House debates Matters of Public Importance

Albanese Government

Thursday, 28 November 2024 House of Representatives

Milton Dick

Milton Dick Speaker

3:45 pm

I've received a letter from the honourable the Leader of the Nationals proposing that a definite matter of public importance be submitted to the House for discussion, namely:

This Prime Minister taking Australia in the wrong direction.

I call upon those honourable members who approve of the proposed discussion to rise in their places.

More than the number of members required by the standing orders having risen in their places—

David Littleproud

David Littleproud Maranoa, National Party, Shadow Minister for Agriculture

I ask you to cast your mind back to election it when the Prime Minister said, 'No-one will be held back, no-one will be left behind.' Bring yourself forward 2½ years, and Australians are now asking themselves: do they really feel better off after 2½ years of Anthony Albanese? After those 2½ years, the country has clearly gone in one direction—one where he has divided a country and sent us broke. We got a real insight into that in just under 12 months, when he decided to take the country down a path of the Voice referendum, dividing this nation. He told us that he was going to spend over $450 million on a referendum without even going through the proper process of calling a constitutional convention, bringing all Australians together, because the Constitution is owned by every Australian. Instead he told us that we're going to repeat the mistakes of the past by bringing back ATSIC Mark 2—not changing the livelihoods of regional Indigenous Australians but repeating those mistakes. Australians saw through it.

Instead of listening to the Australian people after that referendum, the Prime Minister did nothing. The only action to take place—and it was, in fact, the very week after that referendum—was that taken by the Leader of the Opposition and I. We came to this place, and we heard that the result of that referendum was that they didn't want more bureaucracy. They wanted a better bureaucracy, and they wanted action. So we introduced in this place two pieces of legislation. One was around a royal commission into child sexual abuse in Central Australia, and the second was about an audit to ensure that the over $4 billion that's being spent by Australian taxpayers in the expectation that we will close the gap for the most marginalised in this country is being spent wisely. That's common sense. But this government could not even bring themselves to respect the result of the referendum and listen to the voices of the Australian people about the action that they wanted. Instead, they turned their back on it and, since then, have barely uttered one word about Indigenous Australians. They wasted $450 million that could have helped close the gap with practical solutions. They wasted Australian taxpayers' money, and all it ended up being was a vibe.

The government's economic management continues to put pressure on Australian families. Some Australian families tonight will not be able to afford dinner. In a country as rich as Australia, in a country of 27 million people that produces enough food and fibre for 80 million, that is a national shame. It's a shame because what this government has done is continue to spend Australian taxpayers' money because their belief in their ideology hasn't met the practical reality of addressing the fundamentals of what's keeping your interest rates higher: the fact that inflation is staying higher. Discretionary spends have stopped. We've stopped going to Gerry Harvey and buying TVs and fridges because we can't afford it, but your fixed spending continues to go up because those opposite—this government—after 2½ years have failed to acknowledge that they have to address the fundamentals.

If you look at where the fixed spending continues to remain high and continues to increase, it's in energy, food and rents. That has kept inflation higher, which means your interest rates have remained higher. In fact, the average mortgage in this country has gone up an extra $35,000. So $35,000 has ben ripped out of Australian families' wallets because of the mismanagement of this government. They haven't been prepared to face up to the fact that the ideology around shifting to an all-renewables approach for an energy grid cannot work. There's no country of the industrial scale and size of Australia that has gone with an all-renewables approach. Instead, they have sent investment signals that have reduced our baseload supply, driven up prices and take away confidence not just in households but also in the industry.

Manufacturing cannot continue to be subsidised to keep going. To have manufacturing in this country you have to fix fundamentals. You have to have affordable and reliable baseload power and you have to have proper industrial relations policy. This government's failed on both. But, then, because they understood that households were copping it in the neck because of their promise of a $275 reduction in electricity bills for households that was never going to be seen—in fact, we have seen an increase of over $800—they had to do something about it. What they did is spend $6.5 billion of Australian taxpayer dollars in papering over cracks and to say, 'We're not going to fix the fundamentals; we're just going to buy ourselves out of trouble politically.'

There was a politician up in my home state of Queensland who did that about three months ago—Steven Miles. He had a closing down sale in Queensland. He gave the show away. He gave everything away in a crude attempt to hold power. That is what this government is doing. They are giving it all away. They're now dipping into your Future Fund because of their economic mismanagement. In fact, they still can't face up to those fundamentals of inflation, and we're seeing poor inflation. That real number that the RBA governor uses to determine where rates will go went up last month from 3.2 to 3.5 per cent. The RBA governor only acts in reaction to the actions of this government, and the reckless spending of this government continues to put pressure on the RBA governor. That is putting pressure on households and putting pressure on businesses. In fact, things are so bad out there at the moment that we are seeing over 20,000 small-business insolvencies. They employ mums and dads that are trying to pay their mortgages. They have lost their livelihoods and businesses. They've had to sweat and have the courage of their own convictions to go and start a business and employ people, and now they have lost it and had to let their employees go.

You can see that what is happening out there in this economy is that this government is ramming this economy into a wall. The RBA governor is now in a state of flux about what to do. They cannot control inflation, but they are sending the economy dead broke. This is the challenge that Australians are feeling today. When you think about the central policies that will address the fundamentals, they include having an all-energy mix, not putting all our energy eggs in one basket. We have sovereignty of all our resources. That will address the energy prices that you are receiving now. If you want to bring them down quicker, get some more gas into the supply quickly. You can get gas into the grid quickly. That will bring food prices down. Food processors are paying three to sometimes four times what they were two to three years ago.

