House debates Personal Explanations

Wednesday, 23 June 2010 House of Representatives

Janelle Saffin

Janelle Saffin Page, Australian Labor Party

3:49 pm

Mr Speaker, I wish to make a personal explanation.

Harry Jenkins

Harry Jenkins Speaker

Does the honourable member claim to have been misrepresented?

Janelle Saffin

Janelle Saffin Page, Australian Labor Party

Yes.

Janelle Saffin

Janelle Saffin Page, Australian Labor Party

The member for Cowper said in tabling a petition in the House last week on the issue of bats at Maclean High School that bureaucratic inaction had been made worse by my refusal to support removal of the bats. The member for Cowper needs to tell the truth about this situation. I have been working closely with this school community since mid February to help new principal Mr Tony Carr, the parents and citizens association and the New South Wales Department of Education and Training lodge a fresh application for approval to disperse flying foxes. I had previously advised how to achieve this, as with the expiration of the licence there had been no action taken.

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Opposition Members:

Opposition members interjecting—

Harry Jenkins

Harry Jenkins Speaker

It seems okay for other people to break the House rules.

Mrs Bronwyn Bishop

Mrs Bronwyn Bishop Mackellar, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Seniors

Mr Speaker, I rise on a point of order. The member is entitled to show where she has been misrepresented, but she is debating the issue and that is outside the standing orders.

Harry Jenkins

Harry Jenkins Speaker

I will make the decision about when she gets into debating. The member for Page should be very careful. She will conclude her personal explanation.

Janelle Saffin

Janelle Saffin Page, Australian Labor Party

I am showing where I was misrepresented.

Harry Jenkins

Harry Jenkins Speaker

The member for Page will just continue.

Janelle Saffin

Janelle Saffin Page, Australian Labor Party

I also received this month a letter from the Maclean High School P&C, which said that members wished to express their gratitude for my comprehensive assistance in regard to moving this matter forward and hope that this support will continue in the future.

Harry Jenkins

Harry Jenkins Speaker

The member for Page will resume her seat.

Janelle Saffin

Janelle Saffin Page, Australian Labor Party

Ms Saffin interjecting

Harry Jenkins

Harry Jenkins Speaker

The member for Page will resume her seat! I do not thank the member for continuing after she was asked and invited to resume her seat, especially when the microphones prevented her from adding argument to the explanation.