House debates Bills
Australian Centre for Disease Control Bill 2025, Australian Centre for Disease Control (Consequential Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2025; Second Reading
Tim Wilson Goldstein, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Small Business
7:07 pm
I can assure you, Deputy Speaker Young, I'm definitely being relevant where we have institutions of state that have been established and other institutions that the government wishes to establish to give themselves large amounts of power to use as justification to control Australians' lives. That's part of the legislative framework of what they're putting forward.
All I'm doing is simply looking at historical precedent of how those things have been abused and how members on the other side of this chamber applauded that every step of the way and condemned anybody who at any point has stood up to challenge or question their authority. We have just heard that from the whip when I dared raise questions about the despicable conduct and behaviour that occurred during that period, where we saw children denied education under the banner, without any evidence, which caused mental scars and long-term or lifelong mental health damage because some experts declared that they knew better than everybody else.
I understand it was difficult, but one of the biggest problems was the complete and utter failure of the so-called experts to be able to adapt, evolve or acknowledge that they got some things wrong. We heard recently from the former chief medical officer of Victoria that, in fact, there wasn't a lively evidentiary base, but that certainly wasn't how it was presented to the people of Victoria at that time. What we actually needed from the public health community at that time was a little bit of humility—for them to acknowledge that they got something wrong and to actually take the public with them and persuade them.
And yes, sometimes I'm raising my voice about this. I tell you what—no matter what you said at that time, people were bullied and silenced if they dared to speak up. In fact, some people were even shot with rubber bullets, simply because they dared to have a contrarian view. So yes, people were angry. And some people are still angry, because they were never heard and they were never listened to.
No comments