The bill that the government brought in today around the big tough penalties they're bringing in for supermarkets is business as usual. They're bringing in infringement notices to tell the supermarkets that they are treating farmers and also consumers poorly to a maximum of $187,800. If I whip down to Civic here and go to one of their stores, I could pull that out of the till. That's just a cost of doing business. Supermarkets do not fear these people. When you see Australians who, tonight, will struggle to put food on the table, why wouldn't you do something about it? Those are the real policy levers you can pull that don't cost a cent. They would put downward pressure on prices.

You've also got to give Australians the hope of one day fulfilling that dream of owning a home. This crowd are bringing 1.67 million people into this country. That is a city bigger than the size of Adelaide. They are bringing in dog groomers and martial arts instructors instead of maybe thinking about bringing in some builders, sparkies, roofers and tilers. If you're going to bring that number in, you're going to have to build some homes. What's happened is young people have lost hope. They've lost hope of ever owning a home, because it's all about supply. While building that supply sits with state and local government, the levers that we pull in this place help them. If you're going to not have the commonsense solution around migration to bring in—because we should determine who comes the country, the skills they have and where we want them to live. We're giving those people around planet the greatest gift we give anybody: a ticket to Australia.

Our coalition, if we become government after the next election, will ban foreigners from competing with Australians for residential options for two years. We're going to put a pause on this increase in building standards going up to seven stars, lifting the cost of building a home by over $60,000. No wonder no-one can afford it. We've got to get back to some basics, get back to understanding we've been given the privilege of spending Australian taxpayers' money. We've got to do it properly and to pull the policy levers that will actually do the lifting rather than having to spend Australian taxpayers' money, because, ultimately, Australians can't afford another three more years of Anthony Albanese.

Kristy McBain

Kristy McBain Eden-Monaro, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Regional Development, Local Government and Territories

3:56 pm

It's a pleasure to respond to this MPI, because what we have heard is that basically those opposite gave up. After nine years, they said: 'We're out of ideas. We can't do anymore rorts. We've gone through every colour coded spreadsheet we can find, and we still can't make a difference in Australians' lives.' That is why in 2022 the population voted for change and voted for an Albanese Labor government. We as a government are building Australia's future because we understand the importance of having a strong direction for our country—something that those opposite still don't have in opposition. They still don't have a single costed policy. There is no detail about their nuclear thought bubble. They are determined to hold people back.

Since we came to government, we've got wages moving again after a decade of deliberately holding wages low. We have tackled inflation and we have delivered two budget surpluses without wasting money on 'back in black' mugs for a surplus that didn't happen under those opposite. We've made medicines cheaper, we've boosted bulk-billing, we've strengthened Medicare and we've increased regional health services.

If it was up to those opposite, cost-of-living relief wouldn't actually be a thing, because they're determined to block every measure that we've put forward, without a single alternative solution. We have delivered a tax cut for every Australian, something that—you guessed it—those opposite voted against. We have expanded paid parental leave and will also pay superannuation on it, because taking time out to care for your children shouldn't leave you worse off. Our energy bill relief is rolling out, which, let's not forget, we implemented because the shadow Treasurer deliberately changed the law to hide electricity bill increases until after the 2022 election. From 1 July, 2.6 million minimum and award wage workers received a pay rise—the third consecutive pay rise increase under our government—because Labor will always stand up for workers and their rights. Aged-care workers, childcare workers and other workers low-paid industries—and that's on top of our record aged-care and childcare worker pay rises reducing pressure on some of our most valued workers, who are in professions that have been overlooked for too long under those opposite.

Every regional community that I visit tells me the same thing: 'We need more housing to attract and retain the workers that we need.' And let me be clear: housing was not an issue that didn't exist before 2022. It was just that on this side of the House we actually recognised that, as the federal government, we had a role to play in it. That's why our government has invested $32 billion in housing initiatives, the biggest investment in a decade. It will ensure we get more homes off the ground in our regions. We've already seen more than 13,000 people now have homeownership under our regional first home buyer grant, because we expanded the eligibility criteria. We've announced under round 1 of the Housing Australia Future Fund more than 13,000 homes. That's more than we saw in an entire decade, because you actually have to put money where your mouth is and get on with delivering.

Our $1.5 billion Housing Support Program is supporting local governments and state and territory governments to build enabling infrastructure, because councils told us that they needed more help getting the groundwork done. Fifty million dollars is already flowing to 80 projects across Australia under stream 1, including 73 local council projects aimed at boosting planning capabilities, and just this week our Help to Buy legislation passed parliament, something those opposite in bed with the Greens voted against time and time again. This will now help 40,000 low-and middle-income earners turn the keys on their own property. That's nurses; that's cleaners; that's carers; that's childcare workers.

Something else our regional communities tell me all the time is that they need more help to repair and maintain roads across their council areas because for a decade, under those opposite, roads were literally driven into the ground. That's why we're progressively doubling Roads to Recovery over the next five years to a billion dollars annually. In the Leader of the Nationals' own electorate, that's more than $156 million over the next five years—an increase of $49 million. Just today, I met with one of the councils from the Maranoa electorate—Murweh Shire Council—and they will receive $10.7 million in Roads to Recovery, which is an increase of $3.4 million. I can tell you what they're saying: that this funding increase is not moving in the wrong direction; it's finally moving in the right direction.

