 'We haven't got enough investment, we haven't got enough workers, we haven't got enough skills.' The problem is if you send a message that you want to expand the green sector and critical minerals and green steel and green hydrogen but then you also say, 'We're going to approve new coal and gas projects at the rate of knots,' not only do you fast-track climate collapse, which is what this government is doing, but you divert resources, capital and workers away from it. If the government really wants the critical minerals sector to succeed, it will stop backing new coal and gas projects because they're going to be competing for the same workers and competing for investment as well as fast-tracking the climate collapse.

Every time the government stands up and approves one of those 28 new coal and gas projects, workers and communities—they're not dumb; they're cluey. They look at it and they say: 'Hold on. You've told us we've got to get away from coal and gas and make the transition, but you've just approved a whole bunch of new climate-destroying projects.' It destroys confidence in the transition because you can't have it both ways, Labor. The coalition say they don't even believe in climate at all and they just want to fast-track climate collapse and have more coal and gas in the system and add nuclear on top of it, but the Labor Party come in and say they believe in renewables and the transition—but what they say and what they do are different things, because then they go and they open up and approve more coal and gas projects.

We are at a massive climate tipping point and, at the recent climate summit, it was said that we may have already hit 1½ degrees and that may be out of reach. That is what some people are claiming now. They are saying very, very, very clearly that, if we want to avoid for our kids who are at primary school now climate collapse during their lifetime, we need to massively reduce emissions now and, at a minimum, we need to stop opening new coal and gas projects. That is the message from the scientists right now who are ringing the alarm bells. The atmosphere is full. There is just not capacity to put more CO2 or methane into it by opening up new coal and gas projects.

So the government has a real opportunity here, which is to stop opening the new coal and gas projects and instead throw their full weight behind industries like green metals, green steel, green hydrogen and critical minerals. This bill, even though it may not have been exactly how we have would designed it, has the Greens' support because it is a very important step in the right direction. But the government now needs to answer to every parent who is worried about their kid's future and to everyone who doesn't want their kids to have to go through every summer wondering how many people are going to die in the next bushfire or the next heatwave why they keep approving new coal and gas projects. It is at directly at odds with the very good aims of this bill. I have not yet heard one of the members of the government come in and actually justify how they can say that they care about the climate crisis but also approve 28 new coal and gas projects.

Some important data is going to be released in about an hour about climate in Australia. We will look at it with interest because what the data to date shows is that emissions are actually higher under Labor than they were under Scott Morrison. After people voted for climate action at the election, so far—again, we will see what the data says at 12 o'clock today—Labor has lifted emissions. Can you believe that? Labor has actually lifted emissions above where they were under Scott Morrison. If you approve 28 new coal and gas projects, it is absolutely no wonder.

So I commend this bill to the House and we support it, but I urge the government to take the opportunity to reflect on the climate criminality of approving new coal and gas projects and the absolute reprehensibility of approving 28 new coal and gas projects in a time of climate crisis, as cars are being piled up in the streets in Spain and as there are floods and fires threatening again here. In the Northern Rivers in New South Wales, there are people who still haven't been able to get back into their homes after the last floods. There are people in Brisbane who can't afford to get insurance now. They can't afford to insure their inner-city homes. It's happening right around the country. Labor's opening of 28 new coal and gas projects is utterly reprehensible.

I might just conclude, Deputy Speaker, with a question for you. I'm just inquiring as to whether the call no longer alternates in this place now or whether the call no longer goes to the person who is first on their feet. We just had two speakers on the government side. I understand that some members of government can get precedence, but surely that could be dealt with within the ordinary speaking arrangements. Given that standing order 65 requires the call to go to the person who is first on their feet and that general practice is that the call alternates, I just have a question for you, Deputy Speaker, as to whether we now have a different approach in this House where the call no longer alternates. If so, I think that the House would be interested in knowing that.

Steve Georganas

Steve Georganas Adelaide, Australian Labor Party

You are quite correct: it's an alternative shot on each side. But when a senior minister or the Prime Minister is on their feet the precedent has been in the past that you can give the call to the Prime Minister or the senior minister, and that was the decision I made.

Matt Thistlethwaite

Matt Thistlethwaite Kingsford Smith, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Immigration

11:14 am

I move:

That the debate be adjourned and the resumption of the debate made an order of the day for a later hour this day.

Milton Dick

Milton Dick Speaker

The question before the House is that the debate be adjourned.