House debates Bills

Australian Centre for Disease Control Bill 2025, Australian Centre for Disease Control (Consequential Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2025; Second Reading

Wednesday, 8 October 2025 House of Representatives

Tim Wilson

Tim Wilson Goldstein, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Small Business

7:07 pm

I want to follow on from the remarks in the member for Macarthur's speech—erudite. I want to make it clear how much respect I have for the member for Macarthur. We came into parliament together in 2016. I went walkabout for three years, but he has always, I thought, served the parliament extremely well. Obviously we have a difference of opinion occasionally with how we vote, but his contributions in this chamber—particularly on matters related to the context of health care—have always added substance. He's actually lacked a partisanship, because I think he's motivated from a heartfelt and genuinely sincere place. I say that, genuinely and sincerely, from the bottom of my heart as well. So I take everything he has just said on board with sincerity and the good spirits in which it's intended.

Nobody who's debating this legislation starts from a position of arguing against the importance of preparation around health care, making sure that we have access to services, containment of diseases or, of course, protection of the Australian public. I'm sure he's not suggesting anything along those lines or an unwillingness to focus on disease control. How best we do that, though, in terms of legislation, the institutions we build and the powers they have is an enormously important part of the framework, particularly because—as the member for Macarthur correctly identified—it comes off the back of a period in which there has been, let's say, an elevated level of distrust from a large section of the Australian community about how powers have been used and/or abused in recent years.

Being from the great state of Victoria myself, I watched as our state government lied to the people of Victoria. When I say 'lied', I mean they explicitly lied and said that there was evidence as the basis and justification. They used the case of expert evidence which never existed to shut down, silence people, lock people in their homes, impose a curfew and bully children and families for two years and refuse to adapt and adjust. I fully understand that there is a need to have evolutionary policy to address the challenges of health care. But I can tell you one thing—some of us are deeply sceptical of the idea of a starting point where we just get together people who through a different basis of argument are declared experts and who then declare emergencies and the job of the Australian people is to suddenly conform.

It doesn't matter what the issue is. It doesn't even matter whether I agree with it or not. Democratic accountability and responsibility are a necessary part of the institutions of our democracy. But it's not just that; it's also so that people can be held accountable because the member for Macarthur is right—we got things wrong during the pandemic. I don't just mean this in chamber; I also mean the state governments and their failure to adapt.

One of the greatest problems is how unwilling we as a nation have been to acknowledge some of those problems at different points, but there is no state where that has been more egregious than the great state of Victoria, which literally bullied Victorian citizens into compliance and control. Once upon a time you'd say the peak point of insanity in the state of Victoria was when—I say this politely and with the greatest respect to my fellow citizens—they re-elected the government that did that. But, actually, I'm wrong. The peak point of insanity in the state of Victoria was when our former premier decided to sidle up against the world's most horrific and egregious dictators and get happy snaps next to people like the President of Russia and Kim Jong Un. This is insanity.

This is not a partisan point I'm seeking to prosecute. It is a point about control. One of the reasons why, at the core, people like me are Liberal is that we believe that people should be empowered to be able to make decisions about their lives. They should not have a situation where the government seeks to impose control over people's lives. I know the government whip has rushed in here against the idea of somebody daring to stand up against the idea of Labor Party control—using instruments of state to impose conformity onto people's lives and to bully people. How dare people raise that banner! But that is the reality—

Comments

No comments