What they did say, though, was that our ongoing commitment to regional aviation is incredibly important for places like the Charleville Airport. Our $80 million investment to keep Rex's regional routes running shows we understand the importance of a strong regional aviation network. It keeps people connected. It keeps our businesses running and it ensures our regional communities thrive. Just like roads, the opposition did nothing for the regional aviation sector in their decade in government. Cancellations and delays are their only MO.

But not everyone can travel by air, which is why we've increased a range of road programs including $437 million just announced for 230 priority upgrades across New South Wales, many in our regional areas. In my own electorate of Eden-Monaro, that's over $50 million to 16 projects. The road Black Spot Program is increasing from $110 million a year to $150 million a year, meaning more money for improving some of the most dangerous sections of our roads. We've launched the new Safer Local Roads and Infrastructure Program, which is a $200 million program annually, and we delivered an additional $250 million to regional councils through phase 4 of the Local Roads and Community Infrastructure Program. These programs not only make our roads safer; they make it easier for people to get around.

Those opposite wouldn't know the right direction for this country if it was screaming out at them from a map, but a paper map is probably all you'd get from the opposition because they're determined to hold Australia back when it comes to digital connectivity, too. They bungled the rollout of the NBN with their deliberate underinvestment, and just 15 minutes down the road from here in my own electorate, half of some of the streets were stuck on the coalition's copper network for a decade while the other half had fibre to the premise under the previous Labor government. We have now fixed that with an investment of $2.4 billion to expand full-fibre NBN, including to 660,000 homes in our regions. Now they're looking to sell off the NBN to the lowest bidder because they're the party of privatisation, and, as the mayor of Flinders Ranges Council said, the first thing that goes under privatisation is service.

We're a government that understands the value of investing in people and supporting them to build their own futures. We're supporting people to train at home so they can continue working locally because you shouldn't have to pack your bags to build a career. Our fee-free TAFE has already supported 500,000 people nationally, including over 127,000 people in our regions; 35,000 in construction courses and the same amount in early education; 50,000 in digital technology; 130,000 in aged care and disability care. This is a program that we'll make permanent because it's hugely successful. The Australian Council of Trade Unions said fee-free TAFE is making education more affordable and accessible, easing pressure on household budgets and ensuring more young people have the financial freedom to pursue their dreams.

But the opposition, yet again at odds with the community, are now standing in the way of people's futures. Just last week, the Deputy Leader of the Opposition said, 'if you don't pay for it, you don't value it'. Well, tell that to the apprentice chef that said, 'I'm going to school to get a better job so we can have a better life'; or the student nurse that said, 'It gives a lot of young people and older people an opportunity.' This reckless disregard for people and what they need is the approach that those opposite took to Medicare and to the NDIS—they gutted both. But under an Albanese Labor government, we're delivering record investments to rebuild that damage, including an increase to the bulk billing incentive, cheaper medicines and 29 additional urgent care clinics in our most recent budget alone, including one in my own electorate on Morisset Street in Queanbeyan.

As we enter our high-risk weather season—let's talk about the wrong direction, eh?—having been through the devastating Black Summer bushfires with my communities in the Bega Valley, I know the consequences of turning your back on disaster preparedness, which is exactly what we saw under those opposite. That is why we have set up the National Emergency Management Agency, to ensure that we have a coordinated approach when we need it. We have built the largest firefighting air fleet in the country's history, with 160 aircraft positioned across the country to protect our communities. And we established the $1 billion Disaster Ready Fund to invest in disaster resilience and risk reduction.

Backwards is the only direction this country would be heading under the reckless approach by the Leader of the Opposition, Peter Dutton, and his 'no-alition'. We will continue to build Australia 's future on this side of the House and stand up for communities right across the country.

Sharon Claydon

Sharon Claydon Newcastle, Australian Labor Party

I'm just going to remind the minister and all speakers thereafter that when referring to people who are members in this place you must use their correct titles.

Kevin Hogan

Kevin Hogan Page, National Party, Shadow Minister for Trade and Tourism

4:06 pm

Australia is heading in the wrong direction. I'm saying that but it is not just me saying that. Deputy Speaker, do you know who is saying that? The majority of the Australian people are saying that. When people are polled and asked: do you think Australia is heading in the wrong direction, the majority of people, the vast majority, a significant majority of people, are saying yes, and that has changed over the period in the last 12 to 18 months. The majority of people have decided that Australia is heading in the wrong direction. Why would they say that? Why do you think they would say that?

There is obviously great disappointment in the government, all of you over there are representing that government, and the majority of people in Australia think you are sending this country in the wrong direction. Why would they think that? Why would they be saying that? One of the reasons, obviously, is cost of living. The figure that has been quoted over here a lot, which has been analysed by independent people—not a figure that we made up—is that the average family is $35,000 a year worse off, and $20,000 of that is because of the 12 interest rate increases we've seen from the other side. So the average mortgage is more than $20,000 what it was when those opposite came to government. Of course, we have increases in energy costs, increases in groceries. We just had an increase in everything that people buy and sell.

I'm getting interjections over there all the time from the member for Hasluck, who I think will be a one-term member because people aren't happy in her electorate either. Do you know why they are unhappy with the member for Hasluck and with many others? They are unhappy because this government didn't have a focus for a long time. For the first 18 months they were talking about a Voice, which divided the country, divided families, divided friendship groups. They were focused on that while interest rates were going up, they were focused on that while food prices were going up and they were focused on that while energy costs were going up.

Just over the last week or two, what was the main game of those opposite? They weren't talking about cost of living; they were talking about a misinformation bill. That was a big focus for them and that is what they wanted to push through. What was that going to do? It would shut down free speech in this country. That is all it was going to do. If you had an opinion that disagreed with them they were not going to let you wear it.

The member for Hasluck, keep interjecting because you are not going to have many more opportunities.

Sharon Claydon

Sharon Claydon Newcastle, Australian Labor Party

I would ask you not to encourage the interjections and I am going to ask the member for Hasluck, who I often have to ask, not to interject. Let 's get through this debate, the last one for the year. Over to you, Member for Page.

Kevin Hogan

Kevin Hogan Page, National Party, Shadow Minister for Trade and Tourism

They focused on the Voice to divide our country, focused on the misinformation bill to shut down free speech in this country. That is what the government is focused on while we are heading in the wrong direction. As a regional MP, I certainly feel this. Regional Australia certainly knows this government is not going in the correct direction. I remind this House that regional Australia is the economic powerhouse of this country. A lot of our city cousins, I don't think, appreciate that. The four biggest exports in this country are coal, iron ore, gas and food. None of that comes from a city seat. Deputy Speaker, as a regional MP, you would certainly appreciate that none of that comes from a city seat.

Regional Australia is driving the wealth of this country, but that's certainly not how this government treats regional Australia. We've seen so many infrastructure programs shut down. The Stronger Communities program was a favourite of mine, for the little community groups that it would help out: $10,000 or $15,000 for a little community group. It was a great program in regional Australia. Obviously every person on that side didn't want that, because it disappeared. Another great program was the Local Roads and Community Infrastructure Program. It has been abandoned under this government.

Another decision that was very detrimental to regional Australia was the Murray-Darling Basin Plan, where we've seen this government basically commit to take water out of communities, which takes jobs out of communities and takes food out of communities. That hasn't been a good direction for our country. And the other one—we spent a whole MPI on it—is the reckless renewables policy of this government. In sanctimonious-hypocrisy corner over there we have the member for Warringah, who doesn't want eight wind turbines and a hectare of solar panels on North Head, but gee, it's okay to build millions of solar panels and tens of thousands of wind turbines out in the regions, because apparently we don't have culturally or environmentally significant issues with that.

I could go on about health—the Distribution Priority Areas, which ravaged GPs from the regions as well. The Australian public is right: this government is putting Australia in the wrong direction. (Time expired)

Zaneta Mascarenhas

Zaneta Mascarenhas Swan, Australian Labor Party

4:11 pm

It's really interesting, standing in this place and getting lectured about directions. I think quite a lot of people would know what I mean when I say, 'Never eat soggy Weet-bix'—north, east, south, west. One of the reasons I talk about that is that I think it's important to think about compasses, including moral compasses. So it's really fascinating getting lectured by the opposition about a sense of direction, particularly when we had a member for Cook who didn't have a particularly good moral compass. I think multiple people from his side referred to him as a liar, and international leaders described—

Sharon Claydon

Sharon Claydon Newcastle, Australian Labor Party

Member for Swan, I understand that you may be quoting, but that is an unparliamentary term.

Zaneta Mascarenhas

Zaneta Mascarenhas Swan, Australian Labor Party

Okay. Thank you very much, Deputy Speaker. The thing I would say is that there were five secret ministries, and they were ministries that nobody knew about. So, it was really interesting to hear them talk about that sense of direction. I remember the days when we didn't have GPSs, and I feel as though sometimes the Nationals are using a paper street directory, sometimes known as a UBD. But I think that's a TLA that this generation doesn't necessarily know.

But when we're talking about directions, I think it's important that we look at the megatrends that are happening in our economy at the moment, such as inflation, which is a really important issue for all households. When we took office, the inflation rate had a six in front of it, and at the moment it has a two in front of it. Also, talking about numbers, because I'm kind of into numbers: a tax cut for every taxpayer. I talk about that because it's something I see as being tangibly important to all Australians. But I also kind of want to give a lesson on systems thinking. In our economy there are big systems, feedback loops, input parameters, time lags and input variables. There's no definitive science to this, but something that was really exciting to me was when I went and visited St Vinnies in my electorate of Swan and they showed me statistics on the number of phone calls they get from people in the community who are facing financial hardship. I saw a significant reduction, from July this year, in the number of people seeking assistance. That indicated to me that our tax cuts are having an impact, and so is our electricity relief credit.

But you need to look at multiple numbers. I also had a NAB team member come and visit me, and he was talking about the stats they were seeing in their office. They've also seen a reduction in the number of people seeking hardship terms. So we're starting to see the change that Australians need.

Also, speaking of directions, one of the things that was interesting for me when I was at the Canning show was the unsolicited feedback on federal government policy that I got when I was speaking to a couple of different constituents. Some of it was on robodebt. A young man said to me, 'I could never vote for the coalition, because of the mental trauma that they put me through.' An air hostess manager said: 'Hey dude, how are you going? We're totally supporting you, and that's because of Same Job, Same Pay.' She asked, 'Did you know that someone that's doing the same job as me can be paid $50,000 more?' Same job and, previously, not the same pay: does that sound fair?

If I think about Australia, I think of it as a country that's about fairness. When people think about Australia as a place to come to, they think about the things that make it better: a good industrial relations system; a good Medicare system, which we will continue to invest in; and a good education system, which is something Labor governments are amazing at supporting.

I spoke to another person about the culture of Centrelink. He said, 'When you guys took over, it felt like there was a change in the culture when I walked in the door within the actual Centrelink office.' We need to take pride in our institutions and continue to work really hard to make sure that we make a positive difference for everyday Australians.

Melissa Price

Melissa Price Durack, Liberal Party

4:16 pm

There is no doubt that Australians are worse off under this Prime Minister. Since the election, the cost of food has gone up by 11.8 per cent. The cost of housing has gone up by 11.7 per cent and rents are up by 16.1 per cent. Gas prices are up by a whopping 32.2 per cent. Health care costs are up by 10.4 per cent, education by 11.5 per cent and financial and insurance services by 18.2 per cent.

As you can see, everything's going up, and Australians want action. They do feel that they've been let down by this Albanese government. The good people of WA really feel let down. In particular, the people living in regional WA feel let down.

There's been a lot of chatter about when the election will be and whether or not we'll be coming back in February. I'm sure the Prime Minister's receiving a lot of feedback from his colleagues about when he should go. No matter what date he lands on, Australians will still be faced with the same question of whether they are better off now than they were three years ago. It's that question which must really frighten those opposite. It's noteworthy that they've stacked the MPI with the Western Australians today. How worried are they about the result in WA?

In question time yesterday, I asked the Prime Minister about the terrible collapse of living standards in Australia. This is what my constituents, like all Australians, care about. It was interesting to hear him bring up his recent trip to Geraldton, which is in my wonderful electorate of Durack. In that question, he failed to mention that he was in Geraldton for only one hour. Honestly, it's a real shame that the Prime Minister didn't take the opportunity to hear from the Geraldton locals about the real issues for them. He didn't want to hear about the housing crisis or the cost-of-living crisis. He didn't want to hear about any of that. No, it was simply a photo opportunity. That is absolutely disgusting, and how disrespectful to the people of Geraldton.

Christmas is less than a month away but, yet again, it's going to look a lot different this year. This Christmas, Australians will be forced to cut back on their spending whilst seeing this government spend, spend and spend a little bit more. Unfortunately, this means fewer presents under the tree for our children to open on Christmas Day. There aren't going to be a lot of those long, expensive family holidays during January, which would otherwise have been a source of wonderful, treasured memories. As we approach the new year, families are needing to reconsider school options, and I'm hearing about this across the electorate. They're reconsidering whether they can continue to pay for their children's sports. These are real issues.

After 2½ years of this government, this is beginning to, unfortunately, look like the new normal. In Australia, core inflation is rising, and it is higher than in any other major advanced economy. This demonstrates that inflation is homegrown and that, out of all of the leaders of the advanced economies, ours has delivered the worst results.

The election will certainly be an uphill battle for the coalition; we recognise that. Not since 1931 has a Commonwealth government failed to win a second term. Yet, despite history being on Labor's side, I think you'd struggle to find anyone in the government feeling absolutely certain about their chances or really positive about their future as a member of parliament. They know they're failing, and they know that Australians know it.

In 2022 Labor campaigned on making life easier and cheaper for Australians. This Prime Minister and his government have been in charge now for over 2½ years, yet those opposite refuse to accept any responsibility for Australia's ongoing high inflation. It is simply shameful. They would have you believe that high energy prices have nothing to do their renewable-only strategy; they'd have you believe that inflation has nothing to do with their spending of $315 billion; and they'd have you believe that business insolvencies hitting an all-time record high had nothing to do with their industrial relations changes, which only make it harder to do business in this country.

I would like to conclude by addressing some serious fires that are currently being battled around my electorate of Durack. One such fire is in the Shire of Toodyay. I believe the people of West Toodyay are currently under the 'leave now' bushfire warning. Another very serious fire is in the Shire of Dandaragan, around Cervantes; it is approximately 48 kilometres long, north to south, and is proving very difficult to combat. It's my understanding that there are over 200 firefighters working tirelessly to get this under control. I would like to thank them all. I would like to extend my heartfelt thoughts to everyone impacted by these fires, including the two firefighters who were injured yesterday during the Dandaragan fire. Be safe, everyone. (Time expired)

Matt Burnell

Matt Burnell Spence, Australian Labor Party

4:21 pm

The matter put before the House today refers to the direction Australia is moving in, so let's talk about that. Let's talk about the direction this country will be moving in under the nuclear energy policy proposed by the LNP—or I wish I could say that, because the opposition don't really have one. They don't know what they're doing. We have six pages of nothing, which were given to the Australian public over six months ago, but that's been discreetly taken down, to the point where you can't access it anymore online. If you need a copy, please reach out to my office; we're more than happy to provide one. The Liberals did that because they realised there was a problem with their nuclear energy policy: they don't know how much it's going to cost, they don't know how long it's going to take, they don't know what these reactors will look like, they don't know what kind of nuclear reactors they want to build, and they don't know how much nuclear waste this policy will produce. Is it a Coke can? I think not.

They don't know how their nuclear policy is going to help Australians. They're not telling us about the supposed savings Aussie families will get, and I would go as far as to say that the opposition don't know why they're heading in this direction, because, outside of taking advantage of Aussies who need help with the cost of living and trying to capitalise on their suffering for the express purpose of winning Liberal votes, there is absolutely no reason to think, and it is grounded in absolutely no scientific evidence, that this direction of the coalition—if you can call it that—is going to achieve anything in Australia, given our current position in energy. The LNP's nuclear policy is pure fantasy.

The member for Fairfax—who is the main character on this 'wheel of fortune policy' from the LNP—must have seen Wicked the other day, because the nuclear snake oil he is peddling to the public is straight out of a scene from The Wizard of Oz. The member for Fairfax is playing the role of Dorothy, following the 'yellowcake road'. He is followed closely by little Toto, played by the member for Cook. They're off to see the wizard, the wonderful wizard of half-baked ideas and destruction—played by this opposition leader. The member for Fairfax has asked the wizard to grant him his heart's desire. His wish is for some direction on energy policy. The opposition leader, with a twist and a flick of his magic wand, grants that wish by handing down a nuclear energy policy that costs too much, takes too long and annihilates Australia's path to cheaper power bills and cleaner energy because the wizard thinks it'll earn him some blue votes next year. But the member for Fairfax doesn't care. With the member for Cook in his arms, he taps his heels three times and teleports all around the country, riding the high of Aussies struggling to pay their bills, and presents them with the sheer fiction that is their nuclear policy. That is the direction of the Liberals—they are absolutely aimless. That's why this Labor government, under this Prime Minister, has spent the last 2½ years getting Australia back on track.

Labor's direction is fighting the cost of living, and we delivered a bigger, better and fairer tax cut for every Australian to do just that. Those Australians include 67,000 people in my electorate alone on lower and middle incomes, keeping more of what they earn than under the Liberal plan. Labor's direction is smashing barriers of disadvantage in communities like mine, by making education more affordable. That includes a brand new university study hub opening Elizabeth to slash expenses for local students, changing the student loan system so you're paying loans off when you can afford to do so and fee-free TAFE. Labor has enrolled over half a million Aussies into TAFE, for free. If re-elected next year, we will cut 20 per cent off all HELP loans for students.

Labor's direction is making medicines cheaper and health care more affordable. Labor's direction is keeping inflation down to put downward pressure on costs in the family home. And, of course, Labor's direction is staying away from the 'yellowcake road' and actually doing something to make power prices cheaper. We have done that by taking $300 of all power bills for every single Australian household. While the Liberals are busy chasing wizards projecting their magical fantasies onto Australians and attempting to block everything I just mentioned because they want to profit from Aussies doing it tough, this Labor government under this Prime Minister is going the right direction—that is, fighting the cost of living.

Keith Wolahan

Keith Wolahan Menzies, Liberal Party

4:26 pm

There are times in our lives when we stop. We pause and ask: what was the point of it all? We usually do that at significant moments in history or in our lives. The member for Canning and I asked ourselves that question at the end of the Afghanistan war: what was the point of it all? When you do that, you do a serious stocktake of what occurred and what we learned from it.

Right now, Australians are standing at a crossroads, looking at this Prime Minister and this government and they're saying, 'What was the point of it all?' When I listen through the various speeches given by the members, with due respect them as friends and colleagues, I also ask: what was the point of it all?

We have heard lovely speeches given for the people who keep this place ticking—our staff, families and friends, as we should. We did that because Christmas is coming. We owe a great debt to the Australian people. We want them to know that, in this place, we're thinking of them as well with Christmas around the corner. Many families will be having a Christmas they didn't have three years ago. They will be poorer, more stressed, harder-working and less happy. That is on this government because, when you look at the numbers, Australians are going backwards. Everyone is going backwards, bar a few exceptions.

Recently our leader came to a foodbank in my electorate. Went there for two reasons—one was to thank the volunteers and donors for all that they do. We were at Carenet in Templestowe, and I want to thank Kellie Wishart and her team. Templestowe is not an area, if you're from Melbourne, that you would imagine needing a foodbank. It is generally considered a wealthy area, with high incomes and high asset prices, yet in that area they're giving out 4,000 kilograms a week of food.

Our first task was to thank the volunteers for their work. The second task, many people asked about in the comments in the leader's posts and in mine. They asked: what are you going to give them? That's not the right question. The question is: what are we going to do to make the need for this foodbank disappear? We are prosperous nation, and it is a great shame on us that so many Australians are turning up to foodbanks. How is it happening that, in 2024, Australians in metropolitan Melbourne are putting food on the table from foodbanks?

I went to that foodbank on a previous occasion. As I stood there talking to Kellie Wishart, some people were coming in and I recognised some of them. They felt embarrassed, but they shouldn't have because I know that they are hardworking and they have had circumstances in their lives—whether it be unemployment, a separation or illness—that has meant they are struggling and need that help.

Families this Christmas will go to pay the food bill, with the average food bill for a family of four about $400 a week. It has gone up 10 per cent. At Christmas, when you want to put a bit of extra food on the table, it can be double that cost.

Housing is up; rents are up. When we listen to the interjections or the speeches, all we hear is, 'Yes, we've caused this great problem that we're not interested in solving, but here is our little bit of help for the symptoms.' There is no interest in the cause. They are only focused on the symptoms and helping to start a fire that they are not interested in putting out. Here is my little bucket of water to help put it out—that is the focus of this government. It's all symptoms, no cause.

Families paying off a mortgage are in dire straits. A family with an average mortgage is $35,000 worse off. That's for the average mortgage. The closer you get to metropolitan Melbourne—I see that the member for Higgins is here—you know that the average mortgage is way higher than that. Families who are on average wages see no hope, and many are at the brink. Again, we hear the government talk about average wages. They never talk about real wages, and how much money is actually left in people's pockets at the end of all the costs they have to pay that are going up and the rising income taxes through bracket creep. So Australians at this crossroads are saying, 'What was the point of it all?' They will pass judgement soon. (Time expired)

Michelle Ananda-Rajah

Michelle Ananda-Rajah Higgins, Australian Labor Party

4:31 pm

I have learned one thing in life, which is that you judge people not on what they say but on what they actually do. For all the chirping, bleating and, frankly, crocodile tears from the coalition, the Liberals and the Nationals, we know that at every turn they have opposed our offerings to improve the lives of Australians and to help with cost-of-living relief. They have opposed energy bill relief, wage increases amongst our lowest paid workers and Commonwealth rent assistance. There is not a single aspect or component of our cost-of-living relief package that they haven't opposed.

When we came to government, we inherited a really bad hand of economic cards, and this was after a decade of the Liberals and Nationals in action. We basically found an economy with its shock absorbers ripped out when it came to housing, energy and skills. We had economy-wide shortages of skills; nothing had been done about this. We also had the really bad label of being the lowest country in the OECD when it came to sovereign manufacturing capability. We just simply stopped making things in Australia. That was the economy we inherited.

Then, to make matters worse, during the pandemic we had JobKeeper, which basically injected, turbocharged, nearly $90 billion in funding to businesses. We didn't quibble with that at the time, but, when you look back in the rearview mirror, the reality is $38 billion of that went to companies with increasing profits. What it did was actually pour fuel on this inflationary fire. So we have woken up from this pandemic with a very heavy inflationary hangover that was not helped by what we inherited from those opposite.

For the duration of this government, we have tried to respond with support—not with austerity and not with making things worse but with actual, material support—to help the Australian people throughout the lifetime continuum, from the cradle to the grave. When I talk about the cradle, I'm referring, of course, to the early years. For the first time in the Commonwealth's history, we have an early years strategy, and that was backed in with cheaper child care. When we came to government, we found that childcare costs had actually increased 49 per cent over the decade that the Liberals were in power. That was most acutely felt in my own electorate. Higgins has the highest childcare fees of any Victorian electorate. After your mortgage and your car, child care is the next biggest expense. So we injected $5 billion. It came in our first budget, and it's helped to take off some of the pressure on families.

This week, while it was opposed by those opposite, we passed a 15 per cent wage increase for early childhood educators, because we cannot support this vital industry without the workers. On a really positive note, we've also injected more money into toy libraries. Not only are these really important community assets; they also ease the pressure on families during a really tough period. They don't have to waste their money buying expensive toys. They simply need to go to their community toy library. We’ve backed those in.

When it comes to the middle years, this week we increased public school funding—the highest in Commonwealth history. We have linked this to KPIs which are meaningful, such as improved phonics and numeracy benchmarks, improved mental health support for Australian kids and professional development for teachers. This is designed to lift standards right across our public school education sector, something that the Liberals never talked about. They never, ever talked about it when they were in government. To back that in and to protect the mental health of our children, this week we banned social media. We imposed age limits on social media. Admittedly, this was done with bipartisan support, and we thank those opposite.

In terms of post-secondary-school education, perhaps this is where we will have the biggest impact. We have delivered a full suite of reforms to slash HECS debt to make it fairer and to really invest in free TAFE, which those opposite have opposed. That is completely inexplicable given the skill shortages this country was facing and continues to face.

Aaron Violi

Aaron Violi Casey, Liberal Party

4:36 pm

It's good to hear the member for Higgins talk about mental health, and it is great that we have instigated the social media ban. It's a little bit disappointing we didn't hear her speak out when her government slashed the number of Medicare funded mental health sessions from 20 to 10, despite the reports saying that it should stay at 20. That is just one of many examples that I will talk about. The Albanese Labor government is heading in the wrong direction and letting down the Australian people.

It is clear. If you speak to anyone in the community, there is not one Australian that is doing better today than they were in May 2022, when the Prime Minister promised that he had a plan to ease the cost-of-living crisis that Australians were facing—although we did hear from the member for Swan that apparently things have improved in the last six months, which I found staggering; things have got better which have never been better. I assumed that it was just the Prime Minister and the Treasurer that were completely out of touch and that the backbench had to sit quietly and weren't able to tell them, but it appears that the backbench also think that the Australian people have never had it better, the crisis is over and things are going well.

In the real world, when you talk to community groups, you hear a different story. The member for Menzies, my good friend, mentioned food banks in his community. Well, I've also been talking to charities and food banks in my community. In the last two weeks, two food banks that I went to visit, completely independently of each other, referenced the working poor that they are now looking after. To quote Discovery Community Care: 'the working poor category has been the biggest growth demographic for us in 2024. We have grown by 400 per cent since March 2024.' Yet those opposite have the audacity to stand here today and tell us that it's all going well: 'We've never had better, it is improving, the cost-of-living crisis has been solved,' as the member for Swan said. It's all part of the spin of this government.

The Prime Minister and the Treasurer have been talking about the inflation rate this week, but they don't talk about the true mean inflation, which is the true inflation rate that the RBA governor looks at when they decide as a board what's going to happen with interest rates. The reason they won't talk about the true mean inflation is that it actually went up in October. It went from 3.2 per cent in September to 3.5 per cent in October, pushing back any chance of a rate cut in the near future, because the RBA governor has said she will continue to look past the artificial nature of the energy subsidies of the Treasurer and the Prime Minister.

Another thing those opposite don't like to talk about since the election is that promise to reduce energy prices by $275. They made that promise 97 times before the election, and it hasn't been echoed since. Early on in the term, we got some interjections from those opposite: 'Well, we said it would happen by 2025.' Guess what? We're on the doorstep of 2025, and energy bills have not gone down by $275 for the Australian people. The data shows that, when the subsidies come off, they will increase significantly next year. There would have been a 16 per cent increase in energy prices if it wasn't for that rebate. Prices are continuing to go up.

This is a government that is focused on the symptoms and the political spin. They have no answers to the genuine challenges of the Australian people or to ease the cost-of-living crisis. They have to address productivity. That is the core issue that we are facing at the moment. Productivity has fallen 6.3 per cent under this government, but those opposite have no plans, policies or actions to address the productivity crisis that we are facing in Australia.

The reality is that in May 2022 this Prime Minister promised he had a plan for the Australian people, but 2½ years later that plan has failed. There is not one Australian that is better off today than they were in May 2022. We have an out-of-touch Prime Minister who is weak and is not making the right decisions for the Australian people. For those residents that go to food banks that are feeling the pain and are suffering three weeks before Christmas, there is no end in sight to the pain that they feel, and this government has no answers to the challenges and crisis facing the Australian public.

Louise Miller-Frost

Louise Miller-Frost Boothby, Australian Labor Party

4:41 pm

Those opposite seem to have some misplaced nostalgia for the Morrison era. Their 'back on track' mantra offers Australians the spectre of going backwards to the Morrison era. I don't know of any Australians who actually look back fondly on the man who holidayed in Hawaii while Australia burned, but, since they're clear they want to take Australia backwards, let's revisit some of the ghosts of the past.

While we could go through the secret ministries, the rorts or the scandals, let's start with economic mismanagement: nine long years of running up debt with deficit after deficit. They were on track to exceed $1 trillion of debt in the next year, and two-thirds of it ran up before the pandemic. Every Australian family knows that, if you spend more than you earn, you build debt, and that's exactly what those opposite did to our country.

We inherited inflation at 6.1 per cent and rising. Real wages were going back by 3.4 per cent as a deliberate economic strategy by those opposite. When inflation goes up and your wages are going backwards, that's a direct hit on your standard of living. Productivity growth had suffered its worst decade in 60 years. Twenty-four coal-fired power stations had announced closures, and those opposite had done exactly nothing about it. There was a chronic skills shortage in every sector of the economy, and, instead of addressing this, they just put barriers in front of Australians who wanted to upskill to get jobs. They made it more expensive to upskill. Talk about pulling the ladder up behind you. They really don't like young Australians, and they certainly don't want them to be able to build a career, afford a house, start a family or do whatever they want in their lives.

I'm sorry to depress you with that brief sojourn into the dark years when those opposite were wielding their worst on the Australian public to please their wealthy, elite big-business owners, but I think it's important, when they start talking about taking Australia backwards, to remember what that track was. But I don't want to leave you depressed, so what have we been doing? We've turned their nine deficits into back-to-back surpluses. They've been banked, bringing Australia's debt level down and reducing our interest burden. Inflation has more than halved, down from 6.1 per cent to 2.1 per cent, and, yes, underlying inflation is coming down as well.

There have now been four consecutive quarters of real wages growth. This government wants Australians to earn more, and it's happening, but we also want them to keep more of what they earn. That's why Labor's tax cuts benefited every single worker in Australia, not just the wealthy ones that those opposite wanted them to benefit. Over a million jobs have been created, the majority full time. The unemployment rate is on track to average below four per cent for the entire parliamentary term for the first time since records began, and, while those opposite let 24 coal-fired stations announce closures and did nothing to fill the energy gap, we've signed off 65 large-scale renewable projects. That is enough to power over four million Australian homes, including energy storage, an important part of ensuring that we have 24/7 power available for all Australians. To address energy costs for Australians we've capped the costs, and we've provided direct, targeted energy bill relief—both measures that those opposite voted against.

We've wiped $3 billion of student debt for more than three million Australians. We've introduced prac payments for nursing, midwifery, teaching and social work students, to remove another barrier. We've provided over 500,000 fee-free TAFE places, because, unlike those opposite, who pull the ladder up behind them, we understand that not only is this a great hand up for Australians who want to upskill and have great careers; it's also fundamental for the prosperity of this country that we solve our skilled labour shortage. We've put $32 billion into addressing the housing shortage. Those opposite cared so little about housing for Australians that for much of the last decade they didn't even have a housing minister. In the health sector, we tripled bulk-billing incentives, leading to an average four per cent increase in bulk-billing consults in my state of South Australia. We've provided cheaper medicines by cutting the co-payment, freezing PBS prices and introducing 60-day prescriptions. They voted against it. These are all measures that save Australians money.

While those opposite talk openly about taking Australia backwards, we cannot risk the man voted by doctors as the worst health minister ever. He was the worst home affairs minister. This is a reckless, arrogant opposition leader who seems to think he can go to an election with zero costed policies in the public domain. I'm left with a question: does the opposition leader actually not have any plan, or is he just keeping it secret from the Australian voters? Either way, it's too big a risk.

Lisa Chesters

Lisa Chesters Bendigo, Australian Labor Party

The discussion has concluded.